Service was very nice. We traded in weights to get a different kind of weights and they helped us with it. There supply on every sport is endless. The prices for there stuff is good there was a golf driver marked down for 50 dollars less. read more

Great people, Knowledgeable & Very Attentive/Helpful Staff‼. The owner actually works there a few times a week, takes time to address your specific needs for you or your team's sporting needs. Good $avings on used sports equipment, high standards on items sold to their customers. Highly recommend the PIAS Hilliard location. read more

Cashier was incredibly rude and condescending and unhelpful for every question we had. Made us feel unwelcome and we will not be coming back. read more

I just bought a new pickleball paddle there. They have really improved their selection of pickleball equipment. Matt really knew his stuff and he sold me the Selkirk Vanguard Invicta paddle. I absolutely love it. I have been playing for a few years and this paddle is a significant upgrade for me. I always loved this store but they have really made some nice improvements lately and are branching out in their selection in quite a few sports. They sure have alot of skis and snowboards now as well. Thanks Matt read more

I come here and buy dozens of tennis balls at a time for my dog. They always have a great assortment of tennis balls, I even found some pink ones the last time I went. They have buckets of tennis balls and most of them are really clean, so it's a great spot if your dog is a fetching fanatic. The staff is super nice and friendly, and they always have a line of bikes out front so if you need a bike I'm assuming this is the place to go! I've only ever bought tennis balls and other balls for my dog from here but they have everything for golf, hockey, tennis, volleyball, soccer, lacrosse and more. read more

great experience a lot of hockey gear great service sally was super nice and helpful, would recommend to go

I have always been happy with the selection and prices of equipment. I have purchased a quite varied range of equipment over the years. The employees have been helpful on the phone and in the store. read more

I'm not sure why someone would leave a poor review of a store like this. The staff were friendly and helpful to my needs, while also giving my the space I needed to take my time and peruse. This store has a great selection of weights, skateboards, hockey equipment, ski/snowboard equipment, golf equipment and more! A lot of the stuff is actually new and at a discounted price. I like that all of there stuff in the same category is basically priced the same. I went to look at long boards and all of them were marked at $100 which is a little less than most you'll find online. A good place to go to try out something new and give some equipment a new life! read more

This place is not one that you want to buy stuff but trading in stuff is good they gave me 20 bucks for a old baseball glove.

I can't describe what a rip off this place is. Sold me $500 worth of hockey equipment and after a few weeks, (nothing used) offered me $25 for the same stuff I bought. I brought my receipt and everything was in original packaging with scan codes. Scam artist pawn shop read more

Can't say enough about the outstanding customer service I received from Dave Tanner and his team at Play it Again. Dave is committed to doing the right thing for the customer and helped me exchange ice skates after I had been having some issues. I'll absolutely be giving them my business in the future. read more

As far as used sports equipment goes, Play It Again Sports is usually pretty awesome in getting what you need cheap, but this particular location is great for hockey equipment. I couldn't believe the selection (even though it is hockey season), and from slightly used to overstock. They have tons of hockey and figure skates too, so if you're interested in giving skating a shot, then you should swing over here so you're not spending a couple hundred or more on skates. I was able to walk out of there with new shoulder pads, elbow pads, a stick, and a new water bottle for just $140. That's a steal considering the stick itself retailed at $120 prior to ending up here. If you're looking for top of the line stuff, you're probably not going to find it here, but if you're doing men's league a couple times a week or just learning to play hockey, then this is definitely where you want to start. The place is a little bit of a mess, since customers don't seem to like hanging things back up on the hangers, but it's easy enough to get around and find what you need. They pack this place to the brim, and it definitely looks like it has a lot more space than the location on Sawmill. There's all kinds of stuff in here for all different sports, and all that can get pretty pricey, so it's totally worth taking a look. It may be a little further out than I like, but I would be out here again in a heartbeat for new equipment. read more

See all

They do have a huge inventory at the store but that could be due to the lack of warmth that they show potential customers. One older "gentleman", I believe his name was Tim, was especially unfriendly. I don't know if he was having a bad day or if he just didn't care for me but if you go there, BEWARE! They had a sign in the window saying that PIAS franchise(s) were available. It wouldn't surprise me if it was this location for sale. They're not going to get any business from me in the future, I assure you. Good luck, Tim and crew. read more

