Service was good, setting was typical for a pizzeria, however the food was FLAVORFUL!!! As a person that enjoys good pizza, I was shocked at how much flavor the pizza had. The sauce is the star of the pie with a solid crispy crust to top off this delicious creation!!! Will definitely return!!! read more

See all

Best pizza we've had in Oxford. Big NY slices (can do individual slices if you want instead). Right amount of sauce that is slightly sweeter. Ask for the crust "well done" to get the perfect crispiness. The Divinci was our favorite since it was slightly different than we normally get but the pep/green pepper had great flavor too. We did pick up, did not eat it in the restaurant and the service was very nice and attentive. read more

Pizza Shop - Pep/green pep - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

See all

I'm not sure how pizza shop only has 3.7 stars in yelp. This is the BEST PIZZA!! Da Vinci and the meat lovers (forgot its name) are DELICIOSO!! read more

Pizza is excellent... huge slices and full of flavor. We chose Plumber Pete & IL Capo. Great service, extremely friendly staff. read more

Pizza Shop - Excellent pizza... IL Capo & Plumber Pete - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

I've picked up from here multiple times and you can't beat the prices or customer service! I've ordered the calzones, by the slice, and full pizzas. The quality is always top tier for Oxford Pizza. The Da Vinci is my favorite. The most recent time I called in, the by the slice pizza was ready in less than 5 minutes, making it the perfect stop if you need a good filling dinner. The service is always great when ordering from here and I've never had any issues! read more

I ordered Pizza Shop on DoorDash tonight. In my notes, I said "well done - don't be afraid to burn it". This is the pizza I got. Perfection! This is a "pizza shop" that listens to their customers! Thank y'all - the pizza was PERFECT for me! (I know some of y'all will take issue with the doneness - this is how I like my pizza!) read more

Pizza Shop - Cheese pizza - ask for well done - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

See all

Got a pizza that was really good last time. This time we tried a speciality pizza that was smaller but was almost the same price. It was not very good at all. I am really surprised in the difference in quality this time vs last time. Price was way too high and pizza was really small and pretty bad read more

I haven't left a good review of anyone in awhile and am beginning to feel that I am tipping toward being only negative here. No one likes that Yelper, so I thought I might leave one on a place I like who I feel has been working hard the last seven or eight months to right a sometimes listing ship. I've been going to Pizza Shop since they opened and have experienced the ebbs and flows of the product there. They've had some consistency issues over the years, but when they get it right, it's arguably the best pizza in town. I've definitely had some five star pies here on numerous occasions, but there have been some hiccups, hence only four stores. They closed for a bit last Spring I believe to revamp everything, and I've been happily surprised by their being very consistent since whatever it was that they did. The owner has been up there a good bit, and he's a real friendly guy. I wanted to leave them a review because I think the average here is a bit too low, and I think they have put a lot of work in to start delivering a consistent product again. It's owned by a family, and I think they are really invested in making the place great. If you haven't gone in a bit, definitely give them another shot, especially if you like NY style pizza. read more

Best pizza in Oxford by far. In fact, I would argue this is the best pizza in entire Memphis area. Classic NY style. Absolutely love this place. Super friendly staff as well. read more

We had the Large 19 inch pizza with 1/2 Buffalo Chix and the other half Magic Dragon (prosciutto, mozzarella and arugula). They make it fresh, so of course it takes time, but it was delicious. Hand tossed thin crust. Everything tasted fresh and facility was clean. read more

Pizza Shop - Large pizza (19") - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

This small pizza place is absolutely amazing! True New York style pizza. Very large portions and it's BOYB. Don't be fooled by the dark windows, they are open. It's a must try. read more

Pizza Shop - Mary Lee - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

See all

Best pizza in Oxford, slice special is out in only five minutes and can fill a grown man for eight bucks

First off great pizza. Best in town since Soul Shine. However on Saturday April 02, 2022 I had an abnormally long wait on a pizza, when I walked in the there were two very swamped employees trying to take care of a full front of house and to go orders. The girl who was visibly nervous and upset told me it would be a bit longer, no problem. When I went back the "manager" had mysteriously materialized out of no where, as my pizza came out the manager slaps my pizza down barks an order at the girl about finishing my pizza, she was already helping another customer and asked him a question his response in front of both myself and another customer was this direct quote "I don't give a damn, I'm the manger cut the pizza and sell and do what I tell you" The girl stood there shell shocked as the manager turned his back to her. What an representation of your business. I tried to tell the girl to keep her head and that she was doing a good job but she was still in shock of being accosted by the bully this business put in charge on a Saturday night. Shameful! read more

Great service. Great food. Fresh ingredients and unique menu items. You can't ask for anything more than that! read more

Pizza Shop - Chicken Phillysteak. The arugula is a nice touch. (This is half of what's left, great portions) - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

Great pizza! Staff is very friendly. Fun to sit and eat or take to go. I got the Margherita pizza, ate several pieces and didn't leave feeling heavy like most pizza these days. Highly recommend. read more

Girlfriend and I wanted to try local pizza and haven't found much that's well priced and good. The pizza has a ton of flavor and very fresh ingredients. I also appreciated the diverse flavors they offered. The cheese calzone was the best calzone I've ever had. I don't even like calzone. I will go again for the calzone. Totally recommend, support local! read more

Pizza Shop - Calzone - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

Visiting daughter at Ole Miss and she found this great new pizza place. Great thin crust with lots of fresh topping choices. Highly recommend read more

