This was the best pizza ever! I usually have to eat my pizza with a fork but this one was baked to perfection and as delicious as can be! It was ready for pick-up at the given time! I will definately be back! Thankyou for the expertise! I love your pizza! Yum! Carrie read more

We really like Romeo's breadsticks the plain ones with a little bit of Parmesan. They seem to do them just right there! They don't overcook them and they make them to your liking too. read more

i've ordered from here before and never had problems! i love they're pizza one of my favs. but yesterday i ordered and the second i bit into a slice i knew something wasn't right. it made me very sick. i'm not sure if it was undercooked but i did not feel good afterwards. read more

So, after my "we're done with this place" review in January, we decided to see if any changes were made. They STILL don't have their fryer hood fixed so we tried a pizza. And, in fairness, it was as good as it used to be in the past--and that's VERY VERY good. If they hit that quality mark every time it would be awesome. Based on this we will try them again soon. Yes, it was great, but it was just one pizza. Trust me when I say we're keeping our fingers crossed that this experience reflects real change and will once again become the norm. read more

Ordered delivery at 8:15 pm Got a call at 9:20 that there were no drivers. Had to go pick the pizza up. NEVER AGAIN!

I have been a rewards member for years. Decided to do a on-line special with 20% off tonight. Since it was my first time ordering on-line I had a few questions so just called the Broadview Heights location. Dennis helped me our and I placed my order. There was no place for "comments" so I called Dennis again after placing the order and requested our order be "baked light", as we normally do. He said no problem "I see your order". Arrived in 30 minutes to beautifully baked calzone & stromboli & bone in wings. Excellent price for what we received. Dennis helped me out to the car with the 3 boxes. Very friendly staff and always good food, especially their thin crust pizzas. Thank you again Dennis. See you next time! Carol T. read more

The Romeo's on Broadview rd is terrible. I made an order for delivery and waited almost 2 hours and it didn't show up. Had My daughter with me who was very hungry. Turns out the delivery driver delivered it to the wrong house !!! So I Called to complain and the person who took my call threatened to hang up and void my order because I was upset. Terrible customer service.... 1/21/2024 ordered wings for delivery... they arrived cold as if they just came out of the fridge. Don't order from here there customer service is terrible read more

Why 4 stars? Because it was our go-to for convenience. --- --- --- I was staying at my Grandmother's house in Broadview Heights for about a week during the NBA Finals. Broadview Heights is not exactly a haven for local business, and Romeo's is located conveniently on the way to I-77 from my grandma's house. Because of all of those factors, we probably ended up here 3 or 4 times during my Cleveland trip. We actually only had pizza one time, and went with sandwiches on all the other visits. Each sandwich and pizza that I tried was the definition of 4-stars: solid. Not bad, not amazing, but solid. But again, the convenience factor is strong here. We would call 15 minutes ahead, and our food would be waiting for us upon arrival. If you're looking for the convenience of fast food, without the low quality, Romeo's is your answer. read more

The Romeo's on Broadview rd is terrible. I made an order for delivery and waited almost 2 hours and it didn't show up. Had My daughter with me who was very hungry. Turns out the delivery driver delivered it to the wrong house !!! So I Called to complain and the person who took my call threatened to hang up and void my order because I was upset. Terrible customer service read more

We loved this pizza! Homemade dough and just the right mix of sauce, cheese, and topping. Tasted a lot like Marcos but better. Very reasonable prices. The stuffed crust with 1 topping was $16 but he gave us $3 off , being nice, because we had asked about a special. I wasn't too impressed with the amount of cheese in the stuffed crust though. Would have liked more. All in all , happy. Friday night pick up was quick and easy. Would go there again. Maybe try something new! read more

Ordered the pepperoni feast I guess$20 wil get you a regular pepperoni pizza! It's sad this use to be a good pizza place now it's over priced and underwhelming! I'd give one star but it's still edible but not what was anticipated, I imagine they'll follow pizza fire! read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broadview Heights, Ohio

I ordered online and received the most delicious meatball pizza in only 20 min. It was hot and fresh with lots of cheese and was a well balanced flavor. The sauce is sweet but I liked it. The meatballs are seasoned nicely for flavor. It was also not overly greasy like some pizza places can be. The crust is thick and tastes like homemade bread. I gave them 4 stars because although the pizza is delicious... The pizza I had in New York City will always be the 5 star one. But since I live in Ohio it's my new favorite pizza place! read more

Romeo's Pizza - Delicious meatball sub! Ordered delivery online and got it in 20 min! - Pizza Near Me - Broadview Heights, Ohio

