I love this place. The tomato sauce is really fresh crushed tomatoes. If you prefer a more marinara like sauce, this might not be your jam. BUT , and I like big buts, if you like fresh tomatoes, fresh ingredients, and brick oven pizza then my friend this IS your jam! The cheese is fantastic, the shop is small, all they do is make great pizza. Crust and dough is on point. Plus if you go to the Windermere Brewery you can order the pizza at the bar and they will deliver it, with paper plates and napkins. Awesome local business, amazing pizza, make sure to give this a try! read more

See all

Disappointing. Only 5 star reviews preceded mine. And I thought over in the way to a 5 star review as well. The order process was simple. The staff was friendly and helpful, both on the phone to order and in person. The little building is beautifully situated and a very pleasant space. Great spot to sit outside and enjoy your pizza. For my first visit I ordered simple as I always do on a first visit to a new-to-me pizza restaurant. And Pizza 14 does ONLY pizza. I had plain cheese on half, pepperoni on a quarter and sausage/peppers on a quarter. The box was sturdy, not going to leak through. The pizza was gorgeous and I was so excited. But it had no taste. I didn't taste the sauce. I didn't taste any seasoning. Very bland. I hope this was an outlier. It wasn't bad. It simply wasn't good. Certainly not great as I expected. I'll try them again, though. read more

See all

This Windermere pizza spot is heavenly. I don't know what they put in their pizza but it is GOOD! reminds me so much of the pizza from our honeymoon in Venice. The flavors are amazing, crust is perfectly crisp but still soft. Cheesy and sauces in the perfect portions. This is a take and eat kind of spot. No indoor seating available. They do have a few tables outside with umbrellas. Parking is located on the side of the building. The sweetest gentleman is always working and the owners are absolutely lovely. read more

Pizza 14 - Outside entrance and seating area - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Straight forward pizza joint with a limited menu and hours. Pizza 14 is located in a charming shared space building with a wrap around porch. You can call to order or walk in to the small shop to place your order. Their menu is simple- just pizza! We ordered a white pizza and took a seat outside on the porch to wait. It was quickly delivered to us with paper plates and napkins. The pizza was delicious! Next time we will try a red pizza. I'd also recommend walking down the street for an ice cream for dessert. read more

Pizza 14 - Bianca Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I really like this place. It looks like they're using a nice hot wood burning oven to cook the pizzas and I think that flavor really translates well. The crust has a great overall flavor and is nice and salty with a deep fermented and yeasty bread flavor. It has a beautiful charred undercarriage that still doesn't make the dough overly tough or difficult to eat. I think they achieved a good balance of a crispy outside with a tender inside. The tomatoes used on the pizza were bright and beautifully vibrant and sweet. What I liked most about their pies was the salt levels. A lot of shops serve mostly bland and under-seasoned pizzas, but the salt levels on these were perfect. Maybe it's because they top them with real grated parmesan, or they make a dough with proper percentages so salt, but it was nice to actually taste something in a pizza for once. Overall: very fresh ingredients as evident by the tomatoes. A perfectly balanced crust, both texture and taste. Wonderful salt levels from the cheese. Added bonus: the service is top notch and everyone is extremely nice and professional. It's somewhat hidden but if you're nearby I highly recommend stopping in to give them a try. read more

Pizza didn't really have flavor. Tomatoes tasted straight out of the can. Pretty expensive ($40 for 2) for a simple, 1 topping, small pizza. The crust was the best part and even that was bland, but the crunch helped. read more

Good Pizza & service. Nice location w/limited convenient parking. Fair prices for quality ingredients. Small menu with the basics. Hoping for future growth for Pizza 14. Glad to support small business! read more

Pizza 14 - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Good pizza! Comfortable al fresco dining only, so be sure you go on a nice day or ready to take to eat elsewhere. They serve soda in a glass bottle and the menu said cane sugar, I didn't get a soda but I'm happy to see they serve the GOOD soda! The ingredients on the pizza were fresh and the flavors were great. We got pepperoni, mushrooms and black olives. The 14" pizza was the perfect amount for 2 very hungry people. The two guys working were very nice and hospitable. read more

Pizza 14 - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

So this is a tiny little place, tucked away in Windermere. But it's worth a find. The pizza is cooked in a oven, yes menu is a little limited.. no they don't have chicken wings, subs or anything else.. but hey it's decent pizza, so give it a go. read more

Pizza 14 - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Very glad I finally tried Pizza 14. Not only do they have great service, they have the best pies that Ive been able to find in this area. The ingredients are fresh and the pizzas are absolutely delicious! There's a nice little seating area out front if you want to eat there. read more

I was hesitant at first because the reviews sounded a little too good to be true, for it to be a perfect "5 starts" but honestly now I understand why. It's in the middle of a white building next to a body building gym. It gives an Italian ambiance, there's no seating inside only outside but it's kept really clean. They have a brick wood oven so the crust comes out extra crunchy. One pizza which was 14" was filling for my man and I. The owner is extremely sweet, it was him and his partner making all the pizzas and he took time to bring us our pizza and then come back around to ask us what we thought about it. Definitely will be coming back. Highly recommend! read more

We've been eyeing Pizza 14 for sometime now and finally checked it out and it did not disappoint! Very fresh and delicious! You can tell it's good quality ingredients in the pie! Will definitely be back in the future. read more

Pizza 14 - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

A bit small at only 14" but pizzas are fast and delicious! Realized that we needed to order an extra pizza to have enough!

