Finally had the opportunity to try Punkin's Pies and not disappointed. The person working (assuming the owner) was very kind. The space being in The Amp is convenient for a quick sweet tooth bite after a savory meal. I ordered 2 Bling and 2 Strawberry Crunch strawberries. The Bling was $4 each and the Crunch was $2.75 each with a requirement of them being sold in pairs. Both were good! The crunch was rich and great increments. The bling is dry on the outside because of the glitter but juicy strawberry on the inside - they are so pretty. She packaged them so well. And I we were able to enjoy at home. read more

See all

4 stars. Have you ever seen a glam berry? Just know that it is so pretty you will feel guilty about eating it! I had never had a strawberry crunch berry before, so I tried it. Not my fav. The outer part was less crunchy (read: soggy) than I had hoped. The texture was a bit off-putting. But... the berry was large and sweet. Service was just like my treats - sweet! Next time, I'll try the truffles! read more

Punkin's Pies - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I was looking for a little treat & came across this place in the Amp. What a cute store! And the person working behind the counter was so nice/friendly. I tried a chocolate covered strawberry, Oreo cheesecake truffle, and a cake pop... and honestly I was unfortunately underwhelmed. The strawberry was quite fresh but the chocolate wasn't rich at all and didn't have much taste. The cheesecake truffle didn't really taste like cheesecake. The cake pop was pretty good though (and big!). Giving it 4 stars because the experience was great & I think this is a wonderful business for corporate/party gifts and the like, but for my personal taste, I probably wouldn't go back just for me. read more

Punkin's Pies - Cake pop - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Love them. Everything in their case was sweet, delicious and even filling. The Cheesecake salad is ridiculous ... ly good.

Oooooh baby! This is your spot for all-things sweet. Most recently, I purchased a white-chocolate-dipped Oreo truffle and milk-chocolate-dipped Oreo. They also have chocolate-covered pretzels, truffles, caramel apples, Rice Krispies, and more. They even have boxes of cheesecake slices and fruit that look incredible. Depending on when you're there, you'll find different treats to enjoy. I was especially thankful for their team too because they weren't open yet when I was there, but they saw me peeking in the glass case and sold a few treats to me anyway. Thank you, Punkin's! read more

See all

The first thing I noticed was the beautiful showcase of dessert bites.  There were cheesecake truffles, cake pops, strawberries dipped in milk chocolate, white chocolate, and also some called "bling" strawberries because they were dipped and then rolled in gold and pink sand sugar.   I got the Oreo cheesecake truffle and it really hit the spot after lunch. My granddaughter got the confetti cake pop and gobbled it right down. We both had to try the gold sparkly strawberry. It came in its own little plastic container. It was delicious! Their gold sparkly strawberry gave me an idea that you could dip strawberries in purple, gold, and green and create a centerpiece for Mardi Gras. How cool would that be? There were plenty more bites to try so we will be back for more! read more

Punkin's Pies - Storefront - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

What a cute little spot in the amp, it's honestly fun just to look at all of the beautiful treats. I decided to pick up some chocolate covered strawberries, and a glam berry. I'll have to report back on the chocolate covered strawBerries, but I have no doubt they are delicious! I got into my glam berry as soon as I got home and it was tasty! I'll be back to check out some more awesome treats! The staff here is great as well! Glad they have a space to sell such pretty and delicious treats! read more

Punkin's Pies - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

So far, I've been fairly underwhelmed by The Amp. There are some exceptions to this general feeling of underwhelm and Punkin's Pies is one of those exceptions. The "Punkin" in this case is Joanna Wilson, the delightfully friendly owner of Punkin's Pies and a lifelong baker who has gradually turned it into her own woman-owned, Black-owned business. Punkin's Pies is easy to find in the fairly new The Amp complex and is definitely worth going out of your way to find it. Punkin's Pies offers a variety of sweet treats including pies, cheesecakes, milk and white chocolate covered items (strawberries, Oreos, etc.), and assorted other items. Having missed the Indiana State Fair this year, I'd been craving a chocolate dipped Oreo. Punkin's made it happen and it was delightful. Punkin's has a beautiful display case that leaves you mouth-watering and wanting to crawl inside the display case. Prices are reasonable and customer service is top-notch. I've been to The Amp a couple times and just haven't felt like the place has found its rhythm yet, but it has certain indie gems worth revisiting and Punkin's Pies is definitely one of those gems. Here's hoping they keep growing because they are an absolute delight. read more

Punkin's Pies - A small portion of the Punkin's treats. - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If you're visiting The Amp, you can't leave without a stop at Punkin's Pies! This sweet shop has it all! Coated oreos, strawberries, rice krispies, fruit bowls, cakes, pies and more! I stopped in with my daughter and she was immediately mesmerized by the blinged out strawberries. She had to get one. I opted for the crunch cheesecake filled strawberry. The selections are huge! You definitely get your money's worth and leave with your sweet tooth satisfied! read more

