This is a review of their single slice pizza. I visited on two occasions several months apart. The first time I visited, I got a double slice and the second time I visited I got a single slice. You can get a single for three dollars or a double slice for five dollars at the time of this review. I got a pepperoni slice each visit. The pizza sits in a three story heated unit on their front desk. They did not warm up the slice in the oven before giving it to me. The slice was warm. The bottom crust was flimsy, no crisp. The cheese was a bit strong and chewy and had a milky flavor. The sauce was lacking some. They put spices on the slice that added flavor. read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - Single slice - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

This is the second time we have ordered from this location the service and product has always been top shelf...just my opinion....good pizza. read more

Enjoyed the apple bacon salad and boneless wings. Both items were delicious in their own right. Wings were hot . Service and del was fast. read more

I am way overdue on this review. We don't order out often, but still manage to get T T at least once every couple of months and last night, for the Super Bowl, was one of those times. I ordered online actually the night before and scheduled the pickup for 5:45pm. This experience is a great summary of the typical experience I have with these guys: fast, friendly service (even on a very busy day), food ready, quick checkout, food perfectly made and accurate. And I want to emphasize that friendliness part. They are always friendly and appreciative of the business. And the food is always spot on. They are a can't miss as far as I'm concerned. I never have any concerns ordering from them. read more

Probably my absolute favorite place to order pizza. They have so many different fun sauces and they are ALL GOOD. Have yet to try a pizza I don't like here. read more

Ordered the Thai calamari from the cuyahoga falls location It was 18.00 for a tiny box My coworker told me the stow location charges 14.00 and gives you a larger portion No more cuyahoga falls twisted tomato for us Very disappointed read more

Pleasantly surprised by the pie we got on Sunday before the football game. We ordered a large thin crust with Twisted sauce, Jalapeños, salami and roasted red pepper. The crust was very good. Cooked very well and was chewy. The toppings were good. Plenty of fresh jalapeños! I would have liked more roasted red peppers but they were good. Salami was a nice alternative to pepperoni. The sauce worked with the heat but I'll try a different sauce next time. The order was ready when I arrived and was piping hot. Friendly worker chatted a bit. Nice! read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - you want a piece of me? two slices $ 20 00 - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

See all

We tried a pickle pizza and a Cajun veggie pizza and both were VERY good. I'm looking forward to the next one soon.

Easily our favorite pizza place. We live in Akron but we always order from the Cuyahoga Falls location through their website and pick it up ourselves. Great service and such good food! If they have the jalapeno mac bites, order two, trust me. Their jojos are also *perfect.* They are exactly what you want from a jojo! Salty and crispy outside, SUPER hot and soft inside, just excellent. Our usual is a large with the white garlic sauce, extra cheese, onion, green pepper, and black olive. Their regular red sauce and sweet tomato sauce are also fantastic; you really can't go wrong. Give them a try, fall in love. read more

They increased their prices by quite a bit since opening. The sheet pizzas were a pretty good price when opening. Now they are ridiculous!

Best pizza in the area, couldn't tell the difference in the original and cauliflower crust very well done. read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - Cauliflower Crust w/ Chicken, Italian Sausage, Pepperoni and fresh Mozzarella, thin crust well done with Garlic Butter Sauce - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

Ever since I moved here, I have been looking for a pizza place that delivers delicious calzones like the ones I would get at georgios or guys pizza where I used to live. Well it took 5 months but I finally found it. Twisted tomato it is! Although the one in Akron won't deliver to me (I'm in North Hill area) because I'm too far away and the first time I ordered from the Cuyahoga Falls location they said I was within their delivery zone so no issues but the second time they said I wasn't so I was confused but they said they would do it if they weren't busy. So I don't know what happened there. So Kayla and I ordered a regular calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms and 2 sides of garlic butter and 1 side of marinara. We also got the calamari because Kayla insists on trying calamari from anywhere she can. Both times there was nothing missing or messed up from our order and everything was DELICIOUS. Kayla said the calamari was one of the best she's ever had! Hopefully they continue to deliver to us because I finally found a calzone worth paying for in the area! read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - Regular Calzone - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

See all

I log this place. I ordered at the one in Stow and tasted great! I defintely would recommend way better than a big chain restaurant. Tastes real and fresh. read more

See all

I tried Twisted Tomato Pizzeria the other night and I had mixed reviews about my experience. Ordering process: I order my food via their webpage since both GrubHub and Uber Eats did not have the full menu available. The menu on the website it a little hard to navigate but the selection of food items is really good. I think there is probably something for everyone if you are wanting something other than pizza. Food: once we received our delivery I thought that the pizza was very good. We ordered a sausage and roasted red pepper pizza on traditional crust with twisted tomato sauce. The overall quality and taste were very good and the twisted sauce was slightly spicy but not over spicy. We also ordered the chicken tenders and fries. They were good but not our cup of tea. The tenders were very large, so you get a good amount for the cost. The fries that came with them were not as good. Slightly greasy and under cooked. Wait time and delivery: the delivery man was very nice and provided us with excellent service. My only issues with this restaurant and what would make me consider not ordering again would be 1- the wait time was outrageous. The website said my order would arrive in 30min. I was skeptical and assumed it would be more like an hour. At an hour and a half from ordering I had to call to get an update. My food had yet to leave for delivery. 2- once the food arrived the pizza was warm but not hot like I would have hoped and expected. Other than those last items mentioned, I think this is a good Pizzaria and would consider ordering again... this time picking up my order. read more

