I had the broiled seafood platter and the food was absolutely cooked to perfection. Our server was attentive, polite, and professional. I said in the bar area in the ambience was clearly in the Italian motif. I had Keylime cheesecake for dessert. The price for the dessert was a little of the height, but it was delicious. read more

We have been to the Brook House many times and it gets better as we explore the menu. Tonight I tried the Chicken Diquatro for the first time. I usually have the Saltimbocca, but the waitress said this was good and it was. I enjoy anything over escarole! My wife had the Veal ala Fedele that includes eggplant and is her favorite. We recommend both these dishes. The portions are generous and packed well to avoid leakage if you have leftovers. We had reservation on a busy, early Saturday evening. The hostess found us, as promised, at the bar after only a short wait. If you are rushed for dinner or just plain impatient then go to a fast food joint. Expect a leisurely meal here and you won't be disappointed. To those who pretend to be Italian gourmets and complain about the sauce, we have never had anything but tasty, well-prepared food. It makes me suspicious that there are people (or bots) with one review to their name who bash an establishment. Enough said. read more

One of my favorite restaurants in Rochester. I remembered that we needed reservations so quickly made them for 4. To my pleasant surprise we were seated in the room off the main dining room. In the room was Fedele's family memorabilia. It decorated the walls. It was so nostalgic and brought back so many beautiful memories. I went to the Brooke house with my family as a child. Our waitress was attentive, efficient, friendly, and patient with us. The food as always was delicious. We ordered one of the specials of the day which was stuffed rigatoni with a meat sauce. The broiled seafood dinner, gnocchi's and calamari as an entree. read more

See all

Fantastic. The service was great. Red came out to our table to check in and deliver a basket of bread. 87 years old and still out on a Friday night. What a legend. Our waitress Lauren was great as well. The food was fantastic. I got the rigatoni and meat sauce. One of the other folks at the table got the gnocchi and they were great. Wife got the greens and beans and they were great. Old school ambiance inside. Just what you want in an old school Italian place read more

I have been a patron for many years. I ordered the broccoli and macaroni. It was terrible. It had absolutely no taste! I could not believe, for an Italian restaurant, the lack of taste in this dish. It needs major improvements!! read more

Saturday night the 8th we went to Red Fedele's for dinner without reservations. it was kind of early so we sat at the bar for about 30 minutes and the hostess came and got us. We sat at a booth by the east side windows. So off to a great start for dinner. Our waitress came over and took our drink order and appetizer order. To which I didn't eat because it was Clams Casino- not a fan and I'm a vegetarian. He enjoyed it though. And he got the fish & shrimp,clams dish with a side of rigatoni to which he said it was delicious. I got the Ziti Cianciola my favorite thing when we dine at the Brook house. Red's happens to be one of my favorite restaurants in Rochester, NY so to me it was a great night out. read more

Red Fedele's Brook House - 6 Piece Clams Casino - Italian Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

RFBH is on the other side of the city from me and I've always heard great things. I always wanted to visit but the food was bland, pasta overcooked and was no better than Olive Garden (as I recall from 10years ago). VERY Disappointing. read more

We are starting to really love coming to Red Fedele's Brook House. The people are friendly, the food is great and the decor cracks me up. They have statues of lots of famous people, pictures of them as well. It was Halloween season when we went and they had witches hats on the little statuettes. But about our dinner- it starts off with some yummy Italian bread and a decent salad. We both ordered the Chicken Saltimbocca this time - it's very tasty with the prosciutto and peppers on top. A side dish of ziti compliments the meat. We both enjoyed our meal- our server Danielle is prolly and ultra- friendly! The place was packed on a regular Tuesday night. Note- call ahead for reservations and get on their list. We will definitely be back. read more

Red Fedele's Brook House - Italian Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I got the chicken french. It was delicious. The service was great. I love the food here. I never get a bad meal.

Great Place, great food! The owner greets everyone--hospitality is outstanding--enjoyed being there-waitress superb!

I love this place. Our server was outstanding, Red visited us and was his adorable, charming self, my ziti with eggplant was perfect, and my pistachio cheesecake was even better than I'd expected. Best of all was the bread and butter, which was the best I've ever eaten. I'm not a bread person, in fact, but oh my word...so delish. The place was packed but everything worked like clockwork. We had a lovely evening. read more

We have been here for dinner numerous times. The food and service have always been great. We only have one complaint and that is about the coffee. It has ranged from weak and warm to strong and warm. It has never been good or hot. So Red, if you read this, do something about the coffee. It's not good. read more

Went there this evening. I had the prime rib that was outstanding! OMG it was flavorful, large and tender. We had this you man. Looked like a kid who was attentive, courteous, accommodating and SHOOK my hand when I got ready to leave. Classy and kudos to Red Fidels read more

Great food, excellent service! Short wait but the food was worth the wait. Highly recommend if you're looking for quality Italian!

