The food is good but their businesses practices are poor. The menu on their website says Crab Cake Platter $10.99 and Salmon Platter $8.50. My husband ordered and I went to pick-up. We thought the total would be $20-ish. I was flabbergasted when they said $39. They claim that crab prices have tripled. If that's the case they owe it to their customers to update their website and also tell the total to the person ordering. Simply because of today's experience, we won't be back. I should have told them to keep the meals and walked away. read more

Pistol Pete's Seafood - Menu - Seafood Markets Near Me - Bristol, Pennsylvania

the best fresh and prepared seafood around! i love this place. fried, broiled or fresh...it's the best!

Pistol Pete's now has sushi! I adore fresh seafood and I am quite lucky to have plenty of seafood markets nearby. This is one of the larger ones offering a vast selection of fresh fish and if they do not have exactly what you are looking for they try to get it for you with a days notice. One of the nicest things about Pistol Pete's is they are also an eatery where you can order you name it and it will be prepared just for you, yay! Different forms of fish and chips, fish or shellfish platters or sandwiches, wraps, raw clams, oysters, shrimp cocktail, the list is as long as any great seafood restaurant would be. I am not real thrilled with their crab cakes, a bit bland and the ratio of crab to fillers could be tipped to the meaty side. However they are known for their salmon cakes and I guarantee you will not find a better tasting one. A wide variety of very fresh fish, raw or cooked shellfish, soups, bisque's and chowders, when they have their shrimp or crab soup with black beans and Anduollo sausage do order it! They have a nice sized case full of ready to be cooked stuffed fish and shellfish, breaded shrimp or they will cook anything for you there to eat in or take home. Pistol Pete's is locally owned and operated, this is their only store and the downside to that is it is located inside the Bristol Amish Market which is only open Thursday through Saturday. However, Pistol Pete's does have their own website and can be contacted by phone for information or ordering http://pistolpetesseafood.com/default.html If you go to the Bristol Amish Markets website you can download monthly coupons, this month it is 10% off fresh fish purchases and it does come in handy since they are on the pricey side http://www.bristolamishmarket.com/index.php Nothing fishy about this seafood shop, variety, convenient for meals to go or eat in, cooked or uncooked, Cajun, blacked, broiled or fried, great soups and the salmon burger baby! Oh and you do know how much I love fish and chips, here you can choose between cod, flounder or Yuengling Lager battered haddock. Crabs, clams and lobsters, oh my! read more

See all

Wow, just wow. I go to the Amish Market once a month and sometimes I go there just to get to Pistol Petes. I love it. The food is always good and fresh... it is everything you can think of. read more

Ordered by phone . Order ready when arrived. Went home and no Crab Soup. Called and he said sorry next time you come in I will give you one. Of course it's never the same when you're expecting it for dinner. next day he gave back the cash as I requested. Good. Crab stuffed shrimp and crab stuffed mushrooms dry lots of filler didn't care for them. Fries not crispy a little soggy but edible. Slaw good. Take out platters no cocktail sauce, no tarter sauce, no napkins or plastic wear to eat with. It should have been each box for on the go. Any time I purchased platters to go they always included plastic wear , salt, pepper, sauces for eating anywhere. read more

I've never been too impressed (and cannot understand the rave reviews on here) with anything from this place but this last visit has convinced me to never buy food from here again. I got lobster bisque and was really looking forward to eating it for dinner that night. I sat down for dinner and took a spoonful of soup and yuck! Thin and watery, no chunks of lobster, no smooth creaminess, awful taste! It was the worst soup I've ever had! It tasted salty and too fishy. I can't even look at this place when I go to the market anymore or I feel like gagging. Never again! read more

Super fresh seafood! Pretty much better then you're going to get anywhere. Staff is super friendly. Love that there cocktail sauce is actually spicy. Only thing I'm not a fan of is the "stuffed with crab" items. But that could be personal preference because I don't care for ol' bay seasoning. read more

I really like this place. I could eat their salmon burgers &/or their blackened salmon wraps daily. I love them both with the Vidalia onion vinaigrette. I've tried and enjoyed a number of other items but I love these two so much that I just keep coming back to them. I also love picking up raw seafood that I can take home and grill up for my family. My work orders from PP occasionally & the fried shrimp seems to be a big hit at the office as is the broiled cod. I feel like the stuffed mushrooms, loaded baked potatoes, and mac & cheese ball might use the same/similar ingredients as they all taste very much alike. They're good, though. The only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is because their soup makes me burp like crazy(likely my issue, not theirs) and I don't like how they have the raw shrimp next to the cooked shrimp. After years in restaurants when I was younger I have a deadly fear of cross contamination. (again, likely my issue, not theirs. I'm sure they're very careful). Over all - I would highly recommend giving this place a try & I can't wait to go back! read more

I have gotten salmon from here several times and have been satisfied with it. With that said, be prepared to have customers cut the line to pick up food they have previously ordered. This is condoned by the staff for some reason. They really should have two lines (a separate one for food pickup), or the person behind the counter should put a stop to this as it gives the other customers a bad experience - yes, even the ones that don't say anything. read more

I really used to like Pistol Pete's seafood. I buy raw, and cook it myself. Lately the quality has gone downhill. The clams casino had bits of clam shell and sand in them the last two times, the salmon burgers were gross because it seemed like they used all the scrap. read more