I was very happy with my meal at Old Chicago. Tasty spaghetti and meatballs. The meatballs were exceptionally well seasoned and the spaghetti perfectly cooked to an al dente delight. My only beef with the meal was that they skimped with the bread. One small piece, not worthy of it's separate plate. But the meal was filling enough. Make your plan to visit. Quick Tip: Though my picture doesn't show it, there were a lot of folks inside. They were enjoying the comfortable dining experience. Give them a quick call to ensure that you can do the same. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Gillette, Wyoming

Convenient location with a good food selection, solid variety of beer on tap, and friendly, attentive waitstaff. The atmosphere is welcoming and makes for an overall pleasant experience. A good spot to stop in when you're in the area. read more

i ordered a thick crust OC pizza to go. Picked it up and got home to discover it was a thin crust, half missing pizza that I can't even identify what it is. i Don't go here often but when I do...it seems something is always messed up. read more

Great Atmosphere! Everything I've Tried Has Been Delicious! SKY was an Awesome Server! Look Forward To Returning!

First off, we had the best service we've had in a long time. Jakson, didn't miss a beat! A young man who truly enjoys taking care of his customers. He was extremely attentive, respectful & made us feel welcome The young man should be training others. The food was nothing short of amazing. I chose the chicken fried chicken & it was absolutely delicious. Hats off to the cooks, they definitely served us quality food beyond our expectations. My other half had the Whiskey Bleu burger, specially ordered & delivered with perfection. Both of us loved our meals, we highly recommend eating here if you want top service, excellent food & reasonable prices!! read more

My husband and I were traveling and this restaurant was close to our hotel. We were not overly hungry so a small pizza was perfect for us. The pizza came out hot and delicious. Service was good and I would definitely stop again. read more

Very solid four stars from this Yelper. Service was exceptional, food tasted great (had the Chicken Fried Chicken), and atmosphere was as well. This place gets VERY busy from 3:30 PM-on, so be aware (at least on Friday's). read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Gillette, Wyoming

See all

We went with our swim team. We were there for 2 1/2 hours and they didn't even give us half of our food. Then on top of that they charged 4000 extra dollars that they refused to refund. The food wasn't even worth that. Safe to say I will never go back read more

Food is always great! Service seems to take a bit long on some visits. Ordered a 'Tall' wing order that was nearly $18 and only got 9 wings! They were good, but not $2 per wing good. Also got some sweet potato fries that were great, but the portion size was laughable. read more

We are traveling cross country and stopped in Gillette for the night. We drove over 12 hours and just wanted some good comfort food. We were staying at the Candlewood Suites and just walked up here for some great food in a cool atmosphere. Daughter did not care much for her chicken but my son loved his pizza and my wife and I shared the Da Meats pizza. Wife and I each had a mixed drink while the kids both had lemonade. I normally don't eat at chain restaurants, but this was pretty damn good and exactly what we were looking for. read more

See all

Great happy hour. Normal Old Chicago, great service, consistently good food. Jo our server was efficient and attentive and explained the beers on tap. read more

See all

Worst group of waitresses I've ever met in my entire career being a food reviewer. Managers as well were nothing but rude and disrespectful towards me and other people there. If you like to not get screwed over chose a different restaurant. read more

IF YOU WANT TO LOSE 5 LBS IN 48 HOURS EAT HERE. I've been trying to diet and workout for years, never have I been somewhere as effective as Old Chicago (2/2) on forcing me to lose 5 lbs. The first time I tried the underdone chicken wings, the second time I had an undercooked pizza! Both were very tasty, even better was the 48-72 hours of food poisoning that followed! If you need to lose 5lbs fast, this is the place! read more

We stopped here for lunch and it was overall good. The spaghetti and meetballs, pizza, and salad were all incredible. We had one service issue where they mixed up our calazone with someone else's. They did however completely remove it from our bill and bring out the right one immediately. The atmosphere was definitely more dinner then lunch and they had professional eating on the television which was a little disturbing while eating your meal. Overall great experience! read more

