Pizza is great. Best in area by far. Luigi's is next runner up. Meatball parm sub is one of the best. Mozz sticks you get a decent amount for the price and better than the usual Sysco ones. No delivery but worth the pickup. Never waiting when arrive. read more

This pizza is absolutely delicious! Great service too. But the pizza was SOOOO Good, I ate it so fast lol, good sauce, good mozzarella cheese & perfect sauce to crust ratio! Dining establishment is casual with no waiters etc. typical pizza place. read more

Romeo's Pizza & Restaurant - Margarita pie - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

The service is great, always checking in to see if there's anything they can do or grab for you. The owners are amazing they truly know what they're doing which shows me how much I can trust them in their work. The ambiance is well with some seatings and a welcoming area. The food is awesome I love their pizza and other items they have available. Romeos food is quick and delicious which is perfect!! I enjoy coming here! read more

In our seemingly never ending search for good pizza in this area, we stumbled on Romeo's and for once, we were not disappointed. The staff were so friendly, it was such a great vibe for an authentic old school pizza spot. I got a pepperoni slice that was very solid and we split a large calzone. The calzone was excellent and huge. We had leftovers for lunch the next day. Prices were very reasonable. Highly recommend and we will be back! read more

Romeo's Pizza & Restaurant - Large Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

1 out of 4 of us had a stomach issue. We just stopped in on Tuesday afternoon around 4pm to grab a quick bite before heading to our t-ball practice with our 2 kids, but later that night my husband complained of having stomach issues. We all had different slices so there was no way to tell if it was isolated to his specific food or not but he was fine before he ate that. The service is basic, no extra frills or thrills here. The ambiance is a general fast counter service set up, it's a casual setting. Their pizza is good, even tasted good on this day, but maybe the white slice he had was off somehow. I had a Buffalo chicken pizza slice, my son had a pepperoni and my daughter had a plain pizza slice. They offer fountain drinks as well as Gatorade, Snapple, Stewart's, snd like one other bottled option. read more

This is a family business in Hazlet for many years. Old school plastic booths and nothing fancy inside. They don't even deliver! But you don't have to when the food is this good. Chicken Parm is one of my favorite Italian meals anywhere I go. Simple but marvelous if done right. Since Covid I have been disappointed in many local pizzeria/restaurants delivery of this dish. Prices have soared and the quality of the chicken are at all time lows. Chicken in other businesses are chewy, stringy or rubbery. NOT AT ROMEO'S! The quality of food is top notch. Give them a try. read more

Romeo's Pizza & Restaurant - Sorry, half eaten chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

They offer great food everything is always perfect! I call ahead and never have to wait to pick up my order it is always ready when I arrive. read more

Been a customer from 1980 ! Family run business same location, same owners. Best Italian around pizza is extraordinary and the chicken Parm , to die for read more

Romeo's Pizza & Restaurant - Owners been in this location forever ! Best Italian - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

See all

The pizza is good. My husband likes their sausage. They do not deliver, however, we never had any issues with delays.

Nice pizzeria good food , good pizza if your in the area ... Excellent buffalo chicken pizza

We had a family gathering and ordered a couple of trays of food from here for dinner: stuffed eggplant parmesan, penne alla vodka, and chicken francese. The portions were large, the food was prepared quickly, and they were all good. But what we really appreciated was that they threw in SIX fresh loaves of Italian bread and a large heaping of garlic knots for us. We definitely will try some of their pizza another time. read more

Romeo's Pizza & Restaurant - a table full of food - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

Solid pizza option. They're generous with the toppings and pizza is made fresh when you order. You totally get an old school vibe here, and they have Italian tv playing in the background. The pizza crust is good. Prices are reasonable and pizza is hot and fresh. I'd definitely order from here again. During Covid - you can call ahead to place an order. Staff wears masks, and there are stickers on the floor for social distancing. read more

See all

Nice neighborhood pizzeria. Food is a little above average. If your in the area is ok but there are better options.

