Thin crust pizza, cut in squares, is my jam! I was really impressed with the quality of the food. The pizza was hot and fresh, made just the way I liked. The server did a wonderful job and was attentive, the only complaint I would have is there was too much cheese on the salad and not enough dressing. But the pizza made up for it. The restaurant was near on the inside, displaying the long history of the place. read more

Pryor's Fresh Pizza - Deluxe pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

I have been going to Pryor`s Pizza in Rolla since I was ten years old, I am now sixty-three. The pizza was always my favorite in the state. I recently had the same pizza I had been getting there for over fifty years. I never thought I would say this but based on my most recent experience this Pizza is now my least favorite in the state. It was clear to me the new owners do not care about the quality of their food. It is sad to see the brand Martha and Doyle worked so hard to establish has deteriorated so much. read more

We were a group of four people having pizza in mid afternoon. The restaurant was nearly empty so it was easy to get quick service. However the kitchen was having air-conditioning problems, and evidently the restaurant had to close an hour after we left. We ordered pizzas and calzones. The pizzas were a better choice, and we had both deluxe pizzas and a pepperoni pizza on a gluten-free crust. That cauliflower crust was surprisingly good, and at least based on a small sample, every bit as tasty as the regular crust. There was also a small salad bar which we did not use. Our server was friendly and prompt. We all enjoyed our experience. The price was somewhat high for the amount of food. read more

See all

People were friendly. That doesn't make up for the pizza, though. Had their large deluxe; it was possibly the worst pizza we have ever eaten. 2 adults and 1 child (unfortunately) all agreed that this pizza was less than good. read more

It's a local treasure and treat! Unique thin crust with real ingredients. Family owned, friendly service.

The restaurant furniture is a hodgepodge of Thrift store tables and chairs that are all uncomfortable. They charge way too much for a sub par salad bar. Something went wrong with our order so we waited for almost an hour and a half and still no pizza. We walked out and went to Alex's. read more

Pryor's Pizza! I have been wanting to try this place for a long time, and tonight I got my chance, what a DISAPPOINTMENT! The restaurant was clean, and the young lady came right over and got our drink orders while we checked out the menu, so we had the Salad Bar (1 Trip) 1 order of Cheesy Bread Sticks and a Large Deluxe Pizza. Let's start with the Salad Bar. I had to ask the young lady who was working the floor if they could put out some Fresh Lettuce, the lettuce that was there was getting brown and nasty looking. The salad bar is small, it could use a few more things like Shredded Carrot, Cucumbers and some Bacon Bits. The Cheesy Bread Sticks, I had to laugh, Really? 4 little bread sticks for 6.00 dollars, Oily, No Taste, you would think they would use some garlic and oregano, something to give them some flavor. The Deluxe Pizza! Very small compared to Imo's Extra Lare Deluxe (16 inches) This pizza tasted like it was made for a nursing home, very bland, not very many toppings, some of the pieces just had cheesy and nothing else, very poor excuse for a Deluxe Pizza, Imo's has a 14 inch Deluxe for 16.50 and you charged us 22.00 for 13 inch nursing home pizza (bland no taste) Let's talk Crust , while the edges were crispy, the center was nasty! you couldn't even pick up a piece without it falling apart due to being so thin and greasy. The Pizza Sauce lacked flavor, it tastes like plain tomato sauce, absolutely no flavor! This is the worst Pizza Dinner I have ever had, I expected so much more. What a DISAPPOINT! 1) Upgrade your Salad Bar (Carrots, Cucumbers and Bacon Bits) 5.50 is fine for a salad, but 12.00 dollars for unlimited, No Way! not for that salad bar, it doesn't offer anything, for what you offer, 5.50 for unlimited and 3.50 for 1 trip to the salad bar would be more like it. 2) Use some Italian Spices in your Pizza, Sauce and on your Breads. Your a Pizza restaurant, not a nursing home, spice things up! get people talking. 3) Up the Size of your Pizzas, Off a 16 inch A lot of room for improvements, I hope you make some. We won't be back anytime soon. The Fountain Pepsi was very good! read more

Passing through town, we stopped to grab a pepperoni and deluxe. Both were great. The dough, cheese, and sause were tasty and combined good.

So I stoped in and got 3 slices of pizza and when I started to eat it the bottom was burnt now when they had the restaurant not the food truck. The food was good when something is burnt it's better and taste like crap all I can say is I hope they find a place because what they're selling now is not worth it read more

Where to start. When my kids and I came in we were greeted immediately. There was an issue with their fan or heater and there was a very loud clunking sound for a minute. The hostess apologized immediately and offered us a table in a quite spot but said it was going it happen til it was fixed. Honestly it wasn't that big of deal. We ordered a large salad to share and drinks. The kids were super happy, the salad was cold and crisp. Lots of extra toppings. The waitress/hostess even brought extra salad dressing for us since she knew we were sharing. We ordered the meat pizza. Now the wait did take a bit but it was well worth it. The pizza was fresh and tasty, thin crust but lots of flavor. They were not greedy with ingredients and it was so good. It tasted of a homemade pizza, definitely not commercial. All in all we took half of the pizza home and ate it later that night. It was just as good. We will return and possible try another flavor pizza but if not, this was the way to go. Price wise, was a little more expensive than ordering commercial pizza but the experience, service and flavor was well worth the extra money. read more

Pryor's Fresh Pizza - Salads and drinks (They now have fountain drinks) - Pizza Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

Over-the-top fantastic pizza, great service. Get the thin crust meat lovers. Oh the pepperoni you'll have! Great retro atmosphere, and outstanding pizza. I'll go out of my way to come back read more

Pryor's Fresh Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

Pizza was great and the staff was very friendly. Definitely worthwhile place to stop and eat.

