As always a great experience. Bill is a great chef and he holds his staff to high standards. Such a gem for Pittsboro. This time we had the cedar island fry and the pork loin special. Never had a bad experience here. Go for the evening! You won't be disappointed! read more

See all

Took friends for their first visit to Postal Fish. We all enjoyed our meals on a rainy weekday evening. We started with a smoked trout appetizer with 'fried' saltines. It was quite flavorful and plentiful for sharing among 4 adults. The saltines were a nice touch! One of our party had shrimp and grits, which he voted 'delicious'; another had the fried seafood platter, which was hot, crisp and 'spot on' . My other friend and I each ordered the Almaco Jack (yellowtail) which was seared and served on a bed of nardello and shitto peppers and carrots. Fish was properly seared and seasoned and veggies were tasty- tho they needed to have been served hot, not luke warm. The foursome shared yummy duck fat fried fingerling potatoes. Topped it off with chocolate mousse - light and very flavorful. A good first visit for my friends! Service was good and attentive. read more

Postal Fish Company - Almaco Jack - Seafood Near Me - Pittsboro, North Carolina

I have been frequenting Postal Fish for several years. What keeps me coming back is Chef Bill's creativity, commitment to fresh and local ingredients and a culture from the staff that you are part of their family and not just a transaction. Many of their servers have worked there for awhile now so you see the same faces each time. You won't get salmon and mashed potatoes here. You get whatever the local fresh catch is paired with a thoughtful and tasty side. I have enjoyed trying new things that I never heard of and now get excited about when I see them on the menu like triggerfish and monkfish. To be honest I would never have thought of ordering these items but once I tried them I realized just how good these lesser know species are especially fresh and cooked perfectly. For the nights I am not wanting seafood there is usually at least one meat and pasta dish. I absolutely love the pork chop from local farms and my wife usually orders the gnocci or risotto which is ridiculous especially when paired with sea scallops. They also have a very extensive bourbon collection at a great price point and a bartender that is creative and will make you whatever you like. I typically ask him to surprise me which has opened my pallette to new drinks. For those in Durham and Raleigh its worth the drive and you can park right out front and not worry about parking and all the traffic. read more

Postal Fish Company - Soft shell crab in a delicious shrimp reduction with a side of fried shrimp. - Seafood Near Me - Pittsboro, North Carolina

This was our first time here. I made a 6:00 reservation which was unnecessary. Service was friendly, helpful and fast. The ambiance was wonderful - especially for an old post office. It was rainy and cold tonight so their outdoor seating was closed. Looked really nice. We started with the grilled oysters which were some of the best I've ever had. We also ordered the smoked fish dip and pimento cheese for my son who doesn't like fish. My husband had the mushroom risotto and I had the wood fired shrimp. I wanted a veggie but there weren't many options for a side and the salad wasn't my jam. I got the smokehouse lounge to drink and it was yummy! Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

I love this place. Fresh seafood all the time. One of the best food & beverage restaurants in Pittsboro.

My sister and niece both ordered the Drum, and I had the soft shelled crab. This was after we shared the smoked trout and fried crackers and buttered biscuits appetizers. We also shared a bottle of wine. All of the food was good to excellent. They pay attention to both playing and pairing to good effect. Accompanying sauces and vegetables were spot on. Service was acceptable. Price for all was $190 before the tip, so expensive, but good value. We will return. read more

Good food at a price. The shrimp was overdone but the fish was perfect. We went there on a recent Friday and had reservations

I now have a new favorite spot and super happy it's only an hour from our home in High Point! We took the day off to visit a Pittsboro since we have not been there in a while and it did not disappoint. Visited several local breweries and finished the night here. We wanted to try loads of things since it was our first time so we had cheddar biscuits, a salad, striped Seabass, and last but not least the most perfect hush puppies I've had in a long, long time! read more

See all

Kevin's service was impeccable. Fish was very fresh and the chefs creativity showed with every dish we had. read more

See all

WHOA. We were so shocked that it wasn't super busy because the food was incredible. Reasonably priced. Clean restaurant and good service. The food was just amazing.. fried oysters and biscuits were to die for. The main meals were thoughtfully crafted. We will be back read more

First time visiting this hidden gem, passers by it many times. The food is cooked perfectly, the chef knows how to balance flavour, texture and eye appeal. My husband and I decided to split the steamed clams, blue sky lettuces, NC Cedar Island Fry, flourless chocolate cake. Kevin, our waiter, was highly knowledgeable, personable and attentive. Highly recommend this seafood restaurant for local veggies, house made desserts and the freshest NC seafood you can find within a couple hrs of the NC coast!! read more

