This is an unassuming pizza place beneath a grocery/convenience store. There is some interesting decor that seems a bit out of place. However, the service and food more than make up for the lack of ambiance. They are always friendly and quick. The pizza is not the best I have ever had but it sure is tasty! The slices are huge and it is extremely affordable. I don't have pics but I have tried their wings and they are delicious. If you are in the area I definitely recommend. They usually have several pies out for a variety of slices and are more like the size of 2 for 1. read more

See all

We picked up a specialty Meat Lovers large pizza for approximately $25. This was literally the biggest large pizza in the area, not close. Plenty of meat, cheese and sauce, tasted good too. However if you're looking for a thin crust, crispy crust NY style pizza this wasn't what we received. Also the pie was a bit on the greasy side. It's worth noting we didn't request a well done or crispy crust pizza. Based on volume of food and value, this place is worth a try. read more

Great pizza, whole or slice. Never had a bad meal. Slices are huge and delicious. Pastries are great.

Outstanding pizza by the slice! Ordered 3 slices - one cheese, one garlic, and one supreme (sausage, pepperoni, red onion, peppers). The slices were gigantic and only $3.50-$4.50 a slice. One cheese slice fed me and my two kids. They came out hot and crisp on the crust but not overdone, just right. Looking at this place from the outside, I'd never think it would be a go-to pizza place, but it is. WOW - loved it! Highly recommend. read more

Red Onion Grocery & Pizzeria - Supreme and garlic slices - Grocery Near Me - Central Square, New York

See all

Best pizza I have had in so long! Remember the giant slices of that NY style we use to get as kids? That delicious thin crust, slightly undersauce, delicious cheese pizza? Well yes! I found it again. It's in the downstairs of this quaint little gas station and grocery store. The pizzeria is ready to serve you up those huge slices we all came to know and love growing up with the pizza places of another time. When I tell you this pizza is amazing and no one is touching it in the three neighboring counties, I am not being sarcastic. Name a place, from Potsdam to Buffalo, to Corning and Oneonta, I've been everywhere searching for that pizza of yesteryear and I had no idea it was always right in my backyard. Here at this tiny little spot, I was blasted to the past of early childhood memories, visits to the pizza parlors in Liverpool at Seneca mall, and late night young adult college outings on Main St. in Oneonta, NY... Not since my visit to New York City and Corning, NY recently have I found pizza like this, and this by far is the best. Don't hesitate, stop in and take a trip to NY style, thin crust heaven! read more

We just got a cheese pizza here. It was $21, so definitely more expressive than most places, but the pizza was quite large. That said, unfortunately it was a tad too thick and doughy for my taste, and it had about 50% more cheese than needed. Didn't quite seem like 100% real cheese either, I could be wrong though.. It's it a blend of mozzarella and something else?? If so, they should advertise that. The sauce was OK, and I think with less cheese it could be good. Can't tell though because the ratio was way off. 3 stars because my belly is full now. read more

Red Onion Grocery & Pizzeria - Too much cheese pizza - Grocery Near Me - Central Square, New York

I am so sorry to say... Do not order food from red onion Three times my friends have ordered fish from here. Terrible... First order over done, unedible, second order under done fish! We tried again... Under done fish was eaten by friend.... To say he was food poisoned is an understatement! Other people, same under done pizza etc! Beware! Only gave one star because I had to! Also steak sandwiches underdone, or hardly any meat all peppers! read more

Great place had a great pizza. And bought fishing bait love the box they come in. Also bought a strawberry rhubarb pie. Very good pie. Thanks read more

Pretty solid little place. Pizza is good, & calzones are tasty. Solid andwiches can be found in either the grocery/head station portion, or fresh made from the pizzeria downstairs. Wings are very good, though their hot sauce is more harsh than spicy. I'd stick with BBQ. They often have big slices until late, too. read more

DON'T ever go to ice cream stand. $12 for two sundaes, and had to toss out both. One had only vanilla ice cream and banana. No hot fudge, no syrup, no nothing!! A big blob of soft vanilla in a $6.50 cup!!! The other sundae was NO better. Big pile of vanilla with whipped cream. If there was peanut butter included, it couldn't be seen. Horrible, horrible experience. Never again will our family go there. Keep local they say, and you get slop that you can't even eat. The owners should be ashamed of having staff this incompetent. read more

Great pizza, amazing chicken wings, great service. The only thing is that you have to call on the phone, right there on the spot to place an order and wait? read more

I ordered an order of wings with bbq sauce. The wings came an hour later with no sauce on them. Had to wait another hour to get the wings with sauce. Have not ordered from here since. read more

Pizza is always nice and hot and were addicted to the garlic knots! So far they are our favorite pizza place around us.

We had breakfast with recommendation of marina. Nicely priced standard breakfast with REAL hash browns. Good pancakes , biscuits, omlettes. See pictures. read more

See all

I have known this family for a long time. They are always eager to help with excellent food and groceries. Their pizza is the best in the area. If they don't have what you need they will get it. Honesty, integrity and community good will are their specialty. Robert G read more

This became our go to pizza place in brewerton. Huge pie, fresh, great dough and toppings. It used to be. Stopped going about a year ago. Something changed, no more store ownership? Noticed guys wearing other pizza place shirts? Horrible pizza, horrible service. Wings tasted like fish, pizza either overdone or under. Over sauced or none. Employees eating while working (gross), dirty, flies, stunk. Girls out back smoking then coming in, no hand wash, handling food. Tried 3 times, horrible last 3 times. I'm done. Talking to others in area, said exact same thing. Beautiful place gone to crap! read more

Had breakfast three times, lunch twice in last ten days. All excellently prepared and promptly served. Currently a super little place. No hesitation in recommending it. read more

When eating under a gas station I expect better service than what was received. It took 45 minutes to receive the order that was placed for 3 people. For starters, over easy eggs were cooked completely, home fries we're undercooked and the corned beef has was mediocre at best. Next time I want breakfast from a gas station, I'll get breakfast pizza that has been sitting for 90 mins and have a better experience. read more

I give it a 1 star for the number of slices they had made up for the store . I guess i'm the only one who wants a few slices at 6:30 pm on a Tuesday . I could understand if they "just ran out" but normally they have 4-6+ pies made up . This is the 3rd time i've been completely let down (and the last)by this place . They have good food but the service is just horrible. read more

Pizza was ok, but really gummy. Sauce is way too pasty. Wings smelled rank with little sauce and salty. Mayb next time?

The place is not bad but in one of the shakers had a little fly in it. Food took to long to get out as well.

This place is a great place straight and to the point the only thing I had wrong with was how long it took to be ready but it happens especially if there's a logical reason . read more