This place is a bit of a mixed bag for me…read more When they're on, they're really on! The plain and margherita pies are some of the best in the area. Great flavor, solid sauce, and overall just really satisfying pizza. The issue is consistency. Sometimes the pies come out perfect with a nice thin crust, and other times they're thicker and a bit floppy. I'd say it hits that top tier about 70% of the time, and the rest is just okay. I also tried the cheesesteaks, and those were underwhelming. They felt light on meat and a bit underfilled, especially compared to what you'd expect. On a positive note, the kids' meal (chicken and fries) was actually really good.. solid portion and well done. Overall, it's a spot I still go to for pizza when I'm craving it, just hoping I catch them on a good day.

We did a vodka chicken pie and a philly cheesesteak pie becuase of how good the pic on here looked…read more Really thin, crispy crust here, so if you like that this is all you. My wife was into it, but it's never my favorite. The vodka pie was great. Loved the flavor and the basil tasted great. Worked really well with the thin crust. The philly was less good. Dry, no help from the thin crust, just not a fan. So a 5 for the vodka and a 3 on the philly gets us to a 4. Not my style, but pretty good.

A rare find in Colts Neck, New Jersey. Hospitality awaits at the door, making you feel less like a…read morecustomer and more like family. We ordered the takeout Grandma's Pie, which absolutely lived up to its reputation, along with an order of Garlic Knots that were outstanding. We returned another day for the Shrimp Francese over linguine, a cheese calzone, and more garlic knots. Everything was authentic, fresh, and simply delicious. Co-owner Nick was a pleasure to meet, and Ryan, the friendly cashier, made us feel right at home. Their welcoming attitude and genuine pride in the restaurant added to an already excellent dining experience. I'm glad we discovered Prima Pizza and look forward to returning on future visits to the area.

Great pizza. I consider myself a bit of a pizza snob. It's…read moremy type of Slice I give it an 8.8 so for Yelp I give it five stars. If you're in the area, you should eat this pizza. Wish I could get Pizza like this in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. I'm from Jersey City my mom's from Brooklyn. I know Pizza.

My daughter and her fiancé told me about this place they happened upon and decided to take me there…read morefor dinner. Apparently they've been there several times because the owner greeted them warmly and welcomed me as the newcomer. The dining area is ornate and interesting. My daughter and her fiancé started with a chicken soup and Caesar salad. The soup was in a tomato base and they enjoyed it and the dressing on the salad. We ordered an eggplant parm dinner with ziti, veal marsala over linguine and a penne vodka with chicken. We all enjoyed our meals, which were substantial in size. I noticed that the sauces on my eggplant and ziti were different in consistency. One complemented the eggplant and the other went well with the ziti. Not many places do that in my experience, making it unique for a small place. Highly recommended and sorry my pic of the eggplant was not good enough to post.

Best meatballs ever!!! Get a meatball parm on toasted garlic bread with ricotta. Also, order the…read morebroccoli roll. So delicious! My two favorite orders from this place.

This is one of the best vegan pizzas I've had in a long time. Great crust. Amazing sauce. Like…read morereally amazing, best I've had in forever. The place is super clean and everyone was so friendly. Indoor and outdoor seating. Ample parking. If they were closer to me, I'd go all the time!

Just got that familiar pizza craving and pulled off the road. Amazing pizza. Nice clean place…read more Friendly service. Decent music and a good selection of beverages. Specials too. Yes I would come back too.

Did a sausage, onion, mushroom pie. Loved the cook on the pie- nice and crispy. They use red onions…read moreand fresh, not canned, mushrooms, which were delicious, and the sausage was good. My gripe here is that there wasn't enough toppings towards the crust, everything was sort of in the middle and tip of the slice, and that the sauce/cheese was just meh... nothing mind blowing. That said, no one would be offended by a plain slice here, so I get it. I really liked it, just not the best I've ever had.

My go to pizza place. Love the pizza and hot sandwiches. Everyone greets you with a smile.read more

I was around the area and was in the mood for a quick slice. Found this place via Google and…read moredecided to give this place a shot since it was very close by. This review is based on their special. They had/have a special, buy one slice get one free so I definitely had to take them up on that offer. I ended up getting the grandma slice and vodka slice. Both were so good, I can they use quality ingredients. You cannot beat this special, if I lived nearby, I would easily come here at least twice a week for lunch or dinner. If your in the mood for great pizza slices, I highly recommend Salvatore's! * 4.5 Stars * Parking on premise * Indoor dining available

Delicious pizza! Being from the east coast and now living in Hawaii, I crave a good slice. Sals hit…read morethe spot!

Another delicious meal at Basil. Pizza, calamari and rice balls... yum!…read moreYou gotta try this place!

Great service and food once again at Basil's! It is tough to find good homemade Italian cooking. We…read morehighly recommend Basil in Manalapan. Thank you from The Vigilante Family

Calamari, chicken parm alla vodka, pear and arugula salad... delish! Food was very good and hit the…read morespot. Looking forward to trying the pizza! Everyone is friendly!

Wow!!!! Completely blown away by this restaurant and already counting down the days until I'm back…read more We ordered several items to share and everything was generous in portion, even the side salads that came with pasta dishes. The clams and linguine had incredible flavor with a great amount of clams in each bite. Very satisfying. The eggplant pasta was also a standout: filling, well-balanced, and packed with flavor. The chicken pesto sandwich was good as well and came with fries on the side. However, the sesame seed pizza! WOW WOW WOW. Absolutely amazing and easily the most memorable item of the meal. Overall, a fantastic experience with delicious food and great portions throughout!