Romeo's is my go-to for Strombolis, calzones, and delicious pizza! I usually get the Stromboli with salami and green peppers--always a solid choice. My friends and I split a half Hawaiian, half cheese pizza, which tasted great, but there was a bit too much sauce, and the square cut made the toppings slide off. Minor issues aside, I'll definitely keep coming back! read more

See all

Got the deep dish and an antipasto salad. Was fantastic. Great quality and really enjoy the sweet sauce. Not bitter like most.

This is my favorite pizza joint close to home. Tonight I tried the cauliflower crust which I've never tried anywhere. It is delicious. I love their pizza sauce which is on the sweeter side. They always have great specials and I've never been disappointed! read more

See all

Picked up a pizza at the new Romeo's in Georgetown, Texas tonight. It was ok. I've had better and worse. Another customer noted in a review that the sauce was a little too sweet. I agree! I think that's what made it taste like a frozen pizza. It was worth trying something new. And, the staff and owners I do believe were there and extremely nice and helpful which seems to be lacking these days. Good customer service! I will try them again and wish them the best. Crank down the sweetness in the sauce! Good luck with your new business. read more

Sweet sauce great crust nothing else like it!can make a drunk man and sober woman happy!

For some reason, you have to tell them not to overcook or burn the calzones and thin crust pizza. See pics for details.

Well, I've NEVER had a pizza joint charge me multiple times until my account came up NSF! Too bad they can't operate a business or take care of their customers. Additionally they refused to give the number for a regional or district manager to make this fuck up right. Police are now involved. Folks you may want to double check your bank statements if you've purchased here. Their follow up customer service was a bullshit hack job that basically blamed us for their fuck up. No class, shitty wings, overpriced pizza and half-assed customer service. There is an open police report on file against this particular store. You've been warned. Oh, and I still had to contact my bank branch because the charge was STILL trying to post in my account. read more

Romeo's Pizza - If you call THIS number take cash. - Pizza Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

Love the sauce they put on the pizza. A little sweet which we like. A great ground sausage.

Ordered a steak sandwich. Asking for dressing on side. Swimming in dressing. Ummmm what I got was a BREAD sandwich. No steak on this thing whatsoever. I'm going to call and get corporates #. This is ridiculous. If this entire sandwich had 2 oz of meat on-- that would be generous. "Begnets" were burnt. ????!!!!!!! I just never learn. I'm getting a refund. The deep dish pizza is good, when they don't make it soggy. Get a grip ppl. This isn't rocket science. read more

Pasta Review This no seating at this location - take out or delivery... you choose :-) Phone Order - friendly and quick. This is the first week of their "Create Your Own Pasta Bowl" and the order taker was super careful to get it right. Pick Up - It took a couple of extra minutes, but the counter help was friendly, apologized, and handled the payment quickly. Jo Jo's - generous pile of well seasoned potato segments... not too much salt... covered in shredded cheddar and a few bacon bits that tasted real. There was one lone catsup packet on top of almost 2 large potatoes worth of segments - if you are heading to Blossom... bring your own! Side Salad - Well stuffed with iceberg, carrot, purple cabbage, red onion, tomato, cucumbers and olives. Pieces are rather large and hearty... pack a steak knife to carve it down. Marzetti dressing (with corn syrup) is included. Hubby's Pasta Bowl - Rigatoni, Alfredo and Baked mozzarella - he finished half, enjoyed it, but commented that the sauce tasted commercial. His baked moz. evenly covered the entire dish. My Pasta Bowl - 9 cheese ravioli were more than I could finish. I couldn't really taste the baked mozzarella as all of the cheeses ran together. There was no asiago or Romano to break up the ricotta / parm blandness. Not really any garlic to mention even. Garlic Bread - individually wrapped 6 inch pieces that stayed warm for the 5 mile ride home. VERY buttery and garlicy. We will try other things at this location, but wouldn't order the Alfredo again. read more

Pizza was cold and took 2 hours to be delivered, Pickerington location is not very good.

always a fantastic place to grab a high quality pie!!!! Dont let a $5 pizza fool you. This pizza is WELL worth the money!!! Must try to Great Ranch Potato Pizza read more

