Second time here, came shortly after opening. Both times were okay/good. The Baklava Cheesecake was very good but not as creamy as a standard cheesecake. On the fence on the $12 price point for the size. Very good coffee. Creamers should be more readily visible/available rather than only on each dining table. Quiet dining area (nice!). Very clean. Friendly. No offer of a bakery box for multiple items (another customer). Had to be requested then checked if available; that should be standard in a bakery. It's local and everything in the case looked yummy and fresh. I'd come back and give it another whirl. read more

See all

We visited Rex Brothers Bakery last Thursday, and had a nice conversation with one of the brothers. We bought a cheesecake cupcake with chocolate chips, an 8-inch plain cheesecake, and meatloaf topped with candied bacon. The 8-inch cheesecake was good, not great. The cheesecake cupcake was dry and unremarkable. The meatloaf was inedible: the texture was mushy and it had a weird chemical-like flavor which you could smell upon reheating. We ended up throwing away the meatloaf. I wanted to give 2 stars, but my husband enjoyed the cheesecake (more than I did) and lobbied for 3. read more

Breakfast burrito is my fave here, and I get it every time, unless I get the Frenchtoast, or a cheesesteak, , or.... . Very friendly, local family business. Everything cooked to order, fresh ingredients, good service, and this is our goto place. Clean too read more

Good breakfast. Very quick service. Great prices for a small family of 3. Outstanding baked goods!

*****The address is 3558 W 26th St***** Very nice employees, friendly, food is good, space is clean and bright and and well decorated. Would be a good place for anyone, but kids would enjoy the decor as well due to dinosaur theme. If in Erie, come on in read more

Cannoli and cream puffs are not too sweet and melt in mouth . They have a large selection and dinosaur cookies if course ! What a great place to host a child's birthday parry ! read more

The breakfast and lunch are AMAZING! The stuff is so helpful and very nice. Really cute place to take your friends and family, specially your little kiddos :)) read more

Rex Brothers Bakery - a giant inflatable pole in a parking lot - Bakeries Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

My sister was visiting from Cleveland last month to celebrate her birthday here, in Erie. I had went to Rex's to ask them if they could make me a Cleveland Style Cassata Cake, (which is my sisters favorite) they hadn't heard of it. They immediately googled it and looked at some pictures and recipes and they, without hesitation said "we can make it happen!" I was supposed to pick up the cake later that week but a snow storm hit so my sister rescheduled for the following week. I called Rex's and told them and they said no problem we will have the cake ready for next week. I picked up the cake and it was absolutely massive! I swear the cake could feed 30 people! It was the best cake I had ever eaten in my life!! It tasted insanely moist and fresh. Incredible customer service and very accommodating to our wishes. Thank you, Rex Brothers! I would recommend these guys if you are looking for custom cakes! read more

Rex Brothers Bakery - Mini cannoli, brownie, chocolate chip cookies, mini strawberry cheesecake, mini blueberry cheesecake, mini raspberry cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

This is a GREAT family owned business. The baked goods are delicious and reasonably priced!

Came during posted business hours. Closed. Nobody there. Nobody answered phone. Wasted journey.

My overall assessment is it's OK. If you want a quick review you can just skip to the last paragraph. If not here is my long winded review: I would like to say that I went here three times before I wrote this review. Now I know you're asking yourself. If it's just ok why have you gone there 3 times. 1. It's a brand new local place and I hate leaving bad reviews on someone that is starting out. 2. The owners we're working the counter and they are really nice. 3. The place was really clean each time i've visited and you can tell they are really trying to create a positive experience for their customers. The first time was when they first opened and just had baked goods. It seemed like they weren't very busy so some of the cookies were a little dry. They reminded me of the leftover cookies from Christmas that have been laying around for a few days. The second time I went they had just started serving lunch. I had a smash burger style hamburger. It was pretty good. Much better than the cookies that I got this trip but the fudge was delicious. The third time I visited I had chicken tenders and I tried their home made pepperoni balls. The tenders were great but I've had much better pepperoni balls at other places. I also saw that they now serve breakfast which I haven't tried so I can't tell you if it's any good. Overall the place is clean, has a good feel but with a weird floor plan, OK baked goods and pretty good food. The problem is you can tell that they are trying to find a niche that they fit in. I think they started as a bakery and that didn't pay the bills so they started selling food which is actually pretty decent and now have expanded to breakfast. Each time I've gone there they've gotten better, so hopefully the next time I go there I'll be able to bump this up from a 3 star review. read more

First visit to Rex Brothers and sorry to say, it will be my last. Bought a variety of baked goods to serve to guests over the New Year's holiday, and they were all a big disappointment. The apple pie was under-baked (doughy crust and apples as hard as rocks); the cheesecake cupcakes were over-baked and dry; baklava was too sweet. The employees were friendly, but unfortunately, that's the only good thing I can say. read more

I had the smash burger which was juicy and big. The flavor was very good. I also had the pineapple upside down cake which wAs exquisite. I'd recommend this place to anyone. read more

I'm sorry to write a negative review, but the baked goods I purchased from Rex Bros Bakery on Monday 2/20/23 were stale and hard. The macaroon cookie would break a tooth, the cinnamon bun was hard and the cupcakes were dried out. I won't be going back. read more

Very accommodating and great food/baked goods. Homemade and delicious. Friendly service and food that doesn't disappoint.

Stumbled across this awesome place. Very friendly and accommodating staff. I had a burger and fries it's highly recommend home cooked food.