First visit. Came in on a Friday for lunch at 11:30. It was very empty. We decided on flounder…read morebites (because they were out of grouper) and they were very delicious.the clam chowder was good. I had the cold lobster roll- it was definitely smaller than expected. Mac and cheese was ok- not the best not the worst. One person had the stuffed flounder- decent. Blackened mahi was really good. And on Friday, you get free cake!!! Would love to go back and try some of the fried options

I came for a weekday lunch and had attentive service and good food -- a bowl of a thick New England…read moreclam chowder and an oyster poor boy. Draft beer prices were lower than a lot of other Goldsboro restaurants which is great. There is lots of off-street parking -- also a plus. Worth repeat visits.

The customer service and quality of the seafood is great. I like having a seafood market near…read more Support this business.

1st disappointing meal in years. My fried flounder had obviously sat under a warming light for…read morequite some time before it was served. It was dried out and tough. My fried shrimp was only warming, not hot. Best part of my meal were the hush puppies and cole slaw. I hate to post a negative review but the quality was definitely off on my visit. Unfortunately I'm only in the area once year; I hope next years visit will be more like my previous ones.

Place opens at 3pm, by 3:20 there was a wait list. Had to wait for a table but it was worth it…read more Great hushpuppies followed by some very tasty seafood. Got the 3 combo flounder, shrimp, devil crab. Nice light breading on flounder and shrimp. Some of the best deviled crab I've had in a long time -.light and delicious. Service was excellent. Place has the nautical theme. If in the area I strongly recommend

I love Mayflower Seafood and have eaten at almost every site in Wake, Johnston and Wake counties…read more My experience at this one was just okay. This wasn't really the fault of our server, who was extremely nice to us, although our order did get botched. I was afraid that might happen when she didn't write it down. She was attentive and gave good recommendations (including that the flounder wasn't particularly good that night), so I give her points. She was the best part of our experience. My husband had the broiled shrimp and said it was very good. Our roommate had fried shrimp. I ordered fried oysters and fried catfish, but got fried catfish and fried shrimp instead. Our server apologized and brought me a small bowl with some oysters, and only charged me for the shrimp and catfish. The oysters were absolutely delicious - I just wish I'd gotten a full order of them. The shrimp were also excellent, if only I'd really wanted shrimp. My share of the french fries was a smaller portion than I get at other Mayflowers. My sweet tea wasn't good at all! It tasted more like tra sweetened with Stevia or Sweet N' Low than sugar. Sweet Tea in the south is not Diet Sweetener Tea. I hope this was just because we came in later in the evening. I admit to being picky about my tea! Restaurant itself was typical of the Mayflowers and clean. We'll go back and I hope that I get a full order of oysters that are as good as the sample I got this time.

Note to self: When you see a empty parking lot and no customers inside RUN! This was my first and…read morelast time going to Mayflower. The good news is our server was amazing and she should seek employment elsewhere. The interior looks nice and has a good aroma. It was 3 people with me and nobody was happy with their meal. The food looks good but nothing had seasoning. The flounder had scales on it. The shrimp was double breaded to make it look jumbo. The Ice Tea was nasty. The only good part of my meal was the French fries. The waitress did apologize and take one meal off the bill. I heard this place use to be good several years ago but they really need to file bankruptcy and stop wasting people time.

Glam-girly, playful, modern lounge- my new favorite spot downtown! Perfect for a special night out…read morelike our Galentine's party. (A little hidden on the street wedged between shops) Phenomenal service and good vibes all around. We got the truffle fries, "Big Bird" crispy chicken breast sandwich, and "On Cloud" Mahi. All very good; a bit pricey but the aesthetic is a big part of it. This place has been open just shy of a year and is well maintained. Definitely great for cute pics with a lot of edgy but feminine decor!

Everything was great! The food was amazing and our server was very kind and explained everything to…read moreus because it was our first time eating there.

Delicious food! Very very friendly staff but maybe a bit understaffed. The service was a tad slow,…read morewhich would've been annoying if we were in a rush, but eating such tasty food made it well worth the wait. Will definitely be back.

Great service, wait time isn't bad, food prepared in a timely manner, the atmosphere was fine.read more

Great, fresh, bbq buffet. One of the best left in the state. Nothing is not good country cooking. I…read morewas there at like 230 so not the normal lunch rush. The fried chicken barbecue the fried shrimp all hot fresh new items coming out to the bar. Less their hearts, they have three different cobblers banana pudding there never is and really never has been anything wrong with this restaurant. Literally if you don't like something any of the servers you could just tell them about it. They'll get fresh. I'll take care of it just delicious.

The entire family comes to Goldsboro on a weekend in Dec for Christmas with everyone at my mother…read morein laws house. The last few years we have made it easier cooking wise to get food from McCalls. It was a great decision. They sell fried chicken, bar b q, hushpuppies, slaw, etc. The fried chicken is excellent and so is the bar b q. We have done this now for about 3-4 years and it is a big order... for 17 or so people. It is always ready when we get there and hot. And so far, always been good!