See all

The restaurant was roomy and tables weren't crammed together. This is accessible to those with mobility devices to move around with ease. The waiter was great and knowledgeable about the menu. The food was very tasty and reasonably priced. I spoke to the owner after and he was very pleasant also. We drove 45 minutes and it was very worth it. read more

See all

What an amazing experience! We are traveling through and looked to yelp for a recommendation for dinner so we are paying it forward. This place has incredible food from starter to dessert. I had shrimp and grits and my husband had the fish fry. 100% recommend. The town is adorable too. read more

Food was really good and fresh. Portions are Small so if you're looking for quantity and over quality this isn't the place for you. Happy we have seafood here in Pittsboro finally! Will be back read more

Every time I've been I've been so impressed by the amazing and creative fresh dishes, especially those fired on the wood grill. Service has been welcoming, yet relaxed and able to answer the occasionally odd question I've asked. Though I've been happy eating at the bar, I'd always book as can certainly be booked out. Loving it. read more

A simple and dark ambiance with very friendly and welcoming staff. Our waitress walked us through the options on the menu we had questions about. And their menu changes depending on what's available. The cheddary biscuit appetizers were delicious. We liked the first order so much we had seconds. The fish was fresh and tasty as was my friends salad. I was going to get fish too but the description of the steak on the menu just sounded so good. And it's one of the best steaks I've ever had, go figure In a seafood place. A bit pricey but worth a try. read more

Always amazing....beyond amazing!! The service, the food, the ambiance are all top notch! read more

The wine and the grits were five stars! I feel this place is a tad overrated. They sure know how to write up a description of the food and make you want to order everything on the menu however i found myself thinking that when the plate arrived the vegetables were barely visible that they mentioned. I loved the hush puppies. The table enjoyed the fritters. The trout was flavorful and the gnocchi dumplings were good without the sauce which i could have lived without. The other dinner loved her shrimp and grits. If you are going to offer outdoor seating please try to prevent flies as much as possible. I was totally uncomfortable and my dinner ruined due to the fly infestation buzzing all around the table and our food. Which left me in a growly mood. Put out some foggers in the morning--hire a pest company but do something as nothing is more disgusting than a filthy fly when your trying to eat. read more

What an excellent meal with outstanding service. We took our son and daughter-in-love here for their anniversary. It was a beautiful evening so we opted to eat outside. For the appetizers we ordered roasted beets with goat cheese and fried oysters. We had hoped to get fresh oysters but there was no shucker tonight. For our main courses my husband ordered the flounder and scallops, my son ordered the whole bass, my daughter in love ordered the catfish, and I ordered the fire grilled shrimp. Everything was well seasoned and prepared to perfection. For dessert we all tried the chocolate torte and the bread pudding with pecan sauce. Our server was friendly and attentive. Excellent place with delicious food. read more

This is one of those places that's been on my "must review" list for months and months, but every time I sit down to write it, I think of something else on the menu I want to try first - but since I will probably never achieve that equilibrium, here we go. First: this is a LOUDASS restaurant, so if that is not your thing, don't come, and definitely don't come and then complain to the super-sweet host staff. Its location in the old post office is quaint and eclectic, and I'm personally obsessed with the insane stone walls that make me feel like I'm back in the sunken great room of my childhood 70s split-level. There are a variety of seating options, from the bar to a family table to a mix of two- and four-tops. Highly recommend a reservation, though; just tried to walk in on a Saturday at 5:45p and was given an estimated seating time of 7:30p -- so, the secret's out, y'all. The foooooooood, omg. Ok, so. The hushpuppies are only ok to me. They aren't as good as the outdoor fish camp ones of my South Carolina youth (yes, this review doubles as my memoir, thank you), which remain the quintessence of oblong corny goodness. But, I always forget about PFC's bread bucket and accidentally order hush puppies too. Don't do that - the bread bucket stands alone. It's Parker House style buns with huge salt crystals on top; I die. Also perfect here: the fried oysters. I recently tried the mushroom dumplings because I like to try non-seafood stuff at seafood places to see if they put the same care into the construction of the dish. These were decent but not worthy of a repeat order OR skipping fried things. Still on my list to try - the key lime pie. This is my all time favorite dessert and I'm on a quest to try every available version, but I need to stay away from that bread bucket if this dream is to become reality, alas. read more

See all

Fresh local seafood with great flavor. Good selection of bourbons. Nice outdoor seating as well as well spaced indoor seating. Open kitchen where you can sit at the counter if you want to watch them cook your food. Will definitely be back. read more

