If you are from up north and you miss proper New York pizza, go to I Love New York Pizza in…read moreMcDonough. Seriously. Go. My partner is originally from New York, I'm originally from Connecticut, and we are both very fussy about pizza. We are the kind of people who will drive an hour from Conyers just to get a pizza here, with no other errands attached. That alone should tell you everything. We usually get a huge pepperoni pie and share it. They do have slices, and the slices are excellent too, but I recommend getting the whole pie if you can. Every pizza we have had here has been picture-perfect. Perfect crust, perfect sauce, perfect cheese, properly cooked toppings, and that real New York-style balance of crispy, chewy, melty, slightly floppy, and dangerously hot. The crust has the right crisp and chew. The sauce is flavorful without being too much. The cheese has that classic low-moisture mozzarella richness, and it is seasoned beautifully before baking. That is one of those details a lot of places miss. Up north, the cheese is not just bland melted cheese sitting there doing nothing. It has flavor. It has oregano. It has seasoning. It has personality. I Love New York Pizza gets that right. The first time we went, the owner was there, the family was there, and people were speaking Italian behind the counter. Then I saw the case full of slices and immediately thought, "Okay, we are safe. We are in good hands." You can tell just by looking at the pizza that it is right. Is this the greatest New York pizza you will ever have in your life? Maybe not. Is it possibly the best New York-style pizza you are going to get in this area? Absolutely. To me, it tastes like the kind of standard, classic, universally enjoyable New York pizza you would bring someone to for their first real slice experience. We almost always dine in, and there is always enough to take leftovers home. The staff is great, the service is great, the timing is great, and the consistency is honestly impressive. We drive an hour hoping to get the same perfect pizza we had last time, and they deliver every time. I will be honest: I come here for the pizza. I do not really care for the garlic knots, and I have not been especially attached to the non-pizza items I have tried. But if you have a serious up-north pizza craving, that does not matter. Get the pizza. Get the whole pie. Let it set for a minute if you have the patience, because it comes out burning hot. Or risk it all and burn your mouth on the first bite like I sometimes do. Worth it. I Love New York Pizza is the spot. Picky Northerner approved.

Huge portion for an appetizer! Loaded with goodies and served hot. I have only tried the loaded…read morefries they offer, but am pleased so far.

My Family and I ordered a carry on order on the 4th of July. We arrived when the cook was making…read moreour order. No one was wearing gloves. The guy in the front was taking orders answer the phone scratching his head and handling completed orders. But what concerned me, was as we watch the lady make our pizza, she winced in pain and my husband asked her what was wrong and she jalepenos that she was putting on the pizza burned her finger. So she clearly had a cut on her hand but was making pizzas Bare handed. Unsanitary and unsafe for consumption. Needless to say we didnt eat the pizzas. I would never eat there again. And I think the management needs to have clear conversations to staff about the importance of food handling and public safety.

My family and I ordered here a lot before but stopped recently because they would give us somewhat…read moreburnt pizza and sometimes messed up on the type of crust we wanted but other than that I can't complain . You guys have to me mindful when reviewing places because it's a lot of stress dealing with different energies and faces each and every day

Our time at 15th street pizza was great…read more You can sit either inside or outside and more than enough parking spots. If you love beer, then you will experience a very long list of various beers and I like that's it's broken down by variety and flavor. The pizza was good but if you prefer NY Style pizza you might not like how thick the crust is. Overall the pizza was good and fairly priced. This was our first time here so I'm not sure if it was normal but even though it wasn't really busy, service was slow. Our waitress was really friendly but she was working both inside and outside so we did have to wait around a while for our check. It didn't bother me too much since I had already ordered another beer that I had to finish but I could tell my wife and kids were ready to go. Overall it's a nice spot and it's cool to see Henry county getting more dining options.

