Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Potter's By the Sea

    4.8 (4 reviews)

    Potter's By the Sea Photos

    POTTER'S BY THE SEA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    Recommended Reviews - Potter's By the Sea

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Jim N.
    4987
    622
    5114

    2 years ago

    Helpful 14
    Thanks 2
    Love this 9
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Great service. Best lobster on the island. Music in background so you can still hear your friends talking.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rod M.
    17
    70
    66

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Duffy's Love Shack - Conch fritters

    Duffy's Love Shack

    4.0(436 reviews)
    66.5 km
    $$

    Located in downtown Red Hook. On the opposite side of the more touristy road…read more This tiki shack style place sits to the middle of a parking lot in a small strip mall. Hand down the best place to eat in the area. It's very small, but packs a punch with great customer service, cool drinks and outstanding food. Best to try and get in on their off hours to get a table without a wait. We literally ate here 4 times when we were on the island. An absolute MUST to order is their Bacon Jalapeno tater kegs! OMG-They're the bomb! Wings are decent and the burgers are juicy, flavorful and delicious! You really can't go wrong with ANYTHING on the menu. Everything is made fresh to order. The decor is island themed chaos in every fun way possible. If you happen to have to use the restroom it's located outside (customs ONLY) The key ring they'll hand you is a toilet lid! LOL You can ring in another way too! On your trip to the john, call in sick to work and stay on the island! You're enticed too by the retro phone sitting a top a keg outdoors as well. Great photo opts! Happy Hour is daily! The Love Shack offers particular deals with half-priced cocktails. We did Margs on Monday! Signature drinks include the 50oz Volcano Drink, Shark Attack, and souvenir cocktails like the Pirates Booty in a ceramic mugs. FYI- They may attach a certain creature to your glass also. Perfect vibe, casual dinning and great accommodations by the staff (for our big party) who were so friendly and professional. This is a must experience spot when visiting St Thomas.

    Amazing and fun place! Our waitress was awesome! Food was delicious and ambiance was relaxed and…read morefun! Best tiki drink in a long time!

    Photos
    Duffy's Love Shack - Polynesian PuPu Platter

    Polynesian PuPu Platter

    Duffy's Love Shack
    Duffy's Love Shack

    See all

    Pelicans Beach Bar - Free parking to go to Pelicans. Pass the main lobby, make a right onto public beach access road, parking spots are marked on the right.

    Pelicans Beach Bar

    5.0(2 reviews)
    66.1 km

    Happy hour that lasts all day?! What?! You may just have your check liver light go on before the…read moreday is over! Pelicans Beach Bar is dangerously good at making cocktails go in and having the fun come out of you! $5 mix drinks, $4 beers, $8 crafted frozen all day for happy hour! This little 7 seat bar at the Ritz Carlton Resort is the farthest down the beach next to the serenity pool. Shhhhhhhhh......be quiet.....yea right when happy hour is all day and your bartenders are mad cool! Not sure of why they put this next to the "library" section of the resort but this bar just opened up in November. Our bartender Alex and her side kick Ryan were awesome compliments to the beachy view of St. John and our delicious cocktails. My favorites were the Lilikoi Mango Mojito and Caribbean Fiesta (not on menu but Alex knows of how to make them). For those Patron lovers like my hubby, try the Sandy Day, he loved it! Sushi is Japanese for yummylicious! Pelicans Beach Bar expands (seating wise) during the evening to a few 4 tops for an all you can eat sushi pig out session every Wednesday from 5p-8p for $45! Thursday's is taco day from 5p-8p with unlimited rice, beans, chips and salsa! You've already tortured yourself in dieting to get into bikini ready shape, let this sushi and taco fun be your free pass to choose your love of food, over not wanting to get fat! If staying at the Ritz these two nights should be checked out. If you don't want to chillax under the stars while listening to music next to tiki torches, you can box up your grub and take it back to your room. Tacos and sushi not your thing? You can order from Coconut Cove, another restaurant on the resort and they'll deliver your food to you at this bar. If not staying at the Ritz, great bay beach, which Pelicans Beach Bar sits on is actually a public beach. There is hidden free public beach parking past the main hotel lobby port cochere and down a steep road. Pictures attached show the way. My only complaint is that the bathroom locations seem like the distance needed to get to St. John. But that's the laziness (aka selective participation) in me that gets stronger with each cocktail! Cheers!

    Excellent bar spot with an all day happy hour right on the Ritz Carlton Residence property. The…read morebartenders Alex and Ryan were super friendly and made excellent drinks. Drinks are only $8-$10 each, so we were at this spot several times per day. Really made our trip and stay at the Ritz Residences more enjoyable. We also tried the taco night on Thursday which was also very good (5-8pm). Definitely check this place out if you are staying nearby.

    Photos
    Pelicans Beach Bar - All day happy hour fun!

    All day happy hour fun!

    Pelicans Beach Bar - The bar!

    See all

    The bar!

    Paddle-In Tiki Bar - Pina Colada

    Paddle-In Tiki Bar

    3.9(8 reviews)
    56.5 km
    $$

    A great place to stop and get a drink while enjoying Maho Bay. It's right across the street from…read morethe main beach, and they accept card - no need to carry cash! The drinks are a little pricier, but taking into account you're in the middle of a national park with not much around, the prices make sense. Drinks absolutely delicious - we loved the pina colada! They have plenty of seating, so you can either stay and enjoy or take your drinks back to the beach across the street. I'm not sure if they're related or not, but there is a little food shop little right next to it with the same available seating. As with the drinks, food there is a little pricier but take into account where you are. We ordered the mahi bites. Absolutely delicious. Fish was solid enough to pick up but flaked apart in your mouth. Would totally order again. Great place to stop when you're enjoying the beach at Maho Bay.

    Fun tiki bar with ample seating options in pristine Maho Bay…read more We stayed in the bay on a catamaran for approx 5 days and came ashore to the tiki bar daily for cocktails, live music, tshirt shopping. This place is the hub for anything fun you plan to do in Maho bay: ample rentals to kayak, paddle board, snorkel, chair rentals for the beach front. Great strong drinks and a fun chill vibe to chillax, play corn hole, kick back and people watch, or stare at the stunning turquoise wonder that is Maho Bay. Very highly recommended.

    Photos
    Paddle-In Tiki Bar - Mahi Bites

    Mahi Bites

    Paddle-In Tiki Bar - Live music at Paddle-In Tiki Bar.

    Live music at Paddle-In Tiki Bar.

    Paddle-In Tiki Bar

    See all

    Potter's By the Sea - bars - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...