Postal Fish Company - Scallops - Seafood Near Me - Pittsboro, North Carolina

Don't sit outside unless you want to be joined by flies. Our dinner was overwhelmed with "uninvited guests " as our waiter put it. I thought it was rather unfortunate and really ruined my appetite quickly. The bread was fresh and fluffy and the serving of hush puppies were huge. I didn't enjoy the fish spread which was a very strong flavor - overwhelmingly fishy and not balanced. The scallops are excellently cooked and paired beautifully with vegetables. The shrimp and grits were interesting- larger grits, lots of onions with beautiful shrimp but by this point the flies had overwhelmed us. While the restaurant and our waiter noticed, they seemed completely to feel it was our problem. a few bugs are to be expected sitting outside but we were basically among 50 flies which feels disgusting. I would consider the restaurant but only indoors. read more

Postal Fish Company - Scallop - Seafood Near Me - Pittsboro, North Carolina

Postal Fish is a fantastic restaurant. Fresh, local seafood expertly prepared and paired with fresh, local produce. I've enjoyed so many wonderful dishes here - from catfish to drum, shrimp, and scallops. And the biscuits are a mainstay always worth ordering! The wait staff is attentive and it's easy to get a reservation, even at the last minute. I can't say enough great things about this wonderful place. read more

I was off to mail a package. At least I though so. Until I found the Pittsboro office closed. Now I'm Not just talking after 5 pm closed as most Government offices. I mean closed not there gone moved In it's place well you guessed it the new name sake Postal Fosh Company. So come check out some epic seafood meals. read more

See all

Great service and a great place to eat! The hostess and waitress were amazing! Food was delicious! The environment was friendly and the food was brought out so quickly! read more

Service was good, nice place I just didn't like the style of seafood, heavily breaded and fried with a cornmeal type breading, I believe. Maybe we'll try it again and I'll order something else. I can't knock em for the food style. If that's your thing then go for it. read more

The location is super cute! The restaurant was built inside of an old post office and the decor is lovely. It does seem a bit too open, like there's a good bit of unused space, but other than that, I enjoyed the atmopshere. I ended up choosing bacon fat monkfish because I'd never had it before and the server said it was one of her favorites. I didn't expect it to be so rich, but considering the words "bacon" and "fat" were written in the description, that's on me. The risotto was nice but heavy. The fish itself I wasn't a huge fan of, but I felt the portion size was nice for the price (which I think was around $21). My friend decided on the blackened trout and that looked much more appealing to me. It came on a bed of bright greens - I definitely had food envy. I wouldn't choose the monkfish again, but I would absolutely return and try different dishes. Just about everything on the menu sounded great to me, and what I saw being brought out to other tables looked fantastic. read more

Postal Fish Company - Bacon fat monkfish! With some sort of risotto. Super tasty, but on the heavier side for sure. - Seafood Near Me - Pittsboro, North Carolina

I've written several reviews for the postal fish company over the years. My on-going theme is that "they never disappoint". I realize that's a hard complement to live up to, but to their credit they absolutely do!Tonight my wife and I had a lovely dinner there. I had the blackened catfish with a chorizo sauce. That was frankly unbelievable. My wife had a pork chop. Both these items are not always on the menu. In fact, their menu changes weekly. If you live in the Pittsboro area or even in the greater Raleigh area, it's worth a trip to have a phenomenal meal here at postal fish company. Everything is reasonably price and the sauces are utterly amazing. I give this place my highest reviews. read more

See all

Absolutely fresh and delicious. Menu changes weekly with a couple staples. Friendly and attentive staff, great wine, cocktail and bourbon lists. My only complaint is that I wish they were closer to Durham ;). I would recommend this restaurant to anyone. Apps: Nag's head fish spread with buttered saltine. 1/2 dozen oysters (this time three types of NC) Dinner: Scollops with a pesto and vegetable mix (excellent, like woah). Trout with garden greens/tomatoes and balsamic (good, had a purposeful smokey flavor) Dessert: Cheese cake with black berry coolie. (Light but moist interior, the exact way it should be). Wine: A Spanish white (grape I couldn't pronounce) that had a slight effervescence. Somewhat like a pino. Waitress knew the wine menu well so she was able to make meaningful recommendations: awesome. I've been twice and I'll be back. read more

See all

food was amazing! Shrimp and Grits insanely good Evan our server was great! We'll be back! read more

What an exquisite meal! We were in a hurry and wanted a tasty low-carb meal and PFC, did NOT disappoint!! We cannot wait to try out more items here. Hubby had the Blackened Catfish and truly enjoyed the Wanchese Black Drum with Romanesco! read more

