If you have a sweet tooth for baked treats, this is the spot. I truly love their cookies but the absolute stars are the cinnamon rolls. Both are on the expensive side, however the price is commiserate with the quality. Fluffy, perfectly risen, and the flavor is throughout, not just on top like the flavored rolls at other stores. I recommend ordering ahead for a quick in/out and to make sure what you want is in stock. I've seen the line quite long, but you can get lucky with no line on a weekday. The inside is cute but there is no seating inside. You're going to get a little messy eating your cinnamon roll and want to be in the privacy of your own home anyway. My one very minor piece of feedback is I wish some rolls were sweet rolls (i.e. skip the cinnamon). Fruity Pebble is a little overpowered by cinnamon but I'd still get it. Cookie Monster is the #1 flavor for me and I can't wait to catch Pineapple Upsidedown in stock. read more

See all

I think this place is more known towards their cinnamon rolls, I came here towards end of business and there were barely anything in stock, there's also no visible menu I could find so I just got what's left from the case. At $5 per cookie I think is pricey, as they were in a medium size yes they were thick but not as big circumference wise They're were good cookies though, just don't think $5 good I'd try this place again maybe for their cinnamon rolls read more

The Cavity Factory - Inside - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This place has good cookies and cinnamon rolls. The cinnamon rolls are to die for. The prices are reasonable. She always has a long line here due to the cinnamon rolls and cookies. She is a one woman show. Customer service is great.the store front is nice. read more

The Cavity Factory - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Good cinnamon rolls and very big! For the price and the consistency however it is definitely 3 stars. My husband and I ordered cinnamon rolls from Cavity Factory twice, and was told the first time stopping in (after driving from 45 minutes away) we had to order online and come back and pick them up. It was 11 am, and the first slot available was 3, so we spent 3 and a half hours around broad ripple, came back and picked them up. Extremely inconvenient, but since covid we've been losing the art of fully functioning store fronts, so it wasn't surprising. I got the banana pudding cinnamon rolls, which the flavor was very good, but the filling (which I took a picture of) was very sparse so the roll was very bready. I took a bite of my husband's, which was the original, and it was delicious! The filling was generous, and it was baked to perfection. For $26 for two cinnamon rolls and a 4 hour wait (which by all means is extremely steep) we were relatively happy. However, today, we picked up one original cinnamon roll and scheduled the pick up ahead of time. It looked entirely different from our first order aesthetically, but it was still pretty good. However, the middle of the roll was undercooked. It had that weird gummy bread texture, similar to raw biscuit dough. I ended up having to toss it out. For $12 + tax and a 45 minute drive, that is definitely disappointing. The cinnamon rolls are pretty good, but as you can see in some other reviews, it lacks greatly in consistency, the food and business alike. And for the price point, it leaves a lot more to be desired before $15 is a genuinely fair price. read more

The Cavity Factory - Banana pudding cinnamon roll - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The service was amazing, the establishment looked great inside and out, the ambience was very quaint and cozy, and the desserts were top-tier!!! I give this establishment a 10 out of 10 highly recommend!!! read more

I love these cookies! The flavors are so unique and the cookies are always soft and packed with flavor! Make sure you stop by Friday-Sunday to get new flavors! She posts her cookie schedule on instagram so you can plan your taste bud experience! The shop is in the fountain square area and I love the design. It's clean and easy to get your order and go about your day! This weekend I got the pineapple upside down cookies, biscoff, oatmeal butterscotch, lemon, and cookies and cream. They are big enough to share (if you want ). The pineapple upside down cookie was sooooooooooooo good! Didn't make it out the parking lot with that one! You're sure to satisfy your sweet tooth! read more

See all

Some of the best cookies I've ever had (and definitely better than Crumbl and similar places)! They're so soft, super rich, and full of flavor. Make sure you check social media before you go to operating hours and the flavors available for that day. They close when they sell out! There is parking on the side of the building but also free street parking in Fountain Square. It's super easy to run in and out to grab what you want, but the staff is welcoming and friendly if you have questions. This trip I got Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Dubai Pistachio Brownie, Slutty Brownie, Banana Pudding, and White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup-- all delicious!! read more

The Cavity Factory - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This place was such a great find in the neighborhood! I'm not even a big sweets person, but I absolutely love their cookies. They are the perfect portions and there's many fun flavors to try. So far, my favorite has been the s'mores cookie. We've been a few times and the staff are always friendly and our cookies are always delicious. read more

