closest thing to new york pizza in all of orlando winterpark area, 10/10 always bringing the family here.

NYPD Pizza Review We stopped by NYPD Pizza on our way home after spending the day at SeaWorld, and it turned out to be a great choice. We arrived about 30 minutes before closing and were seated right away. Since they were getting ready to close, our waitress came over quickly to take our order, which was completely understandable. Despite the late hour, the service was friendly and efficient. We ordered a large pizza that was half cheese and half pepperoni, lemon pepper chicken wings cooked well done, and cinnamon sugar zeppoles for dessert. The pizza was absolutely delicious and easily the highlight of the meal. The cheese pull was everything you'd want from a great pizza, and every bite was fresh and flavorful. The wings were cooked well, but I was expecting a stronger lemon pepper flavor, as the seasoning was pretty mild. The cinnamon sugar zeppoles were the perfect way to end the meal--light, fluffy, pillowy, and absolutely delicious. Overall, I would definitely recommend NYPD Pizza. The pizza alone is worth the visit, and if I'm ever back in the area, I'd happily stop in again just for another pie. read more

See all

Solid NY style pizza in Orlando. Ordered the combination 14" pizza which was good and there were a good amount of ingredients. I wished the sausage had more flavor. The dough was very good and had a nice chew. Very reasonable pricing as well. Would definitely go back. read more

This place is conveniently located in the shopping center across the street from my hotel. And sometimes you just want some good pizza. The was very nice and knowledgeable. My waiter was extremely helpful in guiding me through the menu. The space is very clean. I sat in the bar area which is smaller, but nice with some TVs so you can watch the game. The garlic knots came highly recommended and they did not disappoint! They had the slightest crunch, were fresh, and smothered in fresh garlic. So good! They are $1/knot so you can get as little or as many as you want! They have a really good lunch special with 2 slices of pizza and a drink. I went with the classic pepperoni and it was delicious! As the name of the restaurant suggests, it is NY style pizza so they are larger slices. If you are looking for some great pizza and excellent garlic knots, this is the place! read more

See all

Nah. It's just OK. Location is nice, and there is a lot of space inside. Some odd vibe in between wait staff and managers - were arguing with each other right in front of customers. Besides that, the service was way too slow. The pizza was decent, but nothing much better than a Domino pizza. Price isn't too bad, but for the quality it was. Not a repeat read more

NYPD Pizza - Vegetarian - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

The food was bad! We ordered garlic knots, and a 18 inch half and half specialty pizza. One half was killer bee and the other was Manhattan meat. There was no flavor what so ever. Worst pizza I ever while visiting Orlando. Let me put it into perspective...we have had Burnt Pizza from flippers on I drive that tasted better. The marinara was absolutely disgusting...it was like tomatoes right out of the can. Way, way too tangy. My family is from New York...I am not, but I have been to Brooklyn many, many times. I have had pizza in NY many many times...this isnt it! I spent 50 bucks plus tip for food we cannot eat. Not sure how they have a 4.1 star rating at the time of my review. Maybe a bad night...idk...but it was a bad first impression. If you eat here...good luck! I will say that the food was made promptly after placing the order. The delivery guy is another story, but that's not the fault of the business. read more

See all

Eternally skeptical of a police themed spot but the pizza was REMARKABLY good! The service was prompt and friendly. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

I came to NYPD for a team lunch after a coworker recommended their great lunch special, and it didn't disappoint. For just $6, I got a soda and two large slices of pizza. The meal was delicious and very filling. Our server was fantastic. They were attentive with our drinks and quick to bring out everything we needed, including utensils, extra napkins, and sliced limes. We came during the lunch rush but were seated right away, and the wait for the food was reasonable. read more

NYPD Pizza - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Excellent pizza, nice salads and very good customer service. Its the place to go if you are in the area and want pizza.

