Great Pizza and Stromboli. We ordered three pies and a steak Stromboli and everyone loved it...even my Italian Dad who's the pickiest pizza eater ever. read more

Pizza was decent, garlic knots were massive and not what any of us expected, wings were not edible- mushy like they had been reheated in a microwave, sauce half on them- waste of $17. Not many choices when staying at Kalahari, but this is not one I'd recommend unless you're JUST getting pizza read more

Stopped in on Labor Day, as most places were closed, so it was my first visit. Very pleased with their excellent veggie pizza and greek salad. I had ordered ahead, and when I walked in the door at the appointed time, the order was there waiting for me. Will be back! read more

See all

Pizza was good Kids were not a fan of the other stuff Buffalo wings were good Garlic parm wings had a sauce on them that the 10yo did not like 15yo loved the Mac n cheese bites Mozzarella stick were ok. Service at pickup was great. Super friendly. read more

2 slice and a drink for $5 is a New Yorkers dream come true! My picky eater really enjoyed the pizza and as NYC native their claim of New York style pizza they lived up to the hype! read more

This is a belated review, but felt it was worth commenting on the service here. Our food was ok but I was very disappointed by the service. We made a fairly large takeout order for a family dinner, over $130 of pizza, wings, sandwiches, salad. When we came to pick it up, I asked for a small plastic cup (like they use for salad dressing) to put some crushed red pepper flakes in for the pizza. It wasn't practical to shake it onto the pie as not everyone likes it spicy. They said they would have to charge me for the little cup. read more

Food was good but interior is very disappointing. Dining room is very unattractive and unwelcoming. They make no effort to make dining room or counter area where you order look nice or welcoming read more

This is our pizza spot for when it's pizza night. Friendlies people, always fast service with a smile!

WOW!! Great customer service! Felt very welcomed. The price was GREAT!! And was nicely priced .

We ordered here a couple times on our recent vacation. I had a chicken parm sandwich and a deluxe pizza. I had to order the sandwich because I was intrigued by the concept of a "Parm House". Makes them seem like Parm Specialists. I liked the chicken parm and it would order it again if Iived in the area. It had plenty of cheese, good sauce and a decent quality cutlet. The pizza was pretty good. It was a bit doughier than I prefer. Also, the toppings weren't evenly distributed. They did seem kind of busy which I'm sure affected the details. In any event, I think AJ's is a pretty good option for takeout pizza or grinders/subs/heroes (whatever the lingo is in that area) if you live in the area. Four Stars read more

See all

Chanelle...Best Pizza Ever!!! You won't be disappointed. Thin slice sweet sauce goodness I will be back for more!!! read more

AJ's Pizza and Parm House - The perfect pie...pizza goodness - Pizza Near Me - Long Pond, Pennsylvania

See all

Best pizza in Mt. Pocono. I've tried most of them and this is my favorite. Chewy, cheesy and fairly priced. The sauce is light and flavorful- not thick and pasty. I make it a point to have it every time I visit. read more

I ordered three pizzas for delivery at 7 pm. They arrived at 9 pm. They were room temperature. The restaurant is 10 minutes away. I don't even know how a pizza place can manage to have service this terrible. read more

Heard that we had a NY style slice in Mt. Pocono and I had to know if I was being lied to or if there was some truth to this. Turns out, this is a factual statement. Still not NY pie (not much is) but very close to what I'd expect and more importantly ... it's not two hours away. Have also had a solid chicken cheesesteak and chicken parm here as well. I'll definitely be back. read more

AJ's Pizza and Parm House - Slice from AJ's - Pizza Near Me - Long Pond, Pennsylvania

See all

Delicious!!!! Very reasonable prices and fantastic NY style pizza! Fast service. Big portions. Friendly service. We went back again!

Having been eating from this place for years but it seems like they have changed the ingredients for the pizza. The pizza used to reminder me on the New York style pizza and now the pizza is super greasy and sweet. read more

AJ's Pizza and Parm House - Pizza Near Me - Long Pond, Pennsylvania

Ordered delivery 3 pizzas. Two regular and a Sicilian. They made a mistake and gave us three regular pizzas. No Sicilian. The pizzas were good and tasty. The gyros was not original on a spit but pre-sliced gyros. read more

See all

We ordered 4 pies, wings, mozzarella sticks, broccoli bites, cauliflower bites to Kalahari waterpark last night... they delivered it right to front door of resort and gave us a five minute heads up call... people on phone were awesome... the wings were really great!!! Like really great... I like my wings sauced up and meaty... the bites were definitely restaurant depot but for the poconos it's fine. As for the pizza it kind of tasted franchised but we ate it and we liked it... almost a dominoes flare... but like I said for the poconos it was good for out party of 12.... If your doing something around area I would recommend the place... we will order again next time we go to resort... read more

