Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pickett House

    1.0 (1 review)

    Pickett House Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pickett House

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hotels 554 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Beach Plum Inn & Restaurant - Who's hungry?

    Beach Plum Inn & Restaurant

    (101 reviews)

    $$$$

    The best setting on the vineyard! It was our last night and my parents anniversary so we wanted to…read moredo something special. This setting is impeccable! Chickens free roaming on the patio, beautiful view of menemshas famous light house gay head. At sunset everyone leaves their tables including wait staff and takes photos! We'd come back again, especially for a fine dining experience in the vineyard. My dad and I loved our chicken we orders and the gnocchi we shared. The Chicken was broiled so lightly crispy, they call it crispy on the menu but definitely not like fried chicken way healthier. The gnocchi wasn't traditionally made but was really good! It was filled with ricotta cheese so bigger than usual gnocchis and more pillowy than most, which I love lighter gnocchis. My mom thought her dish was sub par, not her favorite on the island but good for what she had. Fair review as she had been eating sea food all week and this was the only time she hadn't eaten sea food on the island. My only cons of this restaurant were the wait staff was super off. I don't comment often on wait staff, for the price you pay here they should train better. They were super slow, never even got water refills we asked for. Slow on all food entrees too it was like a two and a half hour dinner. When we first got there when it wasn't crowded they were attentive when they got crowded they got bad. My second negative comment is that there aren't sides that come with the entrees and our portions were pretty small. You'd leave hungry if you don't order an appetizer.

    Good setting but notoriously bad food and weird service. Not on the level of State Road or Chilmark…read moreTavern.

    Duck Inn - Deck room East Q

    Duck Inn

    (8 reviews)

    $$$

    This reminds me of going to my grandmas 100+ year old farmhouse if it were on an island. Up island,…read moreAquinnah (formerly Gay Head area) is nice and quiet in comparison to the rest of the island and Oak Bluffs where the ferry drops off. Elise is just a wonderful person and made the trip special. She makes a breakfast out of this world and the inn has some great animal life. A few bobcats and she has nursed some wildlife back to health. Walk to the rural more private beach is less than ten minutes. We will most certainly be back!

    This is my sanctuary from the world; quiet, serene, listening to the crickets & ocean waves at…read morenight. The breakfasts! OMG carry me though to dinner. Aquinnah is far from the other towns (30 min drive) so plan accordingly. The liquor stores do deliver with enough advance notice, and there are a few restaurants not so far away, but you are out in the country. Love sitting in the hot tub at night watching the stars. This is an old house so you might hear noise from other rooms or when breakfast gets going, but I travel with earplugs & a mask so not a thing for me. Elise is welcoming & has tips for everything you can think of. Free wifi, amazing water & sunset views (except from the downstairs stone-wall room) and blissful calm. There is no AC but mostly it's not needed, and mini fridges in many rooms, bring a small cooler for a day at the beach, a beach towel, good walking shoes, and de-com-press.

    Menemsha Inn & Cottages

    Menemsha Inn & Cottages

    (19 reviews)

    $$$

    Sorry to say that this place needs some serious upgrades. We have been coming here for years and…read moreother than an air conditioning unit there have been no Improvements. Breakfast was discontinued years ago. This is an up island location and breakfast is necessary. Don't tell us we can walk over to a neighboring property for a muffin. The radiator is rusty and paint speckles are all over the floor. The door to outside was stuck closed. This is a safety hazard. Coffee is not available as advertised. Other than the close promo mitt to Menemsha Beach, the place is deteriorating year by year. Ever since then new owners it's been a real disappointment.

    Lovely Front desk person. Reception area hotter than Hades. Was beautiful at one time but the…read moreinfrastructure is in need of a serious update. Very old, which is appealing in some sense, but is not up to the basic standards. Knobs on furniture and closet missing, broken tiles in bathroom (and black stains), Rust in shower drain. WiFi iffy. Phone was broken in room ( w sketchy WiFi.. checked it out in case we needed it.) to be fair, they moved us to a cottage and gave us an upgrade because they had a cancellation so I assume they were paid for that room anyway and they didn't lose anything over it. The fact that management thought that was OK at $500 a night is what my concern is. It was kind, but it didn't have to happen in the first place and we had to move ourselves to a different cottage, and we are not young anymore. I would not stay again.. I hope that it receives the update that it deserves because it was a once beautiful property.

    Cuttyhunk Fishing Club Inn - Fruit cup

    Cuttyhunk Fishing Club Inn

    (10 reviews)

    $$

    My husband and I have been coming to Cuttyhunk for the past several summers on our boat. Usually we…read moreuse it as a stop on our way to the Vineyard from Rhode Island. This time we spent a couple days on this quaint island and took our time exploring. At the intersection of the Corner Store, there was a sign saying breakfast was being served every weekend from 8-11 at the Cuttyhunk Fishing Club. We made our way to the beautiful inn and were delighted to find out they accept debit/credit cards as well as Apple Pay. If you have ever been to Cuttyhunk, you know most of the businesses on the island accept cash only, and there is no ATM on the island (as of the time of my review). For breakfast, I got three large chocolate chip pancakes with a fruit cup on the side. My husband got the Vineyard Sound Bowl. We both enjoyed our food. I couldn't finish my portion (should've opted for the smaller portion); I had no idea how large those pancakes were! Our sweet, mild mannered server Emily took great care of us. She was personable and made us feel welcome. The grounds of rolling greens with the breathtaking views of Vineyard Sound and the historical building make you feel like you've stepped back in time. We will definitely be back! Tip- if you are coming from the harbor, it is a long walk so plan accordingly. The road is paved so it makes for a great scooter ride.

    Excellent staff, great accommodations. Laid back island with great fishing and scenery:read more

    Pickett House - hotels - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...