Takes over 2 hours to get my food every time it always comes cold and soggy and the delivery driver suck! Very rude I wish they did better I used to love this place! Update it's actually been three hours and this is what we got: Cold Italian wedding soup Soggy salad 2 Rock hard pizzas And whatever you want to call the picture (supposed to be a s'mores pizza) I would not recommend this place to anyone!! read more

pocono pizza and eatery - What if should look like per their menu! - Pizza Near Me - Albrightsville, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered from this place because it was a recommendation from our AirBnB host. We ordered over $100 worth of food. Waited THREE HOURS to get it. I ordered through Slice and they weren't able to get in touch with the restaurant. Finally I was able to and the young woman I spoke with initially was very kind and apologetic. The food still hadn't arrived so I called back. The next woman I spoke to was so ridiculously rude. I asked her to call the delivery driver to see where our food was and she said "I don't know what delivery driver takes what food and we have 5 drivers, you want me to call all 5 drivers?!" Uh, yes please, our $100 food order is late. She never said she would call, never apologized. Then she put me on the phone with a man who eventually hung up on me. Inexcusable service in my opinion. We told our AirBnB host to stop recommending them. read more

We ordered from here last year on vacation and waited an hour beyond when our did was to be ready. Did was decent so we gave them another try this year. Our food was too be ready in 45 minutes so we showed up 40 minutes in. The app showed our food was ready but we ended up waiting nearly another 30 minutes. Our order was brought out and we checked it while we were there, saw that the dessert we ordered was missing but opted to just leave and not have our food get even colder. This place is an absolute train wreck. I'm the considerable amount of time I spent there waiting for my food, I never saw a customer receive everything they ordered without a considerable wait or having to come back after getting all the way home. Save yourself the frustration and try virtually anywhere else. read more

My family ordered from this establishment on our holiday getaway in the Poconos. It was one of the only pizza spots around for miles as we were situated in Albrightsville. We ordered 4 large pies for our hungry crew. The bottom of the pizza crust was black, and although the flavors were passing as decent, the cheese did a number on my mom's stomach (she's sensitive to oily foods). Coming from Jersey, i guess you can say I'm spoiled by all the great pizza options that I'm accustomed to having back home, so I consider place beneath my standards. read more

See all

Reading the reviews in the area I wanted to keep an open and think that all the bad reviews were just snooty people from the city and New Jersey. So the photos of the pies on Slice looked good for this place so I decided to order. The mozzarella sticks were ok and I would order them again. The garlic parm wings were absolutely amazing. The pizza that's another story. i got the peirogie pizza and my wife the bbq chicken. Her pie didn't have a lot of chicken and this was hidden by the amount of sauce placed on the pie. Both of our pies were severely dry and stale tasting. It is almost as if they cooked the crust in the morning, let it sit around and then used it later. read more

Pretty solid pizza, came here with a large group and they accommodated us well. Left with stomachs full and happy kids. Very casual, better for only pick up. Not a lot of seating available just a table booth with like four chairs. Good for fast food to take to another place. Your typical pizza. read more

I always get an Italian sub with prosciutto added. I always stress extra mayonnaise, extra sweet peppers and I always get zero mayonnaise and zero sweet peppers. If they would actually listen or write down the order, this could be a very good sandwich. read more

They use to be one of the best now they at the bottom of the list. they give hand your order to you and alway to put EVERTHING you paid for in bag and box. They Don't care. The red sauce or whatever they call it is water down junk. Save you money go anywhere eles. read more

The redeeming factor here was the service. Staff was pretty nice. Some guy walked in to "repay his debts", I guess they gave him a pizza and he didn't pay? Either this place knows how to keep customers, or how to get in debt. God speed. I tried. I ordered the Gyro and that was a mistake. The wrap itself was pretty plain. Hardly any flavor. I started to think it was mistake when I took a closer look at the fries. I ate like 10 before giving up. They're edible (maybe?) but 100% old. Those fries were sad. The pickle... I took a bite for the sake of the review. The picture says it all. But! I came to a pizza joint. It wouldn't be right to judge it based on some dumb silly special that might've been just an attempt to get rid of old stuff. I tried the pizza. It's only good characteristic was the dough. Cheese? Beyond bland. Tomato Sauce? no, tomato flavored water. Try adding salt to it, maybe some other spices too or something. The pepperoni pieces were plain ol' pepp, nothing special. The flavor here was just not there. At all. Needs a better chef. Cooking goes beyond getting things to the right temp, it's gotta taste good too. You guys have like 6 employees, at least. Not sure why. Place doesn't seem that busy. Proof? You guys literally have a wall stacked with pizza boxes. If that doesn't scream "we've got too much time to kill", I don't know what does. While eating and overhearing the guy repaying his debts at the register, I noticed the cashier girl jumped up and looked over to the customers feet, and saying "sorry, thought I saw something"... uhhhh what? could've been a bit smoother lol The place doesn't strike me as dirty, and I really don't care if you guys are busy or not, but just season the food better and try not cook stuff when people order it so people like me aren't getting old fries and god knows what else. read more

