Since we visited Chincoteague during a shoulder season, not everything in town was open. Island…read moreCreamery saved the day with ridiculously delicious ice cream. If you love coffee and chocolate, get the Java Jolt - the coffee ice cream was rich, the chocolate covered espresso beans were delicious, and the brownie chunks were fudgy . If you want something a little fruitier, the Cherry Vanilla is so good. Lots and lots of black cherries. The Pineapple Upside Down was a little bit of a bummer - it was super sweet. We were hoping for a strong pineapple flavor but it mostly tasted of sugar. Still nice but I wouldn't get it again.

I forgot to write down the flavours I got but I combined a chocolate peanut butter ice cream and…read moreanother ice cream (I think the snickers one?) for my shake and it was delicious. I would recommend this place and be down to visit again. Most my friends got ice cream in waffle cones and they looked very good (and had large servings!)

Best soft serve around. Great service just remember they only take cash. My favorite place to visit…read morewhen in Chincoteague.

Scoped this place out in the morning on the way out. This is a very family-oriented establishment…read moreand it shows. Coffee and donuts were decent. I found the Latte to be a bit watered down, but the frozen mocha was good. Peanut butter donut was alright. It was also uncomfortably hot inside at 9am, we were sweating!

Lily is the most adorable cashier at this super cute candy store filled with everything! They have…read moreassorted candy, stuffed animals, toys, shirts, sweatshirts, bracelets, mugs, magnets and keychains! Family owned and operated even during the winter season! So many fun things to do around here after Assatague national park with horses!

Ponytails is a fun store!! They had all sorts of gummies, chocolates, fudge, Dubai chocolate, ice…read morecream, slushies and more candy. There was also clothes, souvenirs, cute cups, crystals, bracelets, and stuffed animals. It was a kids and adults Dreamland!! The town is very laid back and country, so this was one of the larger stores in the area. The vibe was cool and the staff were friendly!! They let us try a few ice cream flavors also. I had a pleasant time taking photos with the cartoon characters and just feeling like a kid again!! The nostalgia was real!! I'm really enjoying this little island and would certainly recommend it to anyone who wants a nice hometown kinda feel and a relaxing getaway. Although you'd think there isn't much to do if you think outside of the box it's just enough to fill up your day. If your a foodie there are a good amount of places to eat at. So if you're here for a visit Pony tails is a place you should definitely add to your list! Check them out!!

People are lined up at all the ice cream and fro yo places, right out the door on any given summer…read moreevening. So why not Hurdy Gurdy? So we took a chance. This is your typical fro yo serve yourself place. The ear splitting rap music was unbearable, and the Methadone clinic decorating didn't help, neither did the glaring lights inside and outside the place. C'mon Mr/mrs Gurdy! Show some pride! You've got the product, you've got the location, now just tweak up the atmosphere and signage and maybe, just maybe, you'll last more than one season.

This business is closed. Only the sign remains. Someone from a neighboring business said the…read morelandlord hasn't taken down the sign.

I first ran into their delicious ice cream when I happened by their sister location right outside…read moreof Ocean City many years ago. My kids (who are now much bigger!) still dream of their favorite ice cream full of yummy bubble gum bits. My favorite is their blueberry! Don't get me started on their cheese! When I heard that they had opened another location, we had to go check it out! This new location is awesome! Not only are there more products to check out (fresh eggs anyone?), you can get your ice cream and sit on their porch and enjoy the gorgeous view.

Ice cre good things to say. The place is clean, local family…read morethat does a great job. They make buyter, and have beef as well. Fresh!

Knowing the ice cream is made with local dairy and in small batches makes indulging so much easier…read more It's almost always busy and service has always been great. If there's a wait it's worth it. It's places like this that's actually made me never wanting bigger named ice cream brands again. Quality is great, tastes amazing and for what you're getting it's super affordable.

Love this place. This time we got a peanut butter cup milkshake and one Java jolt milkshake with a…read morebanana.

Ice cream and service good, fast service, clean environment, farm setting. Plenty of parking, they…read morewill have a market in near future

Listen, we've had a lot of ice cream in the area. It's all…read moredecent but this was so good that we couldn't wait to come back. Preferences vary but I'm just not a fan of Hershey or other wholesale selling ice cream spots. That's what a lot of ice cream places are, resellers of other ice cream. NOT HERE! Lines can get wild in the summer but there is plenty of setting and they have massive farm fans above head. It's just nice to sit and enjoy every once in a while. Plus, it's always nice to see the cows and sometimes you might find calves visiting.

They just have really good ice cream! The counter folks are…read morevery polite and have no problem offering samples of the varied flavors. I usually always order what I sampled. This visit was the Bourbon Caramel Crunch. The decor is Beachy and cozy at this location. It is a very narrow building. They have a garden like seating area in the side alley. The waffle cones are made fresh and they are delicious!

Some of the best ice cream I've had in a while! Classic mom and pop, rich and creamy dessert. They…read moremake the flavors in house and the chocolate peanut butter flavor was unbelievable! The peanut butter and jelly wasn't my favorite, so would skip that one next time but will definitely be back to try more flavors.

Love the blue, green, and pink color scheme. Since Dairy Queen shut down I thought we'd never have…read moreanother ice cream spot to take its place. Thankfully Chilly Billy's isn't far off from where DQ was. I wish they had an eat in area but considering the small size of the building that used to be Laura's pretty paws it's understandable, plus I'm used to it since DQ didn't have one either. The people who served the ice cream were quite friendly and lively. While I'm sure people may complain a bit bout prices, for the high quality, delicious taste, and decent serving sizes, it's worth it. I went there at noon today and tried a birthday cake flavored ice cream on a waffle cone and a large cup of their peanut butter brownie (so good) and cookies and cream ice cream. For $18.02 it's pretty good and worth the money. Will definitely be going there more often!

Hits the spot when you are craving ice cream in the ole' traditional way! The nicest, hometown…read morecustomer service, BIG portions, and delicious. They even have sugar-free options and sorbet. Perfect location and plenty of parking to just swoop in. So swoop!