We've gone to Rotols multiple times and have never been disappointed. We always order the garlic knots, plain wings, combo, and pepperoni pizza, which always tastes great. The service is always quick, and the staff is friendly. We love this place and also love that they offer deals! Good place to have good pizza and watch the games! read more

See all

The food is consistently delicious! Our favorites are the chick-chick-bruh and the pesto manifesto. The service isn't great, but if you can bring your patience the food is definitely worth it. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Pesto manifesto - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

It took over 1.5 hours to get our pizza. I ordered a beverage and it took 30 minutes to get my beverage. The pizza was acceptable but short on the pepperoni but the crust was nice and thin and crispy. The way I like it. read more

Pizza wasn't all it's claimed to be in my honest opinion. It reminded me of frozen pizza - I like a great dough and toppings have to be plentiful and I didn't get either on my pizza! I think I had maybe 6 pieces of pepperoni on my large pizza!! read more

It's been 6 years since my first review, and Rotolo's is still one of my absolutely favorite places to get gluten free crust. My new favorite is the chicken Alfredo pizza and it is my favorite GF pizza I've ever had anywhere. Our whole family loves to eat here and we have recommended Rotolo's many times. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Gluten free pizza crust! So so good! - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

I don't know why I decided to give this place a try .... Again. The glass of water was disgusting. Tasted like the filter hasn't been changed since they opened ten years ago. My order was wrong. Waitress abandoned our table bc of another big party. Tables are left dirty. Avoid coming here at all cost. I should've known better ... it's never been good. Ever. read more

Some solid pizza in Fairhope! AND they have an arcade in the back :0) I only minus one star due to realizing I would not order the adult size pizza again (felt it was under cooked) I was jealous of the kids pizza (pure perfection) and when I'm in town again, if we venture here, I'll be ordering the childrens size for myself too!!! Lol Staff is super friendly, welcoming and happy. Place is clean enough, I'm sure they are struggling with being understaffed as is everyone. Overall, great service, good food, killer arcade read more

We grabbed takeout - the classic Detroit and garden Alfredo pizzas, as well as a salad. Presentation was nice, and the pies were great. Alfredo pizza was wonderful. Will go back when I'm back in fairhope again! read more

Spaghetti & meatballs is so good and Mary is the best host makes you feel like family,,,,,and the pizza is not to shabby

I had the calzone it was really good and fresh. One of the best calzones I've had in a while. Wish I lived over here.

Met friends here today to celebrate September birthdays. Nice area to meet and enjoy lunch with a group of 15. I had a delicious wrap with spicy zapp's chips. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

See all

This was my first time at this place. We picked the pizzas up because delivery would have been 2 hour wait. It was nice and hot but I am picky about my everything so I wasn't pleased with this pizza. I don't like a lot of red sauce, it's so thick, I believe a little goes a long way. Not only was it too saucy but the sauce was so dark in color which to me meant very tomato pasty. If you like thick red sauce then this is your place. It was a bit high cost wise as well as everything is these days. I think if the sauce had been a bit lighter the pizza would have been good. The crust was very good. I prefer thin crust but I let my husband have the thicker crust this time. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

We came back again, and this time with friends. We had more of a variety of food. It was all very good again. The Children's Mac and Cheese is definitely portioned for older kids, my toddler could have eaten off this for 3 days. My friends enjoyed the calzones. Our server was very attentive and patient with us as we had 2 preschoolers with us. We really enjoyed ourselves. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Childrens Mac and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

See all

Stop reading the 1 star reviews. Anyone that walks out before ordering doesn't count. Anyone who says they are intimidated by kitchen staff is, well, going to be intimidated by butter at some point. Food: ParmGar knots are fire! Wings smelled great but at the time we got there they were out. Nbd Pizza was great. Loved Maui Wowi (no onions) Arcade was great. Babysitter for sure. Worth it. Waitress. Didn't recall her name, but awesome. She worked the back and won! Suggestions, drink menus and maybe more wings. Lol. Thanks for the trip there! read more

Mad we waited this long to try this local pizza stop. We ordered to-go through the website which was super simple, and it was ready when we arrived The staff was nice and checked our order before passing it over the bar. We can't wait to go back and dine in and try out the arcade with the little one.. and get some more Parmesan bites! read more

See all

To start we felt like we were in a sauna the whole time because it was so hot. Secondly, our service was awful. The waitress had a terrible attitude and made it seem that she did not want to be there, much less serve us. She stood behind us at least 6-7 feet to ask us our orders. She didn't tell us who had what when placing our food on the table. And when it came time to pay, our tickets were wrong twice. She brought change to someone who paid with a card. She brought cash but not coin change and said "I can go get your 75c if you want it." On top of the bad service, our supreme pizza tasted like it was warmed in a microwave. Our veggies were not cooked. Overall it was a terrible experience, would not recommend. read more

This our go to restaurant for pizza. The pizza crusis thick and yummy. The marinara sauce has just the right spice, mild and they don't load up the pizza with too much sauce. The ingredients are fresh. The waitresses are very nice and they make the experience very happy and pleasant. The wings are mildly spiced but you can order them as Spivey as you would like. They are large wing, I couldn't finish the 10 piece dinner. The blue cheese dressing is unremarkable, but tasted fine. read more

See all

We liked Rotolo's for years. Sadly, the pizza has gone downhill. Tasteless crust, bland skimpy cheese and sauce is way too sweet. Parmesan Bites were our favorite appetizer, not anymore. No flavor. Staff is friendly and the atmosphere is fine for everyone but we're there for the food. Maybe we'll try again in a few months. read more

This place has GOT to quit doing that thing where every single worker ignores the customer and/or walks away from them. Maybe I'm a masochist, but I keep coming back despite the sometimes bad service. The food is good, almost always fresh. The pizzas are unique. But at least once a year, I get straight ignored when I walk in. Today was one of those days. I was really hoping they were over that bad habit. They clearly are not. read more

Best salad as in the spinach, walnut cranberry, and the pizza was delicious and I don't know why I've been going anywhere else. I recommend Rotolo's read more

Second time back in several weeks. They remembered us. The food, the atmosphere, the people are amazing...

