New to area, first time visit. Been in PA for the last…read moredecade where they never really grasped NY style. These folks get it. Ordered large pie w/1/2 mushhrooms. One order of wings, Buffalo. Was quoted 30 minutes and they nailed it. Pie was excellent, wings were excellent. Great service, great food. Exactly what we were expecting and hoping for. Nice job folks. Great first impression We'll be back.

Great NY style pizza. Always provide the best service fresh crispy pizza. Staff is always helpful.read more

I love the smiles and friendliness! of course I love the pizza! I have the pickle pizza and it's my…read morego to every time! thank you !!!!!

As always, excellent service and the most delicious pizza! Toss & Fire will be my go-to pizza -…read moreeverything I've had here has blown me away. I had guests in town and ordered a full pie - 1/2 Ricotta Be Kidding Me and 1/2 Cuse Salt Potato. The crust was thin with the perfect amount of char and chew. Ricotta Be Kidding Me may have become my new #1 specialty pizza. Great balance of flavors and everything tasted super fresh! My guests have already requested Toss & Fire when they visit again, and I'm happy to oblige!

Great pizza and fair price could not be happier regarding service…read more And even the cheese on the pizza's would make your mouth water. Grab your friends and head out to grab a bite of deliciousness.

Pizza was super average but whoever cuts pizza the way these guys do should be in prison. Service…read moreand staff were nice though.

2 minutes ago NEW…read more Order garlic pizza with ricotta cheese - you won't be disappointed! The best pizza place in the area in my opinion. Also, I ordered an antipasto salad recently with summer time weight creeping up and oh my, I was not disappointed! Finally a salad I'm not sad to eat! So delish!

First time visitors. As we often drive through rt31, we…read morehappened to spot this very small, tucked in the middle of a nearly empty plaza, pizza joint. Mostly take out. Not sure about delivery services. Couple days later we placed a pickup order for a large Neapolitan, with mushrooms and pepperoni and a large garden salad, with their own homemade Italian dressing. As we are always searching for great pizza since we moved back to New York, I can honestly say we are thrilled we found this place. The young lady who took my order over the phone was pleasant and very accommodating, and didn't rush me off the phone. Their menu far exceeds being just a pizza joint, but for now we just tried the pie and the salad. In short, the pizza was outstanding as was the large garden salad. Let's talk about that salad. For $7.50, we got a very large "garden" salad that was far from the norm. This thing was packed with fresh greens, assorted veggies, cauliflower etc. This was so close to being called a large chefs salad, just missing the protein. First glance, this place was very clean and well organized. But the star was the pie. Absolutely spot on and we are in the process of trying them all. From their on-line menu: Neapolitan thin crust large 16"Pizza $15.50 Garden Salad Field greens, tomato, roast peppers, olives, onions, giardiniera. $7.50 Both items were worth every penny. Highly recommended and we will be back to start sampling the other items on their extensive menu. Give this gem a try, you won't be disappointed.

Outstanding pizza. Must try for those who have not had Kosta's pizza…read more I've been to Kosta's Pizza House a half-dozen times now and it never disappoints. The Greek-style crust is always crispy yet chewy, the sauce and toppings are spot-on, and the portions are huge for the price. Friendly service every time. If you're in the Syracuse area, this place is a must.

I ordered takeout from this cash-only spot and tried their lamb platter. The platter swapped out…read morethe usual rice for fries, which was an interesting choice but didn't really elevate the meal. It included lamb meat, a few slices of pita bread, a basic salad, and dressing on the side. Overall, the food was average, neither disappointing nor impressive.

Napoli has tasty pizza and fast service. This wasn't my first time here and I can say that their…read morepizza is consistently delicious! Most of their business is take out but there's a small seating area.

Have been hearing about Napoli for the couple weeks they've been open, they're close to work so I…read morestopped in for lunch one day. Its a small place, definitely focused more on take out with just 2 small tables inside. You might miss the place if you don't know what to look for - inside the same building as Big Bowl chinese, next to Dunkin', but there is a sign out front. My first time, I got a chicken & greens sub, with chicken cutlets and Utica greens. Very good, the greens could've used some more heat for me but the owner, who's right at the counter making all the pizza, told me you can always tells them you want more heat when it comes to the greens and they'll accommodate. I'll remember that for next time. Decided I obviously had to try the pizza and wings. Ordered just a normal 16" thin crust with pepperoni and 10 hot buffalo wings. I pre-ordered it for a certain time and it was ready when I showed up. $36 for a large 1 topping and 10 wings. Everything was delicious. The pizza is pretty much perfect, perfectly cooked, thin crust, the right amount of sauce, cheese and toppings. The wings were good too, but these are not your normal Franks and butter buffalo wings. I dunno how to describe their buffalo sauce, but it's different and very tasty. Good food, friendly employees and ownership - will definitely go back.

Got there and were told it was a 30-40 minute wait. After exactly 30 minutes our table was ready…read more The place is not too dimly lit -it's just perfect for a romantic dinner. Our waitress was okay. Now the dinner. We ordered the beet salad which is one of our favorites. It did not disappoint -note that it's seasonal though. For the entrees, we got the chicken parmigiana pasta and the shrimp bolognese pasta. I was debating between that and the shrimp fra diavolo but the latter was out so my choice was decided XD . Our meal, overall, was delicious! For those interested, they have a special three course menu until the 14th of March, 2026, and it is 25$ per person.

Ordered the Apizza pizza, meatball appetizer and broccoli pizza. Don't get the pizza with broccoli…read moreit was bitter. The apizza was very good 7/10 one bite everybody knows the rules. The meatballs were ok. They seemed a little burnt and had hard crust on it. Don't get it can't say I didn't warn you.

Very good pizza! Casual family eatery…read more Pizza by slice also! Very calm environment when tired and hungry.

The people there are very nice, the pizza is yummy. I like their crust. We also had garlic knots…read morethey too were very tasty. The lasagna looked good but I didn't have any. I would say it's definitely worth a try.

We love this restaurant!! One of the best pizza places in Cicero , they by far have one of the…read morefreshest tasting sauces which in my opinion makes a pizza . The service is always friendly and the place just feels cozy and welcoming.

Same atmosphere as 14 years ago on our last visit here but service was immensely better. We shared…read morea calzone & and order of hot wings. All very good.

I've always said I was going to stop in to check this place out. I've passed it multiple times…read moregoing into PP casino. Tonight we decided to stop in for a slice on the way home. It says on the sign New York style. That's my jam! It was nearing closing time, but there were a few slices left on the counter. The service person popped our slices in the oven. When pizza can be reheated and tastes freshly made, you've got something. This pizza was delicious!!! Thin NY style for sure. Well done crust, tasty sauce and toppings. Check out the menu. They have other Italian specialties and subs too. I'd like to see how they fare. Forget Wicked Good pizza in the casino. You want wicked good pizza, stop on your way home!! Check em out!

The food was amazing I have never eaten pizza that good and the service was amazing the lady…read moreworking there treated me amazing and the place just had a nice ambiance