Pie Zanos

66

112

690

2 years ago

Saw this place on triple D and had to make the stop. A relatively small restaurant with huge taste. Meatballs on the pizza were amazing and the chicken was cooked to perfection along with the home made pasta. Everyone we interacted with was helpful and friendly. Will be back!!! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 2

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rachel W.

21

16

25

1 year ago

One of the few good restaurants in Buffalo. They often have seasonal specials and great pizza, drinks, and salads.

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joel P.

7

25

0

1 year ago

The staff are truly amazing and,,,, the food is even BETTER! I can't say enough about this spot,,,, the owners are so kind and attentive and the staff are right in line with them. I'm originally from Chicago and wife is from New York,,, Pie Zanos knows how to make AWESOME PIZZA read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Darren C.

0

18

0

10 months ago

Visiting Buffalo from Denver and was lucky enough to find Pie Zanos. Amazing pizza that stands up against any I've had. Terrific crust, great sauce and toppings were first rate. Luckily I'm in town 3-4 times a year and Pie Zanos will be a frequent stop. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maria H.

0

1

1 year ago

We had a wonderful dinner last night!!! The peach and goat cheese was so different and good. Our entrees were delicious. The flourless chocolate torte was the perfect finish! Service was great as well. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rob C.

0

22

2

1 year ago

We ordered pizza to go, three varieties, all very good! The GF was great. Fast service!

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeanie M.

0

4

0

1 year ago

We had lunch there today. The whole menu was not available and I was very disappointed. There were only 2 people working besides whoever was doing the cooking. Our server was waiting tables, mixing drinks, taking orders. She needed help. Service was slow, as a result. The food was nothing special. We ordered the hot sourdough loaf( good)....a pizza, a salad, and a hot philly cheesesteak. I thought it was overpriced and overrated. I had wanted to eat there because of Guy Fieri. Oh well. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cheryl G.

96

26

0

2 years ago

The BEST wood-fired pizza in Wyoming! Our favorite is the Margherita. The sauce is perfect and the balsamic drizzle and fresh basil take it over the top. The salad specials never disappoint and the portion is generous enough to share. A must experience! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bryan B.

73

1

0

10 months ago

They were very busy but food was still out in a timely manner. Everybody was very happy with the meal.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gina W.

13

40

13

2 years ago

Cozy, fun restaurant with entertaining decor. I had the Buffalo chicken wrap with honey mustard, red cabbage, & romaine which was delicious, served with homemade purple potato chips. Hubby had "burnt ends": bits of smoked brisket on Texas toast with BBQ sauce, which he loved. Dessert was cinnamon cheesecake adorned with caramel pecan sauce. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eric T.

1

2

0

2 years ago

Affordable and simple. Service is great. Good place to hang out with family and friends.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John K.

0

22

6

2 years ago

Love this place. The weekly specials are always excellent. Sky is our favorite waitress, we also love James, Rene and Julie. Lots of parking on street in front of restaurant. Also big lot just north of location. Order a pizza or standard dish. Big portions. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Hank H.

0

4

0

2 years ago

Stopped again in Buffalo, Wyoming on our annual pilgrimage north to cooler temps and once again had a fabulous dinner at Pie Zanos. We love the food and the attentiveness of the staff is exceptional. The calamari, Caesar salad, and Margarita pizza were all excellent along with our bottle of red. We loved the bar tender as she was also our waitress. Will stop again on the return trip. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Judy W.

1

13

3

2 years ago

The food is a unique twist to Italian cuisine. My personal favorite is PieZanoa Pizzaiola, a spicy linguine dish with Italian sausage and peppers. My husband's favorite is the big papa pizza made with pepperoni, jalapeños and dollops of cream cheese. The staff is knowledgeable and attentive. The decor is eclectic and fun. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Becky N.

20

296

297

4 years ago

This is a cool spot in a lovely little town we stayed in on our way to Yellowstone. We were seated in 15 min despite a quoted 45 min wait - though waited a long time for drinks/greeting as I think they were pretty short staffed. Super friendly though and just pack your patience. The kids' fancy Shirley temples were delivered loooong before our beers which was tough - it had been a heck of a long day already! I was really excited to try the chicken saltimbocca - and it was good. My only suggestion would be to let that lemon Alfredo shine and serve plain or lightly oiled linguini with it as opposed to the pesto - it was just a few too many things going on. My husband loved his linguini and marinara with the smoked meatballs. The kids shared pizza and we saw quite a few tables having pizza from that wood fired oven, so I'd say it's a very safe bet! Our bread connoisseur said the bread was "fine" - and was bummed at the cinnamon butter being right out of the fridge (we got there at 8pm). Four stars because we liked our meal, and would have liked to try the pizza too...along with a few other menu items. Atmosphere was cool and I'm betting definitely a fun hangout. A little slow but where isn't these days. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Ben K.

