Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pigeon Creek Saloon & Eatery

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed Closed

    Pigeon Creek Saloon & Eatery Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Pigeon Creek Saloon & Eatery

    Recommended Reviews - Pigeon Creek Saloon & Eatery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 1,058 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    La Fête

    La Fête

    4.2(63 reviews)
    28.2 mi

    La Fete is a wonderful restaurant & the best dining in North Wilmington. We've eaten here 3 times…read morefrom dinner with the duck for 2 & other mains the first month to supper in the lounge & everything was great. The foie gras, steak frites, chocolate mousse & all the courses were amazing. Don't miss this new gem - the ONLY real French food in "our city."

    We were excited to learn that there was a new French restaurant that didn't require traveling to…read morethe city. I wish I could say I was excited after dining there for the first time but I have to say I was left somewhat disappointed. I can overlook most things, but when dining out i go for the food. And the food was just OK. We started out with cocktails. Two of us ordered from the unique signature cocktail menu and one of us just decided to have their usual Kir Royale. Of these three drinks, the Kir Royale was the best. Neither of the others thought that their drink was so great that they would order it again. A young man showed up at our table with three small dishes, asking, "Are you familiar with amuse bouche"? Yes I am. I don't need an 18 or year old to try to make me feel like he knows more than I do. It was condescending at best and just pretentious. He explained it was compressed cantaloupe with a mint oil and a touch of salt. If I had closed my eyes, I never in a million years would have tasted anything except a little bit of salt and a little bit of water. It was flavorless. For appetizers, we shared the snails, the rabbit poutine, and the foie gras. Both the snails and the poutine came with a sauce, and the servers almost insisted on pouring the sauce over the appetizer. One of us opted to stop the server because why would you bring it on the side and then not let me elect how I want it on there. That just did not make sense. There's no theater here you're just pouring. The snails were served in a vol-au-vent and were kind of lost in the too tall puff pastry. Both the snails and the poutine were lacking some serious flavor. The best bite of the appetizers was the piece of foie gras which was served on a comparatively mammoth-sized sleepy zucchini bread and with pickled local strawberries. I didn't care for the combination and for the price, the two bite piece of foie gras was not worth it. (understand you can drive 3 miles to a restaurant that puts more of it on a burger for that equivalent price.-plus you get an 8 oz burger). The pickled strawberry did not work either. We also order the "bread service." I don't like paying for bread but was intrigued by the bone marrow butter upsell. For $20 you get 5 slices of bread, some salted butter, and at most a tablespoon of bone marrow butter. Skip it. Not worth it. For entrées, we ordered the salmon and the duck for two. The salmon was supposed to be seared, but the presentation side looked more like it had been steamed or poached. Perhaps they seared the skin side, but this particular diner did not like salmon skin, so that was lost on it. The diner did not like couscous, which was the side that came with this dish so they asked for the pomme puree as a substitute. The potato purée was also lacking seasoning and of course we got charged $8 for the substitution even though this potato purée is a side for other entrées. The server who took our order recommended the duck. I'm a big fan of duck so our other dining partner indulged me and shared this entrée with me. The duck came with two breasts, two confit legs, baby carrots, cooked in duck fat and a frisée salad. This was probably enough for three people because we took home 1/4 of a duck breast, a whole leg and plenty of carrots. The duck breast was well rendered of the fat, and the skin was crispy. I like a medium rare duck breast but the underside was very rare as if it was never flipped in the pan. The leg was delicious (probably tossed in the deep fryer before serving to crisp the skin) but the carrots were heavy with fat. Very little frisée was served (almost as a garnish ) and it really needed more of it that acid from the dressing to lighten things up. Again the server tried to pour the sauce that came with it over the breast without asking if I wanted it first. I stopped them because I know how much I want and I know where I want it. I don't need you to do that for me. One cocktail, one appetizer and one entree per person was $100 per person on average. No tax in DE Service here is amateurish with training. I have already cited a few things. The waitress who took our order poured water for each of us spilling a significant amount when pouring one glass, said I'm sorry I misjudged. Bad depth perception, she said and continued on with her opening spiel which we got to hear in almost the exact same fashion as she greeted other tables. No offering to change the tablecloth of its two foot diameter circle of wetness. She just kept it moving. We came dressed business casual. We were the best dressed there. Lots of shorts and casual wear. This is not a fancy place. People appear to come as they are. I just did not get that I want to come back here feeling. Service was not great. Food was just ok and not ok for the price. Atmosphere is more American bar than French bistro. I am not super charged to go back.

    Photos
    La Fête - Entrance

    Entrance

    La Fête
    La Fête

    See all

    Next of Kin  - Art of The city

    Next of Kin

    4.7(75 reviews)
    31.9 miFishtown

    We had a large party (6).the attendant at door, got us in quickly, on a Saturday night!…read more We enjoyed exploring the vast drink menu. The visit was a great experience.

