Spread the buffalo chicken out. Cook the pizza a little longer. Seasoning is blessing. read more

Mamma Marias - Food trash. How the buffalo in the middle of the pie. Spread it out and the crust/bottom of the pizza. Straight dough. - Pizza Near Me - Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

Had a craving for Italian, so picked this place after checking out the reviews. It didn't disappoint! We ordered a large meat lovers and chicken parm sub to share amongst 3 people. Lots of meat toppings and good crust; a little soggy in the middle of the pizza, so tough to eat a slice with your hands. The sub was good too, although could have used a little more sauce. Would return when in the area. read more

Been there twice for take out. Grandma pizza and regular. I find it good But expensive. I come from pizza capital of world Old Forge PA. It's good but was over priced and not good looking OH WOW little Sloppy. Other than that Give it a try. My opinion on not.I work at Army Depot I do send ppl there when looking just for pizza if from out of local area. read more

Pizza I ordered was a meat lovers it was ok... Nothing like I grew up with living in Bergen county New Jersey but then again I have yet to find a pizza establishment out here worthy of that kind of pizza. It's also hard to find anybody that delivers by the time I wound up it was $40 plus for this pizza never again read more

Here for a conference and stopped in for some pizza. The staff were so nice and the service was great. The pizza has so much flavor. Check them out. Support local businesses when you are here they are hidden gems. read more

Everyone was friendly and fun. The dining area looked clean and inviting. The service was good. The pizza was not. I ordered a Large Mama Special (?) and the crust was wet and practically raw. Bummed me out because it cost over $35! One way to fix that wiggly crust would be to pre-cook the veggies so the liquid content doesn't affect the crust the way it did. Another way would be to cook it longer - letting the crust crisp up. Just a suggestion folks. I'm not sure if it was an "off" day - I was camping across the street - but, I would be willing to give it a second try. read more

Mamma Marias - No one at our campsite liked the pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

See all

I was staying at my family's house nearby and had a craving for pizza. Mamma Maria's did not disappoint. I'm from NYC so good pizza is important to me. I get the feeling these guys have roots in NY based on the way they make their pizza and the sports paraphernalia on the walls. If you want a New York slice while you're away for the weekend, this is the place for you. The garlic knots were also good! read more

The pizza is ok, everyone needs to stop comparing pocono pizza to New York pizza just because it's cut like a triangle doesn't mean it taste like nyc pizza. It may resemble nyc pizza but way smaller and not the same crisp or taste but it's edible. The Beef patty with coco bread and cheese is over priced. It's not like they make the beef patty or coco bread from scratch. The beef patty you can buy at the super market the brand is Tower isles beef patty. read more

Dreadful. I don't know how they have such positive reviews. This is bowling alley quality pizza for outrageous prices. I paid $25 for a plain medium pie ($35 after delivery fees!!!) to get such a subpar pizza. The only good thing is that they deliver, since most other pizza places in the area don't. Avoid. read more

Mamma Marias - Pizza Near Me - Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

Absolutely delicious! We are picky with our pizza ( originally from Brooklyn) and travel all over the Poconos to try places out, have to say super happy we tried this place out. We ordered a medium pizza half pepperoni and a grandma pizza. Our grandsons loved the pepperoni pizza, as of course grandpa did too lol and the grandma's pizza was super delish! The sauce !!!!!! Yum. Service was wonderful as well, super friendly and quick . Will definitely go back ! read more

We've not been to the Pocono's in over six years. Mamma Maria's was one of our go to place for a good Italian meal. Our Party of four we had eggplant parmigiana was delicious, shrimp fra diavalo was just the right amount of heat, veal parmigiana was delicious, spaghetti and meatballs were good, everyones pasta was Al dente, our salads crispy and fresh, the bread was just ok. Portions were plentiful. Service was attractive and friendly. Still on our list as a very good place for authentic Italian food. read more