11

16

0

3 years ago

Great experience! Looks like a hole in the wall from the street, but large and very nice decor inside. Comfortable seating, moderate noise level. Service was very polite, friendly and prompt. Nice menu options. We had linguini and marinara plus a 12" Sicilian pizza. Pasta was obviously fresh, homemade. Marinara was excellent, rich deep flavor nicely spicy, well incorporated with the pasta. Outstanding dish, large portion. With nice garlic bread too. The pizza was also outstanding. Perfect crust you can only get in a wood fired oven. Tangy but not overwhelming sauce, spicy Italian sausage , pepperoni, caramelized onion and Gorgonzola. Loved it! We also had their daily dessert special, a lemon blueberry puff pastry. Excellent! A great find in a small town. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marcia Ann C.

183

55

19

3 years ago

Everything about this place was excellent! It's right downtown, so I could walk from the hotel. I expected to grab a pizza but they had such a fabulous menu, I tried the fettuccine Alfredo with walnut basil pesto and I LOVED it!! Generous portions, so I took some home, and the prices were very fair. I highly recommend it!! OH! And the service was amazing as well! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Dave K.

1

27

0

2 years ago

Driving across country for a vacation and we had one night in Buffalo so we hopped on yelp and not wanting a heavy fried dinner, Pie Zanos looked like the only option. Thankfully it was delicious! We each had the antipasto salad and split the calamari and a loaf of the sourdough bread. Everything was delicious, the service was good and the prices, while maybe a touch high, seemed reasonable to the quality of food. If we are ever back in Buffalo, no question we would eat here again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Haley M.

66

3

0

2 years ago

Awesome food and wonderful atmosphere! Will absolutely be stopping here every time we go to Buffalo!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom L.

464

97

15

5 years ago

We are visiting Buffalo for a week. As we walked Main St we saw Pie Zanos but they were closed. So we came back the next day. We started dinner with the Chopped Antipasto salad. Then we tried the Carne Amante pizza. Both dishes were awesome. I think we will be back before we leave town. You must eat here. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cynthia C.

41

59

96

7 years ago

We ate here twice and thoroughly enjoyed everything we ordered. The staff runs like crazy to keep up, so be patient... it's worth it! The house made sangria is delicious! Give it a stir before you take a sip Great pasta and artisan pizza, and the artichoke heart cakes were excellent! read more

Pie Zanos - From top to bottom... some of the best pizza we've ever had! - Italian Near Me - Buffalo, Wyoming

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Neal A.

2

44

9

5 years ago

Great spot! Food was out freaking standing. Full bar, service is great. The owner came over chatted for a spell and told us how the restaurant came to be. Easy to find ! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lynette C.

0

58

9

3 years ago

Pizza was wonderful!!! Our server was very nice and attentive but not bothersome. It was a cool place to eat for just passing through. I love the old building. read more

Pie Zanos - Pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Buffalo, Wyoming

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Monica R.

1

19

24

7 years ago

To start: Amazing. Food and service. Our waitress was Dreama and she was attentive, friendly, and just an overall amazing kind and sweet person. She would make sure we had what we needed at all times. Literally one of the best of all times. The food? The best. I hate it when people say meat is "melt in your mouth" because meat has tendons. It does not "melt"- that is a cantaloupe thing. But it was moist, the bbq was sweet and salty, melty, and delicious. The owners, Matt and Renee, were from the south and brought their magical southern flair and charm to Wyoming, where you expect it less. They were sweet and Renee came to the table and talked to us, which was so great that we got to hear her story and learn about the background of the restaurant and the food! My partner and I split the burnt ends sandwich and the chicken and prosciutto sandwich... we were in heaven. They could have charged $15 per meal in Seattle if they wanted! I would have paid $20. Overall, go here. You'll never regret it. Best restaurant I've ever been to, at the most random spot. read more

Pie Zanos - Burnt ends sandwich- bbq and melts in your mouth. Amazing - Italian Near Me - Buffalo, Wyoming

Pie Zanos - My partner in bliss with the most amazing meal of burnt ends sandwich and the chicken prosciutto sandwich we shared. - Italian Near Me - Buffalo, Wyoming

Pie Zanos - Chicken prosciutto sandwich. I wish I could have this for breakfast, lunch and dinner. - Italian Near Me - Buffalo, Wyoming

Pie Zanos - Outside is lovely - Italian Near Me - Buffalo, Wyoming

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dawn H.

