The Sicilian was delicious crispy and loved everything about it. Highly recommend. Glad I stopped by.

Awesome slice made me homesick as close of not better than most places up in NYC try the margarita slice will not disappoint!!! Hey here when you got that pizza crave read more

Wow...wow...wow! I can't believe I just discovered this amazing pizza place in the Loop! I'm a Floridian but travel a lot.... So when the reviews said just like NYC pizza they were not lying! This is by far the BEST pizza in Orlando I have ever eaten (Orlando native as well)! The ingredients are all so fresh and after trying a slice of each....its still like a party with my taste buds! 5 minutes the boys devoured the garlic knots! Calzone was phenomenal with my custom added veggies! I will be back and tell everyone I know and all my Yelp peeps to give them a try! Best part....Local, family owned! It was a bit late but staff al super friendly. Being from Orlando we are the chain capital of the works! Chains are good but love supporting family owned too! I did a to go order, online and it was super easy compared to other pizza chains. With so many options for slices.....I'll be back to try some others! As others mentioned the sauce is so flavorful and prefect! Y'all have to come try them out! read more

See all

Love that they sell pizza buy the slice. Just walk in, few minutes for them to warm it up and done. Quick convenient and tasty.

The best pizza I have eaten outside of New Jersey.Have dined at the restaurant and take out many times ,they are always right on the money.Special one that we always order is Margherita pizza regular and one with extra garlic.Molto Buono. read more

I'm a Jersey transplant who has been searching for " really good" pizza. I have found it int his place!! Fresh ingredients, amazing crust with a hint of char!!! These guys are 2 years into this in a small strip mall space but I am truly addicted to their stuff!! My wife was traveling for a few days while I happened upon Pienezza's. All I could talk about was this pizza! For your own good, pick up the phone, call these guys and grab your pie!!! read more

I was extremely impressed with the Buffalo chicken Mac & cheese pizza. The grandma slice was another phenomenal pick. I enjoyed the little pepperonis they use because it reminded me of prince street pizza in New York! read more

See all

Very good pizza and calzone! Would definitely return again. Located in the Loop shopping center.

Very good pizza and my son loved the spinach fettuccine. I always take points off with "fountain iced tea". That sucks. Real tea is easy.

Our first visit and definitely won't be our last. It was Absolutely Amazing! Ordered a 16" Cheese Neapolitan, 2 slices of Sicilian and a Cobb Salad. The Salad was Very Fresh and looked like something out of a picture. Both pizzas were exactly the way I love it. You know it's Amazing when you're willing to scorch the roof of your mouth with molten lava cheese- totally worth it! Besides the incredible food- the staff was also Amazing! I also got distracted by the other beautiful pies he was creating- WOW!!!! read more

Listen I'm from North Jersey so pizza is king there. So if your from up north it's average at best. Decent regular slice. Their Sicilian was ok. Not much flavor. The dough is so so. I'm guessing it's the water. Not much seasoning. It's the best you're gonna get out here. read more

Please have your pizza maker guy wear a mask (coronavirus) who was working on the night of July 21th pizza overall was okay I asked for light cheese but it still had too much cheese on it overall experience was good **** have them wear the mask & gloves ****** nobody's wants to catch that Rona !!! read more

Pienezza Pizza - Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

Great pizza. Great value. Our favorite place. Really great menu. The pizzas are big also

Great pie's even the day after for reheat or cold as my son likes it. Good quality ingredients and taste fresh. The sides are very good also, read more

Surprisingly great pizza. Wasn't expecting much in Orlando but dang...I was pleasantly surprised. Dough has the right pull. Not too much sauce not too much cheese. Just right. read more

You know how you go through a drive-through and you get one of those expensive salads? Pay a lot less and get a delicious fresh salad for dinner. Their side salads are substantial. I got that, shared a personal pie and it was great. read more

One of my favorites. They make an excellent Sicilian style pizza. The crust is light and tasty. Very small and seating could be an issue. But if you have to wait it's worth your time. read more

Pizza is on point! Love the prosciutto nella neve pie!! This is a must try stop by the loop for a slice, you will not be disappointed.

If you are like me who seeks out real New York style pizza, then this is the place for you. First of all the place looks super clean and the customer service is on point. The worker's are super friendly. Now onto the pizza, I had a regular cheese slice which was super tasty the cheese and the sauce tasted real good then the second slice was a margarita slice and that to me was my favorite out of the two slices. I will highly recommend this place if you're looking for real Pizza with great customer service oh and the price is very good. read more

Pienezza Pizza - A regular cheese slice and a margarita slice. Amazing pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

Very solid food. Pizza is delicious and the pasta is good. I had the baked ziti and the sauce was good. I do wish it had a little more mozarella and a tad bit more salt as it was a little on the bland side, but I am a salt lover. The staff were very friendly, wishing everyone a Happy New Year. It's definitely a good option if you are in The Loop area. read more

Pienezza has a great selections of pizzas! I really enjoyed their friendly staff and clean atmosphere. Their Margarita pizza is sooooo good, a must try!! read more

Something is missing with the flavor. I'm a New Yorker and I keep it real. This ain't NY style pizza. It looks good, the customer service here is top notch, but the pizza is ehh... okay. I like that they have some creative options like the Mac and cheese with jalapeños slice that I ordered but the flavor is...missing. If I had to describe the flavor of the pizza here as a color it would be beige... a very bland beige. I really wanted to give this place five stars but beige flavored pizza isn't my jam. I had to add a bit of salt, garlic, and red pepper flakes with my take out order. Message me and I'll tell y'all where to go for the closest thing to NYC style pizza in this area. Maybe I'll give them another shot in the future. read more