We were more than disappointed and have no.idea what happened to their pizza.. and service..the crust tasted like a processed crust very tasteless and very little sauce on it.. my fault i didnt realize each item u added was 1.89 sausage being over 2.. that being said it was very doughy like not fully cooked. We only ate part of it and left the rest..we will not go back..the customer service was not good as we had to keep calling the waitress for drink refills and extra sauce to try and make it taste better.. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Bar area - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

I really love the calzones here and their Caesar salad. I would definitely give your waitress a heads up when you think you might need something because like with a lot of places nowadays, they are usually shorthanded. read more

We went to dine in here the other day at about 9:30 and we were greeted and sat within minutes. The person seated us walked up to our table and told us he made a mistake and he would have to ask us to leave since they were closing at 10:00. So we got up and left. read more

We have eaten here numerous times. Great pizza and decent Italian food. The kids love the game room, and the ice cream bar. All in all, a quality pizza joint. read more

Placed a $200 order and was told it would be 45 min - we also gave the girl our CC for payment -- after 45 min of waiting we were told they never made our order and it would be another hour and 30 min with no exclamation and treated very rude by the entire staff !! read more

Food is bland, no flavor at all, had to add seasonings to pizza at home to taste anything at all. Dough was soft, pizza was cooked thoroughly, it just didn't have any flavor. The food wasn't bad, it wasn't really anything at all since we couldn't taste it. read more

We were looking for some good delivery pizza and this hit the spot. It took a while for them to deliver on a Saturday night, but it was well worth the wait. Give them a try if you are in the area. read more

Shared a 12" pizza with hubby, which arrived quickly and hot. Loaded with pepperoni, bacon and ham. Very good. Also had the side salad, only $2, which was freshly made. Best part of our first time visit was our server, Kina. She was so nice and accommodating. Very knowledgeable about the menu too. Every restaurant should have servers like her. V read more

Good food and great service. The staff is always prompt and courteous. Generally busy, but never over crowded. The food is very consistent and fresh. Good family atmosphere for watching a game and having wings/pizza. Game room a plus for the kids. read more

Met our daughter, son in law and 14 month old grandson for casual dinner last night. Ordered Greek salad, spinach salad and large pizza. Food was good but the server brought the salad at the same time as the pizza. A little unusual. Pizza was great. After dinner there is gelato for dessert!! Grandson loves the kids arcade area too. read more

Ate there 3/19/15. Pizza was awful. The mushrooms and green peppers were placed on top of the pizza after it came out of the oven. The mushrooms and green peppers were cold. I will not eat there again. The first time was good. The next three times were awful. Only reason I stopped by, it's a half a mile from my house. It's amazing they're still in business. At least the kids have a play room and games. read more

Food was ok , staff needs instruction . 1 . Stay off your phones . 2. Keep your gossip about your friends boyfriend to yourself , no one wants to hear your opinion ! 3. Smile and act like your the wait staff :-( read more

Aaa-maze-ing pizza de-lish!! Blackened chicken sandwich de-lish!! Ceasar salad de-lish!! Rita's strong!! Def recommend Chicken was so moist, salad was covered in dressing just the way I like it. The bread was so soft. Loved it & we will be coming back next time we are in town. read more

We've lived in the area for 3 years but haven't tried this place out. We were pleasantly surprised. Full bar. Nightly (minus Saturday) specials. Pizza was brought to us hot and quickly. Crust is fluffy. Toppings plentiful. Service was great. We will definitely be back read more

We waited more than 10 minutes for drinks. My wife ordered a personal pizza, and I ordered a salad. The pizza arrived, but the salad did not. It took over 10 minutes for my salad to arrive after the pizza was brought to the table. After the salad finally arrived, I was told the kitchen was out of the salad dressing that I had ordered. One of the worst restaurant experiences of my life. We will not be back. read more

Placed order for chicken wings to go. Got them back to my hotel and discovered they were raw inside. Called to complain but could not get a manager to the phone. Discovered the root of the issue. Shame, love other locations of this place. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Raw chicken wings from to go order! - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

I used to enjoy coming here for lunch or dinner, but no more. Their bartender is the most rude, obnoxious person I've ever had to wait on me and my wife. She needs a serious attitude adjustment and certainly does not belong working with the public. Rotolos should fire her immediately and apologize for letting someone like her represent them. read more

Rude manager. Good pizza sauce. Food was pretty good.. calzone had wayyy to many onions and not much meat like they used the onions as filler.. first "free" kids drink of orange juice was so full of ice I had to put the straw in for my son bc he couldn't do it himself- he's 5.. needed a refill since it was 85% ice and they charged for a regular size.. the manager had an attitude.. read more

We had the Muffuletta Traditional and it was amazing! The crust was cooked to perfection and the ingredients were delicious. We will be coming back! read more