See all

I learned about this place from a recent Yelp event where we got to explore The AMP. I got a free chocolate covered strawberry and was hooked! I decided to order a cheesecake bowl and a milk chocolate turtle. The cheesecake bowl contains fresh green grapes, green apples, strawberries, and cheesecake chunks drizzled in white chocolate. There were also two strawberries, one dipped in white chocolate, one in strawberry crunch. Amazing! The turtle was a classic delight. I came back a couple days later and got a couple more strawberries, chocolate dipped pineapple, and Oreo truffles. Everything here is very reasonably priced and the staff is so kind. It's my new favorite dessert place - check them out! read more

See all

Milk chocolate Turtle here is delicious! Perfectl amount of salty sweet ratio, and the texture of the pecans were perfectly in sync with the soft caramel and chocolate. It's a very flat disc that has the right proportions of each in each bite. read more

We went back to AMP for dinner. Dessert was from Punkin's Pies. OMG the Cheese Cake Fruit Plate is AMAZING!!! Apple, strawberry, grapes with cheese cake all topped with white chocolate and carmel sauce. It's cheese cake but it's also fruit so it's healthy right? read more

Punkin's Pies - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Inside the AMP, the newest foodhall retail/space, this place is perfect for a sweet treat after you fill up. There is an assortment of dipped fruit, cheesecake, rice crispies, and truffles. I got the strawberry crunch dipped strawberry. This is very messy to eat, so make sure you have something to catch the crumble. The inside is like a sweetened sugary strawberry. The rice crispy had thick chocolate around it. We both would get something different next time - but it really does hit any sweet tooth! read more

See all

Beautiful dessert options in AMP. I ordered the turtle apple. I cut it myself at home. The Apple was fresh and the toppings were delicious. They dressed up the box so nicely as well as but it in a nice bag to go. The service was friendly. The prices are a little higher than I'm use to but I'm happy to support a local business. read more

Punkin's Pies - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Beautiful treats perfect for Valentine's Day gifting. I bought chocolate-dipped strawberries, but the truly special purchase for a gal pal was a Bling Berry: a glittery glowing dipped strawberry for $4 that comes in its own little snow globe. Many other yummy looking treats. Definitely a place to go if you want something out of the ordinary to gift and then you can buy something for yourself, too! read more

Punkin's Pies - A "Bling Berry"! - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

As a somewhat frequent visitor to the AMP, I've been keeping an eye on this place because it looks so tempting! My wife and I finally got to buy some treats now that they are open! I've heard their cheesecake is really good, but both of us were smitten by the giant Granny Smith apples that are served like taffy apples, but the variety of flavors is wonderful. I ordered a Pecan Caramel apple while my wife ordered a milk chocolate Turtle apple. Each was served in its own container to make it easier to transport home. The only 'negative' is that these are huge! They are nearly impossible to bite into without knocking off some of the topping/nuts. When we got home, we sliced them which made it much easier to enjoy the blend of flavors in each bite. The apples grabbed our attention that we didn't really check out all the other goodies available. My wife was interested to see if they had actual pies available but not at the moment. They were out of one sort of apple combo and offered to make one for us if we could wait on it. We made time! Between this shop, Circle City Sweets, and Boba & Everything, you are sure to find something sweet to satisfy your cravings! Fresh and crisp apples for our treat and excellent pairings of flavors. Worth indulging on the price. Review #3939 read more

See all

Carmel Apple with peanut is really good, the apple is Granny green I think. Well it's a green apple inside. read more

Punkin's Pies - Carmel apple Min - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I am a sucker for a good turtle and Punkin's are huge! The caramel is soft and chewy making it the perfect sweet treat! My husband enjoyed the Oreo truffle. Everything is very reasonably priced. Make sure to stop by! read more

Punkin's Pies' treats are absolutely BEAUTIFUL. I love browsing their case just because I'm constantly impressed with their products. I've only tried their chocolate strawberries, which are sparkly and beautiful -- and probably every five year old's dream, in the very best way. Everything they sell looks wonderful. My only complaint is that the strawberries were a little squishy, but I'm sure it's not easy to keep them perfectly plump after dipping them in chocolate. read more

The staff are the nicest people! The cake pops are the best I ever had! They are so moist and good sized so you get a few good bites. The covered Oreos are great! My kids loved them! This is definitely a nice place to get desserts with the family because they have many different options for everyone and lots of fruit desserts too. They also have a few dairy free options. read more

The dark chocolate covered strawberries were amazing and then I had the white chocolate cheesecake stuffed strawberry crunch covered strawberries and I will be back. The owner was so friendly. 1000% recommend. read more

Well worth the wait. We got there a little before they opened but she was so kind to offer to prepare what we wanted before she opened. I wanted the cheesecake bowl. They were not ready yet. I kept checking back. Each time she was kind. When they were finally ready, they were well worth the wait! I sent one to Illinois so I could share the experience with friends. read more

This place is literally amazing, The bling strawberries did not even look edible and their presentation is very professional. Also the workers are very approachable I will go here every day if I could. read more