Great pizza-poor service. I ordered lunch for 20 a week ahead of time, show up, and they forgot the order. Since nothing was ready they decided to try to sell us reheated slice pizza's instead of the pizza we ordered a week ahead of time. Focus on operational quality. Pizza is already top notch for CNY. read more

I wanted to grab some pizza before leaving New York, so I chose Syracuse. It's a popular local spot that everyone recommends. I ordered two slices and some wings. They packed everything nicely so I could take it on the plane. When I got home, the food was just as good--one slice with pepperoni, the other with cheese. The wings were flavorful and still tasted great after reheating in the oven. The place has a simple setup inside, but it's definitely a pizza spot I'll be returning to. Delicious and satisfying! read more

See all

This used to be 1 of the 2 pizza places in the Syracuse area I would turn to for somewhat in the ballpark NYC style pizza. What has changed is that there are a few pizzerias in the area that have as good or better pies. Now, Paladino's is no doubt still good, but there's one peculiarity about their pizza; when you order a slice in house it is always crispy and always from an 18" pie. When you order a whole pie to go, the largest is 16" and it always has a soft, albeit thin, crust. Their sauce is good, the cheese a little heavy with no stretch or snap and overly oily. The crust has good flavor. Hey, Paladino's, why don't yous make an 18" pie to go? 16" pies are 22% smaller and the slices do not fold quite right. read more

See all

So good. Love it all!! We order for work all the time!! Many different types of chicken wings that are so good. Come check them out. read more

See all

I came here for the first time earlier in the week and placed an order for pizzas for my daughter's birthday party later that week. The gentleman who took the order was very patient and professional and assured me they would be ready by 12:15 since they open at 12 on Saturday. My son and I arrived just a little before 12:15 a to pick them up and they were ready to go right when they said they would be! We got back to the car and my son opened up the box containing a vegetable pizza and I swear the thing looked almost too good to eat. Most veggie pizzas look like someone took stuff off a salad bar and threw it on a pizza. Not this one! The bright colors from the peppers looked like they were arranged just right to give it an almost artistic feel. Needless to say they were a hit at her party and while my family and I don't order food out often, the good folks at Paladino's got themselves some new customers in my family and me. My only regret is that I didn't visit them sooner. Highly recommend! read more

Nice thin, crispy crust with a little flop. Good amount of cheese. There was a nice selection of different pies, but I just needed my favorite... cheese. There are quite a few tables so it was nice to sit and eat in it was a little after lunch but still a bit busy. Solid choice. read more

Paladino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Favorite pizza stop. Have the perfect mix of oil and vinegar on their salads. Have been going there for over 50 years.

If you are looking for a great pizza Paladino's Pizza is the place to order it from. The sauce is delicious and staff makes you feel like a valued customer. We have ordered our pizzas from there since visiting Syracuse and every time the pizzas have been exceptional! You received a great pizza for a reasonable price! read more

After an eight hour drive we were all starving! Searched for a good pizza place in the area of our hotel and find Paladino's. They don't deliver but offer dine in and take out. Hubby is a huge fan of buffalo chicken pizza so we ordered a medium (14") buffalo wing pizza (took 20 minutes because they made it fresh). They sell by the slice pizza as well and you select those from the case fresh. I decided to try this broccoli pizza and it was DELICIOUS--everyone took a bite and really enjoyed it. I also got the mushroom and cheese pizza. It was good but lol I wish I got two slices of that broccoli pizza. I had a kiddo get a pepperoni slice and a cheese slice. Our favorite thing about all the pizzas is that they have a thin crest, plump crest edge, C R I S P Y bottom and the sauces and toppings and cheese were perfect. We also ordered 5 garlic knots. We could have ordered 10...20 of those. Really puffy, garlicky and buttery good! They stick them into the oven for a bit for you when you order them. Everyone working there this evening was so kind and helpful. I think they could tell we were tired and frustrated but they were patient with us and helped us through the ordering process. I believe the owner was there as well and one of the regulars were asking why they discontinued a specialty pizza and he said that every night there is a Friday night. They are just SO busy. Great little pizza spot! read more

