Super cute outside decor caught my eye. Was a bit hungry and had just dropped someone off in the area when I noticed this place. Walked in 9 minutes to close but rather than getting a dirty look and turned away the guy who took my order was patient while I looked at menu. Ordered just 2 appetizers since I just wanted a quick snack for the road. The cheese garlic bread was cheesy and crunchy at the same time. I hate a soggy bun and this was far from it. The star was the marinara dipping sauce. I'm not one of those people that goes crazy over marinara. I take it or leave it but damn was it good! I'm ashamed to admit I might have finished what was left like it was a shot. Ordered a side of calamari too. Breading wasn't too heavy and had good seasoning. Came with the same marry me marinara. Wish I had ordered a pizza but although they might have fulfilled it I was already there minutes to close. Love this place. Wish it was closer. Staff genuinely nice and they deserve to be recognized. Will be sure to stop in again when I'm in the area. I'll be dreaming of the marinara until then. read more

Excellent pasta dishes - generous portions and include a soup or salad as well as garlic bread. The real star of the show are their employees! They are extremely friendly and go out of their way to make you feel very welcome! read more

I was greeted by a very friendly staff. The service was prompt. I placed a carry out order and the food was good. POP's offer a good selection on the menu. Based on my experience I would certainly return read more

Good god do the workers have great attitudes and energy!, I feel like they're my friends even if it's only a 30sec interaction! They also have my favorite wings out of any place and I gobble up wings like Joey chestnut! Trust me when I say this restaurant rocks. read more

My husband, son and myself absolutely love this place. The stuffed pizza is to die for! I personally love their phillysteak and Italian beef the best. They have the best fries! They have dine in but most of their business is carry out and delivery so don't panic when you see an empty parking lot or dinning room. Staff is awesome the young lady who owns the place is awesome so is her specials and you will love her prices and amount of food you get. read more

The food was so good and I was so hungry I couldn't even get a pic!! The online ordering had a bunch of fees that I didn't realize. So I should have called instead! The pizza was honestly one of the best I have had. It is truly thin crust and the flavors are incredible! When we arrived to pick up our pizza the staff was incredibly welcoming and the little pizzeria was cutely decorated. So many fun signs and a huge screen showing a fun cooking show. We had a drink while we waited for our food. Totally going to be grabbing pizzas from here again! read more

I'm sitting here eating my prime rib leftovers as I write... Pops' Pizzeria is such a yummy place with adorable signs and delicious food. We wanted to go to an easy Sunday dinner and was surprised that Pops' wasn't on yelp (yet). I'm so glad I tried this place and will definitely be returning! Food: For Mother's Day they had the prime rib special (with cheddar mash and prosciutto-wrapped asparagus and soup) for $20! I've also been told that they will be having prime rib on Saturday's as well! We also ordered a huge tray of fried appetizers as well as a large pizza. The portions are HUGE and delicious. My prime rib dinner was easily two meals! The cheddar mac was delicious and the soup was wonderful. I love how they added a twist to mashed potatoes and plain asparagus! Their menu also has a bunch of pasta and pizza options! On Sunday they had a buy 1 get 1 pizza special! I can't wait to return to try the pastas! Service: Friendly and super genuine. The servers kept checking in on us. The owner came by and I found out that this place is named after her grandpa! Decor: Check out the adorable decor. They have the cutest signs and nice touches. It's definitely more of a casual spot but super cute for a fun date or lunch with friends! read more

See all

Online ordering is a nightmare They changed services awhile back and its a disaster, the checkout process is frustrating locking up during checkout read more

Great service, The employees are all very friendly. we love the pizza, wings, salad everything is really good!