For delivery, Mamma Maria's is tops! Huge portions that'll feed you right. The Italian Hero made multiple people in my framily very happy (and these folks are...particular...when it comes to a proper Italian Hero!). Their bread is really good. Pasta dishes (we had ravioli and Chicken Parm) were both solid. The most impressive part was how fast the delivery arrived considering it was a large family order (everything in the order was correct and arrived at proper temperature) + the delivery guy having to go through the folks at the gate + our rental house being another 5 mins drive from the gate. And the delivery guy respected the 'No Contact' delivery request. If we're ever vacationing in the area again, we know what our first night meal will be! read more

Mamma Marias - Chicken Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

Pizza was excellent. We are from NY and fussy about our pizza. This pizza was crispy and delicious. We will definitely come back! We'd like to try other menu items! read more

I wasn't a fan of the pizza the shrimp scampi was alright. My son enjoyed his chicken tenders but was upset they didn't send ketchup for the fries or the burger. They could have included condiments and utensils as we are staying at a hotel. Not only did it take over an hour for delivery customer service was just bad.. so glad I don't live here the food wasn't worth the price first and last time ordering. I understand inflation but the food quality has to match the price. read more

I enjoyed the pizza and garlic bread that I ordered, but the cost was crazy expensive. Large pepperoni pizza was almost $27, garlic bread was $9, and with UberEats fees (the person who answered the phone at Mama Maria's said they don't take any phone orders for pickup or delivery) and tip, I paid $54 for just pizza and garlic bread. I prefer to patronize local businesses, but wow. read more

We were staying at an Airbnb in the area and discovered this delectable Italian restaurant . We had the lasagna which was loaded with cheese and an amazing sauce. My wife had a delicious chicken Parmesan hero. The bread was soft and soaked up the sauce nicely. If you are looking for something fancy this is not the place but if you are looking for delicious basic Italian do not pass it up read more

Im so happy I found this place. My kids love pizza and I must say , I truly enjoyed it myself. The garlic knots are delicious. But ofcourse if you are in Pa, you have to try a Philly cheese steak, you won't be disappointed. They just have order for pickup or delivery. read more

See all

Great local restaurant for a good meal. It's certainly nothing fancy but the pizza is actually really good. We've had meals here several times and have alway had great service and good food. They don't have draft beer but the do have nice, cold bottled beer. read more

Party of 20 showed up out of the blue. Sweet vibe in here, adorable waitress and waiter. The garlic rolls were fabulous, eggplant on the money but my favorite was the Grandma Pie which I never even heard of before! Delicious! Sorry we ate most of it before i took a picture! Highly recommend! read more

Mamma Marias - Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

The world's best parmigiana meatball sub in the world ever!! Served hot and fresh to the table, crispy bread crust, soft bread, large tenderloin meatballs, the marinara sauce tasted like perfectly ripe tomatoes were simmered for days. Heavenly comfort food. It was so good I couldn't put it down until it was gone... I was STUFFED! Thank you Mamma Marias for the good food and good service. read more

FAST & HOT Delivery - Pizza is on point - TRY THE GRANDMA Sicilian! Typically I don't like thick crusts so I usually don't like a Sicilian pie but WOW this is a game changer! read more

My wife and I were in town for the weekend on vacation and stopped here because of the yelp review. Right now it's only open for takeout and I guess delivery. We got the grandmas pizza because of the reviews on here. It was delicious. It didn't LOOK as good as it did in the photos here, and the crust was softer than I expected, but it was delicious. We also got the "spaghetti and chicken parm" but substituted fettuccini. It was excellent. We were both impressed. Overall, I'd say it was an enthusiastic 4 :) read more

Mamma Marias - Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

See all

Chose this place bc of the reviews but every that came was extremely disappointing. This Carbonara didn't even move from the mold of the container when i emptied it out it was disgusting. Everyone thought so too. Don't do it. read more

Mamma Marias - Gross - Pizza Near Me - Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

Great service for a large order! The order was correct and ready on time. Best of all, the Pizza was great. Thanks!

