First time. Wow! I loved it! I can see how this place fills up so quickly when it opens! We began the meal with the meatballs, which were a great start. Soft and delicious. We couldn't make our minds up so we ordered two pies for the two of us! The first was the thin brick oven pizza, with mushrooms, and then the grandpa pie. Wow!!!! I loved the grandpa pie with the extra garlic flavor and perfect crust. Absolutely delicious! The thin crust was also excellent in a different way. The ambience was really homey and the waitress was friendly and very informative. Can't wait to come back and try some new pies. read more

See all

There's nothing much I can add to the pizza score than the professionals and generations of customers have not said already. It's fantastic. But I can tell you that the homemade roasted pepper salad may be the best bite of food I have had in a long long time. It's worth the drive here even if you do not want anything else. The service and the unapologetic family atmosphere are even more compelling than the food. It makes me feel at home. Among friends. As if I've been coming here for 50 years. I grew up in NJ. Many of the generational Italian places have since closed. Spirito's in Elizabeth was the cornerstone place for me and my family. 4 generations enjoyed that place. Roma has that type of feel. Even though I'm a visitor to Tuckahoe, I dine here when I want great food and want to feel like I am home. read more

Family owned, long standing restaurant in the community. We were greeted and sat by a very friendly lady who sat us in a nice corner booth. Large restaurant that has another room past the bar for busy weekends or large parties. Our server, Ziggy, was very nice and took our drink order right away. We ended up getting a large pie, 1/2 pepperoni and an arugula and goat cheese salad. The salad was topped with very thin sliced almonds, and a delicious balsamic. The goat cheese and arugula were both very fresh, and it was one of the best salads I've had out. Simple yet incredible. The pizza came out piping hot. Thin, crispy and crunchy crust. The pepperoni slice was flavorful but a tiny bit greasy. Maybe hard to avoid though with pepperoni. The cheese slice was good but lacked salt, but there was salt on the table to add to taste. It's actually kind of nice to not have an overly salty slice you can't do anything about. The pizza held up well, a little bend in the front but just a tiny bit. Perfect really. The crust stayed crispy til the end. I also enjoyed adding the arugula salad on top of the slice to mix it up. The roof of my mouth is still burned because I couldn't wait for it to cool off. It was that good. The staff was really friendly and you can't beat the family vibe. read more

See all

Nice pizza, tasty salad. Friendly host. Nice atmosphere. Fully bellies. Fun times. Family focused. Lots of laughs. Everyone was happy. Will come again read more

Super thin crust pizza that you only get from old school New York spots. Family run, super welcoming and warming people. Highly recommended and great for families with young kids. Also one of the best penne vodkas I've had! read more

See all

Italian restaurant with a regular menu, but also large selection of pizzas. The pizza is Good, a little soggy, but nothing beyond what normally happens when there are 3+ toppings weighing it down. Good penne vodka, other than that other dishes went memorable. I will try the pizza again with less toppings to see if it holds up better. read more

I decided to take a friend out for a surprise birthday dinner. My original restaurant choice was Pastina on Central Ave. However, knowing how much he enjoyed the Linguini in White Clam Sauce at Roma I changed our plans. I strongly recommend before going to Roma to read the reviews on Yelp and Roma's site starting with the worst. Yes the restaurant is known for great pizza, but the food was horrible. 1. Hot Food was served Cold. 2. Food Not Served as Ordered. 3. Slow Service - Not enough wait staff during peak hours. 4. Restaurant is old and tired looking. 5. Overpriced for the quality of the food. 6. Waitress needs training. 7. Manager needs to MANAGE the KITCHEN AND STAFF. The waitress told us the specials and my friend decided to order the special of Ossobuco with Risotto. We waited patiently for the food to be served. The Ossobuco was served with polenta Not risotto as ordered. We finally got the attention of the waitress. She asked if he wanted a side of risotto. She told us she knew the dish was wrong when she picked up the dish to be served WHY SERVE IT? She told us, she was told the dish was served with risotto and there was some confusion about whether it was polenta or risotto. This ISN'T MY PROBLEM!!! We waited 7 minutes for a side order of cold risotto to replace the polenta. The risotto looked like dried crumbled rice cakes on a dish. We asked the waitress for a plate to remove the meat from the polenta it was sitting in. She brought us a dessert plate, not a dinner plate and walked away. The meat was cold by the time the risotto was served. We called her over again and she told her the meat and risotto were both cold. She did ask if we wanted another side of risotto and we asked for the check. Her reply was "I didn't charge you for the side of risotto". How can you charge a patron for side of risotto when you knowingly served the wrong side with the dish we ordered. The waitress should have taken the wrong dish back to the kitchen to keep the meat hot and brought out the dish when it was hot and ready. My side order of penne was warm to cold. I asked for marinara sauce which tasted like tomato paste. It was inedible. The waitress told the manager what happened, however the manager didn't come over. My friend was offered a slice of cake for his birthday dinner. After 30 plus years of going to Roma this is without a doubt my last time going there. I'M TIRED OF PAYING FOR MEDIOCRE FOOD AND SERVICE AT ROMA!! read more

Food is always good and plentiful. Came with my daughter and her husband, my granddaughter and her husband with their 2 and 4 year olds. Ordered pizza for an appetizer. Then had pasta dishes and chicken and pork chops. Service was great. The atmosphere is always warm and welcome. Another good family time at Roma's. Sal E New Rochelle read more

See all

There was no heat in Roma tonight. Really shut the place down when you have heat issues!!!!

