We had a great meal the other night outside on the patio. There were plenty of tables inside and out. The ambiance was great - everyone around us was happily enjoying their meals. We loved sharing a picture of margaritas, chips and salsa and watching the sunset. The food came out relatively quickly, piping hot and delicious. I got the chicken and beef fajitas which came with rice, beans, guacamole, pico de gallo, lettuce and 3 tortillas. The portion was enormous so I happily took home the leftovers which made amazing breakfast burritos. We all enjoyed our food including my fam's favs the Camarones a la Diabla, and chicken nachos. Service was fantastic. The kids had a great experience as well. We look forward to our next visit. read more

See all

Very disappointed with our experience tonight. We ordered drinks off the menu that was on our table and also ordered food. Watch your receipt as they over charged us for our drinks. When I confronted a staff member they told me that it must of been an old menu. I then asked if they would make it right and credit me and they told me no that's how it is in the system. The owner then came out by us and I mentioned what had happened and he just blew us off. No one even came and cleared our table for us either. I wouldn't recommend unless you watch what they charge you. read more

Stopped at Plaza Garibaldi for supper when in town for a baseball game. Overall, it was good, just what you would expect from a Mexican restaurant. I had pastor street tacos which were good but they came with fried onions which wasn't a fan of. Service was good, we were seated in a back room section and I was slightly concerned about being forgotten but our waiter was attentive. read more

I got the Speedy Gonzales lunch special - taco, small burrito, and your choice of rice or beans. Very flavorful and I couldn't come close to finishing it. Quick and friendly service, fun atmosphere, great music. A winner. read more

Mexican shrimp cocktail was authentic and tasty. Pollo con arroz was a bit dry and disappointing as the daily special. Patio was a relaxing place to dine, with a fresh breeze. House margaritas was unimpressive, but the Cadillac Margarita was good! Waiter was knowledgeable (though slow) and free chips and salsa were excellent. read more

Ordered my dinner combo plate for 12.99 chili relano enchilada got my food in 5 minutes. WOW!!! YOU WOULD THINK Nope. Cold food chicken dry as a bone only thing that was a decent was my cheese sauce with my chips,however chips were stale but hot like they were made yesterday . The restaurant is very dark and there booth seats had holes and wood was broken on a few booths chair Seats were the same. The music would be on some songs very loud and on some songs would be very light almost as if the songs that came on they liked they would turn it up. This place needs a makeover very nasty baby poop green booths and chairs . The service was just ok as it took her 15 minutes to refill our drinks and she speaks little to no English also asked her for no ice in my drink and of course I got ice however my wife asked for no tomatoes or onions in her food but we found onions in the food. LISTEN TO YOUR CUSTOMERS!!! the waitress kept trying to talk over us while we were ordering . read more

The food is very good and always quick but almost all the food is ridiculously expensive for what your getting

Wonderful service! Very tasty margarita. Delicious shrimp tacos. Will definitely come back!

My review is based on several visits. New Ulm doesn't provide many options for ethnic food, so based on those standards, Plaza Garibaldi is solid. There are many seats inside, with seating on the patio out front for warmer days. No issues when it comes to parking. The service is always quick, and the food is what you would expect. I recently ordered shrimp fajitas and noticed it wasn't sizzling like it should be when it comes out from the kitchen and was lukewarm. Other than that, the food is always tasty. The strawberry margaritas don't disappoint, even on a cold November day. For birthdays they do come out with a sombrero for the birthday person and sing. Along with that, ice cream is served. Overall, I recommend checking out Plaza Garibaldi if you are in New Ulm and looking for something different. read more

Awesome food, everything had really good flavor, staff was friendly, food was served quickly

People just keep coming here!! Service is excellent and very quick! Lots of staff keeping things clean and running smoothly!! I drove an extra hour tonight to get here, definitely worth it! read more

Plaza Garibaldi Mexican Restaurant - Chimichanga with beans and rice - Mexican Near Me - New Ulm, Minnesota

Fast and friendly service. Great tasting food. Definitely will come back next time I'm in town.

Fast, polite, and the food is delicious to boot. Can't wait to pass through New Ulm again so I can try some other options. read more

Plaza Garibaldi Mexican Restaurant - Awesome lunch specials for less than $10 - Mexican Near Me - New Ulm, Minnesota

Nice service and surprisingly good Mexican food in a gringo town. The menu has some compelling options beyond the usual suspects. I ordered pollo azteca which turned out to be delicious. For my toddler daughter, we ordered a vegetable quesadilla, thinking that it would be similar to what we make for her at home--mostly cheese with a few veggies sneaked in. Wrong--it was absolutely packed with a boatload of fresh, sauteed vegetables. This dish is definitely adult-worthy. And the portions of all of these entrees are huge, especially when you factor in the side of rice. read more

Food was pretty good. The service was decent especially since they were busy. My favorite part was the daiquiri. They added whip cream to the top and my was so good super super good. Thank you Plaza for the good experience! read more

Plaza Garibaldi Mexican Restaurant - Strawberry Daquari - Mexican Near Me - New Ulm, Minnesota

See all

We love Plaza! The food is great, I've loved everything I've tried. My kids approve, too, and they can be tough critics ;) We've had friendly staff, quick service, we will definitely be back. read more

We were recommended to go to this restaurant from the hotel we were staying at. Everything was ok but nothing fantastic and my food was cold. I think a little TLC and this place could be great. Cold food is never acceptable. read more

The food came out pretty fast, portions were really generous. The food tasted okay, your normal Mexican fare. The service was terrible. Our waiter was more interested in messing around with his coworkers than serving us. Took forever for him to take our order, messed up drinks, never checked back...pretty annoying overall. Will not come back again. read more

costumer service is no bueno...so terrible...didn't even give us silver ware...never even asked us how the food was...it was so bland and blah. read more

I ate here and got food poisoning. Was such a terrible experience. I would say to STAY AWAY from this place!