    Next of Kin is a special vibe. It's got the energy of a neighborhood dive with the aesthetic and…read moremixology prowess of a swanky cocktail haven. It is intimate, friendly, down-to-earth, and totally unique. I don't visit Philly as often as I'd like (I live in NYC but grew up here) and while I'm always keeping up with dining scene, it's rare and thus special when I get to put a space to the name, so the speak. Next of Kin has a quirky, playful, impressively creative menu with drinks that are memorable. We came here at around 10:30pm on a Saturday night after dinner. There was a bit of a line outside which moved slowly, but we were given cute champagne jello shot things for our patience which were delightful and a fun little preview of what to expect on the inside. The seating options consist of tables, bar, and what I believe they call "love pods", all of which are beautifully designed. We were seated at the bar, which is our preference anyway. I always like chatting with the bartenders and hearing about the craft, and it is particularly enjoyable when they're as friendly and generous as the folks who work here. We were talking to them about some of their infusions and they let us try a taste of the coconut mezcal and the bruleed banana infused rum and both were unreal on their own. We ended up getting the Coco Bello (coconut mezcal, apertif, aromatized wine) which is a white negroni variation and the Swamp Thang (green chartreuse, herbal liqueur, pineapple and poblano tepache), which was served in some particularly memorable glassware (pictured). Both drinks were exceptional and complex, the former more sophisticated and the latter wacky and wholly unique.

    Photos
    Next of Kin
    Next of Kin  - Godfather Cocktail.

    Godfather Cocktail.

    Next of Kin  - The single greatest duo booths of our time.

    See all

    The single greatest duo booths of our time.

    Midtown - Menu

    Midtown

    4.5(20 reviews)
    18.0 mi

    Wow! what a find Brittnay my server was exceptional. She knew exactly what I wanted. Started off…read morewith the Paper plane, and it was awesome. Had the house salad and the Picana. It was fabulous. Service was amazing and so was the food. Can not say enough about Brittany and her service. Very friendly and efficient and loved her job. Food was amazing as the cabernet from paso. I will be back. Lots of food for the money. Loved this place.

    I was debating between 3 and 4 stars because it was definitely a 3.5-star experience but that's not…read morean option. Service was great. Ambiance is lovely--great decor, comfortable seating, a gorgeous bar, and live music. Fun cocktails and a solid wine list (though the "by the glass" options are a bit limited). Ultimately, though, I think the ambiance and service are doing the heaviest lifting here--it's a bit of a "vibe dining" spot. The food is definitely good, don't get me wrong...but it's not "wow," which was a little disappointing given that you're gonna be spending $$$$. (Most entrees are $30+ and they're pretty standard fare that's not especially inventive--steaks, a few pastas, obligatory short rib dish, elevated burgers, salmon.) We liked everything just fine but I didn't taste a dish that made me go "oh man, I gotta come back for that." Instead I'm thinking "maybe I should try something else next time I'm in." I do like that your entree comes with a salad. The physical menu itself could also use some work, as its quality doesn't match the care and luxury atmosphere of the place overall. Numerous misspellings and a lack of specificity on ingredients in several of the dishes that leave the diner unclear on what, exactly, they're getting. For example, there's an entree that's described simply as "grilled chicken breast served with rosemary potato wedges and grilled zucchini." Are there spices or sauces on that chicken? Are we talking just plain salt/pep? Herbs? What? Anyway, it's fine. It's a solid date night option. We'll be back.

    Photos
    Midtown
    Midtown
    Midtown - Tres major steak

    See all

    Tres major steak

    Big Phil's Bar & Grill - Seafood Trio

    Big Phil's Bar & Grill

    4.2(125 reviews)
    2.7 mi
    $$

    Tried this place because of a Resy promotion. Nice ambiance, has a modern feel…read more Service was ok. They brought the salads at the same time as the entrees which is very odd. The food was just ok. I had the New York steak and it had a giant tendon running through it making half it inedible. Expected more for the price of the food. Don't think I would go here again.

    Converted TGI Friday's located in the former Coventry Mall. Restyling of interior- you quickly…read moreforget your dining in an abandoned chain restaurant inside an uninhabited mall. Upgraded color palette, marble countertops & bar, & spacious booths; some patio seating out front. Inviting. Elevated drink offerings & a bar staff that was friendly & attentive to our needs. Table visit from owner who shared history & vision of space & desire for us to see place as a comfortable spot for repeat business. Bacon-Wrapped Shrimp app- 'twas delicious! Firm, decent-sized, shrimp w/ crisp, salty, exterior of bacon served on smear of aioli. Patty Melt was a simple presentation; 2 thin smash patties, 3 buttery-grilled pieces Texas Toast, & patty sauce which appeared to be just a ketchup/mustard mix. I'm used to a little more going on w/ my patty melts- fried onions, Thousand Island, something- but I'd be a liar if I didn't say it was tasty & I would order it again! BP Cheesesteak, again, simple presentation, but well executed. Beer battered fries in place of chips for upcharge. Dishes priced a bit high for what's presented. I'd like to see a few more menu choices (if there are Specials they weren't mentioned during my visit) in order to make this a routine dinner spot vs. occasional bar lunch, but I look forward to a return visit!

    Photos
    Big Phil's Bar & Grill
    Big Phil's Bar & Grill - Fish & Chips

    Fish & Chips

    Big Phil's Bar & Grill - Chicken Pot Pie

    See all

    Chicken Pot Pie

    Pigeon Creek Saloon & Eatery - tradamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...