Pryor's Pizza was way better than I was expecting. We got two pizzas, which were both delicious and fried ravioli ( which was so good we ended up placing another order). It was a great experience and as we were waiting we played pool at the table in the front. Service was good as well. read more

Local, family pizza place since 1964! Tasty pizza, friendly people. We make it a point to stop here when in Rolla. It's a legacy! read more

Pryor's Fresh Pizza - a pizza house menu - Pizza Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

Pryor's pizza is my all-time favorite. For the uninitiated, it's a thin crust pizza. However, it's not a crispy thin crust. You can (and should) roll a piece up for an optimum eating experience. Pros: The pizza is amazing. The beef pizza is out of this world!! Cons: If you eat in, it takes a long time. And, they're slightly pricey. Since the pizza is the best pizza ever, the pros definitely outweigh the cons. Just order it take out due to the wait. read more

The food tastes really good but it's priced pretty high. This is a place you'd go if you're wanting to splurge on the everyday American greasy foods. I wish the prices were more affordable but I understand that businesses like this need to make more to stay open. They have a great looking dining room, many menu options to choose from, and my personal favorite appetizer is the mozzarella balls. definitely try this place out & decide the rating for yourself, because the food is good ! read more

Ordered takeout. The toppings were fresh and tasty. The this crust was spot on. We will be ordering here again.

Never Judge a book by its cover! From the outside this little pizza place doesn't look like much. In fact for years I have driven right past it time and time again when in Rolla. The Pizza is by far one of the best in the Rolla area. Nothing special in terms of options outside pizza. This is a pizza stop and I believe Pizza and Salad are the only 2 menu options. $1.50 for a canned soda is a little steep but still leaving this at 5 stars for the excellent Pizza. This is not a dine in quick stop. You can expect 20-30 minute wait for food when it's empty inside simply because they make it fresh for you! If your like me and have been driving by over and over stop in! You won't be dissatisfied! read more

Excessively long wait for our Pizza, 45 minutes +. Drinks are cans of soda. Once the food was delivered to our table, we were impressed. The pizza was very good. Some of the best In Missouri. Initially I wanted to give a single star or less. The quality of the pizza made the difference and earned 3 stars. read more

Pryor's Fresh Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

Really? I'm the first? Wow. That's kinda amazing. This place is one of my family favs. They have a thin crust pizza with burnt edges (yes burnt as in good burnt). I remember back when Old Man Pryor ran this joint and it wasn't as "run down" looking with a homey feel to it. You could go in order a pizza, carve your name on their old tin pizza pans ( I don't think you were suppose to.), play the jukebox, and laugh with friends in this little parlor. This place doesn't look fresh and new but it has a lot of history and will always be in my heart! Sausage and Mushroom is my favorite here. Yummy and ooey-gooey goodness! read more

Great thin crust pizza in nostalgic pizza house. Menu on wall since 1962 when a large cheese pizza was $1.35. Don't miss this place if you like thin crust pizza! read more

See all

First let me say that no pizza ever stacks up to Pryor's pizza in my book. I live in St Louis and there have been times when a buddy of mine go on a day trip to Rolla SOLELY for the purpose of getting Pizza at Pryor's. Also, in my book, the best is plain old pepperoni! I've been going to Pryor's since I was a child. It was a special treat while visiting my grandparents. Let me back up. My parents grew up around the Belle, MO area. Rolla was the town to go to! I've heard stories of mass amounts of people leaving the Drive In Theater early and try to get to Pryor's "ahead of the crowd." My parents went on dates in this very same fashion. They introduced my sister and I to Pryor's at a nice early age. It was always a special treat and sometimes before leaving my grandparents I remember literally begging to go the 30 minutes out of our way to Rolla before heading home to Washington MO. According to my grandfather, Mr. Pryor offered to sell the recipe and store to him! Unfortunately for my grandfather (and the rest of the family!), he had to turn down the offer. I don't have children of my own but I have introduced Pryor's to a few friends along the way. Everyone agrees. Great pizza. As a matter of fact, I just got off the phone with Pryor's. I called to see if they were open on Memorial Day. I'll be visiting family in Springfield and fully intend on stopping for a pizza on the way back to St. Louis. But I don't think I'm gonna tell the rest of my family. There could be a riot. I would stop at Pryor's on the way down to Springfield too, but I'll be going through Rolla before Pryor's is open. Besides, if my family knew, they would have me pick up at least a dozen half-baked pizzas to bring down and cook over the weekend! This is how much we love Pryor's Pizza. read more

Best pizza ever. Grew up with this place. And it's the best ever thin crust pizza. And the best fountain root beer in town.