Once again , food was great, service was excellent and Red was a joy to speak to! All around great experience! read more

They charge 2+ dollars for a to go fee! When I'm the one picking it up ... and paying a lot in gas They charge to use your credit card now! They charged me 1.50 to add mushrooms to a salad that used to come with mushrooms (and I have them leave off the cucumbers) I was also told one small dressing for my large chicken salad was all it came with and any more would be an up charge... But when I'm dining in they give you a large soup cup dish full. Makes no sense. I'm choosing you restaurant out of all the choices around here but you're not putting your guests first Nickel and diming read more

See all

We came at 3pm on a Sunday afternoon to celebrate a very special friend'sbirthday. Brooke & David were our phenomenal servers. Everything was served very timely, hot and tasted absolutely delicious. It was my first time and the ambiance both inside and out were beautiful. I would highly recommend dining here. The nicest touch was the owner coming several times to our table to assure we were well taken care of. read more

See all

A family run Italian restaurant that can and will ruin every other Italian cuisine in the area for you! Great people, good food and I assure you, you will have an excellent time! Be sure to look around and notice the history this place has created and contributed to as you inhale the aromas of fresh baked bread and family recipes being cooked and dished out! read more

Was there on evening of July 1st. Great meal. Salad, lasagna, fresh bread and cold beer poured to the top of the glass and great service. Don't miss this one! read more

What a wonderful place. Had a large party and they treated us like royalty. Food was great across the board. Great apps, esp the calamari. The wait staff was phenomenal every step of the way including cutting and plating a cake we brought. (Professional bakery cake, not homemade). The owner Red stopped by several times greeting us like family and checking in throughout the meal. Highly recommend read more

This restaurant was highly recommended by some folks we met while in town for a ballgame. We were told the calamari was the best available. The restaurant was busy, but not at full capacity. We tried the calamari appetizer and it was really good. The salads were also good. The bread that came to the table looked like something purchased from the grocery store. Do not believe it was prepared onsite or fresh. The main courses we ordered were a variety of seafood and pasta dishes that were recommended by the wait staff. None of the 5 members of our party were impressed with the food. Mostly overcooked and canned ingredients. Maybe this was an off night, or maybe this is normal for the area. Giving 2 stars for the appetizer only. read more

I joined my friends, who were celebrating their 47th wedding anniversary, for dinner. For a Tuesday it was very, very busy but after a short wait our table was ready. We ordered drinks and dinner which came in short time even though the kitchen must have been under a great deal of pressure by the sheer number of patrons. I had lasagna... the piece was enormous and delicious. My companions both were very satisfied with their meals. I can't say how happy I was with the service and the food. I will always recommend Brook House . Go. Enjoy. Manga!!! read more

Always good. Have been eating at fedele's for years . They have been around a long while. Red is a great person very family oriented. I always enjoy eating with them it's like eating with family. read more

Sadly, this restaurant has gone terribly downhill. The food is poor to mediocre at best. One of my friends said, 'The sauce tastes like creamy tomato soup'. As an Italian, I will never spend my money to eat here again. The service was quite poor. The waitress was very inattentive and made several mistakes with our orders. People's food came out at all different times. One person didn't get hers until everyone else was almost finished. The decor hasn't been updated in many years and resembles 1960's old cheap, fake Italian party houses. This place was good twenty five years ago; perhaps it's time to retire. read more

This my husband's family's go to for eating good Italian food. The owners know his family quite well. It is always quite busy so definitely make a reservation. Parking is ample and all the dishes are plentiful and hearty. My favorites are the gnocchi and grilled chicken platter. The big clams pasta is also great! In terms of dining in or taking out, it's best to eat in, you get better service and portions. read more

been here a few times now, once for a private party. the family atmosphere feels nice, the staff is kind and attentive. there are 4 sections of the restaurant for available seating. two of the rooms can be for private parties. the first time we sat in the family room in one of the middle tables in the front of the restaurant. got bread and butter (would usually like olive oil with seasoning, but this is fine. the menu has many options with the classic Italian selections. the second time I went in one of the back rooms separated by doors. felt cozy. we were seated with a long table for the party family style. third time I went was in the back room where the bar and tvs. this location is nice if you want to watch any sports. the food and service all three times were great. one visit when the waitress was busy other staff stepped in to help serve us. would always choose to come here for a family celebration or just a night out for Italian food. the place isn't too loud when its busy this might be because of the high ceilings, not sure. either way its a plus. read more

One thing to know about this place - it is SUPER popular with the locals. Expect to wait 30 minutes or more for a table for dinner, if you do not have reservations. This place also seems to appeal strongly to those 60+ years old. Went here twice in the last month. The first time, the food was very mediocre, and service moved kind of slow. I tried their fish fry and it was very overcooked and lacked flavor. The baked potato was equally bland, and they would not substitute the coleslaw for anything else. The second time, I went with the chicken Alfredo. This dish was very, very packed with flavor. It was almost swimming in sauce. Could have came with more chicken for the price tag. The "garlic bread" appetizer was beyond disappointing. For an Italian joint, you'd think this place would place heavy pride in their garlic bread - and not serve tiny little bread pieces with melted cheese and little taste in the way of garlic. The worst part of the second visit - it took 2.5 hours, somehow, from sitting down to get out of there. It became excruciating how LONG the entire process took. SUPER, super friendly service at RFBH is why I'm giving 2 stars instead of 1. read more

