It's a deli you'll miss if you're going to fast down broadway. Honestly I didn't know we had a delightful deli right by us till months later but luckily I came across it looking for bagel spots in the area! Went once last year and ever since then me and my team have been going there multiple times plus did a catering order with them! Delicious food and great service too. read more

Poppy's Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

This my go to breakfast sandwich spot, never go wrong. Staff is always nice, friendly and attentive. It's a nice little cute spot but early morning does get busy. read more

Poppy's Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Amityville, New York

Their bagels are the best! My favorite is their bec on everything bagel :) It's always exceptional, tasty and fresh! Their service is great, they're always super friendly and it's got a pleasant atmosphere! There's parking in the front and a parking lot on the side where you can easily find parking! read more

Poppy's Bagel - Bacon fried eggs cheese on everything bagel with a little bit of ketchup and mayonnaise! - Bagels Near Me - Amityville, New York

Too expensive!! I live pretty close they were doing work @8pm on a weekday on the roof making a lot of noise , I have small kids . read more

Good prices, good food, good friendly staff, good variety. Highly recommended. Try it.

My coworker brought me here to get some bagels for lunch. I will say, it was one of the best bagels I've had in a while! I ordered an everything bagel toasted with cream cheese. The bagel itself had great flavor! They also didn't put a ton of cream cheese on the bagel like every other place on Long Island. It was an absolute perfect cream cheese to bagel ratio. To drink, I was just going to get a coffee. I heard my coworker order a hot chocolate and coffee mix. I decided on that as well. It was very yummy! Customer service was excellent! read more

The food is great and the staff is even better. I would certainly recommend the place 100%

I ordered a few egg sandwiches this morning and two deli sandwiches from here, DELICIOUS! The staff are incredibly nice and helpful. This will be my New go to place! read more

Poppy's Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

our family bagel shop love poppy and the engine behind it ... feels like home ! Nothing better than a long island bagel... great egg sandwiches , muffins are a must here , and they even have a nice deli selection ..... you can call ahead and rest assure your order will be made great with no mistakes ! Locals become family here .... Small seating inside and two main seating spaces out front great for when you need a break! We love poppy read more

One of the best bagel stores around amityville! Fast service and the foods always amazing!

Love this place! 1) The bagels are I get an everything pumpernickel bagel most of the time I come here. 2) The egg sandwiches are amazing and definitely underrated, look at how fluffy these scrambled eggs are! Bacon - krispy as requested! If you don't know, now you know! read more

Poppy's Bagel - Bacon Egg & Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Amityville, New York

excellent and friendly service! we ordered an iced coffee, sesame bagel with egg and cheese, and an egg bagel with strawberry cream cheese- all of which were delicious and affordably priced. we will definitely be back read more

This was my first time going to Poppy's and I can't wait to go again. I ordered a BEC & SEC on a flagel/flat. The bacon was perfectly crispy and not fatty. The flagel/flat was delicious. read more

Walter the owner is a super awesome and amazing person. Every time i come I get treated super friendly and the food is amazing the best bagel shop in Long Island I highly recommend everybody to check this spot. read more

Friendly staff, great service, and delicious food! Just recently moved to this side of LI and on the hunt for the best bagel shop, and I think we already found it! :) Would definitely recommend checking this place, great prices too! read more

Poppy's Bagel - Bacon egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Best bagels in amityville. Honestly this is the freshest spot i know for morning sandwiches in amityville, been coming here for years !