I will never eat here again. The owners wife is rude and not accommodating to patrons. She has an attitude and should stay away from talking to customers. This lady will only hurt this establishment. You will never see me or my family members again. Do not dine here. read more

My family took me here while visiting one day. Very nice old school restaurant. Service was great. Everyone was so friendly. The pizza is to die for. Thin crust and cooked to perfection. I will definitely return next time I visit the area. read more

Romas is an old family run favorite Italian restaurant in Tuckahoe dating back three generations to 1931. My husband's family and I have been frequent customers for many many years. We love their thin crust pizzas and many varieties of pastas. Buon appétito! read more

See all

My brother and I visited ROMA RESTAURANT on Friday evening, July 18. It was our first time there, and immediately we were greeted by one of the owners Filly. We immediately felt like we were at our family's home, and she told us you are in my home now. The service, the food, the hospitality were all amazing. We asked Filly for food recommendations, and she immediately suggested what we should eat as first timers Roma. We followed her recommendations, and the food was delicious, and it immediately brought back memories of our parents and grandparents family dinners. The lasagna was delicious and huge, and the amazing pizza had the thinnest and crispiest crust. And you have to try the delicious meatballs, and the amazing toasted almond cake, dessert Even though the restaurant was so busy, Michael (Filly's husband and co-owner) came to our table and spoke with us for an extended period of time about their almost 100 year history and about our families. Last, but not least, Val our waiter, provided great service, hospitality and was so very attentive to us. Overall, it was an amazing evening at this rare old-school style and amazing restaurant. We so much appreciated everyone and everything! We will be back again very soon and thank you, Best wishes, continued success and God bless. Ken & Lou, the Bronx Guys.. read more

Roma Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Came for a surprise bday and graduation party. It was slow going at first to get things out, even water but once items started coming out it was plentiful and great. The baked stuffed clams were my absolute fave with tons of flavor and huge chunks of clam in them. All the other apps got devoured too. For the main we were given a decent selection of about 7-8 items to choose from and the sole oreganata was fantastic! If I lived near here I would def go back read more

Antonio has been singing the pleasures of Roma for years so it was about time to ask them to prove it. We went there to test their reportedly outstanding pizza. Lo and behold it exceeded our wildest expectations. The salad was delicious too. The service was also exceptional. We will be back to sample their other menu items. read more

Best Sicilian EVER! Grandpa is pretty special also. No frills, nostalgic, and awesome.

Decided to try Romas pizza for takeout. After 45 years in the area, I was reluctant due to a bad experience a long time ago. The pizza was delicious! read more

Used to have the best pizza but now it's hit and miss one day good other to well done to a point crust breaks with no taste. Menu items pretty good for the price. read more

My family eats here quite frequently and they never disappoint! Whether you order a pasta dish or one of the tasty entrees, you can't go wrong. Tip: always end the night with a cappuccino! read more

See all

Roma is a trusted restaurant and pizza pickup in our household. Whether we sit as a family or pick up pizza and go the place is terrific. Food service friendliness. Mike and his family and staff do a great job continually and with smiles all the time. read more

Changing to 5 stars because I think they deserve at least 4 overall. The food is consistently good and I never leave here disappointed. read more

Roma Restaurant - Chicken Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Predictably good food, very fair to generous pricing. Staff are welcoming. Say Hi to Philly when you visit. She is a treasure. Adrian is most professional and accommodating. We love you guys. Tony and Catherine read more

Not only is it the best pizza in Westchester County it is the most consistent. Also, I would not trust the judgement or taste of anyone who has anything negative to say about this place. The food is great, the pizza is exceptional and the people are all warm and friendly. read more

Roma Restaurant - Large sausage & Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

NOT KID FRIENDLY! I've never encountered a more rude manager as the woman who runs this restaurant. I was dining alone with my toddler, and since the service was so slow, by the end of the meal he HAD IT. I used to be a waitress so I always clean the entire table and stack the plates when I'm done eating, which I had done. I was standing waiting for the check sweating, as my son was trying to get down and was crying. I didn't realize he had thrown some fries on the floor. She made a comment to me from across the room and embarrassed me in front of other tables. I said I was sorry and I'm clearly having a tough time but she kept arguing with me. I have never been spoken to like this, not only by a manager, but also a fellow mother. NEVER AGAIN read more

Great Italian home cooked food! It feels like your visiting an old friend that can cook!Everyone is friendly and portions are good for one person...im not sharing next time! read more

Great pies!! Services was excellent and the prices are reasonable. Good place to bring the family.

this restaurant is very casual warm and very good food. My favorite dishes are the Parmesan and the lasagna.