They were great with an awesome winter discount! I got everything I needed to start snowboarding. Board, bindings, boots, helmet, and goggles for half the prices you see online. They have new and used equipment. I got a brand new board, brand new bindings, new helmet, new goggles, and used boots. Definitely worth checking them out over other sporting goods stores. I'll definitely be back! read more

The store is amazing! Anything sports related is here The store is tightly packed with any sports equipment you can imagine. Me and my friend brought in some baseball and lacrosse gear yesterday we thought they were gonna give us a bad price on them but they ended up giving us a very reasonable price. Overall the store is amazing read more

Would recommend you find somewhere else to find sporting goods, maybe a different location, I have always had much better experiences with staff at other PIAS locations (in Iowa). The first staff member misled us about breadth of inventory, telling us that they didn't have used barbells in stock, which were soon after found in a corner. The second and third claimed that the used dumbbells we wanted to buy were new and charged us thusly. Dishonest business practices at best and unethical pricing strategies at worst. read more

Not only does Hilliard Play It Again Sports have used sporting goods, but they also have new merchandise as well. From what I've seen at the Hilliard location, they pretty much have what you would need for football, baseball, basketball, soccer, hockey (a ton of hockey equipment), bikes, golf, weights, treadmills, lacrosse, field hockey, cleats and etc. The store is very clean, organized and the people who work there are very friendly and helpful. I've shopped at that store many times and I will shop there many more times. read more

I was happy to go in here and find a cheap and rusty but totally heavy duty olympic size bar for my weight bench. The middle aged sales guy showed me every bar they had, including some that were stored in a back room. This place or one of its sister stores will be my first stop for anything sports related i might want, chiefly because there is the possibility of getting it at a price substantially below the brand spank-me new retail price. read more

Play it Again Sports Hilliard - Sporting Goods Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

The Play it Again chain has locations around Columbus, but if you're interested in hockey equipment, this is the best one to visit. They keep a large selection of helmets, pads, sticks, blades, shafts, and skates in stock at all times, and I've found items on sale (and frequently with reduced prices) that I never find at the Westerville or Reynoldsburg stores. The staff can be a mixed bag, honestly, but more often than not they're fairly helpful, and I leave happy with my visit. Just keep in mind that unless you're looking for a brand new item, they can't always control what is or is not in stock, or what condition some of the used items may be in. read more

Always a good selection of used equipment from golf to exercise stuff. They have a pretty large golf and exercise section. They used to have a nice used disc golf selection but it seemd to mostly new now. Disc Golf had gained in popularity and more people tend to keep their discs now or sell them at the course. Their adult softball glove section is usually pretty sparse too. One thing you can count on is a service representative near by to help you. They are friendly and helpful. read more

Pros: Big selection. Convenient location. Employees helpful. Cons: Overpriced on new items. Feels dingy inside. Review: They have lots of selection but in my opinion, they are overpriced. I got a helmet here for my daughter and actually found it cheaper, new, online. They have a huge selection of shoes for soccer and other stuff, but for horse riding, gymnastics and maybe a few other sports, not too much. read more

Moderately helpful, biggest issue was a posted discount. Clearly read "New Lacrosse Equipment is 25% off." I selected an unused bag (still with the tags on, very clearly had never been worn, opened, etc). When I asked about the discount at check-out, I was told that, in fact, the bag was not new, and they could tell because of some code on the price tag. I mean, don't tell me something that's objectively false. Just tell me the discount only applies to "New" equipment identified with some secret code on the tag. Not the greatest experience; with two young children who are going to be in need of sporting equipment for the next decade, will likely look elsewhere. read more

I went here a few weeks ago in search of skis accustomed to the higher prices out in Seattle, WA and was very pleased to find a nice pair of relatively new skis, poles and really nice hardly used boots all for under $200. On top of that they gave me a very generous trade in credit for some things that had just been collecting dust. read more

I've found some good used golf equipment at the hilliard location

They have a big selection for cheap it is awesome I got baseball equipment from there and the equipment is awesome and I got it all for cheap and the staff is really nice and helpful I have also got hockey equipment from there and it was really cheap and they have a good selection. read more