Hidden gem. Serves one of the best pizzas in northwest PA. It's a little out of the way but it's…read moreworth it.

We were looking for someplace in Greenville later in the evening on a cold snowy night after…read moreleaving the hospital. Never knew about this place and was very pleased with the food and experience. Mom had pizza which she thought was good. I had Stromboli which was good as well. Hubby had the steak salad that he loved. So, great food. Service, no issues. Prices were not outrageous. Friendly waitress. We would stop in again if in the area.

We always get their pizza to go, but we love it. The Veggie Pizza is awesome, and we've tried many…read moreothers that are delicious. It all tastes authentic and you can't beat the prices!

we love Pizza Joe's great pizzas! our favorite is their veggie pizza, which we can never get…read moreanywhere else nearly as delicious!

My first and last time at BBM. The place was busy and smelled great. A blonde girl at the…read moreregister took my order, 4 xl pizzas with misc toppings. It came to $82. She gave me the change, which I put in the tip jar along with a "thank you". The girl didn't blink, didn't say "thanks", nothing. But, OK, it's busy, maybe she's having a bad day. Our 4 pizzas were up, I went to the counter to pick them up and the same girl was cutting the pizzas. I asked if I could have have a plastic container for chili flakes. The girl didn't acknowledge me for about twenty seconds and then said, "yeah, I'll be right back" and walked to the back. A girl standing in front of me asked, "what did you need?" I said, just a small container for the chili flakes" she reached over and handed me a 2oz plastic container, at which point, the blonde girl returned with a thimble sized plastic container... no exaggeration, thimble sized. The blonde girl literally tried to take the bigger cup out of my hand, which I held onto. I said, "I prefer the larger one, it's for FOUR EXTRA LARGE PIZZAS" and she looked me right in the eye and said, "No, unless you want to pay .50 for it" I pulled the cup away and gave the second girl a buck and told her to keep the change. The two employees who witness this interaction had a "WTF is going on" look on their faces. This was my first time, and obviously last time here, and I'm really not sure what was going on. The whole interaction felt personal. I don't know if she thought is was someone else or a previous bad customer, but I can just as easily drive a 100 yards down the road for a equally good pizza and at least a smile when I walk in.

We are new to the area and this was our first time looking for pizza. We live about 30 minutes away…read morebut it was worth the drive. They were wonderful about communicating that they are CASH ONLY when I was ordering and they were so nice and friendly when we arrived to pick up our food. They thanked us for coming and it added a layer of love for this establishment. The pizza itself was excellent. The sauce to cheese ratio was excellent and the crust was crispy and well made. Both of my kids enjoyed their pizzas and I will absolutely be returning!

The pizzas are beyond delicious with true cupping pepperoni that takes every single pie to the next…read morelevel. The calzones the Hawaiian the all the meats or the true pepperoni and cheese can't be beat on any of the three. This is hands down the best pizza in the area no question no other contender hard stop. Sauces delicious not sweet not too earthy not like they're putting patchouli in their you know sauce it's delicious The cheese freshly grated none of that cakey yucky came from Sam's club type thing true mozzarella. The calzones we've had there have been amazing meatball and pepper ring, pepperoni and cheese, All the meats, Hawaiian, literally just order all of them You will not be disappointed. We've ordered from the one in King Kone in Perry as well as the original in Madison and the true OG in Duffy's in Madison and they are all absolutely amazing. Thank you Kay Jack for giving us good pizza in the 44081 ZIP code.

It's a good pie place. I was a fan of the dough. The sauce with breadsticks is a bit heavy on the…read morespices. I would order again. My picky eater kids loved it and that's good enough for me!

Pizza is super underrated. I'd recommend ordering from here over other pizza joints in town due to…read morethe family friendly prices.

A-plus service and pizza. Staff was hustling taking/making orders while we dined-in and they were…read morevery kind to our party. Pizza: cheese and red sauce were particularly good. Buffalo chicken salad: veggies were fresh and crisp. We'll be back!

