We love to stop for pizza on our way home from boating! Always delicious and friendly serviceread more

Smothered burrito-delish Green chile-spot on…read moreService-excellent Ambiance-fun and memorable

Best pizza in the area!! Other menu items are also…read moredelicious. This is an absolute family favorite and you won't be disappointed.

Ordered food to go. Everything was packed up separately and perfectly! Pick up was ready at the…read moretime they gave us. The Italian beef sandwich (01) with au jus was delicious! Added the fries, but not my favorite. Looks like they use soy oil. We did not care for the baked ziti. Meat sauce had lots of spicy ground sausage. Too spicy for me. Don't care for their red sauce either. And pasta noodles were over cooked. Would definitely get the beef sandwich again. Nice size portion.

Great place to eat glad for trying this place and having a new york style pizza! Thank you!read more

I called after ordering a pizza that the crust was so soggy you couldn't physically pick up the…read morepizza and was told by the front end "the guys in the back remember making your pizzas and they said the crust was borderline burnt, not raw. I'm sorry you didn't enjoy it but that's just how we make our pizzas. This AFTER I told them I didn't want it comped. Didn't want it remade. I just wanted them to know because I still think they're the better pizza place in town. Flavor- 10/10. Crust...usually 5/10. Today 1/10. Customer service, being told "ACTUALLY they said it was 'almost burnt' not raw". Ok then why send it if you thought it was "almost burned?" And why not just accept the feedback with a thank you for taking the time to provide your feedback on our product" instead of being rude and saying "sorry that's just the way our pizza is". Customer service 0/10. Many notes. Do better. And by the way: a pizza that wasn't loaded down with dozens of toppings SHOULD be not so flimsy that it literally falls apart when you pick it up. C'mon now.

I love Tony's pizza!!! I travel to Waupun a couple times a year for work, and Tony's is always a…read morerequired stop. The customer service is top notch, as is the food. When I stopped in a couple days ago, I asked if they could make a meatball calzone, and they did. Nice and crisp on the outside, filled with delicious house made meatballs, needless to say I was VERY happy. Thanks, Tony's Pizza!! I'm already looking forward to stopping in whenever my next work trip bring me to Waupun.

We ordered to go, so not sure about the dining atmosphere. This pizza was done on time and was…read morevery well cooked, the crust was crisp but the cheese was not too brown or burnt. Man, does this place know and understand cheese! This pizza had the best quantity and good quality blend of oozy, gooey goodness! Well cooked, well provided and best of all well enjoyed!

Excellent pizza. Very nice and professional staff. Fairly priced. I have gotten take from her…read moreseveral times.

Went for pizza. Sat in the back room with large screen TV. Watched the UW volleyball game against…read moreNebraska. Ordered the Susie's Supreme pizza on their famous thin crust. Toppings were plentiful and crust was fantastic. Definitely one of the better pizza joints in the region. Service was attentive and food came to the table with little delay. Would definitely return to try other pizza, sandwich and entree choices. Ambience was warm and friendly. High recommend without any reservations. Pizza crust is a gem.

I'll admit I was skeptical walking in. The restaurant is attached to a hotel that isn't the nicest,…read moreand the entrance had a strong hotel‑cleaning‑supply smell that made me apprehensive. But from the moment we sat down, it was all uphill from there. The Italian wedding soup was excellent, rich, flavorful, and clearly homemade. The pizza was decent, nothing extraordinary but solid with plenty of cheese. We also ordered the lasagna, the spicy chicken dish, and spaghetti and meatballs. The standout was the spicy chicken: the "spicy red sauce" turned out to be more of a creamy, spicy blend, and it was fantastic. Everything came out piping hot, which I really appreciated. They also bring out warm rolls, and those were surprisingly tasty, soft, fresh, and perfect for dipping. Overall, I highly recommend this place. Despite the rough first impression, it turned out to be one of the best restaurants in the area.

Oh my goodness--I truly felt like I was back in Italy while dining at Mike's! My husband and I…read morefirst met Mike when he was part owner of Mama Mia's on the square in Baraboo, and now he's opened his own restaurant as the sole owner. Mike immigrated here legally from Albania and became a U.S. citizen, and you can taste the pride he puts into every dish--everything is homemade, even the pasta. I had the spicy chicken arrabbiata with Alfredo sauce, and it was absolutely delicious. The homemade garlic knots were mouthwatering, and the salads were fresh and crisp. My friend ordered the shrimp pasta and loved it. I also brought home two pizzas for my family, and they said it was the best pizza they've ever had! The service was excellent, and the restaurant itself is spacious with a great bar area. From now on, Mike's Italian Restaurant will be our go-to spot whenever we're in Baraboo. If you're in the area, give Mike a try--you won't be disappointed!

Delicious food! Great wait staff! Great place to eat after a day on Green Lake! Great place for…read morefamilies with kids to eat!

Fresh, fresh, fresh! We're NEVER disappointed!! Always our go when we're in town. Everything we've…read moretried has been excellent

Wow! What a great pizza! Our 1st time here. The pizza has a fantastic thin crisp crust. We…read moreordered a chicken, breakfast bacon pizza with 1/2 red sauce and 1/2 white garlic sauce. Both were equally delicious. We will be regulars from now on. 5 stars!

Get the garlic knots!! So delicious. Their food is wonderful. We have tried many different…read morepizzas and never been disappointed. The dill pickle pizza is good. The traditional cheese is great, I mean you can't go wrong with any of them. I love the calzones too, they are very large and just cooked to perfection. We have tried their garlic bread and mozzarella stick and everything is great. They can get busy so just know that for your order. They have tables to eat inside too which is nice. You order and find a seat and they will bring out your order to you. The ingredients are fresh and the dough is made there. Love this place! They also support our local schools, which is an added bonus. The owners and other employees are just wonderful. One of our top pizza places for sure.

We recently moved to town and were excited to try this restaurant. During our visit, we were…read moreimmediately told "a stroller is an inconvenience" to which we kindly offered to park it outside given it was a small space. Our 1-year-old was excited about a baseball game on TV and was talking loudly at times, but remained seated throughout the meal, and we were actively redirecting him. Unfortunately, we felt very unwelcome during our visit. There were comments made about our child to other patrons by staff that made us uncomfortable. When we politely pointed out an error on our bill, the response was sarcastic rather than appreciative. There was no indication that children were not welcome in the restaurant on the website nor via signage, but we left feeling judged rather than welcomed. Because of that experience, we do not plan to return.

If I am ever passing through usually my go to for pizza. My favorite thin crust pizza!read more

We visit Fox Lake twice a year and always stop at the Boat House. It was very nice to meet one of…read morethe new owners. She came over and spoke with us a while. Nice to have owners that engage with the customers. We will definitely be back again for more laughs and awesome food.

I had a chance to meet the new owners while in a girls trip to Fox Lake and they were wonderful…read more They made sure to come and introduce themselves to us and made our visit that much more personable. Can't wait for the next visit in October.