See all

y'all missing out on not being open Sunday n Monday being the best pizza place around not being open two random days of the week makes me never order from u guys. a use to be customer is now a I haven't been to pals in 3 years . dumb idea no way ur racking in the doe so bad u hve to close 2 days ..but I still give ya 5 cause like I said ur the best just never availabl.. Sundays n mondays is literally when ppl eat pizza read more

I've never had a bad experience! Fair prices, good, simple pizza. The staff is friendly, orders come out on time. I don't have a bad thing to say about Paladinos. read more

Food is always hot and good. The wait time is not long. The people are friendly. The portions and pizza size is good. The best part is their wings! OMGosh, their spicy wings are delicious! I definitely recommend them! read more

This is always one of my first stops when visiting home. Been here forever but I'm consistently surprised to come back & find less & less stores in this strip mall yet the pizza shop remains. You cannot find pizza like this everywhere & you locals, God bless you, don't know how good you've got it when it comes to pizza. read more

See all

This is probably the best place for a thin crust pie in CNY. Despite the dreary strip mall that is half empty... It's perfectly safe and worth a trip. read more

Pizza was floppy, greasy, and was impossible to pick up without dousing my hand in orange oil. Absolutely perfect. If you need it to stay together, eat it cold. But hot and floppy is where it's at. There is other pizza in Syracuse, but we have Paladino's in Mattydale. Accept no substitutes. read more

Paladino's Pizza - Sweet cuppin pepperoni! - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Great pizza and wings. Dave got it wrong and I would say more of a 8.5 than a 7.5. Great service and perfect New York pizza place ambience. Very busy, it was lunch time, but well worth the wait for the food. Great music while you eat. Highly recommend!! read more

Love the food! Service was excellent! We came in on a Friday evening and forgot how busy they would be but the manager made sure our orders came out quickly. I ordered eggplant Parmesan and it was AMAZING read more

Closed for vacation, no notification online or on their phone. If you're gonna be a business act like One. I had a $200 lunch order for a Dr office nearby, you're loss. read more

Still.......Top 5 pizza in Cuse area for NYC style. Dave Portnoy agrees! Antipasto salad nice and fresh too. I prefer the Northern Lights location better, which this was. read more

See all

My favorite pizza and wings spot! I was so hungry I forgot to get pics. Lol. We ordered a large cheese pizza and 24 wings. Pizza was perfect and delicious. Wings were crispy and amazing. We got mild and garlic parm and both were so good. Service is always great. Everyone in there is really friendly. read more

Friendly service, pizza was almost perfect. Although the crust had a nice crunch, it was a bit too chewy for me. We ordered a dozen garlic Parmesan wings and those were too oily for my liking and they didn't have all that much of a unique taste. We also ordered an antipasto which was drowned in dressing, but the lettuce was fresh tasting and had a good crisp crunch. Overall, I would go back again, just would adjust what I would order. read more

See all

Best real New York style pizza in Syracuse. It says I need 85 words...................................................................

The best cheese slice in CNY! Location is clean and service is quick and friendly. If you're in the area and want pizza, there is no better around. Closest thing you'll get to a nyc slice of pizza. Thin and crispy! read more

Excellent NY style pies and chicken wings. It's a very casual place. We really loved the no nonsense service and excellent food!

First time ever having pizza in NY and oh man was this great. They have a friendly staff and a great selection of music. This is how all local pizza places should feel like. read more

Delicious food, great people and service. They are located in Northern Lights, so there is plenty of parking. Eat in or take-out only, no delivery. Calzones, pasta are on the menu, but I love their pizza the best. It's nice to be considered a "regular". read more

This place is standard issue when you're on the north side looking for a non-complicated pizza. Quick service, regular price, reliably good pizza, never had any problems. They make the pizza exactly to my preference as far as thickness and texture. I'd love to see more specialty pizzas on the menu. But sometimes you just want to keep it simple, and we often drive miles to make it Paladino's when the evening calls for a just a cheese/pepperoni. read more

Paladino's Pizza - Paladino's Large Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Fantastic pizza and the garlic knots are insane. We will return every time we are local and wanting something delicious!