Well, we love Romeo's. We are a bread loving family, so their think crust and sweet sauce is our fav. And the garlic sauce is better than Papa John's. read more

Few things shut down my appetite like witnessing someone vomiting or even seeing puke. I don't know. Maybe it's just me but I find it really objectionable. Even the smell is troubling. Other reviewers might say Romeo's Pizza is too sweet or has unpleasant off-flavors associated with their pizza, but after a long hot day dealing with people fighting airborne pathogenic infection, it really can hit the spot. I stopped by the other day on the way out of Broadview Heights and decided to grab a large pizza. Or two. You see, they have some interesting and unusual offerings including one called 'the butcher shop' that has a lot of meat on it (cooked) and another called 'the ranch lover's chicken pizza' that replaces cheese with ranch dressing and comes with a generous amount of little nubs of chicken. It has a shiny glaze to it that you would not expect from a pizza slathered in salad dressing. I got one of each. I know what you're thinking. I ordered too much and we're going to come full-circle on the clever vomit intro, but hold your literary presumption. The pizzas were awesome! The meat pizza did in fact evoke thoughts of a place where meat primals are broken down into component cuts and I really did find myself loving the idea of a house without an upstairs while gutting down slices of the salad dressing pizza. Both types were tasty and worked well to trick my hypothalamus into forgetting the day's wretchedness. When I finished my meal, everything smelled like pizza to me instead of smelling like vomit. I even had enough for leftovers the next day! If I can enjoy it after a day like I had, no one grinding through the day in day out horror of postmodern social and environmental degradation within the constraints of Broadview Heights could look up with mouth full and not say, "This pizza tastes great!" read more

Let me just say, I'm a pizza fanatic. I'm constantly trying new places and I have officially hit the Jack pot. I was rather confused when I first opened my box and saw sauce on top. I thought they mixed up my pizza with someone else's. I then noticed the cheese and was like hm... This is a perplexing pizza. I took a bite and said a few astonished profanities at the awesomeness that my tastebuds had just experienced. By far, the best pizza I have had in the area. (and I've had about 10 or 12 places in the Cleveland area) seriously, check this place out. Even if you're anti-chain. You are missing out on phenomenal pizza. read more

Placed an order for several pizzas over an hour ago, and the lady on the other line said it would be 30 minutes. We were on our way to a concert and they claimed our order never went through, we purposefully waited to pick up this for dinner and they claimed it never went through. Everyone in my family was very upset about the poor customer service. When we told them about what happened, there was no apology or concern for the inconvenience that they had intimated. read more

Best pizza in the area. Always fresh and delicious. Love the margarita pizza highly recommend it. Also really enjoy their wings they are small and perfect wing size. read more

they did not have my order ready on time , had me wait for half an hour. my order was entered in the system for next day pick up. employee was not apologetic or offer anything to compensate read more

You either love sweet sauce, or you hate it. The people you hate it, should just steer clear of this place and stop hating on the pizza itself, because Romeos has the best pizza ever! If by any chance you don't like sweet sauce, you have GOT to try the Great Ranch Potato pizza, it has a ranch bacon sauce with sausage, potato, carmalized onion and ranch dusted almonds. It is the best pizza I have ever tried! I've been going to this location for about three years and they never disappoint! read more

See all

The pizza is actually my favorite pizza in the area, however, I had to stop ordering from Romeo's about 5 years ago because they could not get my order correct. They ended up giving me credit to use for future orders, and couldn't get those orders correct. 5 years later, I have a baby. Sleep can be hard to come by, and I often don't have time or energy to cook. I finally decided the management and staff must have changed over in the past several years, so surely by now they know how to read. A few weeks ago, I ordered a standard veggie pizza with broccoli and pepperoni added. I got a pizza with just broccoli and pepperoni. I called and they sent me a new pizza. Tonight, the same exact effing thing happened. I waited 75 minutes and received a pizza with broccoli and pepperoni. I called and spoke to the manager. She said it would be 45 minutes to an hour to get a new one. Since I had already waited well over an hour to get the wrong order and was now starving, I said that was unacceptable. She then offered to also refund my money, so I said fine, I'd wait. An hour and 5 minutes later, I called back. The manager had decided to just refund my money and not send me a new pizza. At this point, I lost my absolute bananas with her on the phone, and she hung up on me. I can't say I didn't deserve that, but honestly... now I'm eating cold broccoli and pepperoni pizza that's been sitting around for over an hour. If you don't mind paying a premium price to get a fraction of what you ordered, or receiving a complete mystery grab bag of whatever the hell pizza they decided to make, you'll be happy! read more

