While planning our trip to Italy, the first place on my list to check out was Roscioli because my friend told me it was the best carbonara he's ever had in his life. Conveniently, it was one of the only restaurants in Rome that I could find that took online reservations in advance, so I was able to snag an 11AM spot. When we got there, a long line was already forming out the door. At first I figured it was just a big group of walk-ins but then when I talked to the host it turns out every single person in line had a reservation. We waited in line for the doors to open, and it sucked because there really wasn't much organization. There were a few people blatantly cutting, and it was frustrating to still have to wait even though we planned way ahead. We ended up getting the second table from the door.
Service/Ambiance: Roscioli was like a deli that was known for amazing pastas and charcuterie. The layout of the tables was extremely crowded, and ours was right next to a wall of wine bottles, across from the deli counter. The service was super frustrating too because it's not like they were taking everyone's order around the same time. The people who were in front of us in line were already getting their first course before we even got a menu. It's like they were processing each table in a single line, and didn't talk to the other tables until that table was completely ordered. It was about 45 minutes between when we sat down and when we got our first dish. We typically fast eaters, especially compared to other tourists and locals, and even our lunch took about 3 hours, purely due to the slow service.
Food: I had some high expectations because everyone was raving about this place. With the popularity also came the tourist pricing. It was about twice the price of any other meal we had in Rome, and I wouldn't say it was even on par with some of the other dishes we had at other restaurants. I personally thought Roscioli was overrated and overhyped.
Pan e coperto: They gave a huge basket of freshly baked bread of different varieties. They had schiacciata, honey rye, some sort of fig and olive loaf, and then my personal favorite: the bacon bread! It literally had pieces of bacon distributed throughout. They also gave us a plate of softened ricotta cheese drizzled with olive oil and pepper, which was a great spread to the bread.
Caprese salad: I'm not a big salad fan, but this actually looked pretty good. Thick slices of green tomatoes, topped with another thick layer of fresh mozzarella, then a pile of crumbled crisp prosciutto on top. It was drizzled with some sort of pesto to finish.
Entrees: I will admit that although this was the most expensive meal, it was also the most Instagram-worthy meal of the entire trip. Every dish was so nicely presented, and the pastas just looked exactly like you'd expect to see in an ad for Rome. For the pastas we settled on the two quintessential Roman classics: carbonara and amatriciana.
Spaghetti alla carbonara - This was super hyped because of all the reviewers on Yelp, and I was a bit underwhelmed. While it looked amazing, it was a bit disappointing for me. The most glaring miss was the pancetta. They were a thicker cut, and wasn't very crispy at all. It pretty much reminded me of cubed spam, which I actually do like, but just wasn't what I was expecting in a high end carbonara. I'll give them credit for the noodles though. Probably the best noodles of our entire trip. They were thick, al dente, and had a nice chew to them. The sauce was a little blander to me. Maybe it's closer to the authentic recipe, but I like my carbonara salty, cheesy, and heavy bacon flavor.
La matriciana o amatriciana - This was just meh for me. I don't see what's so special about it. Almost tasted like plain rigatoni in a tomato sauce topped with some parmesan. I'd take a vodka pasta all day everyday over this one.
Meatballs with chestnut polenta - We weren't a fan of the meatballs because they got all fancy and had a meat blend that included beef and lamb I think. It just tasted off to me. Maybe I'm just a simple American, but I would prefer a fatty Italian meatball with all beef/pork, breadcrumbs, and parm. Then the polenta was pretty bland too.
Dessert: To end the meal they gave us a house gift of amaretto cookie with hazelnut sauce, which was aight. The flavors weren't anything extraordinary, but they were free so I can't knock it.
Overall, food was a bit of a letdown given the price and wait, but we got the gram-worthy pics we came for, so I can't be too disappointed. I honestly don't get why people are head over heels for this place though. I heard the guys to the right of us describe every bite as simply amazing and just "out of this world", and when I looked over, he was just eating a plain slice of mozzarella. Really? Maybe I'm the weird one here, but I just wasn't impressed based on my expectations. You can easily find equally good pasta at many restaurants in Rome. read more