Living close by makes this place convenient for me. The bagels are always fresh tasting and seem to have a quick turnover which is assuring that they have a quality product that is constantly moving. I have had several of their breakfast sandwiches, including a BEC on an everything bagel and also The Hungry Man on a roll. The Hungry Man sandwich is a home run. It's stacked with eggs, bacon, ham, sausage, and cheese on either a bagel or a roll. Definitely the one to try if you're looking for an awesome breakfast. Now, my only suggestion is that I would LOVE if they would put seeds on both the top and bottom of the everything bagels. When only the top has seeds, if you slice that bagel in half to toast it or put cream cheese on it, you end up with a half with seeds and a half without. That is really the only thing I would change here, and honestly it's the only thing keeping me from giving that 5th star. Because as far as bagel places go, they are on the upper end of my breakfast radar. Other things that I like are that they offer a selection of Boars Head cold cuts for both purchase and for their deli-type sandwiches. They offer several types of salads and fruit cups, as well as an assortment of breakfast baked goods such as crumb cake and muffins. The coffee is decent, as is their selection of cold beverages from the fridge. They offer a nice selection of flavored cream cheeses. Prices are on par for area bagel places. There is seating for about 10-12 people at bistro style tables, and everything always looks clean and well kept. There is a TV with the news usually on. The staff is very friendly and efficient. They seem happy in their work which creates a nice, calm atmosphere to enjoy your breakfast. I also appreciate that Jacqueline follows the shop's Yelp page and cares about customer's reviews. She is truly an asset to the business. :-) Lastly... They have a great sense of community which I commend. The morning after Hurricane Sandy swept through, despite a huge chunk of tree blocking their doorway, they were open. While the power was out on most of L.I., the few blocks closest to town hall seemed to be on a separate grid which had power throughout all of it. They did their best to provide breakfast, beverages, and power outlets which several customers were charging up their cell phones. They really came through during that time. Also... The bathroom has been impressively clean every time I've used it. read more

See all

We've been eating lunch here for over 10 years. Always good food, good prices and friendly people. Going back again today!

Have been coming here for years and never had an issue. They always get my order right and they're friendly and the food tastes good. Pricing is pretty average, too, for the Island. read more

Awesome pumpernickel everything bagel with amazing blueberry cream cheese. Not too sweet, just right read more

See all

Visite el local del aeropuerto la guardia pésima atención pague $35.00 y la sorpresa al recibir la comida me prohibieron sentarme para hacer uso de sus mesas y a parte no dieron cubiertos ni servilletas ni bolsas para llevar la comida fue una situación bien bochornosa .mucha falta de respeto y atención. read more

Got a toasted poppy seed bagel with tomato, avocado, and onion. It was good, toasted nicely, had lots of cream cheese, and the vegetables were fresh. The generous amount of avocado was a plus. read more

Poppy's Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Amityville, New York

For some reason the lady keeps hanging up on me and I'm not sure why. There always seem to be an issue with their deliveries and I had to cancel all of them because they never deliver. read more

"Ay Papi" Driving around town during Hurricane Sandy just to charge our phones landed us upon this cute hole in the wall. Yearning for HOT coffee in an area with no electric sent us on a mission. Later we soon arrived upon Poppys. Seeing patrons stroll down the street with hot coffees in their hands was the guarantee. Upon entering they were still making egg sandwiches and such. Talk about having the power. Some staff appear a bit ornery but don't let it sway you from patronizing this joint. They take credit cards to boot! read more

My girlfriend and I order from here every Sunday. They're always very friendly and never leave us waiting for our order. Their menu is pretty extensive and if it isn't on the menu chances are they'll make it for you anyway. read more

Soft and delicious bagels, in the best way. Got a couple of chicken wraps too and they were delicious. Definitely recommend!

Amytiville is filled with awesome people and tons of great places to visit and spend money on. PoppyS Bagel is one of the places in Amityville that definitely gives the town a smile on a cloudy day, especially for the great service and quality of food. A pick up order from this place takes less than 3 minutes. One thing I would recommend is the Steve Special, a hot and melty Roast Beef Sandwich that instantly makes you forget about work and gives you an urge to climb mountains after eating. I would love to come back here for every lunch. Here's to good people, a great town and awesome RBS (roast beef sandwiches) read more

Amazing bagel shop and deli. We're traveling from out of town. Found this by accident. Food was amazing . But more amazing was the owner and staff. So friendly and genuinely nice !! The owner even came out and let us take a photo with him. I'll be back next time I come to long island read more