Great mom and pop place. Doesn't look like much when you walk past but the pizza was great. Friendly staff especially our waiter Elias. Definitely a hard worker. read more

Great mom and pop place. Small, cozy, simplified menu. Prices are average for pizza joints and drinks are via cans and not fountain. Pizza was good staff was friendly but overworked because we were forgotten about for a while. Which brings me to what seems to be the biggest issue especially when talking with other guests. With a mom and pop style place, wait time for food from order to table was about 40 minutes. read more

This place is so cute! I love it. It's perfectly retro and simple and I will be bringing it up as suggestions when people ask where to go. I love a good classic local place. They have only a few different ingredients, so ordering can't be too difficult! Everything was fresh and tasty. read more

See all

If you like cheese and uncooked crust, this is the place for you! I'm surprised they are allowed to even call it pizza. Had to order a side of sauce for the sauceless, uncooked concoction they brought to the table. Also, the place looks like it hasn't been remodeled or cleaned since the 1800s when it opened. Grime on the walls, crumbs on the sticky tables, and decor could have been found in my great great great grannies great grandmas house. I'll be visiting the frozen pizza section in Walmart before paying this place another visit. Oh, and if you need to use the restroom, which you will after eating whatever you put in your mouth from this place, wait until you get home. The bathroom there is less than adequate. A porta potty makes this place look nice. Won't be returning for any reason. read more

This is a Mom and Pap restaurant, and it is our first time coming to Pryor's pizza and it was Very Good. You can watch them make your pizza. There is a lot of topping on the pizza. Next time we come to Rolla Mo. We will go back. The Price was very low also. read more

We have been wanting to try this place for a really long time. We were very disappointed. We waiting for about 45 minutes for the pizza to come out. Then there was way too much cheese on it, the mushrooms were jar mushrooms and were not distributed on the pizza very good at all. They were in huge globs on pieces and then other slices didn't have any mushrooms. Then there were several pieces that the crust was not cooked through. Highly disappointed in this place. We won't be returning again. read more

Delicious pizza.We had a gluten free crust,as I'm wheat intolerant and it was delicious- I haven't tried the regular crust but if the gluten free crust was the only I ever had.I wouldn't be disappointed.The kale caesar was also amazing. read more

We ate here on our visit because it was/ is my moms favorite! 20 years later it did not disappoint her or myself. We ordered a large deluxe. It was good! I love that they are a thin crust pizza (you can order thick crust). The pizza had plenty of toppings and cheese. I also like how they cut the pizza into squares vs the triangles. My brother got the large salad- it was enough to share and looked so delicious (I didn't have any). Customer service was good. read more

The bottom line is that the food isn't very good. Friendly service, but a very limited menu, and bland pizza with cheap ingredients. It didn't taste good and I didn't feel well after eating there. read more

One of my favorite pizza places in Rolla. This one and Alex's pizza are always the best! Pryors has been around since the 60s and I can see why. The servIce was great and the pizza was even better. read more

Good no frills mom and pop shop pizza. Order cheese, by the topping, or deluxe (with five pieces of pepperoni, but plenty of the other stuff). Small or large. Thin crust is tasty, but too stuffed with toppings to hold the Chicago slices in one hand. Just right. Break down and use a fork. Don't look for jalapeños here. Just the basics. Pinapple is as fancy as they get. And leave your belt at the door. read more

We were driving through Missouri from Chicago and wanted some pizza to take back to our hotel. Looked up reviews for local pizza places and Pryor's had the best reviews so we called ahead and ordered so we could pick it up on our way to the hotel. The reviews said it takes a while to get your pizza. Pretty much the only complaint that's why we ordered while we were still driving. Said it would take 25-30 mins and that's when we would arrive so it worked out perfect! Best pizza we've had since we moved to Chicago from Arizona. Wish we lived closer it would be our weekly pizza stop!! You won't be disappointed!!! read more

Terrible Pizza & Terrible people. Needed to talk to the manager and 1/22/19 and kept getting hung up on

A friend new i loved New Jersey style thin crust pizzeria style pizza and thought I would find Pryor's a close match. Sorry, not even close. Not oily like New Jersey, New York, and a strange texture to the crust - crumbly like a cracker. If you are a true pizza connoisseur, and love New York, New Jersey style pizza, this is NOT the place for you. Even Casey's is closer to what you are looking for. Alexes, Penelope and Imo's are yet further. It you are looking for true New Jersey style pizza (the best in the world), you are out of luck in Rolla. Closest is Caseys and it is a long way off. Oh well. read more

A nice "mom & pop" style pizza place, very no frills, but great tasting pizza. Soda in cans, salads & pizza, that's all. Crust is thin, crisp & cooked through, served quickly for being fresh baked (& hot!!!), there's a thick-crust option too. read more

Not my thing, but it's a Rolla institution. A true hometown shop!

Lots of toppings on this pizza. The sauce is good. Could of been cooked little more. Service good. Server soda out of cans no free refills. Dining room clean but has a urine smell. Don't let the old building discourage you the pizza is well worth it. read more