Cancel

Open app

Search

Pickett House

1.0 (1 review)

Pickett House Photos

Recommended Reviews - Pickett House

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

People searched for Hotels 542 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Outermost Inn Aquinnah - Outside upper deck and bar

Outermost Inn Aquinnah

(86 reviews)

We've had a lot of REALLY good meals here. The restaurant is located near the Gay Head Lighthouse…read moreand from the outside patio you can watch the sun setting while deer and rabbits frolic in the meadow. The setting is charming and a little bohemian (the prices, however, are not - our prix fixe dinner in summer of 2026 was $139 per person). Think "the rich elite dress down for a boho meal outside". Up until this visit the service, the atmosphere and the food have been spectacular. Something must have happened this time around, however. To start, they lost our reservation even though I made it over the phone a month ahead of time (I know I did this because I entered it in my calendar.) To their credit they were able to seat us at a lovely table at the edge of the patio. They've replaced their tied-down sail-type patio coverings with a permanent roof but one can still get the evening breeze. Our meal was mostly very very good except for one glaring exception which unfortunately was the main course. We both ordered the fluke - so sorry we did. It was heavily and crustily breaded and badly overcooked - in addition to being virtually tasteless. (I've had frozen fish sticks that tasted better.) Neither of us could eat more than half of it, and I noticed, as the wait staff removed plates from other tables, that there was a lot of half-eaten fish going back to the kitchen. That being said, for the most part the menu is imaginative and the food is well-prepared - the amuse bouches were delicious and dessert was above acceptable. The service is very good and the table settings charming. Having had more than a few fantastic meals here I'm willing to chalk this up to a bad night in the kitchen. Although we will be taking a break from Outermost Inn don't let my review stop you from trying it out - the food is usually very good and the overall experience is really special. If you sit on the patio do take a sweater or a wrap - it gets very chilly there as the sun goes down.

This place is so beautiful. We sat outside with a view of the rolling hills. We saw both a rainbow…read moreand the sunset. It's a very special location. And the decor is lovely: fresh flowers, glass ware, plates. The food was hit and miss. First, I really loved my lavender lemonade. It was one of the best mocktails I've ever had. And I like the prefix menu concept. The meal started with a cold soup, which was delicious. Then there was a mushroom gnocchi; the sauce/flavor was delicious though the gnocchi were a little chewy. The bread they bought to the table was terrible. There were two different kinds and both were tough and flavorless. For my first course, I had a salad, which was fine though unremarkable. My main course was the fluke. It was described as golden crusted fluke, and I was disappointed when it arrived fried. It was served on top of some vegetables, including some very vinegar potatoes. There was a lingonberry sauce on top, which was excellent, but everything else was not very good. I was pretty disappointed. My fish was dry and a tad fishy tasting. I also tasted the pork belly, which was good and the wagyu which I thought was just OK. I got to taste all of the desserts. There were some interesting flavors such as the strawberry rhubarb, but some really odd textures like the cake in that dessert. The chocolate dessert was OK. Would I go back? Sure. It's so stunningly beautiful. I would ask more questions as I ordered about exactly how the food was going to be prepared, and I would lower my expectations for the food.

Duck Inn - Deck room East Q

Duck Inn

(8 reviews)

$$$

This reminds me of going to my grandmas 100+ year old farmhouse if it were on an island. Up island,…read moreAquinnah (formerly Gay Head area) is nice and quiet in comparison to the rest of the island and Oak Bluffs where the ferry drops off. Elise is just a wonderful person and made the trip special. She makes a breakfast out of this world and the inn has some great animal life. A few bobcats and she has nursed some wildlife back to health. Walk to the rural more private beach is less than ten minutes. We will most certainly be back!

This is my sanctuary from the world; quiet, serene, listening to the crickets & ocean waves at…read morenight. The breakfasts! OMG carry me though to dinner. Aquinnah is far from the other towns (30 min drive) so plan accordingly. The liquor stores do deliver with enough advance notice, and there are a few restaurants not so far away, but you are out in the country. Love sitting in the hot tub at night watching the stars. This is an old house so you might hear noise from other rooms or when breakfast gets going, but I travel with earplugs & a mask so not a thing for me. Elise is welcoming & has tips for everything you can think of. Free wifi, amazing water & sunset views (except from the downstairs stone-wall room) and blissful calm. There is no AC but mostly it's not needed, and mini fridges in many rooms, bring a small cooler for a day at the beach, a beach towel, good walking shoes, and de-com-press.

Pickett House - hotels - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...