I was craving a good NY style slice as i was driving on the thruway. The slice is very good and it was easy to get to from the highway. Well worth the short detour. read more

Stopped in for a quick bite while on the road... found through yelp.... Not sure if it was a Grandma or a Margarita slice, but it was absolutely amazing. My co workers had the same, a slice of white and a plain, and all agreed was great pizza. read more

My family loves going to this restaurant. All 11 of us and we all order different meals. Love them all. Cannot wait until they reopen. Checking every day read more

Consistently good food and service. Always a happy customer. Also, they make a great sauce!

Pizza is pretty good, I've tried regular slices &!specialties, they'll basically put whatever you want on your pizza. I used to order for pick up or have delivered when i lived in West Nyack. Very friendly & welcoming staff; clean sitting area. read more

My family has been bringing me here since before I could even walk, and now it's a tradition that's stuck in the family! Every time I travel back to Rockland we always make a trip to Pizzarena. The owner Rich is fabulous and willing to please you in any way that you can. Service and food are always great. read more

My boyfriend works near by. He brought me home a slice of baked ziti pizza. It was delicious. I really liked the cheese on it, it was not salty at all! The sauce was good too! read more

This is our go to for pizza, hands down the best in town. The garlic knots are great too!

Have been there several times over the last few months. Service above average, food is very good & always comes out piping hot. Wonderful hosts & the BYOB feature works for our usual group of 6. The recent expansion has made this into a go to place! read more

Not my favorite pizza or place. I had a ravioli pizza and it was disgusting. Pizza slices aren't worth the money for what they charge. I went because it is the closest to my house. I've had better. I had penne ala vodka again just okay. read more

I moved here recently and was quite happy to discover Pizzarena! I moved from Nyack .. Which has several options in not only pizza but also any kind of food you may be craving at almost any time. Shortly after moving here I wanted to order out and found there weren't many options locally. I tried one pizza place around the corner but it didn't hit the spot! Finally I noticed Pizzarena .. I have literally been going there at least once - twice a week minimum . The service is friendly .. Good made with love .. And quick! Their sauce is something is something to be admired .. So I always order extra! I highly recommend ! read more

Food is good. Pizza is great. Stay away from anything with marinara sauce as it tastes like pure sugar. tick with the pink sauces.S

Came here after the pool with the family! Everyone absolutely loved the pizza: Sicilians, Grandma, & BBQ Chicken. Definitely will be returning! read more

Thin Crust Sicilian is simply outstanding. Reminds me of Rizzo's in Astoria. The Service was fantastic.

This was our first time at Pizzarena, but definitely not the last. We had a 1/2 white with spinach and 1/2 fresh mozzarella and tomatoes, with whole wheat crust. This pizza was simply heavenly. It was hard to say which 1/2 was best as they both were among the best I have ever had, and I am a pizza enthousiast. The white side was loaded with creamy ricotta and the spinach was well seasoned with just the right amount of garlic (not too heavy). The mozzarella and tomatoes had fresh basil and was bursting with flavor. We asked for a side of sauce, which was also very tasty. We did not order salads, but saw our neighbors' and it also looked very nice. The service was excellent, and everyone was very friendly. They made us feel welcome. They worked as a team and both servers made sure we had all we needed. The place was very clean, including the restrooms! It is a notch above your typical pizzeria! Definitely a keeper!! read more

Pizzarena - 1/2 white + spinach, 1/2 mozzarella and tomatoes! Scrumptuous!! - Pizza Near Me - West Nyack, New York

Every time I call I never can get through. Either you need a new number or a new hostess. It's been three weeks & I can't even ask questions on the menu smh read more

Clean Place, very nice people, best sicilian pie around..highly recommend this place..

The margarita pizza beats every pizza place out there!!! You guys are the best and always so nice!!! all the food is great never a disappointment !!! read more

They have one of the best penne a la vodka in Rockland. So good, I get shrimp added to it and it's even better ! The employees are always nice too! read more

A great pizza place for take out or dining in. Staff is friendly, and very attentive. The food is very good and great prices. A no brainier if your in Rockland. read more

ive been going to this place since ive been 16 years old an their food has been consistently amazing for years. the owner is such a nice guy an the food is always fresh an his sauce has been the same for years. i highly recommend this place. the food is great an its not expensive at all. read more

They charge a deliver fee but don't give it to their delivery guys!!!! They use their own car and gas.

Best pizza restaurant in West Nyack Rich and his sister are great! read more

Pizzarena - Pizza Near Me - West Nyack, New York

Pizzarena has great pizza! Weekday specials are really good deals. Rich and his staff are very friendly!

Had the opportunity to eat here multiple times recently and was Very happy with our meals. I had seafood fra Diablo which was absolutely loaded with seafood and was delicious. My guest had baked ravioli....again...delicious. Portions were huge...service great and prices very reasonable. Had occasion to pickup a pizza about a week later... Also,very good...Highly recommend as a mid price Italian eatery. read more

Not the best pizza at all but it's the only pizzeria around (for now). I get it. Also pick up is best because last time I had it delivered and it took over an hour and arrived cold. When I called to complain I was told to put it in the oven for ten minutes and it'll be okay. Lol. Nope and then I spoke to a manager who was more like a teenage girl and she said that was the best they can do. thanks buddy I'll take my business elsewhere. So for that, never again. read more

Best pizza in town! My family orders from here every week. We almost had a heart attack when we kept calling one night and no one answered. We drove over to see they were in the middle of moving next door. We tried a few other pizza places while they were under construction and none of them held a candle to this place. read more

Had Pizzarena cater my daughters graduation party. GREAT FOOD. All the guests (all ages) loved it. The sausage and pepper, penne vodka, chicken francaise and cavatelli with broccoli were all amazing. Thanks for everything! read more

The staff is very friendly and the food is YUMMY! I especially love how they do eggplant. If it's not cooked correctly, it can be rubbery and they cook it perfectly every time. Their garlic rolls are so good. They are those big fat garlicky ones that they deep fry. I highly recommend the Eggplant Rolls or the Eggplant Rollantini. Their portions are enormous. read more

This is hands down the best pizzeria I've been too I don't even write reviews like that but I just felt like I had to share that...

Amazing pizza always great and they are always so nice. Rich always makes you feel welcome and makes amazing pies, try the margherita pizza!

I have been coming here for years. Great pizza, great atmosphere. Rich and all that work there make you feel welcome all the time. The food is always on par. I was so sad when I stopped by and saw the placed closed down. Then I realized they were coming back better than ever. Thanks for being my place to go. And thanks for having the garlic knots and stuffed meat pizza. read more

I have been a loyal customer for the past 9 years since I moved into to the area. I am beyond disappointed over the customer service I received tonight, to the point that I feel the need to write my first Yelp review. I had my whole family over and ordered a total of $130 worth of pizza and salad. I asked if they would include a side of sauce (as my nephew was allergic to cheese and was going to make him something on the side.) when the delivery showed up they forgot the sauce. No big deal? I called the pizza place and asked if they could send it over.. I rudely told by the girl answering the phone that it was just sauce and they had many deliveries to make so they couldn't bring it to me. I promptly asked for the manager figuring maybe she was just young and didn't realize how business or even customer service works. I tried to explain it to him that although I do realize it's just a side of sauce, it was their mistake, and they did not complete the order, when I received the same response from him. They were busy, had 20 deliveries, blah blah, they couldn't do it. Needless to say, they lost a customer tonight. read more