Best pizza ever!!!! Pizza Shop takes pride in making the best!!!! BTW, the BEST meatballs too! I highly recommend Pizza Shop to anyone in or traveling to Oxford! read more

Pizza Shop - 12 inch pepperoni onion mushroom - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

So good! Lenox Avenue Pasta and build your own pizza with white sauce, ricotta, mozzarella and prosciutto!!! I recommend coming here for sure! read more

Pizza Shop - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

See all

Great pizza. Hands down the best I've had in Oxford. Had Square my first trip, not good. This one is outstanding! read more

Pizza Shop - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

It's my birthday and we decided to check out the new pizza place in town. I can guarantee we won't be back. There was only one other customer in the restaurant when we arrived. After we ordered, we proceeded to wait more than an hour (1h and 20 min) for a simple pepperoni pizza and fries. The fries were made immediately, and we watched them sit on top of the oven for 45 minutes before our pizza was ready. By the time we got them they were cold. The pizza itself was greasy, salty, and subpar. The most frustrating part of our experience is not once did someone take responsibility for the wait time. Everyone was served before us, and not once did the person in charge communicate with us (even though he communicated with other customers who had an order messed up). The customer service was appalling and never again will I wait that long for bad pizza. I wish we had asked for our money back. read more

Small place, but GREAT quality food. Nice to see something like this around this part of town. Picked up from here a few times. Not just pizza, but pasta and sandwiches also. Will repeat. read more

Pizza Shop - YUM! - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

I am so excited about this pizza joint!! We enjoyed the vodka pizza and the da Vinci. The crust is perfect, so crispy and light. The pizza flavors are unique. I look forward to returning and trying more of their menu options. The owners was sweet and personable. FYI: if you're from south Mississippi, the have french/Catalina. read more

If you are looking for the best pizza in Oxford...this is it. Best NY pie around. Reasonably priced as well

Very TERRIBLE service. The workers were rude over the phone when I called for a pick up order, absolutely no costumer service skills. Went In to grab the food and asked for 2 waters. Only received one water, then got brought a cup over water, covered in flour on the sides. Why was I given one water bottle, and one cup of water when I was getting a to-go order? I was also CHARGED for two water bottles, when I only received one. I also ordered 2 ranches and only received one. read more

The food here is amazing. The speciality pies are amazing. We got the Davinci and Mary Lee both were great. If you like a spicy pizza the Davinici is really good. If you like an updated cheese pizza the Mary Lee is the one for you. The Caesar salad is the best in town. My wife is gluten free and says the gluten free crust is one of the best she has eaten. The pizza by the slice is great if you do not want a whole pizza. My only complaint would be the truffle fries. There was so much truffle oil I could not taste the other ingredients. The pizza shop is definitely the best pizza in town! read more

The pizza is great. Literally love all of the ones I've tried. Sandwiches are pretty good too. My only complaint is that the past 2 times I've called to place an order I've been immediately put on hold for 10 minutes. It would only take 15 seconds max to write my order down. Wish this would get sorted out. Aside from that the food is great! read more

Got take out with my girlfriend and tried their wings and spaghetti. Wings just looked like burnt rocks and taste awful with way too much breading and the spaghetti was ok. Recommend making spaghetti at home read more

Pizza Shop - Garlic parm wings - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

We ate at the Pizza Shop 2x while in town for a tournament. Pizza was great both times. Lots of fresh veggies; crust was awesome. Yes long wait times but worth the wait. We also had polite and courteous service- no complaints. I hope this shop makes it. read more

Pizza Shop - Sausage, mushroom and green peppers - Italian Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

See all

Dirty restaurant. Took a very long time to get our pizza even though we were the only people in the restaurant. Very hot inside. Couldn't stay to eat the pizza because we were sweating. read more

The pizza was fabulous and the new general manager was very helpful and efficient. I would certainly recommend this place.

I was looking forward to trying this place out for the first time tonight and was excited to see they were open til 1AM on Fri and Sat. This is great for me as a night shift worker. I get my order together online and click the ole "check out" button only to be told that they're closed at just after 11 PM on a Friday night. So much for being excited about this place. The menu I received in the mail and the website both say they're open until 1 AM which is clearly not accurate. Looks like I wont be eating here after all. Back to the national chain brands for me. Very disappointing when a business can't even be honest about their hours. read more

See all

This place was so bad I would give it a 0 but I can't. We have been in the store for 2 hours and I just checked, and our pizza hasn't been put in the oven yet. No one in the restaurant has a pizza, and everyone has been waiting at least an hour. Several people left without anything, and they are turning others away. Employees are on their phones, fighting with each other, and not practicing cleanliness. We will never be back. Couldn't even tell you if the food is good. read more

By far the greasiest pizza I have ever had. Wasn't tasteful, just downright not very good. I know they're new, so hopefully they'll get their stuff down. read more

Eggplant parmesean is my favorite comfort food - tried their sandwich and it is SO GOOD. Got the 19" cheese pizza another time and it was amazing also. A friend of mine got the margherita pizza which looked delicious as well. It was heavy on the sauce for him but he said it tasted homemade. Small interior, seems like it would be best to get to go. Also as previous reviewer said, be aware there are no fountain drinks, cans and bottled water only when we went. read more

It continues to be as slow as all the others who previously complained. Ordered 3 hours ago, and we're still waiting for our food...

Don't waste your time... they need to hire more people and get their stuff straight.

The service is horrible, food was mediocre, it took and hour to get food after I ordered in restaurant. The people behind the counter were clueless read more