We have ordered a few times from Pizza 14 & have always enjoyed the food. Jake helped us with our most recent order on the phone and had excellent customer service! We can't wait to order again soon! read more

Pizza is amazing! I lived in NYC for a while and I search every city I visit for something to compare to good NYC pizza. This place hits this spot. The crust is the perfect amount of crunch. Ingredients are quality. Nothing in Orlando tops this place for me. read more

Pizza 14 - White Margarita! Sooo good. - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

My favorite pizza in Orlando area. Thin crust offerings. Staff is friendly. Pick up only. Parking is convenient.

Amazing pizza here at Pizza 14, I was thoroughly impressed with the experience here and it's clear that the dough is handmade fresh everyday. read more

One of our favorite pizza spots! Don't let the simplicity of the menu fool you - all the ingredients are fresh and pizzas are all delicious. They only have take-out or patio dining, so keep that in mind! One recommendation would be to have beer/wine offered. I think they sell beer/wine but only to go (like, at your home, not on their property). We typically enjoy on site vs take out, but it would be nice to enjoy pizza with a cold beer or nice glass of wine occasionally! read more

We were passing through town and looking for a cute spot to eat outdoors with the kiddos. Pizza 41 was the perfect spot with the greenery view and across from Town Hall. The food was phenomenal, it didn't disappoint. We ordered cheese and pepperoni, the kids beat me to take a nice pic of the pizza. The crust was perfectly crispy, fresh ingredients and sauce. read more

Great place my kids loved the pizza had to buy three. Amazing customer service, very nice and friendly. Will be coming back. Please give them a try. read more

We just visited for the first time tonight. the pizza was amazing. The owner was a great guy. Fun and friendly. we will go back. highly recommend. read more

Great pizza, good service, tasty brew. One of our top choices for pizza being new in town from Seattle.

This is a great, locally owned pizza joint who prides themselves on good, natural ingredients, that make the best tasting pizza around. The limited menu means that everything is done just right, and there is NO bad choice when you go to order. They're doing pizza right and they're doing it right here in Windermere!! read more

See all

Ordered the Pepperoni and Meat Lovers pizza from here last night, and let me tell you.... They were AMAZING! and SO much healthier than commercial pizza restaurants. They were so kind when making the order, called when the pizza was going in the oven, and great service when I showed up to the restaurant. Will definitely be choosing this place over any other pizza place in the area:) and of course the pizza tastes EXCEPTIONAL, and no overpowering tastes at all! read more

I've had a small personal pepperoni from them and tonight had a 14" half and half for my family. We did half cheese and half 3 meats. The pizza is the best I've had in Orlando. Sauce is great, cheese is good proportion, really happy with the service overall. Great food, great job Pizza 14 Team! read more

Highly recommended place. We are very picky with pizza and this one is one of the best in the area. Besides it is a very cute place with great service. read more

Just moved out here. And so far the best pizza I've had. The workers were very friendly. Definitely coming back.

Delicious!! Perfect crust, just enough sauce with a great hint of oregano, and a nice little bite to the pepperoni. The staff was incredibly kind! Great selection of drinks available, too. Can't wait to order again! read more

Pizza 14 - 3 meat pizza with pineapple added - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Wife and I just moved to Florida from NJ, NY area. So finding a good pizza joint was a definite must. Came across Pizza 14 on Yelp and gave it a try. Owner is an amazing guy. Spoke with and learned he was from Brooklyn, NY. We knew we were in good hands, and the pizza did not disappoint. Flavor was good, crust was good, and we loved it. We got the Bianca. Fresh brick oven pizza made right in front of us. Definitely worth a visit. And we will definitely be back for more! read more

Finally tried this local spot- amazing pizza made with the freshest ingredients and homemade crust- yummy! We will be back for sure. read more

Pizza 14 - Finally tried this local pizza place and it was fantastic- freshest ingredients, yummy homemade crust. We will be back! - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

The best pizza I have ever had. Nothing compares to this pizza, not New York, not Chicago's pizza and certainly not any pizza in Florida. This resembles true authentic Italian pizza. The ingredients are all incredibly fresh and delicious. The service is excellent too. read more

Been here two times now. The pizza is awesome; we typically like Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza but this is our new fave spot. Beer and wine are sold but only to take home, just something to keep in mind. Love the little patio area they have outside. We met the owner last time, and he was very interactive. Happy to support a small business! read more

Great pizza, currently limited hours, the blanco is super tasty and the margarita is wonderful.

Great pizza, great area! The Hawaiian & Bianca are the best, but you can't go wrong with any of the pizzas.

Go to place for pizza! We ordered half cheese and half pepperoni. It was cooked to perfection. Our go to place for pizza! Next pizza order will be the white margarita! read more