Romeos is our place to go for good, solid American style pizza. We love the great Ranch and Potato Pizza. Its not cheap, but its not expensive either. Also enjoy a number of the other specialty pizzas and they deliver and I have not had them mess up my order ever. Of my pizza dollars, Romeo's gets the most and deservedly so. read more

We stayed at the Sheraton at the airport and couldn't muster the will to leave again, so we ordered delivery from Romeos. It arrived 10 minutes ahead of schedule (in 40 minutes, not bad) and we tucked in. When I am out trying pizza, I normally stick will plain pepperoni or pep and mush. On this trip, I had my mom with me so we went for the traditional crust (not too thin, not too thick) with 1/2 pep & mush and 1/2 grn pep, onion and mush. The pizza was very lovely. Nice and brown. Upon picking up a slice, I smelled...something...smoke? Now I don't know what this is coming from. Is the pepperoni smoked? I don't know. And I think that is what got the 3 star review from me. I am not a fan of smoked meats or whatnot. I feel like that smell/flavor is phony. I would also say that they are a shade stingy on the cheese. If I had to do it again I would get a cheese pizza with extra cheese. Moms side with the veggies was good, she said. It is often a problem with getting the veggies done, and she said they could have been a little more cooked. The breadsticks were ok, but we ordered with cheese and we couldn't tell if the cheese was on there, maybe another instance of the stingy cheese disease. BOIL IT DOWN: it was ok for whatever we could get delivered to the hotel...not bad. Sweet sauce, good crust, GET EXTRA CHEESE. read more

WOW! The food and service were great! We ordered a ton of different items for a party and the pasta was wonderful the breadsticks "with marinara" were soft and warm and the pizza was to die for. We finally have a pizza shop worth eating at in the Broadview Hts area. They delivered to my family's house in North Royalton and were there is less than a half hr. I am convinced that they will give Antonio's a run for their money. I am sold on their product and they won over a former Antonio's customer. Keep up the good work!! read more

One of my favorite pizzas. I've been ordering from the store since it opened. On the whole, most of the staff are friendly and try to do a good job. The only negative is that I've had a few errors, relatively minor, on my orders over the last couple years, and they (not just one individual) seem resistant to making it right. I don't have that issue with other places, typically, and certainly not consistently. Fix that and it'd be 5 stars. I still go back because I like it, but not everyone will be that forgiving. They are good at having it ready when promised. read more

I love Romeo's sauce! Some people say it's too sweet, but personally I really like it! If you like a sweeter sauce, romeos is for you

Great pizza, the prices are very reasonable. Great service on delivery and carry out. I couldn't really tell you what's my favorite food item here because we order different stuff each time. What i can say for sure is the steak topping should be everyone's go to topping if you're not sure, its soo good! Not far from home, just simply good! read more

We love the pizza. My wife is from Buffalo and says this pizza is the best in Cleveland. The sauce is sweeter but that's what makes it so good. read more

Great pizza, Id say on par with Rosas. Always an easy place to online order. The online order makes it very easy to custom order your pizza, which is something many places lack. read more

First, I do want to point out that I noticed all the bad reviews for Romeo's were put on filter, hmmmmmm .... I guess that means this review will be filtered as well since it won't be a good review, lol. Sorry Romeos, I have to agree with the 2 reviewers in saying that your sauce is way too sweet. I couldn't even finish the pizza. Thumbs down big time. I'll stick with Antonio's! read more

First off when i called, whoever answered was chewing gum loudly in my ear. after she took my order and address, she said "ok" and hung up. Didnt tell me how long or anything. Then the delivery guy shows up with a gyro and a small salad and says i owe him 25 bucks....that wasnt even half my order! So he comes back 10 minutes later with the rest....and the breadsticks had no marinara which the lovely girl on the phone smaking her gum in my ear assured me it came with. We called to complain, but were put on hold for almost 10 minutes before we hung up. I would definitely NOT recommend going here read more

While I am a pizza snob and totally favor the Chicago pizza styes- deep dish, stuffed, and thin, I do love Romeo's. The sauce does it.

Not impressed at all. The sauce was way too sweet and that just totally ruined the pizza! My family of five all agreed that it wasn't good and both my husband and I couldn't even finish our first slice b/c of that sauce. read more

Broadview Heights Romeo's - Phone off the hook on Fri night - really??? We love the pizza and wings and have been getting delivery fairly regularly on Fri or Sat for the last 2 months, since we moved to our present location. Tonight, when I called repeatedly, got a busy signal. Pretty peeved, as I was not planning to cook tonight. My warm and fuzzy "call Romeo's" feeling is gone. :( read more

Poor customer service received at this location. The pizza isn't bad but I won't suggest going to Romeo's after being treated rudely by an employee. read more