Excellent pizza. The space has been nicely renovated, but it still has the feel of the original…read moreshop. All the staff have a particular "we're just making pizza" vibe. You can certainly eat in, but my preference is takeout. The restaurant excels at either. The only detail to note is that this is a cash-only operation, so be prepared. In terms of the actual food, the star of the show is clearly the pizza. I prefer the traditional pizza (i.e., with red sauce). No matter which pizza you order, this is a place that provides a pizza with an excellent crust. Large crumb. Good chew. It's probably the best crust in town. We ordered a series of vegetable toppings, and the result was great. Picking and choosing toppings seems like the best bet for a vegetarian experience. The Aiello's Salad was fine: about what you would expect for a pizza shop salad. The veggie hoagie was nicely flavored, with a good balance of flavor and acidity (from the dressing). The stuffed veggie slice was what it was. We tried it on a whim, and it came out exactly as described: two slices of veggie pizza stuck together. Fine, but not necessary if you're ordering pizza anyway. All told, this is an excellent destination. It's a real Squirrel Hill institution for a reason, and it continues to be worth checking out.

I like Aiellos more than Mineos because 1. It's nicer inside and 2. The food prep area is visible…read moreand you can see everything being made. Pizza and hoagies are outstanding. We visited this evening and service was a smidgen slow ... Which they attributed to having a large order for pickup. Yeah, large meaning 35 pizzas!!! That worked out to $950 some dollars and they were only accepting cash! Imagine your pizza being so good an after-wedding reception orders 35 of them ... Yep, Aiellos is that good. People growing up here have their favorites and Mineos was my fave for pizza and Napolis was my fave for hoagies. Or you could just go to Aiellos and everything is great!

Expansive Pittsburgh pizza dynasty with the maximum cheese allowed for proper pizza proportions…read more I love Mineo's. Big member of their fan club. We drive out from Monroeville just to grab their pies. Located in Squirrel Hill, parking can be a bit of a challenge, but there is a pay-to-park lot across the street tucked behind the businesses. Also, with old school class, Mineo's is cash only. They do have an ATM right in the store - in case you forgot. Dynasty loading - as they now have 4 shops including one directly in the Pittsburgh Airport (check their updated box logos with an airplane flying around!) All day. All year. Always- I would think to give Mineo's five stars, but this order was disappointing. The crust was over floured and lifeless, the cheese was missing the signature flavor pack of herbs, and the toppings were very clumped together under the cheese... but even these nitpicks- this place is a must go to! We ordered three large (and yes, that's a large large) pizzas - mushroom, extra cheese, and pepperoni. They are renowned for their thick layer of cheese with the toppings buried beneath. And this time, all of the pieces were well cut - which is rare. Service was quick. They know how to move through the takeout orders and even if they don't, pull up a seat and enjoy the theater of pizza making that you can witness in the expansive dining area.

I have to get my Mineo's fix when I'm in Pittsburgh! Their pizza is the best; I I've it and crave…read moreit when I'm in Austin. Last night my brother and I, along with a friend, made my obligatory visit. It wasn't hard to convince them to go for a pizza; they're also fans of the place. (They are both locals.) We ordered a small pizza with half pepperoni and half onions. Unfortunately, after waiting the typical 20 minutes, they got the order wrong. Instead of onions, they added mushrooms. My brother went up to the counter to report the topping error. They were so amenable to making things right, they agreed to add the onions. In addition, they offered him two complimentary Orange Crush sodas. The pizza was great as usual, and we all enjoyed the experience. For the first time, they started accepting credit cards, with a 15% fee. (I had already taken out some cash to pay for the pizza, since they previously had a cash-only policy. Now it's more convenient.) It's not a fancy place, but they have both counter and booth seating.

Pastoli's hit the mark for me as I was looking for something I could pick up while heading into…read moretown and take back to my room. I had already done some Yelp research and called on my way and ordered the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. It was a little spicy, for me it was fine but if you don't like spice don't order this pizza. It had french fries on it so I couldn't pass this pizza up. It was very good, my only issue which wasn't a big one is that when I called I was placed on hold for several minutes and had to hang up and call back. Pastoli's is worth giving a try if you're in the area.

The pizza was amazing filled with large amounts of fresh toppings, and plenty of cheese. Both the…read morecrust and sauce were excellent. Also got the Cajun wings, which were very tasty and not spicy and cooked very well. We very much enjoyed our meal and intend to return again. Also enjoyed sitting on the couch and watching the NFL draft while waiting for our order. Very relaxed atmosphere and the staff was very polite and thoughtful. Thanks so much :)

Fantastic pizza and the people are Kool! And the hot sausage are out of this world and the chicken…read moretenders are Great.