This place is beyond amazing! We drive 30 minutes each way to takeout, that's how good it is. The pizza is still piping hot when we get home. We always get the chicken alfredo pizza. It is consistently great! Not sure what they put in their dough but this pizza is beyond addictive. Fresh toppings, quality ingredients and crispy, thin crust. Prior to COVID, I dined in several times and the apps are amazing. Their spinach and artichoke dip is my absolute favorite. You can't let a visit go by without getting a Ponzarotti, a deep fried calzone. It is crispy, light and stuffed with gooey cheese and their yummy pizza sauce. Check out their website for their daily specials. We usually go on Sundays to take advantage of their buy one large pizza, get a large 1 topping pizza free. Can't beat that deal! All of the employees are so nice. Also, take in how cute the restaurant is decorated! read more

Great pizza at a reasonable price. I hope to enjoy a pizza inside the restaurant soon but for now am ok with picking it up. My husband has tried the pasta and enjoyed it as well. We order from here once a week. read more

Pretty bland pasta dishes. Wings were OK. I would luv to review the meatballs I ordered but never received the meatballs. Won't be back

Great food, friendly people, we will visit again! The calamari was some of the best I have ever had!

The food and pizza is very good friendly staff and the service is great they also deliver the pizza is still hot when I received it

Recommend! Pizza joint. Hit or miss with quality but mostly good. Pizza delivered always in "about an hour but rarely does it take that long. Wings are good. Thin crust is good. Serve an XxL Pizza that is good for a group. With lack of delivery places in this small town, it is what it is. One time had an issue. Pizza all slid off to one side like driver tipped it. Made a fresh one but had to return fouled up Pizza. Took 2 hours start to finish to get order right, but they did. What can I say, its Waterford, WI and we don't have competition. read more

The owner is very sweet and appreciative. Employees very nice and friendly. Good is phenomenal. Best pizza in Waterford!

So delicious pizza and affordable too. Perfect for a family dinner dining in or carry out. Yummy !!! read more

Great pizza place in Waterford. Awesomely good lasagna and other Italian dishes. Very good sauce. Generous portions. Easy access. Fast, friendly and well priced. Highly recommended. Ray S read more

We wanted to get pizza for my dad's birthday, so we put in an order. When we went to pick it up, they said they gave our order to someone else and didn't even apologize for it. They left us hanging and didn't even offer to make up for it. Extremely disappointed in the customer service. They even put the blame on us and was extremely rude about it. read more

Had a horrible experience with the owner recently. After several phone conversations with a very nice employee about my severe garlic allergy, I was assured that I could safely order either chicken piccata or chicken Marsala. When we got our "garlic free" order home we were surprised to find a large side order of mostaccioli ( which was very obviously NOT garlic free). We immediately called the restaurant. The owner came to the Phone and was unapologetic and extremely condescending. I told her how serious it was when it had been clearly explained that it was a severe allergy. She kind of laughed and said it's an Italian restaurant. I would never feel safe going here and I would not support a business who's owner is this uncaring and rude. read more

Great Pizza at a Great Price . The Crust and Sauce are delish. The Pan pizza with everything was a big Hit for Me . The Staff and Owner treated us like family throughout our Visit. We will be back. read more

Pizza pretty good, just not cooked to how I requested. Not sure if I'll try them again

I order from them weekly. I love the baked cod fish fry. If I get the 5 piece it is enough for 2 meals. I also love their hamburgers. Why do fast food when I can tell them how I want it done. Their chef salad is large and very good with all the different veggies. I can ask for no green pepper because it doesn't sit well with me. I have had different pastas and pizza and it is all good. They are very nice when I order. I have been using their online ordering which is convenient. I often use delivery and it was great when I came home after a hospital stay and wasn't driving. There is no delivery for many other places out here in the Waterford area. I really like the food from Pop's and it is great to support a locally owned business instead of a fast food chain. And besides I have to watch the salt I have and unlike fast food places, they don't over salt their food. I recommend them for all around good service and food. read more

Just tried this place the other day. Unaware that this was even around. Heard about it through "word of mouth." Excellent pizza, crispy crust, fresh toppings, and definitely trending. The hot wings are delicious, so is the grilled chicken salad. Everything is in abundance and the menu is extensive! The inside seating is very comfortable and inviting. The staff is very friendly and attentive! Prices are very reasonable!Definite will return! read more