Awesome little find while we were away. Great food and great service. We have seafood and the kids had pasta dishes and all of it was tasty and hot when served. read more

been to mamma mia's several times and was always pleased with not only the food but the service as well. today my husband ad i stopped to have lunch. he had veal marsala which was absolutely delicious. along with it came spaghetti and we requested the same marsala sauce be put on the spaghetti... delicious. a salad was served with delicious salad dressing and italian bread before the entree.. i had a meatball parm hero and had to take half home... there again delicious. we are happy to have a go to place that is always good. i would definitely recommend going there. read more

Great food and service would highly recommend!! Also serves drinks and very conveniently placed away from the busy mount Pocono!

We recently moved to area and were looking for dinner. Of course with everything going on take out was our only choice. The last time we visited we tried the pizza at Mamma Maria's and it was a hit. Last night we had the lasagna, chicken Alfredo and fried diablo as entrees. They were all huge portions (enough for lunch today) and tasted super fresh and home made. The calamari were huge and perfectly fried with just the right bite. Service was tops as well, even walked me out to my car and carried my order for me. I would highly recommend! read more

I'm from NY so I'm a very harsh pizza/bagel critic and let me tell you I was SO pleasantly surprised. Came in yesterday while on vacation for a margarita pie & it was mind blowing how delicious it was. The sauce, cheese, flavor, crunch in the crust - just everything! They were super nice and had one of my fav tv shows on. I will absolutely be returning my next visit. Hoping to be buying some property up there soon & that will definitely be our pizzeria of choice! read more

I ordered Chicken Cheese Steak with mushroom, green onion and onion and it was one of the healthiest cheese steak (minus the bread) I've ever had. My friend ordered Chicken Parmigiana and thought it was ok. Service was good and friendly! The address on Yelp is incorrect, see my picture for the correct location. read more

See all

Probably the worst Spaghetti and Eggplant and Chicken Alfredo Pasta I have ever eaten. Absolute tasteless, portions were good size but food was terrible for the price. I can't comment on the pizza, Stromboli's and Calzones which could be better. They should just stick with the quick pickup foods and forego the dinner plates. They probably do ok for business since it's the only pizza joint for miles in the middle of nowhere. read more

I just bought a large pie with sausage, it had hardly no cheese or sausage it was like eating dough with sauce. Terrible pizza at top dollar. Never again. read more

Amazing pizza!! We ordered the Grandma's pizza and a cheese pizza for the kids. Both were delicious!

I would prefer to give 3.5 stars but Yelp won't allow... Let me start by saying I'm a New Yorker and know good pizza. I went to college in PA and had a LOT of bad pizza along the way. For PA pizza to a NYer, it's pretty good. Calzone was average. Staff was friendly. You can order online. They offer free delivery. Don't let the building appearance influence your decision. read more

New owners the food is just ok. Little too expensive. The old family that owned was much better

Got the grandma pizza this evening and I must say it was excellent. This has to be one of the top pizza places in the area. Thank you! read more

The pizza here is basically NY style. When we went here today, the chef wasn't here so the food came pretty slow. They have a lunch deal 2 slices and 1 soda for $5. Pizza tasted good, no complaints. We also got chicken wings and the guy asked us how spicy we wanted, we told him spicy. It's so funny that the wings were extremely spicy, my mouth was burning lol It was probably the spiciest food we ever ate from a restaurant. We love spicy food so we enjoyed it a lot!!!! Overall I would come back again for pizza and spicy chicken wings. read more

See all

A good family run Pizza spot. Delicious food and the people that run the place are really nice.

Amazing pizza!! Stands out above the rest. We're from Philly and were hoping to find a great Tobyhanna go-to while we're up visiting the Poconos and this will certainly be it!! Grandma pizza was our favorite... highly recommended. read more

Mamma Marias - Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

See all

Got one large pie, half plain, half pep. They use the tiny cuppy pepperonis if that counts for anything to you. Pizza is pretty greasy. Surprised it wasn't wearing scuba gear. The sauce was flavorful and the crust wasn't bland. I give it like 6.8/10. read more