Great old school place. Super friendly staff. Good food. Very casual environment. Not a date night type of a place, it's the place you go with the family to just feel super welcomed and eat good food. read more

We always enjoy Romas, it has a great family atmosphere which offers delicious thin crust pizza, which the kiddos and adults both love. Their arugula salad and muscles oreganata are my favorites. The same friendly faces are always welcoming and the food is constantly yummy. Definitely worth the visit. read more

Roma Restaurant - Arugula salad and Cesear salad - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Went for the first time on Friday evening. Pizza was very good and prices were fair ...HOWEVER... the service was very POOR!! The waitress/owner? was very cold. She had ZERO PERSONALITY and bordered on being RUDE!! Ambience was just ok. A bit dim and slightly crammed. Loud kids at multiple tables. Our bill was $81 and my dad gave the waitress a $20 as tip. The waitress took the tip and walked off. Not even a thank you or a single word!! We didn't give her a problem during dinner. We never asked for a refill or sent anything back. Nothing. She was just cold and stone faced. Again, the pizza and appetizers were good but part of the enjoyment of dining out is the experience. Our waitress was the worst one we've had in years... and we dine out often!! (White female, medium brown hair, mid 60's) Avoid her!! read more

After years of driving by we decided to give Roma a try tonight. They have their own lot but there is plenty of street parking and a town lot as well. The restaurant looked to be well maintained and the decor was pretty modern for such an established restaurant. We had our three children with us and we were glad to find that Roma was very family friendly. The wait staff was friendly but busy, but the owner's wife came around a few times and was incredibly warm and inviting. The food was classic Italian, but done very well. The portions were large and the prices very reasonable. The lasagna and the chicken special were top notch, and the kids enjoyed their pasta too. We don't go out for Italian food often, but when we do I think Roma is the perfect place for a casual and affordable night out. read more

I've gotten take-out pizza from this place many times and always enjoyed it. Last night my son and I ate in the restaurant for the first time and really enjoyed the atmosphere and food. The chicken parm was 10/10 and the pizza was better than Portnoy's 7.5 rating! Not sure why I waited so long to dine here but we will be back for sure. read more

Roma Restaurant - Chicken Parm dinner - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

If the app allowed I would go to 4 1/2 a good Italian flavor. Friendly staff and fast service the calamari was fresh and properly cooked (tender not overcooked rubber) I had a Veal parmigiana in was fully the real deal good flavor and tender. My son had the lasagne it was to big for him to finish he loved it a definite place to go don't pass up! read more

Roma Restaurant - Roasted Pepper Fresh Mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

See all

This place is awesome. The food is powerhouse classic NY Italian. Ambiance is honestly perfect. Come here you will NOT be upset about it. Pizza is thin, crispy fantastic. Very very happy to come back soon read more

I'm only give three stars not because the food was not good but the waitress reaction when I accidentally took the restaurant copy of the bill. It was an incident mistake she came running out after me telling me she would lose her tip if she didn't have receipt. Her tip was in cash so not sure what she was talking about. If you were so concerned come back to table and pick up receipts read more

The very best Pizza I ever had!! I have been coming to Roma's for years. I wouldn't think of going anywhere else. The. Servers are friendly and efficient read more

Went in for a drink and appetizer towards the end of the evening. I received the stink eye from the owner and a couple of waitresses who were clearly done working but chose to hang around with an attitude about them indicative of what I will describe as "Mean Girls". I was VERY uncomfortable and they were pretty much snarking about me passive aggressively so I could hear. They were also watching another waitress (my waitress) and nit picking everything she did. I even heard tthem complaining about the amount of paper towels she used. Coincidentally, someone else posted on the local next door app about the same kind of service I received and let's just say dozens of other people chimed in and it wasn't good. I love to support local businesses and want to see the little guy succeed but in my heart, the terrible treatment outweighs the pretty decent food. I'm so disgusted by these nasty people that I cannot recommend this place. Shocked by the good reviews on Yelp. I recommend you look up the chain of complaints on next door. There are several Italian restaurants that actually value and respect their customers. read more

Grandpa pie and house red...you're gonna have a super chill night. The staff here is so kind and chill in a caring way. We call this place the Italian Diner...it's just that comfort place with go to delicious pizza. I also love their penne vodka. You know that type of night...you just want to take it super easy for a while and enjoy a nice Chianti and excessive amounts of cheese. ROMA is your go to read more

Unpleasant staff waitress told my kid to move out of her way. Manager asked me to add more to the tip after the staff hovered over us to leave following a large table. The entitled attitude was a turn off read more

Very friendly and food is always great. Never had a bad experience. Had pizza many times and is always a solid choice. So many pizza spots but so hard to choose one, there pizza is one of the better ones. read more