Egads this was bad. Just came from living in Mexifornia for a very long time and have had tons of autentico MX food. This is Minnesota-Mexican: no seasoning, no flavor. Nice people and I suppose they have to cater to the local taste, but it sure doesn't taste like much. read more

Food was burnt. My kids had chicken nuggets and they were rock hard. Chips and salsa were good. Had to wait a long time for drinks then again to get waited on for our food. Had to ask for refills. I was not that I'm pressed. Won't be back read more

As a non foodie I don't feel qualified to critique the food credibly. What I can say is as I work my way thru the menu, each dish is distinct from the others. When I leave I don't feel greased out or heavy cheese sauced. I leave looking forward to returning to try something different off their menu. read more

I would not return to this establishment... The food was served cold and when asked for a new plate that was hot, it took a very long time only to result in feeling ill the rest of the day. The chicken was not cooked and I was not able to eat it. Not to mention the price and service was awful! Do not recommend! read more

I live in Florida and was up here for a graduation. We were in a large group, so sometimes it is hard to get a good feel for a place in this setting. The waitstaff spoke poor English, so communication was a little difficult. Don't bother asking questions about the menu (which is quite vast). I got the blank look after asking a question, then the head nod with no answer. The free salsa and chips were good, but we ran out due to the large gluttony and competitive eating. The hotsauce at the table was erie! Chalked full of food coloring; my GF was concerned with the neon green color. I can't recall the brand, but who colors hotsauce?!? We ordered the beef fajitas. The flavor was pretty bad honestly. I was board after the first one, and switched back to the salsa and chips. I guess I wouldn't come back after reflecting on the experience. This is a great place to fill your hole after a night of drinking if you would like to sit down IMHO. read more

Food was super bland. We got bored with our food before we finished it. Service was fast and the staff were nice. Though I won't be coming back due to the flavorless entrees we had. read more

Never disappoints. Food is always fast and delish. If you are short on time, this is the place to be! We love the quesidella

The food never disappoints and the service is perfect! We love to eat here! On weekends, it is very busy. I think that means many others like the food and drink also. Wait staff is very friendly. If they have difficulty communicating, ask them to get someone else to help you. read more

Chips and a wonderful house-made salsa upon arrival. We ordered Garibaldi Burrito and Tacos de Carne Asado. They were both very good. The 3 tacos come with doubled corn tortillas and build your own options (e.g., beans, pico de gallo, sauce, etc.). The red sauce that came with the tacos was pretty special. Service was good, too. The only reason we did not give it 5 stars was a minor issue with the fountain drinks - we had to send iced tea back due to a strong sulphur smell and taste, but the server brought something else instead and did not charge us, so it was resolved fairly. We would recommend and come back if ever in New Ulm again. read more

Food was good but the waitress dropped a beer bottle on my foot and it shattered and it hurted

Love this place! Monster margaritas, fantastic food, generous portions. It can get a bit loud at prime times, especially happy hour, but well worth the noise. read more

The food is really good and the servers are all very nice. It's a great place for a group, too, always enough room for however many you have at your table! read more

The thing I dig about this place is they have both American style Mexican, for amateurs :) and more authentic choices. My go-to is definitely the Carnitas with a side of homemade Habanero salsa. The habanero salsa is not on the menu and you have to ask for it special, some of the servers don't even know that it exists, but it's well worth searching it out. Absolutely outrageous! Between the carnitas and the Carne Asada Tacos, you can't go wrong. And they have the american burritos for the kiddies. read more

I just moved here from southern California and this is as close as you can get to authentic.

My absolute favorite place to eat! No lie. I always get the nachos fajitas, I actually just ate there 2 days in a row now!! Their service is absolutely amazing. I would recommend them to everyone I know!!! read more

I have been coming to this restaurant for a few years now and have gotten the same thing. The portions have been getting smaller. I recently found a chicken bone in my chicken chimichanga and the food did not taste very well, it was very bland. I will not be coming to this restaurant for a while. read more

I stopped here while on the road because the sign said "Authentic Mexican restaurant." I started off with the guacamole, which was actually pretty good. But then I ordered a taco and was told they only had beef or chicken. What kind of Mexican restaurant doesn't serve Carnitas? So I ordered the beef soft shell taco and it was exactly as I had feared: just like my mom used to make. It was a flour tortilla with ground beef way over-seasoned with a packaged "taco seasoning", then a little lettuce and tomato. This thing was as un-authentic as you can possibly get. Nothing like they serve in Mexico and nothing like you'll find at a good Mexican restaurant. Definitely wouldn't eat here again. read more

We stopped here with a group on a Saturday night and the place was packed so I was worried about getting a table but surprisingly we were seated right away. Service was fast, everyone said their food was great. Mine tasted great but could have been a little warmer. Overall it is a great restaurant and I would definitely go back again. read more

Only so-so. Wouldn't go back again. My husband said if he was blindfolded he could not tell you what he was eating....pork ? chicken? beef ? burrito. Had hot lettuce over the top ??? Not good. Chicken nachos were tortilla chips with melted cheese then something like chicken salad over the chips. Chicken had no taste and was not hot. We've eaten at their restaurants in New Ulm, Manakto and Redwood Falls. Don't bother. read more

Great service and food, will come again anytime I visit New Ulm.