The mozzarella sticks were a bit limp lol the breading was not as crispy as I'd have liked and lacking a bit of seasoning but the PIZZA! I love a penne alla vodka pizza where they actually put pasta on top! And the vodka sauce was amazing. I think the crust was a bit overdone but I was just happy about getting to eat a solid penne alla vodka pizza with a good sauce and pasta on top. read more

Pizza Gourmet Restaurant - mozzarella sticks - Italian Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

I first went to this restaurant through a special from the too good to go app. They gave eight slices of pizza and they were all very good. The place is small and very clean. The restaurant side very nice. Came back three days later for dinner with my wife. The service was excellent. Very friendly and attentive. I had the veal Parm with broccoli And my wife had the eggplant with broccoli. Both were excellent. The portions are big. The prices are more than reasonable and they even give you bread at the table. As the place is small, I really don't wanna give a will make it tougher to get a. But everything was spot on. read more

Best buff slice we've ever had! Service is great, our favorite spot for date night! Definitely recommend! read more

Very popular and comfortable local Italian pizza restaurant. This restaurant offers a great selection of well prepared and tasty Italian style dishes at very reasonable prices combined with friendly and speedy service. Also take out and delivery available. There is both street parking and a parking lot. read more

See all

food is nasty. got fettucine alfredo was mostly olive oil not much cream not much anything else. I am Italian and I cook so now I do instead of going here. i used to love their eggplant and pizza was decent. I severely miss when Phil owned the place and his brother was a phenonemal cook. the pizza was never as good as sals but had a lot of variety. i stoppped going here a couple years ago. read more

This is the best pizza in Westchester. The thin crust, well done pepperoni- double cut is our go to. The menu offers much more, which I intend to try. But for now it's the pizza I go there for. read more

Was heading to Sal's in Mamaroneck for a square slice and then walk the avenue. Saturday night they're open till 9. It's 8:40. Gotta hurry. I call. No answer. I speed up. Pass a cop hiding in the dark. I keep one eye out the front window as I slow down and one eye waiting for the police lights to let me know I'm done. In my mind I think about my story how I have hungry kids and Sal's is closing. Screw the ticket, follow me and I'll buy you a slice. Is that really bribery? Policeman never chased me. I can make it with 5 minutes to spare. Turns out .. Sal is on Vacation. Now what? PG comes up on Google. What the heck, it's worth a try. When I walk in there only 2 slices left on the counter and they're closing for vacation tomorrow so there's not much to be had. Counter guy says.. no worries I'll make a pie. I don't need a pie but it's after 9 here in whitelandia so I'll be happy to have something. Pizza man happily spins the dough and in 12 minutes my pizza comes out perfect. They were all so friendly and easy to deal with. So far so good. "How many slices you want"? I'm asked. What? You're not making me take the whole thing? "Nah. Take what you want but it's probably cheaper to take a pie than 4 slices". So I took the pie. $22 bucks. Damn good. Friendly, accommodating service. Clean. Quick. No attitude. The pizza was old school good, a little flop, great flavor, a bit of crunch that makes you salivate. Cheese was good and not too oily. Perfectly hit the spot. I'll definitely be back. Met the owners while I waited. Good people. Try this place. If it's not a 5 next time I go I'll update but for now this place is a gem. But just so you know, only Sal's gets you out of getting a ticket. read more

OK so I went to this place when it was a pizzeria and they remodeled and now it's a pizzeria restaurant love the look of a great job. Always love their pizza special one with onions tomatoes chicken and mozzarella. Tonight me and my daughter had the bruschetta the bread was too high and thick but the mix was out of this world it reminded me of the pizza. I had the spaghetti with the clams and shrimp I think the spaghetti was fresh because it had a different texture like fresh made. My daughter had the eggplant Rollo teeny we couldn't finish everything so we took it home. I'm surprise the red sauce on the spaghetti was a little bland. read more

Pizza Gourmet Restaurant - Spaghetti with shrimp and clams with a touch of garlic - Italian Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Casual Italian spot with a large menu and both indoor and outdoor seating The bread and butter was the highlight. It was fantastic I got a pasta and clam dish and was not a big fan. I also tried the tirimisu for dessert and thought it was just fair The waiter was pretty pushy as well 6.5 read more

I've been coming here since 1998, when it opened originally! The food is consistently great! They make the best spaghetti carbonara!! Highly recommend! read more

This place has wonderful customer service, that's #1!! Christine and Marie made us feel very much like we were part of the family here. The food portions are excellent! I brought some home! The food is so delicious, everything cooked perfectly. I went with a few friends on a Monday night for dinner. These entrees were absolutely worth the price. We never ran out of bread or water. The bread was also .. some of the best bread I've ever had!!! I will be back soon! read more

See all

I ordered a personal pie via GrubHub. The pizza arrived cold!! Not pleased! I don't know if I'll order this thru GrubHub again.