I really have no idea who would give this anything higher, than a 1. I was in the area used Yelp and it was rated 4 stars. What a mistake, this is the same as domino's. The dough is very good, great chew. Toppings, I don't think it was real meat, the sauce has to be the worst I have ever, ever had. They say they are the best? They are close to the worst. Do not waste your time or money HORRIBLE read more

Came with some coworkers after a meeting. The lunch special did NOT disappoint- soda, 2 slices for $6! Yes! And, delightfully foldable, with just enough crispy to the crust. Service was friendly and quick without being overbearing, exactly what I expect from a NYC pizza counter. We were one of several groups in when I was there, so it was a little noisy and hard to hear, but considering speed and how busy the location was, not at ALL bad. Another of those times I wish it was nicer outside, because we found a spot in half shade but Florida sun is just brutal. read more

The food is great. I have been a few times already. The host and staff are attentive and super polite I recommend the meatballs (one time I just had the meatballs only they are so good and rich in flavor). It's an appetizer but just not enough to fill you up. Sadly I try to not eat the mitre pie each time.... I finish the entire pie The beers on draft and nice as well. I am happy to support this location. It's a pleasure honestly. read more

NYPD Pizza - This is a small Our Famous Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Food was good. I would get the mozzarella sticks again, I do wish though that it came with 6 and not 5. The cheese and pepperoni pizza were good. The dough would be on of my complaints it just wasn't crunchy like a NY slice would typically be. It also was not as flavorful as would like. The mozzarella sticks though were perfectly country and had a good flavor ! Like I would probably call the food average It's convenient though. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pepperoni slice cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Very good, heard so much about NYPD finally tried it and it lived up to the hype. I screwed up my own online order so I didn't get exactly what I wanted but it was still great pizza! read more

NYPD Pizza is located in a decent sized and relatively well-kept shopping plaza with plenty of parking l. The staff is friendly and professional and the place has a generally good ambiance and vibe. NYPD Pizza offers a pretty good pizza and I have been here a few times and the pizza is pretty consistent. I grew up in New Jersey and I always pretty much took it for granted that great pizza could be found on pretty much every corner. When I moved down here to sunny Florida, imagine my surprise and dismay to find that great pizza, or even good pizza, was not available on every corner. In fact, it was possible to not find pizza in a whole time. So, when you find good pizza, it is indeed a reason to celebrate and what better way to celebrate than with a slice of pizza in hand? I would definitely recommend here. read more

Well, I'm an NYC Boy...44 years' worth, so I consider myself quite knowledgeable about a good pie. Orlando is the last place I'd normally even come CLOSE to ordering a pie, much less having one delivered. Since I now live in the Tampa/Clearwater area, I have one spot we use on a regular basis and a second one on reserve. Meantime here I am in Tourist Trap Central for a week of R&R with my Queen Bee. Guess who wanted pizza? Anyway, I ran across this place which seems to make itself a living homage to my Native Land. I called to order and even tho the girl asked me to confirm a few things twice, she was pleasant and efficient. I only ordered a pie; nothing else. Thus, enter the Sandman: large Mariano add sausage (as an inveterate Yankee fan, I get the reference). Read the description of a pie with garlic, tomato, fresh basil and olive oil; sounded nom noms so there we go. 45-55 minute delivery. Less than 35 minutes later: ding dong! Delivery dude was very nice as well. I preface the pizza itself with the caveat that it was delivered rather than eaten at the restaurant. The crust was certainly baked toward the well done side and had a fairly decent chew for being a fairly thin crust. It didn't taste old; a lil dense but not doughy by any means. Slightly sweet note on the back end as well, so a fairly decent dough overall. Nice amount of toppings too. Queen Bee thought there was too much mutz on the pie; I disagree. The mutz was of good quality also. Had there been too much, then the whole mess might've flopped rather than pass the "fold" test. THAT would've resulted in a one-star review! Since we are only gonna be here another couple of days, it doesn't really allow much time to try other stuff on the menu or even visit them for a fresh slice at lunch. Too bad, because the names of many of their items make me wanna try these people again. Suffice it to say that next time we stay here,it'll be a sure stop. This NYC boy is happy! read more

See all

Joint arrival we were seated immediately. The staff is friendly and patient. We came on a whim because we were wanting a slice of pizza. The ambiance is very NYPD-ish so the name is fitting! Pizza was okay for me, I was expecting larger slices, the garlic rolls were hot and fresh so that was nice. The location is great, and near all the attractions. Stop in and try for yourself. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Every time we are in the Orlando area we try to eat at NYPD Pizza at least once. The service is always prompt, and the experience is always great. We were at a school resource conference this week at Shingle Creek, and stopped in for a salad and mozzarella sticks. Everything was great, as usual and the price was right compared to most of the Orlando area. It's a great atmosphere loaded with NYPD and other NY memorabilia, and it's a draw for local first-responders, law enforcement and other public services professionals. We also opted for the slice of the day on our last day in Orlando, and it was excellent! Try it once and you'll probably enjoy it. read more

This place was delicious. From my salad to the sandwich and garlic knots. Everything was perfect. read more