Really good pizza. Thin crust and we ask for it well done to make sure we get it crunchy . A little salty but we are from Long Island and like it that way. Nice people working there too. Don't let the awful shopping center deter you. The pizza is worth the trip! read more

One of the best pizza places in Syracuse. I was recently introduced by a co-worker and am glad they did. Lunch slices are generous and the prices are reasonable. The slices were thin and crispy - the way good pizza should be. If you like thicker crust Sicilian-style pizza, they have those on hand as well - and they are great. Check this place out - great for lunches. read more

We tried Paladinos for the first time and it was delicious. Located right next to the Christmas Tree Shop-it's in a convenient location with plenty of parking. We highly recommend the pizza and wings! read more

2nd time we've been here. We make it a must stop when we come to Syracuse. Wings are crispy and pizza is legit. Not the best pizza I've ever had...but the best place to get pizza AND wings any day of the week. read more

Paladino's Pizza - Plain wings... Extra crispy - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

No idea how the pizza Can taste this good! It's really tasty honesty! Only thing is, as cute as the building id outside it's really bad looking on the inside. Not cozy and def not a place you want to sit in to eat read more

We had pizza and Lasagna. The pizza was very good and ready just at the right time. The lasagna was just ok. Would definitely go back for pizza. Try the extra cheese it definitely makes it taste better. read more

We were having a mid-point family reunion in Syracuse, NY where each family drove 380 miles! Paladino's was highly rated on Yelp and it did not disappoint anyone in the group, well done!! Housed in a shopping plaza that has seem it's better days, Paladino's is a gem and we plan to return when the family meeting in Syracuse again in six months. They offer a large selection of High quality ingredients and our three large pies were served hot and the staff was very friendly and professional. Thanks, your food passed the quality test among our Italian Long Islanders:-) read more

Excellent pizza probably in the top three or even two in Syracuse the dough is not too hard but it's nice and chewy very tasty sauce and the cheese is very good and always cooked to perfection one of my favorites for sure you can't go wrong read more

Paladino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Best white broccoli pizza I've ever had! A nice, 'heavy' slice with delicious garlic flavor! Only 3-4 slice pies to choose from. Soda is always kinda flat. Personally, I feel like, if we are helping place out by pouring our own soda, we should get free refill (especially since soda is flat). Nice, comfy vibe inside. read more

The olace was nothing much to look at. Standard seating with booths for 2 or booths for 4. There wasnt a TV or anything, so you just look at the people sitting around you or the staff making the pizza. I haplened to look at the wall and the max seating capacity was 30 for this place. So, small joint in the middle of an abandoned shopping strip. (This was one of the obly places open besides a GameStop and sine other shops. Must be a good sign that this place lasted lobger then a Stapkes or a T.J. Maxx. I went into the store around 4:00 PM on a Wednesday. It was pretty busy. To me, that means That's a good thing. A differnet mixture of people were coming and going, getting either 1 or 2 slices of pizza. One lady order 1 slice of cheese. (How can you only eat 1 slice of pizza? Blasphemy!!!) The people working in the "cucina" actually looked Italian. That made me more excited to taste this NY style pizza. It took about 10-15 minutes for them to cook the 14" pizza. Not that bad. Totally expected. Now, on to the pizza in this story. I took a bite and OMG, it was so tasty. Yhe chicken was cooked well, the cheese was nice and mealted, the bacon was crispy and delicious, and the spices were, should I say in Italian, "perfezionare"!! I put a litte extra parmasean cheese on there. The parmasean was stinky, so you know its good. Definitely check this place put if you are in town. Good pizza in my book. Wish I would have gotten sone wings........ read more

Paladino's Pizza - Got the 14" Chicken Bacon Pizza. Looks pretty good so far - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Meh. Haven't had pizza here in a while, and wasn't unimpressed. Nor was anyone in the family. Here's why... The pizza was too thick and the dough was "mealy" as if it had been frozen. I still love the cheese and sauce, but when i get full after 3 slices and a few wings, you know the pizza is too thick. Service was friendly, was done on time etc.. Wings were pretty good, nice sized, decently crisp. FYI: I drove from Cicero because the Cicero Paladino's location has been going downhill imo.. Used to be my favorite and hoped Mattydale would do the trick. I guess now we'll be searching for a new fave. :-( read more

Paladino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

My favorite pizza place by far. And it is also a lot of other peoples favorite place too so make sure to call well ahead on a Friday or Saturday because an hour and a half wait is typical. Takes some planning ahead but is 100% worth it read more