Underwhelming. Did not enjoy my breakfast. The bagel tasted like chalk. The bacon on my bacon egg and cheese was like gum, it was chewy fatty and way undercooked. Their everything bagel is caked in salt. I'll give it 2 stars since I've had worse. But i won't be back here read more

I went there for bagel this morning around 6:30am and was disappointed in the customer service. They were dismissive. One woman was handling money with gloves on then went to handle my food. I politely asked her to change the gloves, she said she is allowed to handle money and food using the same gloves. Then went on to say in a nasty tone that I shouldn't eat out if I ever expect any place to do so. I should always eat at home. What's next? It's ok to handle garbage, use the restroom, clean toilets, etc with the same gloves you handle food with? I'll never go there again. By the way, She still went on to cut rolls with the same gloves. read more

When its Sunday morning, you don't feel like exploring breakfast places for testing purposes. You want a place that has reliable food that is solidly delicious every time. I went to Better Bagel for this experience, however they are to my dismay closed (temporarily?) I needed backup. Fast. My stomach was growling, the eyes were wandering, the road seemed so long. I took out this large electronic device in my pocket, typed in "bagel" into Google Maps...and what comes up? This place. Keep in mind, I am no bagel snob. I like a simple life with a few things...but those things have to be few. One of those things is a bagel. I entered the establishment, and was quickly greeted. OK, good sign. Ordered my bagel. Received it. Opened it. I ordered it with butter...this was a mistake. There was more butter in the bag and on the wax paper. I don't mean 50/50. I mean 10/90. I don't know how they achieved this, perhaps I should have called Guinness World Records. The bagel was ordered toasted. Fine. What I received was akin to a brick. Way too crunchy, I couldn't properly enjoy it. 3 stars for service and attentiveness. Can't recommend for the actual food though with a clean conscience. read more

Been going here since they opened. I will never go again!!!! It is sad when an employee pushes the owner away from the register telling her she had no idea what she was doing. No employee should be made to look stupid I in front of a customer let alone the owner!!! Once I said a something the owner came back at me with her attitude!!! I can't be bring myself to spend money here, especially since prices are made up as they go'nn read more

Every time I come here, I order something simple like one bagel or egg sandwich. Two out of three times my order is wrong, and I've called more than once just to let them know. It's so disappointing. I only go back because it is in a very convenient spot when I'm in a rush. Check your food before you leave read more

Excellent light and airy fresh bagels. All spreads and salads are fresh and homemade. The cream cheese and lox spread is the best I have ever tasted. Staff is very friendly and efficient. The store is immaculate. If in the area give Poppy's Bagels a try you will not be disappointed read more

Nice enough people but the bagels were just not very good. They honestly looked like bagels I could get at the supermarket. It also drives me nuts when places only put seasoning on one side of the bagel. Bottom line is the taste wasn't that great either. Definitely many better places to grab a bagel in the area. read more

Always friendly and considerate service. The food is always top shelf. You cannot get a better breakfast special either. I am happy they are in Amityville, N.Y., my village, where I have my business as well. read more

Great food! The breakfast and lunch are great! Bagels are soft and flavorful. Love the home fries for breakfast! I do love their turkey and American on a egg everything bagel. read more

I love My job!! my boss is the number one!! customers all are friendly GOD BLESS EVERYBODY!!

THE BEST homemade cream cheese EVER!!!! The bagels are delicious, fresh and yes, this is the cleanest bagel store with the friendliest staff on Long Island but, the star of the show is the cream cheese. I love the cinnamon raisin cream cheese, fresh strawberry, fresh blueberry and my husband prefers the more savory salmon and vegetable cream cheese- just delicious...I don't know what they put in this stuff but it's addicting! Simply the best quick breakfast on Long Island. Well worth the trip, thank me later. read more

This was my first time ordering from this place. I got the "Big Bird" on a Poppy bagel, and it exceeded my expectations. The potato salad that I chose as a side was also delicious. Overall a nice little place that isn't too expensive. I'll definitely be coming back in the future. read more