Although the staff here are very polite and I was able to get my engagement ring resized in about…read morean hour or so, I noticed a few minutes after we left that there were scratches and gouges all around the band that were very obvious. I did not notice this initially due to only being concerned with the fit. While I was immediately invited back to fix it when I called to inform them that they scratched my ring and it was then buffed out - I am still confused and disappointed that they would cause damage and not notice what happened before they gave it back the first time. The ring has lost quite a bit of its white gold look due to having to be buffed and will have to be re-dipped already - and I've only had it for a few months. I hope they learned to pay closer attention to their work and unfortunately I will not be using their services again.

I went there to get a price on some gold earrings and their scale weighed my items at 4.6 grams…read morewhereas on a competitor store's scale, my items weighed 5 grams. The owner of the competitor's store told me his scale had just been measured 2 moths earlier. So maybe it's just that The Jewelry & Coin Exchange's scale hadn't been calibrated in a while. And another competing store's scale weighed my items at 4.4 grams. So go to several places and ASK what your items weigh on their scales, get their price quote, then decide where you'll sell your items!

My wife had her platinum diamond earrings altered here and she's happy with the results. They took…read moredetailed pictures of the original pieces, including the laser inscription on the diamonds, to ensure that the original diamonds were kept. Good communication and text messaging when the item was ready for pick-up. Probably a little more expensive than other less established jewelers, but worth it for the peace of mind.

They replaced a diamond in my tennis bracelet and it turned orange after 6 months. They held onto…read moreit for 4 weeks (told me it was a 2 week wait and I had to contact them to get it back). The manager was the one to repair the diamond after I had pointed the missing spot upon pick up inspection. DO NOT GO HERE

Mark and his team are professional, kind, fair priced and artistic!…read moreFrom watch battery replacement to custom jewelry and a lot of choices in between. My husband selected a new ring for me and Mark was accommodating to make sure that I felt that it worked well with my wedding band. I have gone back there multiple times and sent other people there... In fact, took my ring to be cleaned(they showed me that the stones were loose before my ring was cleaned... So it didn't happen during the cleaning)and noticed that there was a couple stones that seemed to be shifting... So I was very happy to have them fix it, and that was also very reasonable.

A long over due review for our favorite jewelers. My now husband and I have purchase many pieces of…read morejewelry for special occasions, got jewelry repaired and had custom rings made for our wedding bands and my engagement ring. Mark and his team always go above and beyond to help us match our vision every time! Hands down the most passionate and accommodating team out there!

Very friendly staff. They are the Omega AD in the area and have a good selection…read more I've visited with a friend who bought a Speedmaster, then again on my own. Each time I told them I was just looking, not buying but they still gave me great service and attention. Last time they had some pre-owned Rolex models. All priced correctly and the staff was very knowledgeable. This would be the only place I'd go for used Rolex, Omega, Oris, etc... Definitely worth the drive from Buffalo.

ADs come in varying qualities, and there are some you have to be wary of, whether because of rude…read morestaff, poor service, or bad pricing. Cornell's does not meet any of those criteria, as they do an amazing job offering you options from mid-tier to luxury watches. Their salespeople are warm, welcoming, and knowledgeable, and their presentation alone makes it worth visiting. In addition to the brands they are ADs for, they also have some nice pre-owned pieces!

My husband wanted to support a local artist for his wedding band and we were so delighted to…read morediscover Sesto Synergy. He was so easy to work with and has many design options available with the ability to create a ring from just about any material you want, including sentimental items. The turnaround time was great, the prices were affordable, and he has a unique ring he loves that he always receives compliments on. Highly recommend checking out their website and shop!

So, I'm speaking from the bride side, but I know my groom had the best experience as well. Mark…read moreNulton is the owner and he made our wedding rings and my engagement ring! We love them. He is a custom ring maker and will tailor your likes and needs to the jewelry you envision. He does sell his own jewelry that he personally makes in his newly self renovated beautiful victorian house in penfield. To the right, as you walk in, is his shop with some earrings, necklaces, and rings. To the left is his office where you can start and finish discussing about the jewelry you would like. it's decorated very beautifully and feels homey and personable. Mark is very patient and accommodating. I can say this because I'm a very indecisive person! For longer than I needed to, I was struggling to decide on the best wedding ring for myself that fit my hand/personality. He helped this process by providing advice and his best opinions without being a pushy salesman. He was able to order certain rings so I could see them in person and try different types on so I could see what looked best. Once I decided which ring I wanted he then was able to change it slightly to be exactly what I wanted. The exact same process went for my groom. Mark also polished my engagement ring a few times before the wedding. If you're looking to go to a jewelry store and don't want someone breathing down your neck, pouncing on you as soon as you walk in the door, or pushing you to buy something..... Nulton Jewelers is the place to go. My groom searched for a place that was friendly, calm, and personable and that's Mark. Also, thanks for the bottle of champagne and thank you note!

If you're looking for a jeweler, Nulton is the place. Great family business! I had prongs replaced…read moreon my ring and another sized, reasonable price, super service! Thank you Nultons!!

I cannot say enough wonderful things about Forsyth Jewelry!! This was hands‑down one of the best…read moreexperiences I've ever had. The owners, their family, and the staff are incredibly warm, welcoming, and engaging. They take the time to listen, explain, and truly care--never rushed, never pushy, just honest and fair. You can immediately tell this is a family business built on trust and relationships, not just sales. If you're looking for a place where you feel valued and treated like family, this is it. I will absolutely be back and will recommend Forsyth Jewelry to everyone I know!!!!!!

My fiancé and I stopped here to look at wedding bands and had a fantastic experience! Amanda helped…read moreus out and she was so nice and patient (we tried on so many styles). They had a great selection and also said they can do custom rings. We haven't made our decision yet but could definitely see us coming back here to get custom rings for our wedding!

Lovely customer service. Owner kept in touch by text, and took the time to explain why what I…read morerequested (polishing of diamond and Jade) could not happen for technical reasons related to the design of my ring. She also educated me that semi precious stones grew doll over time, and they could not be restored to their original shine. She advised not wearing the ring every day anymore. Nonetheless, the diamond replacement was perfect, and the quality of the work was high. It also cost only $60!

We have been customers of Stefan Otters for over 35 years, and they are like family to us. Just…read morerececently, because of an accident, my diamond wedding ring had to be cut in half. Stefan magically reubuilt it and restored it to looking even more beautiful than beore! (this was no easy task!). He is a genius at his craft! The expense was very reasonable and saved me from buying a whole new ring! Mariela is wonderfully kind and so easy to work with, wanting each customer to be totally happy and satisfied with their jewelry needs. Stefan Otters - a trusting, reliable family owned business which we in Rochester are so fortunate to have!