Absolutely incredible pizza and you get to watch them make it. I was particularly helped by Mr…read moreScotto himself and he was just like talking to my own family. I had a standard slice of cheese pizza and a cheese cake and both were premium. The

This place takes me back to the old Shenango Valley Mall days when I worked at the record store…read more next to Scotto's. The pizza is still very: very good. We go with choose or with the veggie pizza with Italian sausage. No matter what you will get authentic and delicious pizza. FYI this pizza is every bit as good reheated as it is the first day. That rare but it just might be the crust ;)

Their wings, in particular the dry rub Cajun, are DELICIOUS! I really enjoy their pizza too! Good…read moreservice, affordable, and nice staff!

Typical older bar as far as appearance. A little dingy on the bar side of the building. It is a…read morelarge space and also has a patio. They have a good number of pool tables and skill games. Tried the pizza because that is what this place is known for. While it was good I would not say it is the best pizza I've ever had. I do like the fact that the toppings go clear to the edge of the thick crust so there is never a crust only bite. The day we were there our food came out quickly. For those who might not realize you order at the bar then the food is brought out to you by a kitchen worker.

We drove here with friends after we had a recommendation for the 'best pizza' in the area. We were…read moreimmediately concerned with some of the people in the bar fighting and the amount of smoke, but we'd already driven there, so we figured we might as well try it out. We sat down at a booth to look at a menu and realized after about 10 min of no one even looking our way that we were going to have to go to the bar to order. We went to the bar and were pretty sure the bartender was high. She seemed to float around having no idea what she was doing and not actually getting anything done. She took one of our orders, then walked away as if she was done with all four of us. Then she made one of the drink orders and forgot about the others. She made mention of an upcoming shift change as if she didn't really like the fact she was serving us at all when she wouldn't benefit from it. The pop for the drinks was completely flat which was a little disappointing. Between us, we ordered a large pepperoni pizza, a dozen wings, two half meatball subs, fries, fried mushrooms, and pickled eggs. While waiting for the food, the bartenders changed over, so we went to get another drink. While standing there, we actually commented on how the new bartender was working hard, then a local came over and started yelling for her, and pointed to us as if WE were impatient. She immediately seemed to hate us and when we told her our tabs she said "yeah I know who YOU are." Once the food finally came, the bartender seemed way nicer all of the sudden. We loved the meatball subs, wings, mushrooms. The pizza was good, but we all agreed it barely had any sauce on it. I realized I never got my pickled eggs at the end when I went to pay, so the bartender gave them to me to go. I wish they hadn't forgotten - they were the best pickled eggs I've ever had in my life, I would have ordered a dozen! I'll go back just to pick those up. Prices are really great so while service and atmosphere are lacking, I would get food to go if in the area.

Don't come here hungry or you will end up ordering a ton of food. So many selections, hard to make…read moreup my mind. We ordered a large cheese pizza, the bbq meal and a bunch of specialty cookies. It is very cozy inside, not tons of room. But does finally have indoor seating It did take a while for the food, but it was a busy holiday weekend.

We ordered a few pepperoni pizzas and a small cheese pizza for our crew while staying in Conneaut…read moreLake. It was a Sunday night and the other local pizza shop was closed. Our order was ready in an hour. We went on the golf cart to pick it up (for reference on how close it is to this part of the lake). It's mostly a take-out spot although there were a few tables inside for dine-in. I really liked the oregano baked into the cheese. The pepperonis had a bit of a spicy flavor to it which I enjoyed. The crust was light and airy. I would definitely choose Ice House again for pizza at Conneaut Lake!

Sausage Pizza is delicious and delivery was fast! I'm going to try a different pizza next time.read more

if I could give this zero stars I would. I got a grilled chicken salad today for dinner. Took it to…read morego. The pieces of chicken were about an inch . They were no bigger than bacon bits. I work hard for my money and I don't like to feel that I got beat on something that I spent my hard earned money on. Total rip off! I will never spend my money there again