This review pertains to the new 4dx theater experience where my brother and I watched Black Panther. I've been waiting to check this out for a while, but was hesitant to check it out because at 25 bucks a ticket (before fees, total cost for 2 tickets was $56) I can go to either Cinerama or IMAX at the Science center for $5-10 cheaper.
We wanted to experience the opening night atmosphere and couldn't find 2 seats available in the upper 4 rows when we went online to pick out seats. We bought 2 seats in the second row, which normally I wouldn't go for, but as there's only 6 rows in the entire auditorium we didn't think it would be detrimental to the viewing experience . We were super excited both for Black Panther and to try 4D so we showed up about 25 minutes before showtime. We got to our seats and while both agreed the two lower rows weren't ideal, they weren't worth cancelling our seats, but that if we liked 4d and came back some day we would only buy tickets in the upper 4 rows.
Our first impression was that the chairs looked really cool. Really big chairs with lots of contraptions with two separate platforms for your feet. They don't recline, are very upright, and are not very ergonomic or comfortable. After the trailers played we got our first taste of the 4d experience when the Regal Coaster that plays before all Regal movies came up on screen enhanced with all 4d effects and the whole theater was giggling with joy by the end of it. The way the chairs simulate gliding is really effective and the Regal Coaster along with a car chase scene in black panther where the highlights of the night.
The 4d effects overall were a mixed bag. The gliding of the chairs was fun and mostly synced pretty well with the movie. The chair vibrators were fun, and could even simulate gentle punches in your upper back that made me laugh when used at the beginning of a fight sequence. There was a sequence involving a waterfall that used water mist in a really fun way, and you have the option to turn it off if you don't care for it. It shoots puffs of air from behind and in front that were used primarily to make it feel as if though bullets were flying past you. These weren't really synced well enough to the movie to really enhance the experience. There's a flower/herb that was grown as part of the plot of Black Panther, and that was the only time I detected any smell they added to the movie, and I would say mostly pleasant. There were however, a couple effects that in my opinion actually detracted from my enjoyment of the movie.
The chairs rumbled and shook during explosions and hand to hand combat scenes, which in and of itself didn't bother me. However, the frequency with which this effect was used coupled with the fact that the chairs weren't very comfortable in the first place made for a pretty brutal experience for our behinds. When the chairs rumbled and where tilted forward, it made it difficult to keep your eyes on the screen. There was a "wind" effect (or at least that's what I think it was) that primarily consisted of really loud fans coming from overhead that I didn't really feel but definitely heard. There was also a "lightning" effect. There wasn't any lightning in the movie, but it would sometimes be used when there was sparks in the movie or gunfire. It basically just consisted of a light from the side of the auditorium that was as if though someone took a picture of the screen with the flash on. Ambient light and projectors don't mix people!
So in summary, I would have to say that 4d in this iteration isn't ready for prime time. The 3d doesn't really compete with the crystal clear 3d I saw after they remodeled the Pacific Science Center IMAX. The surround sound doesn't compete with either IMAX or Dolby Atmos. The 4d effects are fun at times, but in some cases are overly-gimmicky and detract from the overall experience and without a doubt don't justify the pricepoint, especially compared to other premium formats (Cinerama, IMAX, Dolby Vision) that currently exist. read more