0

6

11

3 years ago

Best pizza and breaded calamari I've ever had! All their food is delicious. The staff are all super friendly and accommodating, the service exceptional and the food...DELECTABLE! Fun, cozy ambiance makes it a real fun place to dine. Oh, and a full bar! Highly recommended. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Laura H.

8

11

3 years ago

Wood fired pizza. The best crust this side of East Coast. True Italian pizza. The margarita is my favorite with fresh basil and balsamic added after out of the oven read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julien M.

0

15

3

6 years ago

This is an excellent restaurant. Lasagna was the best I've had in the US. We also ordered chicken saltimbuca and beignets for desert and everything was amazing. Service was excellent too. We found a gem ! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tiffany G.

0

6

0

3 years ago

We will not be returning to this restaurant. We have been a couple of times and the food has been good, slow service but tasty food. However tonight's experience was one of the worst I have encountered. We never received drink refills, our food was slow to come out, but it was Friday night so that's expected. We received our food and as my son was eating he found something in his fettuccine Alfredo, upon further inspection it turned out to be a BUG We informed the waitress and she was going to speak to her manager, the waitress came by and breezily apologized and said they would take off his meal from the ticket. The manager never once came by, to the point of avoiding our table. While we were waiting for our ticket the waitress proceeds to sweep under our table. While I know computers act up they had to reboot it and that took over 25 minutes. But again, never explained what was taking so long, just ignored. The decor would be considered tacky Halloween, and while I know that's not a major factor it really was the cherry on top of this disaster of an evening. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 5

Parker P.

0

8

1

8 years ago

Super friendly staff and the food was fantastic! Had a large party size and our wait time wasn't bad at all! The prices were great for what we all got! Our server was very kind and helpful with the navigation of the menu! I will definitely be back here again! (I got the Buffalo Chicken Pizza! It was bomb!) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Susan Cochrane B.

85

9

0

4 years ago

They were pretty busy for the staff they had on and still provided good service. The food was really tasty, I'd recommend to others.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Van M.

0

1

0

4 years ago

We picked up carry out pizza and a salad. It was a great meal. Ready in about 20 minutes.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carrson P.

0

12

2

6 years ago

The food is amazing and carol is one of the best waitresses in the food business! She is super sweet and is always there to talk when she isn't serving. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

madison m.

0

1

0

3 years ago

My experience at pie zanos was horrific. The waitress put the incorrect menu item into the ordering system when she took my order. It took 45 minutes for my meal to come out and when it did, it was the wrong meal. The waitress offered me a free $7 glass of wine to make up for the fact I ended up waiting over 75 minutes of my meal, that they charged me in full for $30. I waited so long for my correct meal that I had to get it to go since my entire dinner party had been served over 30 minutes prior. I will never be back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom M.

0

9

0

3 years ago

The food is really good, but the service is all over the place. Whether it's taking an order, knowing when a table or food will be available, knowing what items are available, remembering your order, or getting you the right thing, it seems like pure chaos. Everyone was friendly and it seemed like they were doing their best with not enough staff. I hope we just came on an off weekend. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jesse M.

305

29

57

7 years ago

This quaint restaurant nestled in the small town of Buffalo is the perfect spot for delicious food, whether traveling through or staying in Buffalo. I ordered the blueberry bruschetta (which was a sweet and savory treat), the artichoke cakes (a wonderful dish), and the sweet and spicy pizza (mouthwatering)! The service was excellent, good selection of local brews, and great atmosphere (not too loud). I can't wait to return and try more of their delicious dishes! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stephen G.

0

14

9

6 years ago

Got stuck in Buffalo with car troubles and walked to Pie Zanos for some dinner. Had some good pizza here. Staff was friendly and prices were reasonable. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tami K.

3

32

1

5 years ago

A real gem in the Buffalo downtown. They offer salads, fresh Brushetta, along with entrees and pizza. Everyone is so welcoming and friendly, the atmosphere is still Buffalo history, but the building feels light and airy. Make sure this ace.is on your list! I will visit again.y only regret is that I wish I had found it the first day of my stay! read more

Pie Zanos - Olive you pizza, margherita pizza and speedboat beer!! - Italian Near Me - Buffalo, Wyoming

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Adam M.

