My fiance and I had the BEST experience at Rohr. We were a bit nervous to be shopping for rings as a queer couple, but Sam put us completely at ease. He was funny, knowledgeable and made us feel comfortable. Instead of trying to talk us into the most expensive ring, he convinced me to use the diamond from my great grandma's ring. He offered great suggestions about the setting for the security of the diamond that we wouldn't have considered, and the custom ring turned out even better than imagined. We would highly recommend working with Rohr for your custom engagement ring! read more

Rohr Jewelers - Hand with engagement ring held up with fall foliage in the background - Jewelry Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

My fiance and I DEEPLY regret getting my brand new engagement ring (purchased elsewhere) sized down through Rohr. The soder point where the shank was cut for resizing the ring broke apart twice in a matter of weeks, the 2nd time it happened was less than 48 hours after I picked it up. While picking up my ring for the 3rd time I noticed my solitare morganite now has an enormous gouge across its face as well as a gouge on the band itself. The clerk who gave it to me insists it's normal wear and tear I just couldn't see before he cleaned it. It's my belief that I absolutely would have noticed such significant damage to my brand new engagement ring before leaving it with Rohr. Buyer be ware they do NOT document any existing damage when repairing outside jewelry, so sadly there is no paper trail to prove either way if the damage was pre-existing. I've only had my ring for 3 months and my fiancé and I now have to save for a whole new engagement ring. read more

Rohr Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

the staff is Great ..... did a return was more than happy to help me! the girl they had in the store was knowledgeable and eager to help ! Small town store that's a pleasure to be in! Thank You read more

I just got my engagement ring here and I could not be more pleased!!! I found an antique ring that I loved, but I figured it would simply be a guide for my now fiancé to find something similar as I was set on getting a purple sapphire for my stone and this ring had a blue stone. As I was blissfully unaware, they had several purple sapphires shipped from a supplier and re-set the ring with the new stone! They even did a second setting adjustment for free after the original purchase! They were incredibly dedicated to us getting what we wanted and I am very grateful. If you're in the marker for some antique or custom gemstone jewelry, this is the place for you! read more

Rohr Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Rohr is fantastic! My fiancé got my engagement ring from Rohr and my family has been going to Sam (the owner) for YEARS! Sam have been timely about resizing my ring and fixing it as well. Myself and my family will continue to go to Rohr for years to come! read more

Rohr Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Sam at Rohr is honest and kind. He also has great taste . I highly recommend Rohr, let's support our outstanding local businesses.

I had a wonderful experience this afternoon with my friend. The jeweler was kind and helped us with our limited knowledge, making us feel comfortable. It was lovely to feel like we weren't being taken advantage of. read more

Highly recommend! What a great experience! I was only in town for a couple days and wanted to resize polish and engrave a ring for my husband. They did it all same day. Friendly staff and great jewelry selection. read more

Sam the owner is highly knowledgable and fair. I was referred here and it is so much better than places like Jerod or Kesslers. Give this place a shot and at least go there to compare. I plan to ONLY go here to buy jewelry from now on!! read more

Rohr Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Just bought engagement ring from Sam. Looked at a LARGE competitor, and knew I needed to go to Rohr, a small intimate store that is so personalized where we felt so comfortable. I love this store! Sam and his lovely assistants Jo and Tina made our visit something very special; designs are so beautiful and prices are comparable, but the key selling point is how comfortable we felt. I wish I would win the lottery so I could buy some of Sam's glorious jewelry! Love my ring Sam! read more

bill was sounding like he would be quick and fast about fixing up a necklace for me I was quickly met with anger and felt like a burden when he told me my piece was something else. when I went to pick up he left off the pendant (which was on the chain so he had to remove it to solder the chain) and acted as if it was my fault. will not be coming back or recommending to anyone. guy is a major dick! read more

Sam surprised and delighted me by fixing my engagement ring in just hours, when I was expecting it to take days. I have a number of small diamonds in the ring and discovered one morning to my horror that one was missing. He used one he had on hand to replace it and also checked the others to ensure they weren't loose. This is now my jeweler of choice. Great selection, especially the pearls. Outstanding service. Thank you. read more

My husband and I fell in love with Rohr Jewelers and Sam's brilliance when we purchased my wedding bands through him two years ago. Most recently, my husband bought a simple gold band with diamonds from Rohrs for an anniversary gift. The band itself was lovely, but I wanted more dimension. I was able to have an honest conversation with Sam and he made my vision come to life in a tasteful new creation. We highly recommend Sam and Rohr Jewelers for any purchase. His collection is endless and his ability to design anything cannot be beat. read more