We got takeout from here when staying at a nearby hotel, during a cross-country road trip. We had the deep dish pizza and the buffalo chicken rolls. Not the highest quality food, but tasty bar food type that we enjoyed in the moment and regretted in the morning, college style. They were also very skimpy on the order of fries (think smaller than a size small fries from McDonald's). read more

Was in the mood for a casual dinner, decided to go here. Me and my party of three were seated almost immediately. Drink orders were taken and delivered quickly. It took the food awhile to come to our table, service was kind of slow but it was also kind of busy. One person in my party got a pizza, he said he was unimpressed with the crust and that it could've been better. Another person got a burger and they said the sauce was pretty bland. My calzone was fresh and the dough was crisp but the flavors were pretty flat. Probably won't be back here, just okay food with friendly staff read more

Nothing special. Not great, it's okay. I'm kinda of indecisive to be honest. We were skeptical based on reviews on Yelp and I think they were pretty accurate. Service isn't overly impressive, my husband thought the waitress was being condescending when I asked questions but I didn't pick up on it, although I normally pick up on snarky people. We wouldn't go out of my way to come back, we ordered the artichoke dip and it was Luke warm and theres way more chips/garlic bread than dip, waitress didn't come back to check on us so we ended up eating all of it. Then we ordered Thai Pie pizza and it was good, the top was a little over cooked and the bottom was this soft but it was still good. The veggies on the pizza were fresh, which was a plus for me. It did come with broccoli though, and there was some but it looked like the picture below. Lastly, the bathrooms weren't great. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Thai pie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gillette, Wyoming

See all

Great patio, beer selections and food was fantastic. Server was exceptional, friendly and helpful when I'd asked for suggestions. Will have it on my list next time I come through town!! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - three glasses of beer on a table - Pizza Near Me - Gillette, Wyoming

Food was not very good. Spaghetti could use another 2 minutes. Sauce is just chopped tomatoes. Son ate a hamburger - took one bite and said it was nasty. Nothing else there he would eat. Spent $45 and only 1 person was able to eat. Just won't be returning. read more

Not my favorite restaurant in town, but they have a variety of food which is nice. The service is slow and not the best. There are some servers who are great but they don't last long because they're tired of picking up the slack of the others. The bartenders are slow unless you're sitting directly at the bar. I came in with my family once and sat in a booth in the bar area because that's what was available. We probably sat there 15 minutes before we got up and left due to lack of service. Nobody greeted us, got our drink orders or anything. Very disappointed. On the other hand, we have gone and sat in the dining area and the service was fast and great. If you do go, sit in the dining area even if it's a little longer of a wait. The restaurant is always packed but the food is good so I understand why. read more

The place itself is awesome,with good music.The service was okay not the worst or best.When she came over we ordered water to drink we were still trying to decide on what beer we wanted.This place has alot of good choices,the waitress said "water ok" with an attitude..Usually that's all we drink going out because it's what we like but with pizza yeah of course a beer..We only got one because of the server where we would have had more.Anyways my husband got a pizza which he loved and the cheese dip for pretzels was good.My calzone Chicago 7 was big but mainly dough,barely any toppings and it had 1 banana pepper in it,no red peppers like it said....overall it was ok food but want go back read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - a slice of pizza on a pan - Pizza Near Me - Gillette, Wyoming

Old Chicago Pizza is an Oasis. The patio is outstanding. I love the vibe here. I few bike from out of town, including mine, and tons of locals. A great spot if your missing a touch of sophistication in a Wyoming world. If you get a chance, sit in Dani's station. She is an Angel and will take care of you as you might expect from the left coast. A special girl in an average city. A great spot. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Outdoor Patio. - Pizza Near Me - Gillette, Wyoming

See all

Our table was dirty, the floor under and around our table had lots of food on the floor no one came to clean it up. Food was so so I have had better else where. This is a sport grill restaurant. I would not come back. Dirty! Dirty! read more

it sucked. I ordered appetizers and they wouldn't bring me the food. horribal service. never go here

I ordered 2 medium pizzas to go last week, got them home and the pizzas had no sauce, and we're cold and under cooked. I called and talked to the floor manager. She said she would cancel the order. That never happened. Call yesterday and asked for the GM to call me...still nothing. This place has really gone down hill. They should be shut down by the health department. read more