See all

This place used to be a solid option. Got a very simple order, pierogis, cheese fries and garlic knots. Ordered takeout, went back to the Airbnb and they didn't include the cheese sauce or onions for the pierogis, had to drive back. Upon return, the fries were super soggy, onions were not fried and the garlic knots were terrible. I had to doctor up the whole order to be edible. You will have a much better experience with Gagliano's Pizza down the street, this place does not make food with any love or care and expensive. read more

Very yummy!! The chicken parm pizza is to die for, and I recommend the grandma Sicilian

Food was burnt , and forgot the salad dressing. Staff would just smile at you like they did not understand English.

The food is very good, I'll give them that but they are cutting back. A cheesesteak used to have meat falling off of it. The last one I got, although delicious, only had half the roll with meat in it. I ordered 12 wings and only received 9, I didn't feel like driving back so I just sucked it up. They are making it difficult to place an order. They're so involved with Slice that your call now goes to a Slice call center and then it goes to the restaurant. More people involved means more mistakes in my opinion. And the woman on the register, oh boy! I swear she has wet brain or something. read more

Food was delicious ! Fast delivery and the food was hot and fresh when we received it. Labor Day weekend staying at an Airbnb. Would order from here again. read more

See all

I like their sweet chili boneless wings. I usually order the same stuff.. I like their pepperoni pizza.It can be a hit or miss depending on how busy it is.I would still recommend them though. read more

Very very yummy food sir, I enjoyed the food a lot and it made my tummy twinkle, the service was good and the guy was kinda bad ngl, and I'm pretty sure there was a termite in my pizza but that's okay cause it's extra protein read more

So I decided to give this place another chance because I only hear good things, but yet again I was let down... They forgot a good portion of my order like they always do. At this point it really feels a little personal as I used to work there and left due to there lack of running a good business and the disrespect I was getting from grown adults at the age of 15. They're terrible at getting orders out on time and when you call to ask about anything regarding your food they are very rude with the answers. read more

Ordered delivery and they forgot to send the pizza... the biggest part of the order. We then had to drive to pick it up in a snowstorm, and they seemed annoyed when we arrived to get it. On top of that the pizza was left just sitting in the counter so it was ice cold by the time we got there. The least they could've done is kept it warm since we spoke to them on the phone and they're the ones who told us to come pick it up. Absolute jerks. read more

Placed order through Yelp. Via grubhub at 7:15 pm. $113. Estimated deliver 8:14-8:34 Called the shop at 8:50 since we still never received order. They don't know if it's out for delivery or not and couldn't tell me anything. Called grubhub and they tell me order was received by the store and my card has been charged. Told me to call back at 9:20 to figure it out with manager. Grubhub then puts me on hold and calls the shop. They tell me they got a hold of the manager and said the "pizza will be cold" "they're running out of dough" and that it will be on its way right away. The manager offered a $21 discount off of the order. (The way this is going who knows if my card will even be reimbursed) Delivery guy calls me and tells me that he's at my address when he's not and tells me there's no 726. Tells me to come out to the road to show him while I'm standing on the second floor balcony and can see down the road. He's no where close. Delivers the food. Gives us a soda. Get inside. Food cold like expected. The $22 dollar cheesesteak Stromboli has no cheesesteak lmao. Gets better and better. Pic for reference Thanks for the free dough and cheese. Yeah. Thank god I got that $21 discount. read more

pocono pizza and eatery - Cheesesteak Stromboli. $22 - Pizza Near Me - Albrightsville, Pennsylvania

See all

Placed order and it was never delivered. Never answered calls but was charged..... disappointing

Read reviews before ordering from here!! The only redeeming quality about this place was the lady who took our order over the phone. We were told that our pizza would be delivered in 45 minutes- 1 hour. That couldn't be further from the truth. We called again after 1.5 hours just for them to tell us that they will contact the delivery driver to figure out where our pizza was. Over TWO hours passed and still no sign of the driver.... We call once again for them to tell us that our ticket was lost and they had to place our order again. So after almost 3 hours of waiting, we finally recieved our food and it was absolutely not worth the wait. It was mediocre at best and definitely not worth the price nor the wait. Choose another pizza place elsewhere in the area! read more

It's delicious!!! Best pizza around. All food was hot and fresh. Service really great too. I like that you can order on the Slice app.

2 hour wait even for pickup. Staff not concerned with service. Food was cold because we had to wait for the pizza.