I spent my childhood in a pizzeria so I consider myself high maintenance when it comes to pizza. Out of the 10+ pizzerias within the 3 mile radius this is one of my favorites. Love their pinwheels, their tomato sauce, square and specialty slices. Always fresh. Cute outdoor seating when it's nice outside and friendly service. read more

We were a party of five and everyone enjoyed their dinner. Great service too! Nice variety of appetizers, entrees, desserts, and beverages to pick from. read more

We were looking for a place off the Hutchinson that served whole wheat crust pizza.....and Pizza Gourmet delivered! They also have gluten free pizza as well. This is pretty astonishing considering this is not some place that looks like it was spun out of some hippie college town. Pizza Gourmet is a tiny pizza shop with about 10 tables for a dining area, that really looks like any "XYZ House of Pizza" that dots New England and New York. We were a bit skeptical, but they came through. The service was friendly and the pizza was delicious. The whole wheat pizza was great, and I got a slice of the "regular" pizza just to check it out, and it passed with flying colors. read more

This is our go to pizza place in mamaroneck. I love the regular slice. Their food is great too. I've used them for trays of food for parties. We love coming here... With one thing we hate. The music! Lol It's the worst 80s stuff. Freestyle? I don't even know what to call it. I've never known one song that is being played. My husband and I always joke about how bad it is but today my son actually said he was getting a headache from it and never wanted to come back! He is 7. Delivery is usually fast! I always ask for Steve to deliver if possible! I love him:) read more

Pizza Gourmet Restaurant - Seating area - Italian Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

First Let me tell you the food is out of this world every dish is a homemade dish. Staff is excellent, very friendly. I have used the LocalFlavor coupons, Phil the owner makes you feel like you're getting a discount because you are part of the family. Great food with great atmosphere a win win situation. George read more

consistently great food with extremely nice people and always have the best sports games on the TV

I've ordered food from them for years with no problem. It took 2 orders to get my food. It arrived cold. The seafood was cold and uneatable. I called and spoke to the manager who was unresponsive to anything I had to say. I told him if they didn't take care of it I would call Amex. So I did. Not sure if they have new owners but will never order from them and I don't recommend you to either. read more

Definitely the best pizza in the area. No idea why anyone thinks Sal's is good or even comparable. Pizza Gourmet recently opened a nice sit down restaurant next door to their old store, and it's nice and cozy. Seems like a family run business. The pizza is good; the plain slices are solid and, unexpectedly, the four cheese pizza with American cheese was really good! The ricotta is so fresh and delicious, I could eat a bucket of it. The pasta is above average; I ordered the arrabiata, which was quite spicy. They also have these yummy roasted peppers that are worth a try. A good place to grab a bite or take something to go. Service is friendly and they seem to be open late. read more

I started eating at Pizza Gourmet last year when Vin started working there and I am so glad I did. Absolutely amazing pizza and entrees and even better soups. With the expansion, the place also looks great and isn't as cramped as it was. And don't listen to these other peckerwoods complaining about delivery. I've gotten delivery via Grubhub about ten times over the past year and have had zero problems. Always be wary of these self-important pricks that come on Yelp after one "bad" (it's often not even bad) experience. Fuck them. read more

I was in the area with my family and stopped at this restaurant to get a slice. Ended up staying for dinner and wow was I impressed. Food was great, there chicken gourmet, with tomato and onion salad. There pizza was fresh, my son had regular slice I had the focaccia with olives. Pizza was so good I took a pie home. Definitely would come back for dinner. read more

Brought my nephew here and the food was good, however my experience was muddied by a disgruntled old man loudly exclaiming that he "hates Democrats with a passion", that "hopefully they will all disappear soon", and lamenting the fact that "nobody writes in script anymore" because that is how things were done back in his days. His wife tried to shush him, however it's the restaurant's inability to control this blatant display of aggression that is a deterrent for me - won't be returning. Shame. read more