A decent pizza, better if they had placed the pepperoni on it, as ordered. Staff could use some…read morecustomer service training. A welcome in helps. Woman behind counter was cold and said nothing while the older cook glared at me, creating a very uncomfortable feeling.

Solid local pizza. The pizza crust is nicely done: not too thick, but with a really nice chew and…read moregood leavening. The toppings were about what you would expect, but overall nicely presented. My only minor feedback was that the pizza was a little light on tomato sauce. The house salad was also nicely done. At first, it looked a little heavy on the cheese, but there was plenty of lettuce and vegetable toppings to balance things out. It made for a nice pizza shop style salad. In terms of ordering, everything was fairly easy. They don't really have a web site, so the best option is to call to place an order. In terms of finding a menu, they seem to have menu photos listed on their Facebook page. Not ideal, but that's where they are. If all else fails, you can basically expect all the normal options for a pizza place. Also note that this is very much a takeout pizza establishment. The space really isn't optimized for dine-in options. All told, this is a solid destination. Certainly some of the best pizza in the Greenfield area.

So yummy! Very reasonably priced, cash only! We got the pepperoni pizza which had generous amount…read moreas well.

Great Buffalo Pizza! I add broccoli Spinach and jalapeno peppers for added spice! Awesome!read more

Ordered pick up on a busy Friday night. They don't answer their phone. Must either place order…read moreonline or in person and wait. 16" cheese (was free with coupon) 14" Shadyside Special: loaded with too many toppings. The thin center of the pizza is too wimpy to handle all the toppings. Tastes just like Dominos Pizza. Sorry.

The pizza is a must try. We were blown away with the crispiness of the pie, and I don't know why…read morepeople aren't recommending this order to travelers. Some of the best thin crust pizza we've had!

I've seen a lot of pizza in my life, but never anything close to as big as these slices which need…read more2 plates to carry. Giving it a 3-star for the ambiance. While the brick and big pizza ovens are the characteristic of East Carson Street to be expected, the seating area was less than to be desired. The cracks in the old stuffed plastic benches are literally duct taped with electrical tape. I like the "reuse" but it could be a bit more pleasant. There aren't any options for drinks in the refrigerator that aren't super sugary or "diet," i.e. no seltzer waters or juices, just sodas, lemonades, and sweet teas. But if you're hungry for a slice of pizza two times as large as your face, you know where you can find it!

life savers! really, I was injured and had no appetite for days . My daughter called in an order of…read moremy favorite foods. My Oder was delivered quickly, the food was still warm and beautifully prepared, and oh so good! I have a long recovery but thanks to the best pizza in town, I'm on my way back.

When i first moved to munhall the food was excellent. This was my go to place. We even gave the…read moreowner a statue of a pizza man. However, after they caught on fire and reopened the food went down hill fast. I ordered a plain pizza and it was burnt top to bottom. I called and was told the manager was not there and he would call back. I never got a call back. I went the next morning to speak to the owner or manager. He was a heavy guy who could barely walk. He said they don't give refunds. I showed him the pizza that was black. He gave me half of my money back, so I never went back. Food: 0 service: 0 and the ambiance is a 0. I have never gone back because of how rude they were.

Good enough. This place is nearby and under new ownership (apparently?) so we gave it a try and…read moreordered some pizzas and a salad. The pizzas were generally good but could have used a little more browning in the oven, particularly for the vegetable toppings. The dough was somewhat thick, but not otherwise noteworthy. The greek salad was fine but uninspired: it was overwhelmed by pita wedges but the vegetables were generally fresh. The shop itself is entirely set up for takeout, complete with coolers full of bottled soda. All told, this is a decent place to pick up some pizzas if you're nearby and not looking for something exceptional.

My fiancé and I called for takeout on a Friday evening and was told it would be about 30 min wait…read more We had a coupon for $22 large pizza & breadsticks, and we also got an order of mozzarella sticks. We topped our pizza with pepperoni & banana peppers. We really enjoyed the pizza - the crust was fluffy which I love. The mozzarella sticks were basic but tasty. The breadsticks were good; they were soft but I wish they'd had a little more seasoning. Would definitely order again - it's a solid meal, and it's close to where we live!

Pizza is as close we can get to what's served in Italy…read more Only downer is Shadyside doesn't take reservations. Food is worth it. Faux Chappell site does

Came back for another Roberto pizza. Still absolutely delicious. We have been craving this pizza…read moreand finally got our fix. Quick, friendly service. We sat at a table for two by the pizza station.