0

11

1

6 years ago

This is the best restaurant in Buffalo. The pizza is absolutely amazing and the service is wonderful! You should definitely eat here. Great atmosphere. The best in Buffalo! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Patrick H.

13

356

58

10 years ago

The service is slow and the food is good. Don't drink all your water it will take forever to get more. Pizza is great and the brisket is awesome. Kids pasta is ok but the meatball is too smoked for most kids read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 3

See more reviews

More info about Pie Zanos

17 N Main St
Buffalo, WY 82834
Directions
(307) 278-0161
Call Now
Visit Website
http://piezanoswy.com

Hours

What time does Pie Zanos open?

Pie Zanos opens at 4:00 PM on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Pie Zanos close?

Pie Zanos is closed on Monday, Tuesday and Sunday.Pie Zanos closes at 8:30 PM on Wednesday.Pie Zanos closes at 9:00 PM on Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Tue, Sun ClosedWed 4:00 PM - 8:30 PMThu-Sat 4:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Pie Zanos take credit cards?

Yes, Pie Zanos takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Pie Zanos serve alcohol?

Yes, Pie Zanos serves alcohol. Full Bar

Indoor Amenities

Does Pie Zanos allow dogs?

Yes, Pie Zanos allows dogs.

Does Pie Zanos have TVs?

Yes, Pie Zanos has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Pie Zanos have bike parking?

Yes, Pie Zanos has bike parking.

Does Pie Zanos have outdoor seating?

Yes, Pie Zanos has outdoor seating options.

Does Pie Zanos have parking?

Yes, Pie Zanos has parking options. Street Parking, Validated Parking

Other Amenities

Does Pie Zanos have free WiFi?

Yes, Pie Zanos has free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

Review Highlights - Pie Zanos

“We went in for Italian but ended up ordering the artichoke cakes and my husband ordered the ribs.”

Mentioned in 7 reviews

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Pizza Carrello

This place was awesome from service to food to the ambiance!!…read more Kate/Katie gave us great service and recommendations despite our late(ish) arrival. We started with the jalapeño poppers with raspberry dipping sauce...very tasty! Then we were able to put toppings of two different signature pizzas onto each half of a single large pizza (of which we will also be enjoying for breakfast!!!) both pizzas were delicious! The dessert calzones were phenomenal as well. Oh, and for the review by the idiot who complained about the slight char on the crust, FYI, that is exactly the way it should come from a wood fired pizza oven! AMAZING!!!

We are driving through, saw the menu on this place and had to give it a try! We had the bacon…read morewrapped jalapeños with the raspberry dipping sauce. They were superb. And we were delighted to find out that you could split a large pizza into two types. Both were absolutely fantastic! Generous portions, we shared the large (two of us) and still had half leftover for breakfast tomorrow! I absolutely love what FIRE pizza, I've had it all over the world, including Italy and they definitely nailed it! We also got the dessert calzones, which were great too, and what a plus that they carry local craft beer on draft! Katie was her server and she was so attentive and kind! We literally walked in 30 minutes before they closed and everybody treated us with great customer service! Bravo, for creating such fun, unique pizzas! And for having great service in atmosphere!

Just had there pepperoni and the pickle, both very good and the service was nice

See all

Outside

Armando's Taco & Pasta Shop

My kids really enjoyed their rice they have here. They ate plenty of it. Nice and fluffy and not…read moretoo spicy. I had the steak fajita salad. It was good but seemed to be cooked in a lot of oil, which I didn't appreciate since I was trying to eat healthy. It actually gleamed with oil. Prices were fair and service was good. Nice ambiance for WY.

On our road trip from Yellowstone to Mt Rushmore we stopped in for dinner. Can't remember where I…read moreread about the place but the person at the front desk of the hotel also highly recommended it. I had the spicy pork enchiladas with both sauces (green and red) and wife had chicken enchiladas with read sauce. Both dishes were out of this world with awesome flavor and freshness. You could tell the rice was fresh and the beans were NOT a slab of dryness that you get at a lot of places. Bothe were delicious mixed together in the extra sauce on the plate. Now, let's not forget about the fresh homemade pico de galo, which could double as a nice fresh crunchy salad. Highly recommended this place

FETTUCCINE BOLOGNESE. Amazing.