Ordered two pizzas and garlic knots from this restaurant through GrubHub the other day. The pizza was decent, however I was a little unimpressed with the four cheese pizza as it literally had strips of American cheese topping it though it claimed it had cheddar. They also sent us burnt garlic knots, which were basically inedible so I was not happy with that. It was ok at best. read more

Best pizza place in the area! They've got everything there from individual gourmet slices to classic Italian dinner entrees. The owner and his staff are warm and friendly. When you dine in they take real good care of you. Phil, the owner will often come out and ask patrons how the food is. There are always a lot of people here especially during dinner time. If you haven't tried it you need to. Place really is the best in mamaroneck! read more

Love this Place! The Pizza is good but the dinners are awesome! Never disappointed! Menu is extensive and the specials are a worth the trip read more

Pizza Gourmet Restaurant - Balsamic Chicken and sausage - Italian Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

I give this restaurant 5 stars because the staff is very attentive and the food is great. I had catered from this place twice and have been to the restaurant many times and everything was exceptional. read more

This is no ordinary pizza place - they have pasta and entrees that rival a fine Italian restaurant...and they deliver! Our favorites are the penne ala vodka and calamari fra diavlo over linguine. We also love chicken and shrimp Francese and veal marsala . Sometimes they have homemade Italian cheesecake or cannolis for dessert, and gelato in the summer! Don't forget the salad and garlic bread..yum!! read more

My favorite local restaurant. I come here every week and the food is always awesome. I've tried so many dishes on the menu. The soups, pastas, and main dishes are so fantastic. Carmela is a super waitress. Definitely a neighborhood friendly place... read more

since it changed owners a few months ago the food is not the same I wouldn't go back or order again. guess sals pizza for regular and Sicilian pizza and I dont know for eggplant or ziti w vodka sauce. read more

As far as the pizza is concerned here I really like it. Ive been getting pizza mainly from the Halstead strip in Harrison where a total of 5 pizzerias are located. Not all but most of them Id have to get toppings just to make the pizza pleasurable. Finally after years I decided to try Pizza Gourmet and finally found a place where you can get an excellent plain cheese pie. Have ordered many times since and will continue to do so. read more

Pizza Gourmet Restaurant - 18" Plain Pie minus 2 Slices - Italian Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

It was really good! Perfect for a quick bite. Definitely recommend getting the classic Grandma Style pizza. I've been thinking about it for days. Also, the Pasta Fagioli tasted just like my dads! So good!! read more

Lame. 1:20 to deliver a quarter mile away. No courtesy call to say it's late. No apology when I called to see where it was. Mediocre pizza - terrible service. read more

This place is like a little slice of Sicily. Really authentic and has amazing food, especially pizza. My favorite being the focaccia slices. Great options to chose from and the friendliest service around. The owner and his employees are fantastic. A+ restaurant!!! read more

Super authentic Italian and an important community staple. Great entrepreneurial spirit, quality ingredients and yummy food. Their Grandma pizza is the best. Love the staff, so much personality. Really delighted that they are surviving COVID-19 times. read more

Got delivery-pizza and pasta were ok, but there is better in the area. Brown lettuce in the salad, cheese stuck to the lid of the pizza box because there was no plastic piece to hold it up, way too much parsley in the pasta.... Sloppy. Try villa Maria for pizza and Leonardo's for pasta. read more

I had good pizza and focaccia when I was in the location, however when ordering pizza for delivery The pizzas arrived cold and tasteless, and we live pretty close from the restaurant. It's like they took them from the restaurant showcase, like we don't know, and also a bit overpriced. I don't mind to pay for fresh warm pizzas but it was kind of a rip off. I don't knot if I will call them again. read more

Phils special salad with chicken is delicious. One of my favorite spots to grab a salad and a slice. Everyone is friendly and makes you feel at home. I love that they have a waitress even though it's a small seating area. Never disappointed. read more

These guys have been around for a while, and it shows- they aim to please. This is the spot for a slice and a glass of vino!

Great pizza. Delevery always quick, never physically ate there. Loved their white pizza. But have tried many and was never dissapointed. The delivery men we always nice and never a smart ass teenager, which was great. Prices were ok for what you get. read more