I Love Cheesecake so, my wife and I were walking down Morris Park Ave and came upon this bake shop,…read morewe found it to be quite nice and old fashioned looking, I ordered a strawberry cheesecake and my wife ordered some cookies, when I got home I was anxious to taste this cheesecake that I had never had before, that's when the disappointment came, the taste was very bitter, not good at all...

I went to this Bakery by mistake , Thinking it was part of Veniero's .... I was very happy and…read moreexcited for trying theirs delicious pastries ....... It wasn't the case. The day was Xmas eve , came here with my husband to get dessert for our Xmas Dinner. A young lady "helped" us .... Her service was off .... I asked her about the Cheesecakes , her answer was extremely Rude, I was like oh why is she being rude ( in my head ) but didn't say anything ..... I ordered 2 full size cheesecakes ..... then I asked her if the Bakery was part of Veniero's .... Again very rude responded. Keep in mind I was hosting Xmas Dinner so I just didn't want her get me in a bad mood ..... overall just bad service We also order some pastries on the side with coffees ..... very dry pastries , coffees very weak ( watery ) I really don't know why a cashier / server will have such a bad attitude with patrons. Maybe she was just Racist Keep in mind we're not From Europe ..... we're a Hispanic Couple that just wanted some Good Dessert for Xmas Dinner But instead we got horrible service and old pastries

Omgoodness. I finally made it to the bakery "There should always be cake" and Its as cute as Ever!…read moreFreindly customer service! Best best surprise is KLove music was playing. And immediately I knew God is awesome!! I was stranded in the auto zone across the street waiting for a tow truck for over 4 hrs in the blazing scorching heat and When finally I left to walk home. Heaven opened up its doors and all I saw was " there should always be cake" their prices are ridiculous reasonable. I feel like they need to up $ the prices of their delicious desserts and drinks. Cost of living is up. Their beautiful dessertsand DELICIOUS COLd coffee blend. Yummmmm!! Worth every penny. For whaat its worth I felt amazing sitting here indulging while listening to my favorite christian songs. The establishment feels like its a tiny gem from a lifetime movie and I am here for this !! Super clean. Did I mention super cute seating area. Please don't come and eat all the desserts leave me some. Show some love and support to this bakery. Its adorable.

Went there to get a chocolate cake with chocolate filling last year. The service was good and…read morequick. The ambiance is very cute inside. I took off a star for the vegan vanilla cupcakes they were ok and the price. For this small cake it was probably at least $100 and the top part of the cake I got separately from Etsy.

Worst supermarket ever! They laugh at people' misfortune. Employees gossip about customers'…read moreunfortunate situations. If you interrupt them to ask a simple question they give your extreme attitudes, yell at you and get defensive when you return the same message back. They don't allow to time to speak because they're speaking over you. Management is scarce and the manager onsite enables the behavior. Customer service is non existent at this place. It does not even deserve a star. It could improve by getting more customer friendly staff.

I have to take off a star. I went to get my fresh multi-grain croissants and they don't sell them…read moreanymore. So sad.

Asked this amazing team of women to bake a cake and treats for my daughter's 1st birthday, and they…read moreDID NOT disappoint. Fluffy and delicious. Their banana pudding is AMAZING! They love what they do and it shows.

They bake with love and it shows! You can literally taste the love in the pastries. Cakes are…read moredelicious!!

Great cake both taste and look. We were thrilled with how they made it extra tall to accommodate…read morethe additional people guests attending the party.

I feel bad to write this review because I want to support a woman owned small business but...I wish…read moreI had not ordered my birthday cake from here. I was initially lured in by the good Yelp reviews. I liked that I could do everything online, I had a particular vision for what I wanted my birthday cake to look like and they communicated with me via email that could make my vision come true. I had a birthday celebration at a restaurant, which I asked The Evercake to have delivered directly to the restaurant. The delivery was smooth and the restaurant had the cake before I even got there. The cake was very cute and did look like what I had pictured. But...what I majorly disliked was the actual taste of the cake and being misled about what the contents of the cake would be. I selected the strawberry shortcake option for my cake and what I got was not what I thought it would be. I think it's quite normal for a strawberry shortcake to have like...real strawberries in between the layers. My cake didn't really have that, and if it did it was hidden in all the strawberry jam that there instead. I was not a fan of the cake texture too and the cream outside of the cake. Overall I felt so sad that I was feeding this to my friends and I told them that they didn't have to finish it because I wasn't going to either. So embarrassing :( Would you believe that this flop of a cake was nearly $200? And that's after the 10% coupon. I'm giving 2 stars instead of 1 because it wasn't completely bad, but the cake not tasting good was the biggest thing for me. I would have preferred it the other way around at least, like if the service was so bad but the cake tasted amazing, but unfortunately that was not the case for me. After digging through the reviews some more, I found that this happened to another customer as well. I wish I had seen their review before ordering a "strawberry" shortcake from here lol dang