If you're not up for reading a long review but ARE up for meeting a talented jeweler with unique and interesting offerings, go to Rohr Jewelers. Now. If you like the details, continue on: Before getting engaged, I never understood the hype about "the ring." I just couldn't grasp why brides put so much emphasis on the size, cut, design of a singular piece of jewelery. With that kind of interest (aka disinterest), you can imagine how lost my husband was when picking out a ring. It was no surprise then that he proposed with my mom's ring (which had been sitting in her drawer for years) knowing that at least I'd appreciate the sentimental connection to my roots. I was overjoyed, but then I quickly realized I wasn't comfortable with having my mom's ring. It may sound sweet when you say "it was my grandmother's ring" but not when you say "it is my happily-married-very-much-alive mother's ring." It just doesn't have the same appeal. So I went to Sam. I had once seen a ring from him that I liked, so I figured it was worth seeing how he could help. He patiently listened while I explained my situation. "I LOVE my mom's ring and my mom...and my mom and dad...and I'd love to have a ring rooted in their love, but I also need a ring that represents ME and the love I have with MY man." I explained my style and showed him some pictures of rings that had elements which I liked, and he took it from there. And when I say he took it from there, I mean he went on to create the MOST PERFECT ENGAGEMENT RING, using the diamond and metal from my mom's ring, but also adding some extra diamonds and gold. When I picked it up, I finally understood the hype. I had never been so in love with a material item in my life. It was beautiful. And so "me." It looked like me, it felt like me, and yet beneath it all, there was a beautiful symbol of my parent's love. A true blend of "new" and "traditional." Sam had nailed it. But the engagement ring was just the beginning. Over the course of a few weeks, I would stop in to have my ring cleaned and chat with Sam, Amber, and Tiffany. They are a quirky, funny, and authentic bunch, and it didn't take long for us to become friends. Soon I was stopping by just to eat their chocolate and share some laughs. Whenever I'd feel overwhelmed by the rest of the wedding planning process, I'd just pop over by them and remind myself that some of it was fun. When I explained to Sam and Amber that I wanted to give my bridesmaids a jewelry set, they worked with me to create the perfect necklace/earring combo for the dresses we had picked out. And the best part was, they did it all within my less-than-extravagant budget! The jewelry was a huge hit with my friends and many of them have worn the pieces since the wedding. Sam and Co. didn't just stop with my bridesmaids' jewelry, though, they designed a necklace for me as well. I know you're probably thinking "a custom necklace? this chick must be hoighty toighty." But the truth is, I didn't ever dream of having a custom necklace. As I said earlier, Sam, Amber, and Tiffany had become my friends, so one night I brought my wedding dress to their shop and tried it on--a viewing for my friends. As any bride playing dress up in a jewelry store, I naturally had to try on nearly every fabulous necklace in the shop and dream of wearing them on my wedding day. But that's all it was-a fun game of pretend. On my next visit to the shop, though, my pretend became reality. Sam had designed a pearl necklace that was truly made for my dress. While Sam made the necklace, I need to give Amber credit for coming up with the drop pearls in the back. You are a creative genius, too, Amber! The dress and necklace could not both exist without being worn together, so of course I donned the beautiful pearls on my wedding day. Wearing them made me feel extra special and beautiful. And I couldn't even begin to count the guests that wanted to know where I got the necklace and how stunning it was. Rohr Jewelers! That's where I got it, folks, along with my engagement ring and wedding band and bridesmaid jewelry....and if you can't tell by now, I highly recommend that you go check out the shop. If you don't see exactly what you're looking for, talk to Sam, Amber, and Tiffany. They may be able to come up with something that's even better than what you're looking for. read more

AWFUL service here! I will never return to buy or service any jewelry here again. I ordered a resizing for a ring of mine on May 28, and it was only finished on JULY 13! Seriously?? When i inquired about a full or at least partial refund, the cashier said it wasnt their fault, as they were having problems with the company they'd shipped the ring out to be resized. I told her flat out this was not my problem and paid. She replied with a very curt, "i mean, its not like we gave you a time frame." Really? I was quoted TWO WEEKS MAX when I first came in, and got the same quote EVERY WEEK for almost SEVEN WEEKS!! Instead of footing the bill like any good business would have, they permanently lost a customer and lied blatantly to my face. They do however get one star for the resizing service, which i'd say for the $40 they charged me is still ridiculous. Horrible business, horrible service. GO LITERALLY ANYWHERE ELSE BUT HERE!! read more

I love Rohr jewelers! They have the best service and staff. I recently broke my wedding ring, split in two places! I took it in last Saturday and they had that and a fee other pieces fixed for me by Wednesday! My ring being an antique is a difficult ring to fix, but I wouldn't trust anyone else with it. I love that the never have to send it out to anyone else, they do it all in house, couldn't ask for anything more! read more

He never lets me down I brought a watch in very dear to me and he advised he does not do batteries or watches anymore but I showed him my broken watch bracelet and he took a short while to custom fit a rivet for me good as new then wouldn't charge me and said come back when I need some jewelry. Twice now they went above and beyond the call for customer service! I work downtown and they are 3 blocks away and When I need to buy jewelry or point one out to others it will always be Rohr. Thanks so much :) read more