Really solid pizza place. No, it's not gourmet, but for the price you couldn't possibly do better. Pizza was delicious, big slices, great crust. Garlic knots perfect. Boneless wings as good or better than Pizza Hut. Great place to grab food on the way in or out of Hickory Run State Park. read more

Came here to order for the first time. I understand the weekend is extremely busy & some customers can be so vulgar and rude, you can see there's about 10 orders on the board and people can be so terrible. One lady came here and she demanded that her pizza was remade and then she called one of the workers a racist term to go back to their country, I would highly recommend this place, and support a family business over a chain. They're doing the best they can, be patient and show kindness. read more

My family and I were on vacation in Albrightsville,Jan 2024. We ordered one pizza pie & wings at 6:11pm on a Monday. With tip it cost us around $44 which is whatever because we're on vacation. At 7:40 we still haven't received our food so I called to see if they got our order (made online). The delivery driver came at 7:50 which was roughly hour and forty minutes after we placed it on a Monday. Pizza was cold & wings had zero sauce. I hate to bash a local establishment but if you're on vacation I'd look elsewhere. read more

Unfortunately, this is a situation where I have to leave a negative review. We ordered through Door Dash and the ETA was about 75 minutes, which is totally reasonable on a holiday weekend. Three hours later, still no pizza. Two Dashers were assigned and left because the restaurant was so behind. I get it, it's Labor Day Weekend. Maybe don't sign up for Door Dash? I contacted support and they advised me to cancel. Here's my beef - they're still showing up as available on Slice. Good luck to those folks. Do not order for delivery. There's a high likelihood that you won't get it. read more

Pocono pizza is gross. Three days ago me and my two friends order a slide of chicken bacon ranch pizza and we all had food poisoning the next two days . My brothers went and got a slide of regular pepperoni pizza too and they threw it up. Something is off about that place.... Also we shouldn't have had to wait twice for single slices of pizza two hours each time . One time they asked me to come back to pick it up at close when ordered it at 7:30 read more

This place is a hit or miss. Their eggplant parmigiana is good. Their french fries were terrible (I know it's a pizza place, but how do you mess up french fries??) read more

Was much better when the former owners had it. Pizza was terrible. Way too much oregano. I ate 1.5 slices and threw the rest in the trash. The fries were the one thing they didn't change much and they were good. read more

Ordered pick up two days in a row from here and it was super delicious!! Best chicken parm sub I've ever had-- they load it up! Also very yummy wings. The fry portion is pretty sad to be honest, but all the other portions are great. Everyone there was nice, both on the phone and in person. Would definitely come back if I'm ever in the area! read more

Great spot for take out, food is good from the pasta to the chicken cheesesteak, fresh cut French Fries, and the pizza. Baked ziti was amazing according to my wife, mom ordered the fries which she liked, my brother got the chicken cheese steak with bacon, and I split a pizza with my son, order was ready fast, and the food was hot and exactly what we ordered, hope the consistency is there when we order next time read more

See all

The pizza, and especially the fries are great. Their cheese steaks, not so much. I asked for a Pizza steak with fried onions, and I got a cheese steak with sauce and onions. Although I would not complain most of the time, since that is my go to sandwich, I purposely asked for a pizza steak because I knew I did not like their regular cheese steaks because they use that yellow soupy cheese, which in my opinion, makes it taste awful. If they stuck with white American cheese and melted it throughout on the grill, it may taste better. There were plenty of fatty pieces of meat in the sandwich as well. I had to cut my losses and just throw away the sandwich. I wanted pizza cheese and the toasted roll that comes on a pizza steak but it didn't happen. Maybe I'll try it again but this time, make sure they understand the difference between a cheese steak with sauce and a pizza steak. read more

oth my wife and I ordered pasta, which were some of the worst pasta dishes we've ever eaten. For starters, I had requested Ziti, and got Penne instead. The order in total was $40, which is very overpriced. As far as flavor goes, the meals tasted bland, old, and rancid even. We both got stomach aches after eating. I don't recommend this restaurant's services to anyone. read more

Great pizza and sandwiches. Quick and friendly service. We hit it three times while on vacation.

the crazy fries are fries with ketchup and mayo gross and $7.50 for a tiny portion this place wont be around for long read more

Great food! We picked up our order on our way to the cabin. They were very busy but right on time with our food.

Nice place good food people were friendly. Had a pie with half pepperoni and half onion was good and spaghetti with meat sauce was good .. would I go back if I'm in the Pocono .. Yes , read more

I ordered a large pie, wings and jalapeño corn cheese poppers and when I called they said I have a attitude when I did not she said I can't hear you because there's a lot of people in here then on purpose she forgot to give me the jalapeño corn cheese poppers. Then I called back and said I have placed an order and picked it up and you guys forgot to give me my jalapeño cheese poppers then I said is it possible you could deliver them and she said yes. Then once the delivery person got here she said next time you order tell them you have 10% off. read more

I'm a snobby New Yorker...well at least when it comes to pizza. I wasn't expecting much when I ordered two pies, I was just hungry and Pocono Pizza and Eatery were the closest to my location. I was pleasantly surprised by how good their pizza is. Also I highly recommend their pirogies and garlic knots, absolutely delicious. If you meet the time window, which I think is 9pm, their delivery guy is awesome. The two times we got delivery he came earlier than expected, which is great when you're hungry. read more