The cakes here are delicious. They are known for the Boston Cream pie but everything is great…read more The workers are courteous & professional. In a part of Morris Park that's changed, Conti's is a great asset. My constructive criticism on Conti's. I ordered 2 cakes online. Paid in full for both last week. They gave me a pickup window 9AM. I show up early & there's a big line. I ask a worker & she says there's 1 line. She states there's 1 line for picking up a cake paid in full, ordering a new cake, getting coffee, getting pastries. Guys NO GOOD! Why pay in full & order a week prior? You should have 2/3 lines. 1 line picking up cakes paid in full only. 1 bread line only. 1 line for new orders. I mean this criticism as constructive

a pound of cookies went from $15 to $22 in a year. I understand the economy is bad, but 10 cookies…read morefor $22?? that's highway robbery. I remember when Conties would price the specialty cheesecakes to $30-$35 max. a 12inch pistatchio cheesecake is $46???? i know for a fact the employees dont get paid enough for the price of a cheesecake to increase that dramatically. one of the girls said the pies/cakes are made a week before they're sold, so the price on soon to expire pastries is insane. for $46 dollars I can get a larger and better quality cheesecake in Manhattan. The ladies behind the counter look unhappy and find every request to be inconvenient. this place is definitely ripping you off. UPDATE: I opened the box of cookies for my friend, she reached for the first cookie and as soon as she took a bite, she pulled out a blond hair from the cookie. $22 dollars for cookies full of hair. I'm never going back.

First of all I am a bonus mommy and the bio mom dropped the ball with getting a bday cake. Party…read morewas Saturday and I started searching for bakers on instagram for my step daughter's 10th birthday. Any came up and her work looked extremely clean. I filled out an inquiry form and she responded within the hour. I ordered a cake and paid in full right then & there after reviewing with my husband. The flavor selection & customer service was beyond what I was expecting especially with my order being last minute. When I picked up the cake it was way more than i expected and tasted so freaking good. Funfetti with white chocolate ganache frosting. My baby girl loved it.

I am not a big fan of sweets. My friend orders from Amy all of the time. Literally, for every event…read moreso it's like I had no choice but to take a piece one day. When I tell you that the cake is AMAZING, believe me. I do not regret taking 2 pieces of the cake that day. LOL!!! Do Not Hesitate, Order Today.

What a good feeling to be back in NY the home of amazing Italian bakeries …read more I live out of state and it's one of the guilty pleasures I miss besides my loved ones of course . I was like a kid in a candy store. The service was pleasurable and nice. I ordered 2 fresh challah breads which are only made on fridays which was fine for me. There's nothing like fresh everything. The smells are amazing and I recommend them %100. It was a nice addition to my daughters birthday brunch spread.

Wow wow wow! I love this bakery. I stopped by today after visiting Sunday off cafe and chase near…read moreby and so glad i did. I love a good Italian bakery but this one is def up there. Cannolis to die for, cannoli cream puffs are delicious and my husband got bread that's good too. I love how close they are to the train station ! Staff were also nice and friendly and the desserts were affordable. Will def be back soon!

Still the same Excellent Artisan Italian Pastries in America…read more I have been enjoying the Pastries for 30 years. The Pastry Line is still consistently Spectacular in Flavor, Freshness and Presentation. I recommend all of the Pastries for all those interested in a Uniquely Enjoyable Delight of Fine Italian Pastries.

The one star is for the service. The young man who helped me was great! (However I did ask for a…read moremarble loaf and it wasn't in my bag. I don't know if he charged me because he didn't give me an itemized receipt.) I usually go to Brooklyn but I was in the Bronx this go around. Ordered a lot of items and everything was underwhelming. Everything. The rainbow cookies (dry and not flavorful). The chocolate cannolis (wth was that. That was not ricotta cheese and mascarpone cheese filling). The strawberry shortcake cake (fake frosting). The lava cakes. The Oreo cupcakes. Everything tasted fake and blah. Sigh. I spent about $100. I'm thankful he DIDN'T put the marble loaf in my bag. Even if he did end up charging me. Keep it.

I love Valencia Bakery, Been going here since I was a kid, I'm an adult now I got all my kids cakes…read morefrom here they even have my son cake birthday cake pictures on display in the store on 3rd Ave. My whole family get cakes from here. They have all kinds of filling our favorites are custard, pineapple, and strawberry.

I'll start with my whole family & I have been a Valencia fan & customer for more than 40 years …read more I can say hands down all their cakes are fantastic. I went to the 9 w W burnside ave Bronx NY I ordered 2 dozens cupcakes I wanted that traditional Valencia taste. To my disappointment they were tuff so dry nobody even attempted to finish one. I call the store mine you I wasn't asking for a refund never mentioned that . I believe she was the owner didn't take it well . She said & I quote well maybe everyone didn't know how to eat them . We should've cut them & inverted them smh i said kids here we're not going to do that . Then she raved on how many orders a day come in& out and how one customer byes everyday that cupcake . Again I was polite reassuring her I loved Valencia & I said I wasn't trying & to insult her but she didn't for once apologize or take responsibility for her product or business. I'm so disappointed . She was so defensive & dismissive . Won't go there anymore .