Its a take out place in a shopping center. Pizza was greasy and underwhelming. Pepperoni roll was overfilled and greasy. Parm, yes its in their name, is meh at best. Sauce is way overgarlicky and wet. read more

Great pizza and great prices Stayed at Kalahari and their pizza was too overpriced Yours was perfect will be back ! read more

First time ordering from here might be my last Everyone is always looking for great pizza I can say this probably isn't it I'm not trying to be rude but both pizzas were very greasy the toppings on the pepperoni pizza had slid to the corner of the box and the cuts were a little weird very small slices and very large slices Maybe it's because I ordered later in the evening and they were just in a hurry I will say that I did like the crust read more

AJ's Pizza and Parm House - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Long Pond, Pennsylvania

See all

Finally have some good pizza in Pocono Pines. Their Stromboli is huge and really tasty. Good pizza and subs. Staff is very friendly and helpful. Make sure to look at their specials - some good deals during the week. read more

Ordered 5 pizzas last night, they were ready in 20 minutes, $99 for 2 cheese, 1 peperoni, 1 meatball, and 1 chicken bacon ranch. There was an issue with the order and upon finding out the owner reached out to me personally to offer ways to remedy the situation, which he did. Pepperoni pizza was their best, cheese pizza was good, the corrected meatball pizza was great! Good food, good service. Thank you. read more

Delicious! We were in town for a superbowl party with family and it was perfect! My kids live in NYC and they know a thing or two about pizza, said it was outstanding! read more

Absolutely amazing pizza that will blow your taste buds away! The staff are incredibly friendly, and the delivery drivers bring good vibes straight to your door. Every bite is a celebration, and the whole experience is just fantastic! read more

AJs is our favorite pizza spot! The best pizza on the mountain. The owner Mike is awesome.

Food is delicious! And Thank you for your service for making my sandwiches to my liking!!

Great place that delivers to Kalahari and the stuff was all made fresh. Had two slices and a Stromboli. The real deal. Next time the garlic knots are on my list. Asian cashier was super friendly and was kind enough to bring our order out to us. Service with a smile. read more

Great pizza Friendly staff The restaurant was neat and clean This was our second time getting takeout The pizza has a great ny style crust Tonight we tried the chicken bacon ranch And it was delicious!! 10 out of 10 read more

Wow!!! I ordered the Meatball Parm and it was fantastic!! The dinner came with a good looking salad and a mini loaf of bread. As for the meal - the meatballs taste homemade and the flavor was very good. Tons of sauce - I wish I had more noodles to balance out the meatballs! I would definitely order again! read more

AJ's Pizza and Parm House - Meatball Parmesan - $16 - Pizza Near Me - Long Pond, Pennsylvania

See all

The pizza is always great. The best pizza I've had in the area ever. The one guy,I think the owner, makes it amazing and the other pizza makers are pretty good too. Never didn't like our order. read more

what great pizza this place makes. I drive from Effort pa which is maybe 20 min drive. that said totally worth it.

Deeeeeeeeeelicoussss!! I'm staying at kalahari and was hungry for pizza and found AJs!! Love it!! Would definitely come again! Thank you Mike and Chanel lol! read more

Now this is great pizza! I've tried many pizza places in the area and they have all been disappointing. AJ's has a crispy crust and quality cheese. It's the NY pizza we've been missing! Can't wait to return. read more

I was disappointed with the ham calzone I had yesterday. I have ordered the ham calzone three times now. The first two times it was made perfectly and I really liked it. The one yesterday was mostly bread and very little ham and cheese filling. I am very leery to order it again. read more

The food and service here were amazing. I highly recommend it. The pizza we ordered was true NYC style, faghetaboufit!!

For the Poconos (from NJ) this was very good pizza and calzones. Got plain and pepperoni pies (needed some more slices of pepperoni, was definitely a little lacking), and got cheese and sausage calzones - everything was great. The real highlight was the garlic knots. Amazing!! Huge, garlicky, cheesy, hot - everything you want! Don't come here without ordering them. read more

We ordered takeout on a Friday. When we called the wait time was long but it was a good sign that they were busy. First time trying the pizza and now it is my favorite. The baked garlic parm knots and gyros were excellent as well. The honey bbq wings were delicious. Definetly ordering again. read more

This hidden shopping center on route 940 holds AJ's Pizza and Parm House, the absolute best pizza we've found in the Poconos. The food is so delicious, and the people are welcoming and really friendly. Parking is abundant and easy. read more

Food was delicious. We had pizzas, strombolis and calzones and it was all great! Delivery was a little slow on a Sunday night but worth the wait! read more