See all

Pizza Hut

Service was great. Adam was so greeting and served us even though they were close to closing. We…read morewere so grateful. We had been traveling all day from Denver to Buffalo, Wyoming and we were starving. Thank you Pizza Hut! Our family appreciated the kindness and food.

Great service! Good! Food 5/5 after long day of driving they stayed open 30 extra minutes to let us…read moreeat

See all

Powder River Pizza

Just. Wow!!! First…read moreoff - the food here is AWESOME! The first thing you will notice is "a new menu" with lowered pricing (they say) - but beware the portions and up charges - they are brutal Opinion - A diminished serving size on all time favorite appetizers will NEVER draw repeat customers (no matter the cost saving) Again, the food and atmosphere is on point (for flavor and pizza offerings) - and customer service is great! - But man, if you order wrong , you can definitely walk away hungry...

Unsuspectingly delicious!! Pizza is crisp, full of flavors, not too thick, not too thin. House…read moresalad was perfect. And the playlist was legit. Passing through but will remember this spot if I'm ever back out west

Hawaiian Build Your Own Pizza

Business signage.

See all

The cowpoke with jalapeños, LOVE this place, it's on my top 5 list of pizzas.

Sagewood Cafe

This is the only place in town that does serve food that is not fried and all homemade from Soups…read moreto Salads to the bread and cakes and cookies. A staple in Buffalo.

This place had the BEST homemade soup and sandwiches Cindy…read morethe Owner / Cook was great Cassidy was a great waitress Highly recommended we were heading back from Yellowstone FIVE STARS ***** Jay from Onalaska WI

But check out the daily specials

Special

See all

Verdello

4.2

(5 reviews)

33.7 mi

Stellar selection of (slightly pricey) items…read more Midnight Moon cheese Runamok Sparkle Maple Syrup Rummo pastas Truffle Olive Oil (amazing) The list goes on... If you want to buy something very special to make an extra beautiful meal this is your spot in Sheridan. Also, the staff was awesome.

Verdello is one of those specialty food shops with various Italian pastas, sauces, and the like,…read morebut probably has the big draw of flavored olive oils and vinegars. Sampling is easy here, small cubes of bread, a box of toothpicks and small bowls of product spread throughout the store makes it easy to try before making a commitment. And they're near everything in addition to the oils and vinegars. You can spend a lot of time browsing here, looking at the options, checking out the recipes and letting your culinary imagination go crazy. Half the store has the oils, vinegars, various salts, and sauces of every kind, the other half is a cheese shop along with hard-to-find condiments to complement the cheeses. Verdello also has cooking classes for both adults and kids, with small class sizes and comes with the recipes to take home. In looking at the upcoming schedule, many of the classes fill quickly, so it's best not to wait if something catches your eye. With all the good here (4+ stars), I struggled to justify even a three-star rating based on the service. Maybe because it was early, maybe because it was a weekend, but when I asked for assistance in getting some product, the barely concealed resentment was palpable: from the eye-rolling to the deep sighs, to the terse sentences. At the usual questions during checkout, be assured that when I said I likely wouldn't be coming back, it wasn't because I'm not from the area. Customer service must be foreign concept here. That's too bad, because I otherwise liked this place.

See all

Sackett's Market

Beautiful family owned deli with a great atmosphere. Gourmet foods and a beautiful butcher shop…read more Annie at the counter was very helpful. Thank you Annie. Wish we had one of these in our hometown.

Sackett's is awesome. Full deli, salad bar, meat market and mini gourmet grocery store. It's got a…read morebeautiful self-serve eating cafe in the front with complimentary berry water and cheap self-serve Coffee. The sandwiches for lunch are amazing and are reasonably priced. But most of the rest of the gourmet goods in the store, the cheeses, the meats are expensive. Excellent quality though. Very friendly service.

Sackett's Market deli counters

See all

Good deli!

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

I was very happy with my meal at Old Chicago. Tasty spaghetti and meatballs. The meatballs were…read moreexceptionally well seasoned and the spaghetti perfectly cooked to an al dente delight. My only beef with the meal was that they skimped with the bread. One small piece, not worthy of it's separate plate. But the meal was filling enough. Make your plan to visit. Quick Tip: Though my picture doesn't show it, there were a lot of folks inside. They were enjoying the comfortable dining experience. Give them a quick call to ensure that you can do the same.

Convenient location with a good food selection, solid variety of beer on tap, and friendly,…read moreattentive waitstaff. The atmosphere is welcoming and makes for an overall pleasant experience. A good spot to stop in when you're in the area.