I haven't had their pizza but if you're in the area and want a hot submarine sandwich then browse Romeos menu to see what you think. I ordered a godfather sub over the phone and they told me that it would be ready in 15 minutes for the price of what I think was 6.99. When I arrived they were sill assembling my sub. Upon arriving home I unwrapped my sub and took my first bite. It was very good for what I paid! This sub is extremely greasy, so beware! Get lots of napkins. read more

If I could give 0 stars I would, horrible service! ordered at 6:06, 2 pizzas for my family, told 45 minutes, at 7:15, over an hour later, we had to call to ask where it was, at 7:28 it shows up cold! The managers response was, what else do you want me to do I already offered you 50% off your next order. There and no, I'm sorry we will get 2 fresh ones right out to you, nope, just we took your order and then got a bunch more so we were slammed.....well that isnt my problem, my problem is cold pizza delivered 45 minutes late. will not be ordering from there again read more

Very poor customer service. I have been a long time customer and always say great things about this pizza, however the last 3 times ordering from here, something with the order has gone wrong and when I call to talk to a manager she\he has no time to speak to me. I will be taking my weekly business else where and will suggest to others they do the same. This is not a place that values it's customers. read more

This location is so inconsistent. One time the pizza is perfect... Next time they make it totally wrong. And please don't have any issues that you need to talk to a manager about ..... Because the young girl they call a "manager" couldn't be less of one. She rude and not helpful at all. She sounds like a complete ditz on the phone. She has a very passive aggressive personality about her and it's very unbecoming. She's one of the reasons we don't order from there anymore. We've had at least 4 orders made wrong and we don't complain. But when we call in to complain--- she then scolds us for not calling in right away to correct the problem. (Sorry, I work all day and my daughter doesn't like doing that kind of thing ) It just makes me upset that they don't care. We ordered with our loyalty points today and the pizza was extremely sub-par. We always order the deep dish and it wasn't a deep dish. It looked more to be just a regular pizza with the sauce on top. Idk. I don't think I would get so upset if I wasn't spending in the upwards of $18-20 each time. Bcuz the stupid pizza is all mainly dough and that's like 100% profit for them. So I expect it to be made well. This is a chain run by little girls and young ppl that could care less about their jobs. It evident because of how they treat their customers. Oh well... That's life. Take it how u want it. read more

Seriously excellent pizzas. I haven't tried them all, but this is about as good as it gets for delivery around Cuyahoga Falls.

Extremely overpriced. You're better off buy a frozen pizza from the store. I'd rate the food a C- it's nothing but a little below average food. The customer service I'd rate a D- the workers act like you are bothering them when you call and/or walk in. read more

We ordered pizza (new to Ohio, and looking for a good pizza co.) and was told online it would be a 50 minute wait. It was over and hour+ wait and the pizza was cold and the cheese was hard. The crust had the same feel as the cardboard box. I was so disappointed and will never order from Romeo's again. We threw it in the trash....what a waste of $24 for a pepperoni pizza. read more

I usually get a sub, which is amazing. their Italian dressing is phenomenal. the pizza is the best around though. sauce is easily the best part and I usually don't even like sauce on my pizza. only 4 stars though because they are pretty expensive for a pizza place. read more

I have always loved Romeo's but tonight their customer service was less than desirable. I placed a large order which included boneless wings. Although online I am pretty sure I selected Teriyaki with sauce on wings they told me when I called that the manager said he was not bringing sauce because I only said I wanted sauce on wings. When I came in and my order wasn't even ready not one person asked about it. I called because I now how 24 chicken nuggets with no sauce, I was basically told too bad. Sad that my weekly patronage to this store means nothing, with orders average $50-60. They have now lost my business, there are plenty of other pizza places that I am sure will like my weekly order. read more

This was the worst pizza & boneless wings that I have ever ordered. I don't understand what has changed, but any pizza I have ordered in the past was good. Today, the boneless wings were worse than frozen Tyson chicken nuggets with some hot sauce on them. The pizza was horrible. It was a deluxe, but only had burnt, tiny bits of pepper, onion & mushrooms on it. There was hardly any sausage or cheese. The crust was the weirdest I have ever tasted. I ordered thin crust, but it was like they used the thin crust recipe, but made it a thick crust. It was an awful consistency. I will never order from there again. read more

Excellent pizza and an overall excellent customer experience! The employees were gracious and accommodating even though I arrived late to pick up my pizza. read more