Been coming to this place for years! Food is hot and fresh! The service has always been nice! Moved away from Orlando but still get here to this place now and then! Do miss them and great value a good pizza! Pepperoni roll is always a must! read more

This is one of the Orlando locations on Universal. Located in a strip mall with lots of parking. Food (3.5/5) - had the Margherita and it was average overall in my opinion. It's NY style in ways but I was hoping it would have a bit more of a traditional Margherita taste. Wasn't sure if was San Marzano or not.. bit bland to me. Service (4.5/5) - very attentive and friendly from the host to the order person. Pizza from order to table in about 15 minutes. Atmosphere (4/5) - pretty good layout with tables and booths. Also TVs for evening snack and a beer. Overall (4/5) - it's a good spot and solid overall. Kinda wanted the Margherita to be bit more flavourful but will return and try out some of the other choices too. read more

NYPD Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Pizza was good and authentic New York style, but kind of pricey. Service was quick and friendly.

I don't usually leave reviews, but after what happened to my friend, I'm genuinely furious. She's vegan and gluten-free for serious health reasons -- not by choice, but because she has to be. Eating out is already a challenge for her, and instead of risking her health, she brought her own small, pre-made meal just so she could still sit with everyone and enjoy the outing. The second she opened it, one of the waitresses rushed over and snapped, saying something along the lines of "No, you're not allowed to eat that. There's a clear sign out front. Not only was the tone completely disrespectful and condescending, but it felt like they were going out of their way to make her feel embarrassed and unwelcome in front of everyone. What do you think you are? Disney? And it gets worse -- the manager doubled down, offering ZERO empathy, ZERO options, and acting like she was a problem just for existing. There was no attempt to be understanding, no kindness, no solution -- just cold, rude dismissal. Let's be real: hospitality isn't just about food, it's about how you treat people. Especially those with dietary restrictions that aren't just preferences. NYPD Pizzeria failed completely. The way my friend was treated was unacceptable, and I'll never support a business that makes someone feel so small for simply trying to protect their health. The pizza was mediocre at best. read more

This place was only okay, the wings weren't bad they just didn't have enough sauce (I asked for extra hot sauce for our wings, and they charged me for it). The pizza left a lot to be desired. It just lacked texture, flavor, and everything that you love in a pizza. The waitress acted as if she didn't want to be at work that day, so it was just not a great experience overall. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza was nothing to write home about. - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

I like this place & we have contract close by. There are a few good places around here that are reasonable to grab a bite & a drink. I don't care for the fact that the bar seating is often half occupied by kitchen staff which would be against policy at most establishments. So great for a bite - bar seating leaves a bit to be desired. If you prefer bar seating - Beth's burgers is just across the parking lot read more

The pizza is full of flavor and worth the buy. The service is convenient and easy to get. The ambiance is family oriented. I recommend this restaurant. read more

We came to waste some time And are we glad we did! The Baked Ziti was hot and delicious and enough for us to share. I love that it was served in an oval casserole dish which kept it hot til the last bite. It came with a choice of salad, garlic knots or soup. We got the salad and ordered an extra. We also bought a bottle of Cab and took half home--a much better deal. read more

See all

Their meatballs are not meatballs. Do not order in pizza or calzones it is just unseasoned ground beef it is an insult to all who know good food. read more

The pizza was good (former New Yorker ) considering its in Florida , but the service was excellent.. enjoyed looking at the New York signs and the bar was packed as well as most if not all the tables read more

NYPD Pizza - Store sign - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

My wife is from NYC and I grew up in the northeast as well, so we know good pizza and NYPD Pizza was a letdown. We tried 3 different slices (pepperoni, cheese, and sausage/mushroom) and it was surprising how little flavor there was in the pepperoni and the sausage/mushroom tasted exactly like Domino's. We also had a side salad and the feta cheese on it was flavorless as well. This was unfortunately a disappointing meal and we won't be trying NYPD Pizza again. read more

See all

Can't beat 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $6!!!! If you want to add toppings $0.80 each. The pizza slices are almost Costco size! Pizza was tasty and I would go back for the lunch special. My son got the wings and said they were good. read more