The best local Holmdel pizza, great service and got to chat with the pizza makers and staff on my last visit. My (80+y/o) parents also loved the quality of the dough, sauce and cheese - reminded them and me of some of the better Brooklyn and back home Italian well-run and respectable pizza establishments. Thank you! God bless read more

Just moved here from nyc and saw the reviews so had to try it out being it's impossible to find decent pizza in jersey. Got a Sicilian half pepperoni half special and a round half plain half pepperoni. It was decent at best. Definitely tasted better the next day reheated in the oven. So far probably slightly better than the others I've tried in the area. I'll still be searching in the mean time. read more

Always good. Classic jersey pizzeria with a great slice. Can't speak much for the food but when I am around here I pop in fast and it's fast and the staff is friendly read more

Best in the area. We've been coming here since we were little and it's never changed! Delicious pizza and great people!

Ordered from the catering menu for a retirement lunch. Food was delicious and was ready at the time requested.

I've been going to Romeo's for over 30 years. Same great owners. Same great pizza!!! Crispy crust, just enough sauce. Their squares ( Sicilians) are the best! Sandwiches are also delicious. All of them! And this review comes from someone who grew up in Brooklyn, worked in Manhattan and have eaten some really great pizza! Romeo's is right up there. read more

Amazing pizza best in town you can't get any better than this place. The staff is very nice and it's nice to sit in there too and have a slice read more

Place is average, ALL BOOTHS NO TABLES!! I'm fat, of course, I'm eating pizza right? Couldn't fit in their very narrow BOOTHS...pizza average- clearly don't understand pizza well done. STILL UNDERDONE.....CAPEESH Perhaps I should order more salads and eat at places with only tables...I'll have a convo with Jenny. read more

The crust was perfect but the sauce wasn't. It was too bland. The service was great and the place looks a lot better since the redo.

I have to say I am really disappointed in this place. Moved to the area recently and was looking for a good spot for some pastas and salads. Placed a $45 Togo order of chicken parmesan and penne vodka sauce with a large Caesar salad and a 2 litter soda. $45.... Ok expect it to me amazing. Not even in the slightest! The Caesar salad was doused in dressing which I'm not even sure was dressing, it tasted like plain mayo! I had to add lots of salt and pepper to everything. Then the side salad that came with the chicken parmesan was wilting and the dressing did not taste fresh, had a strange taste to it. The chicken parmesan was ok but the pastas were terrible. The penne vodka sauce had absolutely no flavor and the pasta tasted like 3 minute boxed pasta. The loaf and a half of Italian bread that came with the food tasted like it was the cheapest bread ever made, if that it's even a thing. read more

Romeo's Pizza & Restaurant - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

See all

This is thee only place my family goes for pizza, subs, eggplant parm (my fave), garlic knots, antipasto salad, etc. The family that owns Romeo's is exemplary! They always recognize and treat us with kindness & enthusiasm. We have been eating here since 1979!! read more

Maybe i am an outlier cause the place was packed went i went yesterday Friday and 5pm and orders coming in like crazy. I found the pizza to be a bit tasteless, certainly not as tasty as Salerno's I was bothered that one of the teenagers behind the counter, at least for the 20 minutes i was there waiting for my order, didn't have his mask covering his nose and he was serving most people their food. Everyone else behind the counter had masks on properly, it was odd they didn't have him fix his read more

Pizza was great All of the staff is running around to get carry out orders. Conversations between employees and customers reminded me of the area I grew up in outside Chicago. Family spot where everyone knows everyone. Loved every minute of it!!! read more

Just a very good and tasty pizza shop. Incredibly friendly staff. Everything I have ordered thus far has been above average

I feel liKe a horrible person for not having left a review for Romeos yet. We live walking distance and find ourselves at Romeos at least once a week, they save me on the nights I don't feel like cooking or my son demands pizza on the way home; my son loves their pizza and we love their pizza and the rest of their food too. The staff is awesome, such friendly/warm owners and workers and they really put in great effort to serve awesome food and service. Love this place so much that we haven't ventured out to try other pizza places since moving to Hazlet in April, why fix something that ain't broken? read more