The delivery was timely and front end customer service over the phone was good. The pizza crust was not cooked thoroughly and the crust was tasteless. There was a good portion of toppings and the sauce was light and Very little taste. The pizza was very salty. read more

I was very disappointed in this restaurant. Online prices were different from what they charged me. It was $32 for two medium pizzas. when I asked I was told sorry prices have gone up. I understand prices are up but then don't advertise a cheaper price on your menu. I was dismissed and told sorry about that and he walked away. Other worker was sitting up front swearing about personal issues. In a time where businesses need customers you lost one. 100% would not recommend. there are plenty of other pizza places around that taste just as good or better. read more

Pizza is never cook to where the crust is crispy, even when asked. Flavor is good but this last experience was absolutely ridiculous. See picture read more

Pops' Pizzeria - Cheese running off chewy dough. - Pizza Near Me - Waterford, Wisconsin

Best pizza in Waterford. Excellent service and pizza is good every time! We had a great heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day. read more

Pops' Pizzeria - heart shaped pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waterford, Wisconsin

I got a pizza here and when I picked it up and got home it had no sauce on it and it was all stuck to 5he bottom of the box so I ask for my money back called again tonight and the owner answers the phone I order the pizza with extra sauce that they charge for and was told very rudely I wont give your money back this time if it's not right I will never ever step foot in this place or order from there again With that great customer service they should -5 stars cause this place sucks read more

We decided to try the Pizza place in town. We we're very surprised to find out the variety of food on their menu! We ordered The everything pizza and we saw that they had a Reuben pizza so we asked if we could have the sauerkraut on our pizza. When we lived in Milwaukee there was a place that had sauerkraut that you could add to your pizza and it was delicious. We had to wait 29 years to find a place that you could put sauerkraut on your pizza. It was very deliciousThe service was excellent the price was also very reasonable I would highly recommend this place to anybody who wants to have a variety of pizzas and also a great experience. We will definitely be a loyal customer read more

Excellent pizza. Excellent customer service. Great prices. The lasagna, chicken parmesan, and tortellini are very good too. They do have cannoli which was great. We love this place! read more

This is THE BEST GLUTEN FREE PIZZA EVER. Gluten free pasta too. Great service, always very quick for pickup, our new favorite pizza place.

I had the thin crust pizza here a few times and am very satisfied with it. There are about 8 tables inside so there is plenty of room for sit down. Also, they have daily specials which are very economical. read more

Awful service. Waited over 2 hours for 2 large pizzas when they said it would be an hour. Every time I called after an hour passed it was an excuse with no offer to compensate. Will not be coming here again. read more

Pleasantly surprise! Had a nice meal here. Had a calzone with spinach and artichoke. It was tasty. Their marinara sauce was very good. Waitress was very attentive and friendly. They had the Brewers game on a big screen so I I was able to peek at the game once in awhile. Generous pour on the wine which is much appreciated. The chocolate chip cookie at the end sealed the deal. I will be back. read more

We had a coupon but had read it wrong. It was for a delivery but we were doing carry out, but they honored it. It was our first time. The large is gargantuan! The pizza was excellent! The service was very friendly! It was ready on time! What's not to love! We'll be back!! read more

We ordered take out on 11/1/2018 around 4 pm, everything was ready for pick up. I had a small pizza, thin crust and crispy with cheese and sausage. The pizza was more than I expected, lots of cheese and a lot of sausage, not soggy just right. My wife ordered the lasagna, that came with soup or salad, she had the potato soup. That was also a 5 star meal, actually 2 meals. This was our first time there, we read about it in the Waterford post. We will get the word out . thanks John read more

Called at 7 was told 35-40 minutes. Arrived at 7:45 and waited another 20 min. Went to ask and the worker was rude and said still 10 more minutes. No call no refund will not be back and will tell others. I'm still waiting after an hour and 20. read more