NYPD Pizza - Lunch special and wings. - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Main reason for going here was because some yelper complained he didnt have cell service and that the restaurant didn't have WIFI. He also made a political comment. None of these things need to be in a yelp review. He gave the restaurant 2 stars based on those reasons. I wanted to check out the restaurant and gave it 5 stars. The food I had was great. Pizza was cheesy and the eggplant sandwich with fresh mozzarella and balsamic glaze was better than the pizza. It was a busy lunch when we went. Service was great and the food came out promptly. BTW not sure who Jeff is but I loved his response to the yelper who couldn't make a call or use his WIFI. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

The pizza here is excellent. It's flat and still stands up well. These people know how to make a NYC pizza. They really need to teach and train the NYPD in Hunters Creek how to make a New York style pizza that isn't soggy and puffy. They could use the help since their pizza isn't close to the one on universal blvd read more

We ate here twice in one week. And they consistently awesome. The knots were crispy, flavorful (lots of garlic) and tasty. The pizza (Queens Deluxe Pie) had an even distribution of toppings. The crust was crisp and not soggy middle (even as we ate it). It didn't fold over when picking up the slices. And top it all off, it's affordable (a change from the area). Our servers were top notch, she was all about "Pitter Patter - Letterkenny". This is our new goto location when visiting. read more

NYPD Pizza - Wonderful Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

First time here but have heard good things. The staff was friendly and when asked what was good recommended the wings and calzones (obviously pizza was recommended as well). I ordered hot boneless wings which were supposed to be good (as they were recommended), However the actual wings were not hot and I mean spicy and temperature wise it was more room temperature and it was more like the most mild mild sauce I've ever tasted. This one missed the mark. French fries were wonderfully seasoned hot and fresh and not greasy. Can't get any better than this for french fries. The garlic knots were the perfect temperature when it came out. The flavor was good tasted like garlic knots but not the crappy kind that's doughy or overly buttered. Came with a side of marinara sauce for dipping appropriately, this is some thing that I would definitely order again. Last but not least the Pièce de résistance Cheese pizza. The pizza came out hot, the dough was thin but not so too thin. The cheese and sauce were perfect ratio, the crust was not too thick and not too chewy which is essential when you want to do the classic New York fold to eat the pizza. Truthfully I usually add some buffalo hot sauce to most pizzas, but this pizza didn't need it. although this is my first time here I'll definitely come back. read more

See all

We ordered a medium pizza topped with fresh mozzarella, sausage, and oregano. The dough was fresh, but a little off, as it ripped apart before I could fold it. The cannoli was good average. Our waitress was very nice and fast to bring us refills and check on us. The price was modest for a medium pie at $19. There's much better pie at 5 Star pizza and one other in St Augustine. This joint might be the best for the area, but I don't consider it anywhere near the level of Rays Pizza in NY. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

I just hit them up right before the storm, my 85 year old dad loves how perfect their pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom pizza is. Great tasting and the wings!!!! Stellar! Easily the best in Orlando. Great bang for your buck as they deliver. Fast service and friendly staff as they always greet you with grand smiles and happy to please attitude, We love this place! Great family environment! read more

Very disappointed with the pizza. I had the high expectations because I grew up in New York and I was hopeful that I would get a taste of a great New York pizza while here in town. Sorry, but not even close. Closest thing to the pizza is Costco pizza. I ordered a half plain cheese pie and half margherita. The pizza was not cooked enough. It's still doughy near the outer edges of the pie. The slice is not even crunchy and when you fold it in half it flops right over. Way too much cheese on the plain side and the margherita side did not have fresh basil or tomato. I called the manager after we left and she listened to what I said and she just gave a "meh" answer and doesn't seem to care either way. I was hoping not to write this review, but after that response I want to make sure others don't get suckered into thinking this is a NY pizza place. read more

first off this was our first time here and was the greatest pizza we have ever had. great server and everyone was friendly. they messed up one of our pizzas gave us cheese when we asked for pepp (which was no big deal) then proceeded to let us have the cheese pizza and brought us out some dessert in which we didn't have to pay for. definitely reccomend this place to anyone visiting orlando. read more

I had a pretty disappointing experience here that I think other people with dietary restrictions should know about. I'm vegan and gluten-free due to health reasons, and when I visited this restaurant, I brought a small meal with me--just in case I couldn't find anything suitable on the menu. Unfortunately, I was told I couldn't bring in my own food, even after I explained my dietary needs. I totally understand that restaurants have policies, but I wasn't trying to take advantage--just trying to eat something safe for me. It was frustrating and honestly a bit disheartening to feel like my health needs weren't taken seriously. The staff was super rude for no reason I even had to get the manager. Overall the place was nice but I wouldn't come back. read more