Not too shabby of a meal...kitchen was a little slow but the server was super nice. Food came out…read morehot and the veggies were fresh. Which goes along way for the part of town it's in. Burger patty appeared to be a frozen variety that they smash flat. She liked it...but she's also not the best gauge of quality food. The calzone was good, ricotta was actually inside, the basil was fresh and leafy, pepperoni was standard and the onions were purple and the crust was crispy...I enjoyed it but nothing was mind blowing or new path paving. My kid liked her cheesy bread with a side of cheese sauce...what else is there in life that's better than carbs and cheese. I will say that the crust was still pretty soft and crispy even the next day and reheating in the oven...that wasn't something I was expecting.

Marcos!!! My guilty pleasure!!…read more Please don't get rid of the Pepperoni Magnifico cause Idk what I'll do without it!!! Service is always great. Even when training or busy- they are always able to troubleshoot and provide exceptional service and product Feel free to sit and wait for your pizza if you order when you arrive. They have a few chairs inside to use. Tip: Treat yourself to the cinnamon squares!!! Ask for extra butter and extra cinnamon!!

We use to order from here a couple times a month but now, it seems like they are skimping on…read moreingredients AND they cannot get an order right for ANYTHING!!! I even have the person taking the order to read it back and still, they manage to screw it up!!! I'm from Chicago so the pizza in Georgia sucks anyway but, this was our go to and now they suck!!! We will head to the city when looking for pizza.

Located next to a Publix on Hwy 20; this us my family's go-to Papa John's. The place is clean. The…read morefood is fresh. The curbside pickup works unlike many businesses and it is effective. The new Crustless is AMAZING!!! i would recommend this location to anyone.

Always order delivery, this is the fastest pizza delivery around! Always delivered within 15-30…read moreminutes!?! It's unbelievable. Happy customer, happy ratings!

12/28/25 around 6 pm Hampton ga store @ 1958 McDonough road. we have two issues. First one…read morefemale employee was at the beginning of the make line. Right hand had pepperoni's in it, the other hand she was using her phone. No gloves before or after this happened . she put her phone down and finished making the pizza. That's right, never washed hands before or after making pizza. Then she came right out front to serve customer's . The manager tells me on a phone call, they are not required to wear gloves at this location, i said what about the phone ??? Anytime you touch a phone, you are contaminating your hands. when i confronted her she just immediately left the front and went to back and did not come back. a guy came out front, i told him what i saw, but he did not respond at all. So no gloves, no hand washing, What else is not right there??!!

Stood at the counter for 10 minutes as the employees, little guy and girl, were sitting in the back…read morepaying absolutely no attention. From the looks of it and smell they don't have anything hot and ready either. This was at 12:45 on a Tuesday afternoon.

A worker had dug an scratched her behind. And the food was late aven thought it was ready on the…read moreapp. The surrounding is dirty and not really kept well.

I have continued to try and give this location a chance because of the location However the last…read moreorder was the last straw I ordered delivery via the app d after placing order received notification that carry out was ready when I called they claimed the would change it only to call back 5 min later to say the had no delivery drivers and it would be 25 min but they would remake. The pizza was delivered 30 min later cold and forgot the soda the. When I told driver he LIED and said he would bring it back and never showed up!!

Nasty and unprofessional Rude, just there for the pay check…read moreand no interest in customer care. Manager was rude, if in fact she really was the manager.

Burnt food! We used to go here a lot but now I'm changing my mind! Service was fast but the tots…read moreare burnt

Amazing customer service! Worked very hard to resolve unanticipated issue and found a solution…read moreafter showing much care and consideration. I am impressed with the problem-resolution skills, teamwork, and work ethic put in by the staff here. I recommend stopping by, forming your own opinion, and leaving a positive review. Restaurant is clean and food is hot and made to order!

False advertisement on website vs what you get. Ordered 3 melts, got 1/2 of each of them. After…read moreshowing the cook what was ordered and how deceptive that was, they said have the office call him and he'd recook it. Really? Why should I fix what's wrong with your advertisemen, I'm on lunch break and we don't have time for that. Give the customer what they ordered or refund them. That's that. Beaware of what you order!