A croissant with a chocolate chip cookie inside and drizzled with chocolate sauce..... need I say more? Wow! The service was quick. It's a cute little shop and there is a small parking lot on the side. The creative menu that changes weekly is definitely something to check out. I will be visiting again, as soon as I burn off the calories from today's yummy dessert. I recommend checking it out! read more

The Cavity Factory - Croissant with chocolate chip cookie inside and chocolate drizzle on the outside - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Well, we WANT to like this place but it's hard when 2 of the last 3 times we have tried to go it has been closed--not sold out, but CLOSED--during stated business hours. The first time we checked the FB page and she had posted that she had to close due to illness. Ok, that's understandable, and we learned to check the FB page before driving over. But we tried to go this past Saturday at 12:30 p.m. and the doors were locked, no one there, and nothing was posted on FB or anywhere. It's a 30-minute drive each way for us, so it's hard to want to even try to go back when we may drive an hour round-trip with nothing to show for it but spent gas money. So we're kinda souring on this place. read more

I recently tried two cinnamon rolls from The Cavity Factory: the Biscoff and the Strawberry and wanted to share an honest but balanced review. First, the presentation is a standout. Both rolls are generously sized, and the toppings are applied heavily. The frosting is rich and plentiful, which I personally appreciated. The Biscoff roll came loaded with cookie crumble, and the strawberry roll looked beautiful with the fresh strawberry on top. Visually, these rolls definitely deliver that over-the-top dessert look. The dough itself was fluffy, which I enjoyed, but it wasn't anything particularly special or unique. For a $14 roll, I expected a more elevated, artisan-style dough or something that set it apart from a standard cinnamon roll. Most of the excitement comes from the toppings and frosting rather than the base of the roll. Where the experience really fell short for me was the strawberry drizzle. It tasted like the inexpensive artificial gel you usually find on grocery-store pastries. It stood out because the rolls are priced and presented as a premium product, so the cheaper-tasting drizzle didn't match the expectation. The Biscoff flavor was tasty, but again, the strength of the roll was in the toppings, not the craftsmanship of the base. Overall, these rolls are fun, indulgent, and very Instagram-worthy. But in my opinion, the ingredient quality especially the drizzle and the dough not being particularly distinctive doesn't fully justify the $14 per roll price. They're worth trying once for the experience, but at this cost, I expected a more elevated flavor profile behind the toppings. read more

The Cavity Factory - Strawberry & Biscoff cinnamon roll - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Worth the hype. So worth the hype. Open 11:30 til sellout, weekends only. Came in at 2pm on a Friday to only the Biscoff crookie (croissant cookie mix) and birthday cake cookie. Had one of each and I will undoubtedly be back, earlier next time. Very active on Facebook with updates on what's in stock, and the menu changes weekly. Follow The Cavity Factory on Facebook so you won't be disappointed by making the drive in if they sell out early. I'd post pictures but there are none because I couldn't stop myself to take one. It's that good y'all. Cult good. read more

We stopped here for a quick dessert and we were happy to see they weren't sold out or closed! I got the lemon cheesecake cookie and my husband got the Oreo butterfinger cookie. My cookie had a filling inside and it was soft and delicious. My husband really enjoyed his as well. The staff are friendly and explained all the cookies. I would come back again read more

The most excellent, soft cookies EVER!!!! My favorite is the strawberry crumble one....This may not be the real name of it but, it was still the best!! This was my very first visit and it did not disappoint! Parking was a little tight but worth the trip to Historic Fountain Square area! read more

SO GOOD. nice small shop just south of Ft. Sq on Shelby. In & out quickly .... the cookies are DELICIOUS and plump. read more

See all

Let's start with the pros here. 1. The cookies are very good and unique. 2. Local and minority owned. 3. Ever changing menu to keep it fresh. Now, for the not so great aspects: The hours that the owner herself set are merely a "suggestion" at best. She will open & close more quickly than the weather changes here in Indy. This makes it difficult for those that work, make special trips to get your product, etc very difficult when you randomly close or don't open when your hours say etc. I have talked with many people that say the make special trips only to arrive and her doors be locked, a sign on the door taking a break, or closed early or whatever. Next, she is very rude and aggressive on social media. Making comments about her "problems" and such. Very much a complainer about the line of work she chose. You have a great product that people want, be happy about that. Not complaining about how busy you are and don't have time to make more. This is why people continue to shop at insomnia, cookie plug and others. We'd all love to support local but you make it very hard with your negative attitude and lack of care for your customers who without you'd be out of business. Something to keep in mind. I'd suggest going back to lesser hours as it seems you have been "overwhelmed"' trying to work a full day several days a week. read more

i've been wanting to try this spot ever since the pink truck . i finally was in the area today and was able to do so. it's so clean and colorful on the inside , very instagram worthy. the cookies are amazing , and i love that the flavors change weekly . we were greeted as soon as we walked in , and the owner was super friendly . can't wait to come back another time read more