Ordered from this place a few times and the food is always on point. This time I ordered bbq wings antipasto salad with a medium chicken pot pie pizza and mmm good!! read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - Chicken pot pie pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

The staff was very friendly and the service was top notch. Since I am a vegetarian, they let me sub out the meat for other toppings, which many other places would not allow you to do that. I ordered the pesto pie (forgot what it's called on the menu) and spaghetti calzone (again forgot what it's called on the menu ). Both of the dishes were really good, but too greasy for me (only reason it's not a five star). If you enjoy very heavy dishes with a lot of cheese this is the place for you!! If you do not, then I would ask them to go easy on the cheese. Overall, I highly recommend trying this place. It offers many different dishes to try, so I will be going back for sure. The price is little expensive, but they do load their dishes with toppings. read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - Pesto pie - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

See all

I would compare this to any frozen pizza you buy in the grocery store. I ordered a think crust well done and what I got a was a doughy floppy mess that was overloaded with cheese and greasy beyond comprehension. I ordered pepperoni and there were chunks of pepper in the pizza. just was so bad. I ate a slice and threw the rest away. I can't remember the last time I ordered a pizza this bad read more

I'm banging my head against the wall with this place I get a response back here on yelp from the owner Brad I ordered food March 4 2025 never received my order Door Dash stole my food I was supposed to be refunded my money the general manager refunded a woman that has the same four last digits of my credit card it was refunded back to a Visa for 23.70 I made my purchase on a Mastercard for 45.00 so the wrong person with a totally different credit card got a refund not me I keep calling the owners twisted tomato in Cuyahoga Falls he is purposely not calling me back so I can explain the situation I saved the refund text on my phone which I will be glad to show him but obviously he does not want to pay me my money back so door dash had dinner on me and Brad pocketed my money and I got nothing this is bad business his genius general manager credits the wrong person for an order they had placed in October think twice about eating here all I can say is dumb and dumber I don't like being ripped off my first time ordering from this place what an experience read more

Formerly Guy's Pizza, before going independent in 2020-- and what a great move, because the food only got better! They took everything great about Guy's and improved on it. The pizza sauce is tastier, the toppings got better, the crust is on par with Gionino's. Twisted Tomato is easily the best pizza shop in the Falls-- excited to try some of their new additions to the menu next! read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - The classic pepperoni pizza. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

This was the absolute worst experience. I ordered my food for pick up at noon. I waited for 40 minutes inside the Akron location. I never received my order. I'll never go back. read more

I'm a disgruntled New Yorker when it comes to OH pizza, but I'm quite happy with the pizza I just got. I will definitely be coming back again! read more

I ordered for Tuesday March 4 in the evening I did not know they use Door Dash well Door Dash never showed up with my food so I called the restaurant they said they would refund my credit card I did not receive the refund I called the the restaurant Thursday March 6 the manager on duty refused to process my refund he said it was not his problem Door Dash ripped me off he totally lied to me saying only the general manager can do refunds no one else is allowed to do them I talked to the restaurant Thursday evening the manager that supposedly did my refund said he was the one who helped her do the refund all I can say is if you want to have delivery don't order from this place they only use Door Dash and Door Dash are nothing but thieves now this place has turned me off I know I was ripped off on purpose because DD was supposed to call me when they were on the way this place is too cheap to hire there own delivery people so they use DD in read more

Really enjoyed this pizza! When I first saw the size of the box I was somewhat disappointed until I picked it up and realized how heavy the pizza was. Good dense dough with a perfectly crispy crust. Not shy on the toppings either read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - Large pepperoni and sausage pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

Having just moved to the falls, me and the hubby were trying to find a new favorite new York style pizza. We tried one other place and liked it ok, but realized there was a place even closer to where we lived. So we decided to give it and shot and... immediately we are in love with this little pizza shop. New York style pizza is a GIANT pizza so it's great to get when you're entertaining guests and want to surprise them with gigantic slices of pizza. The sauce is slightly sweet and I really like it. Of course their normal sized pizzas are just as good I'm pretty sure one week we ordered from them three times lol. I will say too sometimes they get busy and don't correctly estimate their pick up times. They go live on Facebook on Fridays and spin a wheel for specials. That's kinda cute! Definitely a place to try for pizza lovers. Who needs pizza hut?? Go to twisted tomato! read more