See all

Save yourself do not eat here or waste your money . Said something to the owner on the way out he could've cared less!!!! The service was terrible and the food not cook and what was sort of cooked tasted disgusting!!!! Bread and butter is the savior for the night. Was with a small group of friends and every single one had an awful meal! The problem was our server was no where to be found . Took 30 mins to even see a waitress. So I would never recommend this place I don't care how long it's been in Greece, NY absolute garbage . Doesn't even deserve one star read more

Everything was awesome, as usual! Specials are great price and always fresh and delicious. Love when they try a new dish, usually excellent. Staff, so very busy but attentive to a tables needs. I appreciate that. "Red" is so special, meets and greats all his customers. We always feel his kindness and care. Thank you Red read more

Service staff very friendly, along with Red (owner) visits to just about every table The food is like going to your friends for a great homemade meal. This is one of our go to restaurants so I have had a different dish every time and they have been good read more

Generally always crowded but food keeps people coming back. A bit noisy at times but service was very good despite large crowd. Nice place to celebrate special events in larger groups. Italian is the main theme but very wide menu options make it even better! read more

Wonderful food and atmosphere! Never had a bad meal. Every single time I've visited this resturant (since the 90s) Red makes a point to stop at every table to check in with his guests. If I could give more stars I would. read more

We go here every year for our anniversary dinner it's been 42 years consecutively. We went again last night for our 42nd anniversary dinner and had an outstanding experience. The restaurant offers ample parking and easy access for those individuals with handicaps. The restaurant's always decorated for the current holiday season. It's especially beautiful during the Christmas and New Year holiday. At this time reservations are required! The restaurant is known for their Italian food and the menu offers enough choices to satisfy anyone's appetite. My wife usually gets the veal ala Fidele which is a breaded veal pattie along with a breaded eggplant Pattie with a side of rigatonis. I either get the linguine and white clam sauce or the veal parmesan. Both are outstanding. Last night we had an appetizer of fried calamari which was fantastic. Calamari was cooked to perfection. Red Fidele the original owner always comes around to the tables and greets folks and talks about the meals and their satisfaction when he's in the restaurant. This is a very welcomed touch, when having dinner at their establishment. It really makes you feel special and a part of the family. Their wine list isn't extensive but it offers something for everyone's tastes. I only wish they had more New York State wines on the list. We both had after dinner drinks and a dessert to go as an ending to a wonderful dinner. The restaurant also offers outdoor seating when the weather permits. read more

We came here on valentine's day and it was a very short wait. they decorated the restaurant for valentines and it was so cute! the food was hot and delicious and came out at a reasonable time and our waitress was very nice. love it here! highly recommend if you're looking for authentic italian food! read more

I really appreciated the abundant holiday decorations when we had a family dinner on 12/26 there. The bread was tasty, the staff were nice, and I really enjoyed the chicken parm. It was one of the best I have had in Rochester. The salad with crumbly blue cheese and house dressing was also tasty. The look of the restaurant is not modern, but I actually liked that it has character and is unique. read more

See all

Very authentic Italian food! My absolute go to when I visit Rochester. Great venue. Pasta greens and beans to die for. Artichoke French, so delicious All the people here are very friendly. read more

I came here for my grandmas birthday and my family rented out the whole back room for the celebration. The space was set up very nicely with a table full of wines and coffee and a buffet line with a carving station. There were lots of options for food, including salad, bread, olives, fruit, pastas, chicken parm, eggplant parm and then the ribeye station. I tried everything and it was so delicious! Very very impressed with the service and quality of food. Everyone throughly enjoyed themselves and this was the perfect way to celebrate a milestone birthday. I would definitely come back for a dinner! read more

I give it only one star because of the ambush I got on my bill when we finished our meal! There was no mention of charging us to use our credit card. The charge was over $4.00. So, our server got $4.00 less in his tip...let Red chip in the rest for him!! As a business person it's best to figure all your costs into your sale...not adding on afterwards. Maybe they just don't want people paying with credit cards...easy for me, I will NOT be returning again. Myself, my family and friends have had events and many dinners there...not anymore. read more

Our server was wonderful but our meals took over an hour because other servers stole our meals for their tables. My daughter's meal took an extra 10 minutes to come out after everyone else had their food. The portions of the food were really off. Everyone at the table had a full plate of food. I left the restaurant still hungry after finishing my entree of ravioli. There was people at the table next to us that clearly had too much alcohol and were being very loud and not being respectful of others in the restaurant read more

We had a 6 PM reservation on May 11, 2024. Placed our order when we were seated at 6:15. We were told by our server that it may be half an hour to 45 minutes, which we were fine with. At 7:30 we watched 2 tables that arrived after be served and we still sat there with no food. When we were finally able to flag down our server she informed us that half of our order had been taken by a different server and given to the table seated after us, so we had to wait some more. Four of our five dishes were served at almost 8 PM. The fifth arrived 10 minutes later. Totally UNACCEPTABLE. read more