Fabulous place definitely worth the time to stop bye Great service great food and even had some smoked fish to go read more

Postal Fish Company - Seafood Near Me - Pittsboro, North Carolina

See all

I've had dinner here a few times. Each time the food and service were excellent. We will continue to dine at Pittsboro's beloved Postal Fish Co. read more

Reservations are needed for more than 2, but you can walk in & eat @ the bar. The fried Brussel sprouts and smoked fish dip were delicious. For mains we got the St. Louis ribs & the fish stew, both on point and plenty to share or take home. read more

This company sells fish for you to eat. I don't know if they are associated with the USPS but that is a possibility. I will update after I contact USPS. My dog absolutely LOVES fish. He likes salmons, tunas and occasionally calamari. He gets fish flavored treats when he does a good sit or rollover. I am taking my dog to the beach soon so that he can see where all his food comes from. I believe it is important for a dog to see the origin of it's food in order to be in touch with their primal instinct. Here is a pic of my dog for context. 5 stars read more

Postal Fish Company - Seafood Near Me - Pittsboro, North Carolina

I've been wanting to try this place in Pittsboro since it got high ratings and because I love seafood! I'm originally from Virginia Beach and am used to seafood being readily available so moving to the Triangle was a bit of an eye-opener as I really can't find many seafood places being more inland. The ambiance of the place is nice. Good seating with indoor/outdoor options and the dining area is a decent size. It's actually bigger than I thought it would be. They also have a pretty good bar area and I spotted some high quality bourbon there if that's your thing! For appetizers we ordered the fried oysters and the smoked fish dip. The fried oysters were a pretty big. It is lightly breaded which I like because you can taste more of the seafood itself and not just breading. The oysters were good and creamy and pretty much what you would expect from a fried oyster. The sauce that it was in was pretty good as well. The smoked fish dip reminded me a little bit of tuna salad but with a smoky flavor. Honestly, I loved it! Probably because I like tuna salad but with the extra smokiness, mixed with the sweet relish on top, it was just an overall solid dip. For the main course my wife and I ordered the Sapelo Island GA Middleneck Clams and the NC Cedar Island fry. I loved that the clams aren't over dressed. Just some white wine, sweet garlic and butter. Honestly, simple is best and I felt like they did a good job at not over complicating it. Clams are already opened, and all you have to do is take them out, bathe them in the juices and go to town. The fried plate was ok. Nothing much to it really. Fried fish, oysters and shrimp. It was good, but nothing really wowed me. I will say that it wasn't overly breaded and it was more of a "soft" fry where the food wasn't too crispy or greasy. That's how I prefer my fried seafood. The fish (don't remember what kind), was actually juicy though even though it was fried. That was nice. The homemade chips were pretty good. The hushpuppies were a little dry which I found disappointing. The icebox slaw, however, was actually very good. It's not like your typical creamy slaw. It's more of a "fresh" slaw. It was sweet and tangy. Reminiscent of sauerkraut. I thought this actually complimented all the fried food on the rest of the plate to give your palate a little cleansing. My favorite part of the night was the dessert. We ordered the oreo bread pudding with caramel drizzle and ice cream. I'm partial to bread pudding and have had a lot of them in my day, and I will say that this was especially delicious. The texture of the bread was perfect. Not too mushy and hard enough to withstand the melty ice cream but not too hard where it tastes stale. It also wasn't overly sweet. I have a sweet tooth and love things sweet, but this was just at the right level. Overall, I'm giving this place 3 stars not because the food was bad. I think because we are more inland, the price for seafood here is a little different than what I'm typically used to. I felt like the portion sizes for the price were a little small, and I'm not sure if the tastes met up to the price point. However, the waitress we had was super friendly and it was a decent experience for a Friday family dinner out. read more

One of my favorite restaurants in PBoro - always quality. Love the grilled oysters and so many fresh features to choose from. Love!

Delicious food, great service. Nice wine selection. Not always able to get raw oysters, so call first!

This place is always solid. The other night, We had the catfish, the clams (simply amazing) and the trout dip (incredible). The relish on the trout dip, ahhh so good! The fried oysters are dried out and too salty so I'd avoid that but... They used to serve bread to start and no longer so that's a bummer. It was that local bread company and it went t sways with Covid I think. Great spot! read more

We scheduled a dinner date with friends , met there on a Thursday Night at 5 pm . We showed up ans it was closed. No sign on door, phone just rang busy. We drove away to another restaurant to eat. 2 hours later it was still closed. Completely bummed read more