Owner was rude my fiancé and I have been ordering from them for a while now and we ordered tonight for dinner and when we got home we saw that our steak roll wasn't as good as it usually was so my fiancé called up to tell them and the owner was nothing but rude to him. We just want you to do good! But now you won't be getting our money anymore! Learn better customer service please. Just horrible. read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - No steak the owner was rude and will never receive our business again was a jerk - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

Great pizza and cinn pops Love everything. Ive had here so far

order pizza Saturday evening small cheese pizza with JoJo's the pizza was so chewy you could barely chew or eat it. The JoJo were burnt due to. They were down to one fire instead of my order taken 45 minutes to an hour and 45 minutes so just letting you know I'm more likely that I probably won't come back like to discuss this my name Steve give me a call at 330-389-0412. read more

TL;DR This is a great little pizza and pasta shop run by some great people. Definitely our go-to pizza place in the area. Haven't had a bad speciality pizza yet, great weekly specials, good prices, and good service. This used to be a guys pizza, but now has a cooler name and more freedom to make awesome food. They have tons of pizza and pasta options, including a monthly speciality pizza that rotates. One of our favorite weekly specials is "Wing Wednesday" where boneless wings are $0.60 a piece, no limit and tons of yummy sauces to choose from. They also do a fun rotating special on Friday and Saturday where they spin a wheel - just gotta check their Facebook page for the video. Presto pesto is definitely my favorite speciality pizza - highly recommend it. The pesto pasta is one of my favorites as well. The managers are also super cool and have started doing "make your own pizza" kits for the kiddos for the pandemic for $10, as well as a "pay it forward" program where people can donate pizzas and money to others. This is a great small business run by caring people who take pride in their pizza! I highly recommend giving them a shot. read more

Placed order at 6:25pm online. The system said we would have delivery by 6:49pm. It's now 9:20pm. No food. I've left several voicemails on their answering service - no response. No updates. Nothing. Won't be ordering from them again as this is not the first time we've been through this with them. read more

Our first time ordering pizza from Twisted Tomatoes... we were very happy with the quality of the pizza! Crust was perfect, contents were just right, flavor was delicious. Delivery was slower than expected, but the food was well worth the wait. The zuccini sidedish was delicious as well. This is definitely our order out place from now on! read more

This is not handmade pizza. I watched the young lady make my pizza. The dough was premade.

Chicken dinner was really good. The only request I had was an all Dark dinner and the employee denied the request. I asked to pay a little more to fill the request and again it was denied. Everyone else who served chicken in the area offers all dark or all white along with mixed. read more

Ordered a pizza tonight and they said it be at our place in 30 minutes. We didn't get it until 2.5 hours later. Not even an apology or a discount. Just a tough luck. If they could have advised us it would take longer than usual from the get go it be different but they never did. We didn't get the delivery until we threatened to cancel and then it came 19 minutes later. We used to order here all the time but never again after tonight. read more

We ordered Peter Piper Pickle pizza and chicken Hawaiian heat pizza. The pickle pizza was amazing! The white sauce, garlic and pickles came together perfectly. Why isn't pickle pizza more popular?! The Hawaiian pizza was good as well. The seasoned chicken and jalapeños added a great touch. I will definitely be back for more pickle pizza!! read more

Very good. Loved the twisted tomato sauce. Def going to go back. You can def is taste the difference. Very Zesty. Can you buy this in a jar? read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - Sausage and onion with twisted tomato sauce - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

See all

I had a mushroom and banana pepper calzone, and it was absolutely delicious! The sauce was fantastic as well. I also ordered two cannolis and they were also tasty! read more

Great pizza for our area. We tried PIG OUT, PETER PIPER PICKLE PIZZA, and NESSA MARGHERITA. How and delicious! Chewy crust! We felt like the sauce was a little bit more greasy(specifically the white garlic sauce) than we preferred, but great fresh ingredients! Uses quality ingredients for the price. My toddlers LOVED the pickle pizza! The "chop" on the ingredients in Pig Out meant that every bite had a combo of flavors. The Nessa had a sweeter balsamic and sauce. And it was AMAZING!!!! read more

No fancy review needed. Great pizza lots of stuff on the menu my hubby can't wait to try the wings. We just got a pesto pizza and can't wait to go back and try more. Very happy to have to have this pizza place in our neighborhood. We went back and got the pickle pizza! It does not disappoint. read more

I ordered a calzone and a 4 piece chicken and jojos. DELICIOUS! The calzone took me 3 days to finish, I sent my best friend this picture & she said it looked like stuffed breadsticks that come separately. Oh this was my first time ordering Twisted Tomato Pizzeria, & I will for sure be ordering again. The chicken was crispy & not too greasy, the jojos are thinner but crispy and still have potato in the middle. Super good, can't wait to try other stuff. read more

Twisted Tomato Pizzeria - Calzone - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio

Great local pizza business! Owner is really nice and is a great local business with some unique pizza offerings. Love the rotating monthly special pizza (check their Facebook page to see the monthly special) I recommend trying the Pickle pizza with Alfredo sauce! read more