See all

The Prime Rib Restaurant & Wine Cellar

Yes i'm leaving ANOTHER review...... but this one is even better…read more Sadly I can't have dairy or gluten :/ so I got the chicken cashew salad--and OH MY GOODNESS. Let's just say it was worth every penny (except someone else paid for me, so bless their heart.) Our server was FANTASTIC-- super nice. There was a big group of us and they cared for us wonderfully. It was really enjoyable. My husband got the steak sirloin with french fries--and omgoodness their french fries are everything Love love love!!! Not in our budget though..... so we will probably not be back for a long time.

To start we ate the most delicious and tender calamari. We ordered the Senior Prine rib dinner and…read moreadded the wedge salad for an extra $5.99. The prime rib didn't look as how we expected, very lean but it was surprisingly tasty. Our waitress said the potato soup was good and so we chose that. It was nice with chunks of potatoes with a deep cheddar flavor. The wedge salad was half a head of iceberg lettuce cut in half. It was so huge that I needed to use two plates to cut up the lettuce and toss it wth all the toppings. It was quite delicious and fillings. We also ordered a Rib Eye dinner which tasted really good. To end our meal we ordered the Sky High mud Pie to share. It had delicious coffee ice cream covered in whipped cream and drizzled with chocolate and maybe it was caramel syrup and a lot of chopped peanuts around the edge of the plate. It was really delicious but now that I think about it I think if it were toasted almonds instead of peanuts it could of been tastier to me. Our waitress was so wonderful, funny and attentive. She was good and honest about recommendations and wanted to know what we thought about the calamari because she gets mixed reviews. The restaurant is open to 10 which makes it great for those on roadtrips and want to stop at and have a nice sit down dinner. We arrived around 8:30 and the restaurant was still busy.

Great salad and wonderful dressing

See all

Olha’s Market

4.9

(37 reviews)

32.2 mi

My hubby and I had the pleasure of having dinner at olha's for dinner which we enjoyed the cabbage…read moreroll dinner it was about fabulous. We shared the dinner..the flavor was spot on with tender cabbage and flavor of the pork .. The mash was excellent homemade fluffy goodness that was like eating Sunday dinner at home The dishes are authentic Ukraine flavors with top quality ingredients and attention to detail...it was more than expected the portion was more than enough for 2 and the beautiful golden baked sourdough bread is over the top baked to perfection.. The sdb was like a pillow of goodness with the perfect amount of flavor.. The baked goods are above and beyond what Grandma use to bake Olha's is that hidden gem that once you find it you'll always go back and the lovely Amanda was more like an ole friend and took very good care of us and the conversation was definitely the best part of dinner we look forward to coming back in the near future thank you If I could give them a higher star rating I would

My grandfather is Polish from Detroit, and I grew up in Chicago, so pączki during Fat Thursday week…read morehas always been a tradition for me. Despite Sheridan County's Polish population, I was surprised not to find a Polish bakery of any sort. Fortunately, someone recommended Olha's Market as a Ukrainian option which may have something similar. I walked in asking if they had pączki, and the staff simply served me pampushky without missing a beat, as if that's exactly what I'd asked for! It wasn't until later that I learned the Ukrainian name for these delicious fried dough treats. The pampushky were absolutely wonderful: light, fluffy, and perfectly sweet. They reminded me of pączki but had their own unique character. The bakery case was full of beautiful pastries and breads that all looked delicious, and the restaurant side had an enticing menu of Ukrainian dishes. The service was warm and efficient, and it's clear this is a place run by people who genuinely care about their food and their heritage. They understood exactly what I was looking for, even if I didn't know the right word for it. Whether you're Ukrainian, Polish, or just someone who appreciates great Eastern European food, Olha's Market is worth a visit. I came in looking for something familiar and left with something even better: a new favorite spot and a little more knowledge about Ukrainian culture. My wife and I will definitely be back to try their pierogi and holubtsi for lunch, and we're curious to sample more of those baked goods! Slava Ukraini! Niech żyje Ukraina! Smacznego!

Lots of delicious pastry options!

Peri-Peri Chicken

See all

Sagewood Cafe

This is the only place in town that does serve food that is not fried and all homemade from Soups…read moreto Salads to the bread and cakes and cookies. A staple in Buffalo.

This place had the BEST homemade soup and sandwiches Cindy…read morethe Owner / Cook was great Cassidy was a great waitress Highly recommended we were heading back from Yellowstone FIVE STARS ***** Jay from Onalaska WI