See all

Took my girl here. The entire place is oozing positivity. They Served with smiles. The vibes made us feel right at home. You can tell the place is run by family, the love was practically floating out from the kitchen filling the whole restaurant. along with the great music playlist. That's besides the food. We ordered 2 slices of grandma pizza, something I haven't seen on a menu in FL anywhere. A medium chicken buffalo pie, and a large order of garlic knots. Every bite filled our faces with smiles. This place deserves 5 stars. read more

Decided to give this place a try. We ordered a cheese pizza and a spinach roll. OMG this place is the best pizza I've had in my 3 years in Orlando. This is now my new spot. read more

Visiting from Miami, came upon this place after reading reviews. Have to say this place is one of my favorite I've been to in Florida. Great service, I got in just before closing and without hesitation, they allowed me to order. Very friendly staff. The pizzas were amazingly good. Had a regular cheese as well as the Meat Monster both were equally great. This place will become our new "go-to" as we continue to visit Orlando. I highly recommend for pizza lovers. read more

Pienezza Pizza - Walking in just before closing time - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

Amazing ! Called ahead to ask about the vegan pizza and I was reassured it was one of their best sellers . They had a clean kitchen and staff was really nice. The pizza was great, no vegan cheese but that didn't hold back all the great flavor of the sauce and veggies. I was really impressed with the use of sesame seeds on the crust and garlic knots, I also ordered some kind of fries, have i no idea what it was but they were gone as soon as they were cool enough to eat. Very nice location, prime location at that. If I'm ever in Orlando/Kissimmee again I'll be here for a slice, or two . read more

Pienezza Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

I'm on a diet and ordered a cauliflower crust pizza, and they gave me a regular crust pizza instead which ruined my diet and made my stomach hurt. We specifically asked for cauliflower crust on the phone and repeated it 3 times and they STILL messed up. They said sorry it was because of the new girl they just hired. They should take this more seriously because some people are actually allergic to gluten and could've been sent to the Emergency Room. They get 3 stars because their calamari is good. Not sure if I'm coming back. The actual pizza flavor was just ok. I enjoyed the calamari more. read more

Best pizza in Central Florida. Try the Mama's Lasagna pizza with sesame​ crust OR the Grandma's square pizza. Both are AMAZING! read more

Pienezza Pizza - New menu as of June 2019 - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

See all

Love this place! Great atmosphere and good food. Everyone here is like family. Looking forward to coming again.

I was just reading the recent review by Ross K a fellow New Yorker. It's taken me almost 3 years to find Pienezza Pizza. Loved the Pizza, I'm a traditional large Cheese myself with no other toppings. As I travel to NYC often for work I've had pizza in all 5 boros plus NJ and Long Island and Pienezza stands with all of them. I will definitely be back probably at least once a week. My wife had a side of meatballs and the mixed vegetables and loved it. Thank you Pienezza for ending my need to search for good NY Pizza in the Orlando area. They had a sufficient dining area with around 7 tables plus a bar top and two outside high top tables. Also they were playing the best of Billy Joel. You cant beat a great pizza with scenes from an Italian restaurant playing in the background. Staff was great and very friendly. read more

Super friendly staff and really good pie. No much else to add. Everyone made us feel right at home, checked on us frequently and man what a really good traditional pizza. read more

I have waited for over 15 years to say this, I have finally vacationed in Florida and found the perfect pizza place. We have tried dozens of places but they have been a huge disappointment until I stumbled on Pienezza. You can tell they make the dough fresh and it's full of flavor. The sauce is flavorful, not too sour or sweet, and there is plenty of toppings. My pizzas where hot right out of the oven. It's definitely worth every penny. They only thing I wish was different is that the cannoli was bigger only because I had to share with my kids . This will be a place I go to each time I visit Kissimmee. read more

See all

Delicious fresh pizza, and generous with the toppings. The restaurant is clean and the staff are attentive! They tend to go heavy on the sauce so I always order light sauce and that's perfect for me. read more

Very good pizza!!! The crust is thin (which I like) & toppings are delicious. If you like ricotta get the Lasagna pizza. The meat lovers is great & the meatball is also very good. Definitely will try again!! read more

Cheese Pizza was 10/10 honestly I'm from New Jersey and if you know you know. This pizza was fire!

High quality pizza at an affordable price. We ordered the Sicilian pizza to go and it was the best Sicilian pizza we've had anywhere in the Orlando area. Though we weren't able to get it with the white sauce which we prefer (probably to keep its authenticity), it was delicious. Thick crust, mouthy texture with a nice chew, and bright flavorful sauce. Seems to be family owned and they were very smiley and friendly. We will be back for more, and definitely recommend to anyone near and far. read more

We vacationed in Orlando and decided to try Pienezza. I ordered a large meats specialty and a large sausage pizza. Pizza was delicious, ingredients tasted fresh, and the people working there were very nice. My whole family enjoyed the meal. I recommend this place and will return if I'm in Orlando again. read more

5/5 stars. My husband and I are from New Jersey and were in Florida on vacation. We came here TWICE on vacation, we liked it so much. Delicious vegan options, full of fresh and delicious ingredients. I absolutely loved it. read more

Great pizza, friendly staff. Wasn't bothered about the lack of dogs. We got a slice, a personal pizza, knots, and fries. The pizza is solid NY style, and the price point is very reasonable. I would strongly recommend it. My only reservation is about the fries, which I think should be rethought. But again, buy a slice for $2.50, fold it up, and you're in for a good time. read more

Great pizza, friendly staff. Had a large Hey Brooklyn and it was really good. Would definitely eat here again.