Love this place!! Raised in Hazlet this was our "go to" for the best pizza! It's still a great place for pizza. I haven't tried other items on the menu. The pizza has the perfect crust, the sauce is the best flavor and the cheese is the delicious. Romeo's is the same owner for 20+ years. When ever I am in the hazlet area we stop for pizza. You won't be disappointed! Enjoy! read more

Nothing has stopped Romeo's from serving the best take out food. The pies are amazing, no matter which kind you order, and sandwiches to dinners are simply delicious. Love the staff here as well. Kudos to them for keeping up during these tough times. We will always continue to support them. read more

Romeo's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

Business as usual at Romeos ! Great food , friendly family run restaurant and as I discovered tonight really really good tuna salad hero ! Wife had the Ceasar salad with chicken and I picked off her plate and it was a salad Ceasar would be proud of. Portions are good and in fact unlike myself I'll be packing up half my tuna salad hero to go ! Also a bonus is desert next door at Ralph's Italian ices ! Go to Romeo's now ! J read more

We decided to give them a try since all we do is get pizza from Salerno's. Oh man ! The meatball sub and cheesesteak( they had an option with tomato and lettuce ) iwere so good! Also why is their pasta fagioli is soo good??? We can't wait to try more menu options. Sorry no pics we were to busy eating! read more

This is my local Pizza/Italian food place. The quality of food and pizza is a constant. The Chicken Parm Sub is my favorite and my go to meal. The pizza is high quality and always fresh. Love the Knots! Seating area is small, No delivery but well worth the drive to pick-up! The staff/owners have remained the same, great service, always smiling and friendly! read more

See all

I started going to this pizza shop about a year ago. I will never buy a pie from anywhere else in the Monmouth County area again. Hands down, the best there is. Even though they don't deliver, I'd still rather pack my family in the car and drive there just to pick up a couple pies on pizza night, than order from a mediocre joint that delivers. Classic pizzeria, with real Italians behind the counter... 5 stars! I've also ordered their chicken parm, amazing. read more

Just moved to union beach and this is the best pizza spot around! Garlic knots, Cesare salad , and their grilled chicken was amazing and very good quality. Repeat customer from now on read more

First, the order arrived 30 min late. Then, only half of the order was there. The delivery driver seemed to know he was missing something, but he had no idea what - and was hoping I wouldn't notice. He didn't comment until I asked where the rest of my order was - then he said "Oh, is that what that charge was?" Really? When I called in to let them know, they did nothing to make it right, except say that they'd send it. It's been another 25 minutes and it's still not here. The pizza was barely warm. The crust was burnt to a crisp. The toppings slid right off the top. Can't review the appetizer combo, as it hasn't arrived yet. I see there are other positive reviews - but this experience is so bad, I'm not sure I can stand to try it again. There are too many competitors to try so it's tough to put up with a poor experience like this. read more

Great pizza with tons of veggies! The staff was great too. We were about to depart on a long road trip and didn't bring quarters for tolls, I asked them for a buck or two of quarters and they exchanged a $10 bill for a whole roll of quarters! This kind of service is what all businesses should strive for. read more

Awesome baked ziti pizza! Great local pizzeria, owner goes the extra mile to make you feel welcome. They are conveniently open late (10 pm) so a great for a late night bite. Also right next door to Ralph's ice creams... two great eats in one shot! read more

This is my new go to Pizza spot in the area. I've been here for 6 years and our favorite spots have been Denino's, DiBari's and Krispy Pizza, but I recently tried Romeo's and it beats them all, hands down. With some of these other places, the crust is sometimes burnt or the ratios are off but this one was perfect. My kids normally only eat plain pizzas, but they loved the romeo special which had peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage and pepperoni. read more

My in laws introduced me to Romeo's. I thought I had good pizza before but I think this place takes the cake. It's incredible and well balanced between the cheese, sauce and dough. No doubt about it, amazing NJ pizza. read more