The Cavity Factory - outdoor entrance - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Hey viewers and fellow Yelpers!! If you haven't heard the buzz around The Cavity Factory, I'd be surprised!! And I'd say that you are missing out! The Cavity Factory is a small business built ground up by Destinee who is super kind and hardworking! I first experienced her cookies at the pink truck on Keystone last year! Today I finally was able to make it to her store front! The store front is not an establishment where you can sit so there will likely be a line! Once you get inside it's super duper cute with the wall of art! The cookies are absolutely delicious! They hit ever taste bud in the best ways! I'd choose her over crumble cookie and several other places any day! Her cookies are normally priced at $5 and the crookies are $8.50! Worth every penny! Parking can be challenging if it's a very busy day for other businesses in the area otherwise you can park in the lots of other places nearby where allowed. Watch for any towing indicators. Although they have opening and closing hours because The Cavity Factory is well known they typically sell out prior to their closing hour! With that being said be sure to keep watch of their social media posts on Instagram and Facebook so that you are up to date on inventory and sell out! ‼‼ read more

See all

RUN TO THE CAVITY FACTORY! The cookies are amazing!! The service is great and the owner is very friendly! The store is a cute little shop that is on the left side of the strip. Make sure you get there early because she sells out! read more

See all

The Cavity Factory was the first sweet spot that I wanted to try when I first moved here last year. I went to KY Kingdom to ride rollercoasters (my literal favorite thing because I'm a middle aged kid) and then I asked the husband to find the pink truck and I haven't been the same girl since. Anyways, let's discuss. These cookies are soft. Someone on Facebook said they have an under baked quality to them and I nearly lost my mind but I decided to go for peace because there's a huge difference between an under baked consistency (that's actually Crumbl) and these. These are fat and chonky and delicious. Each cookie weighs 4oz. They cost $5. Recently we got a new product called Crookies. Croissant cookie combos that I didn't want to love but here we are. One million out of 10. Destinee knocks it out of the park 100% of the time. Important: they are open until sellout. Then closed. Please don't write a bad review. This is just how this place operates. Perfection creates demand. Minus one star for Lucky Charm only being available in March. Lol jk. read more

The Cavity Factory - Lemon Cheesecake is my new favorite. - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Always-friendly service, even when there is a line. Delicious fresh cookies and a great store in Historic Fountain Square. I have tried the banana pudding, blueberry cheesecake, Hostess Cupcake, oatmeal apple cookies and they were all delicious! I don't have a big sweet tooth, but will always pass on any grocery store sweets and drive to The Cavity Factory. Also, a very informative social media, updating what flavors are coming up for the next weekend and posts when they are close to selling out. Just a heads up, they usually sell out way before 4:30. read more

This is my FAVE cookie shop! I have been supporting Destiny (the owner) since she first arrived in her little pink truck. Definitely arrive early if you want to get these cookies because she sells out everyday! The cookies are always soft and moist and surprisingly not too sweet! The best cookies in the city in my opinion read more

I have followed the food truck for a long time and hunted her out almost every weekend! She is far better than any other cookie place out there that is everywhere! Her service is unmatched and her creativity is astounding! The ambiance in her store reflects her product. And you know you will always get something good going into that store just as much as going to her truck and waiting in the long lines!! Every bite is worth the time!! read more

These cookies are ridiculously good! Not good but Amazing! We cannot wait to go back! Destinee was great to talk with as well!

The snickerdoodle crookie is worth the drive. The snickerdoodle crookie is worth the drive. The snickerdoodle crookie is worth the drive. 10/10 read more

The Cavity Factory - Snickerdoodle crookie - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Amazing cookies locally owned with great customer service. I would highly recommend !!!

These cookies are the best in the city. If you are looking for a great cookie this is the place.