I had Tiara as my server and she was the best server I've ever had. She was super quick to bring orders and constantly checked up on our table. Super happy with my experience! read more

We love Old Chicago in Gillette as long as we have Tiara for our waitress. We request her every time! She is attentive and extremely personable! read more

I was utterly unimpressed with this place. I felt like they had a business model where they have a fancy building that's aesthetically nice, and pay for it by using the absolute cheapest ingredients while charging an arm and a leg for a pizza. I don't know if they get local business it seems like they're just trying to service people who come in for work. read more

Food was excellent! We had spaghetti and meatballs, lasagna, chicken fried steak, and turkey club. We all loved our food! Onion rings were also excellent. Service was good-server very attentive. We would go there again! read more

we waited so long to get service, when we did finally the waitress served the people whio came after us i feel like this place is not worthy of anyones money. the waitress are to busy playing with each others hair to know whats going on on your dime. awful place! I WAS GROSSED OUT WHEN I SEEN THE WAITRESS PLAYING WITH EACH OTHER HAIR, THEN HAND OUT MENUS TO PEOPLE WITHOUT WASHING THEIR HANDS read more

We ate here on 7/16/19. Good food. I had the calzone, which was huge, very tasty. Kids were happy with their dinners too. They had burgers- very generous portions, and wings were also good. The waitress was nice enough, but the service was very slow. read more

Good service but terrible covid-19 executions. Little to no workers were wearing masks and invaded personal space. Will not be coming back until this issue is addressed. read more

They have a fantastic Happy Hour. Summer was my bar tender, she stayed on top of keeping us hydrated. Food was awesome, drinks were awesome and had some great conversations with total strangers. read more

Really good food. Really spotty service. Last night (Sunday) an hour before closing - great service. Tonight at 8pm, patrons at half capacity, service was non-existent. After asking about my to-go dessert, and waiting some more, I had to leave. I'm disappointed that I won't get to try that new berry/cookie dessert. It looked good (in the picture). The food is 5/5, even compared to other locations. It's really, really good here. The service gets 0/5. There were nowhere near enough patrons there to justify the inattentiveness. That averages to 2.5 stars. We will go with 3/5 because sometimes good food is worth bad service. read more

okay, went back to try the pizza again, got a large. Hurrah its served in a deep dish pan. but....it is not deep dish, chicago style or not. it was fine, but nothing special. Honestly if you are going for pizza, Pizza hut is just as good as Old Chicago's deep dish. I still think that the casper location had honest to god Chicago Style deep dish, but I could be mistaken. Because that would mean either that Old Chicago has changed their way of cooking or that the gillette location just does it wrong (which is possible). So, go to old chicago's for a great happy hour, good food, but only so-so hand tossed style pizza. Service and prep has gotten alot better since they first opened. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - "Deep Dish" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gillette, Wyoming

Great food. Comfortable atmosphere. Great customer service. Skyla is good people and a fantastic waitress. If you are ever in Gillette. Stop by and get some excellent pizza. read more

Excellent service, I sat at the bar and was helped by a stunningly beautiful waitress. Thats definitely a plus. They had lots of great beers to try and most of them local. I ordered the chicago style deep dish pizza. It was so filling and so so so good. Would definitely come back if I didnt live in a different state... read more

Great service. One if the best calzones we have ever had with excellent, spicy Marinara. Yummmm We agree the music is too loud but the food and service made up for it read more

I came here for lunch on a business trip. I ordered a coke and a calzone. Food was good. So was the service. My problem was the music. It was upbeat and fun, but the themes of alcohol, sex and swearing would never allow me to bring my family here. There is no way I could sensor it all. To be clear, I take my kids to movies and do not hide them away from the real world, so I could handle a little here and there... this was just a bit too much. Tone it down a little and they would be good to go. read more

One of the best pizza places to eat!! I love the meatme pan crust is the bomb! I could eat it everyday!! You will not be disappointed by going here. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Gillette, Wyoming