They have "Specials" that are SO WORTH IT !!! Everyday…read moreuntil 4pm today's ( see photo) we're $10.00 & 2 slices pizza W/ soda was $7.00. A real find ! Both my hubby & I wanted pizza.... We are originally from NY - so this was a True find ! Inside is on the small side, only 8 tables some seated 6, but could add the next table to seat 10 ! Service was fantastic welcomed when we walked in, to Pointing out the specials ! Pizza as it SHOULD ALWAYS be served FRESH, HOT & DELICIOUS

The family was craving pizza, so after checking reviews we decided to try this spot, and I'm glad…read morewe did (mostly). It's a small place with limited seating, but we were able to sit right away, which was a plus. We ordered a large pie, half chicken with vodka sauce and half pepperoni, plus a Philly cheesesteak sandwich. Let's start with the highlight: the pizza was fire. The chicken with vodka sauce was absolutely divine, easily the standout. Honestly, we all agreed we should've just gotten the whole pie that way because it was that good. The pepperoni side was solid too, but that vodka combo stole the show. Now...the downside. The cheesesteak missed the mark completely. It lacked flavor, the bread wasn't great, and overall it was pretty disappointing. I was close to giving this place 3 stars because of that, but at the end of the day--it's a pizza spot, and the pizza delivered. So 4 stars it is. Just stick to the pizza and you'll be happy.

One of my favorite pizza places. The pizza is always so…read moreFresh and delicious. The prices are unbeatable. And the staff are very friendly. The restaurant is super clean. I order a lot from door dash and the pizza is always so great! As well as their wings. Their specials are priced very well. The only thing I don't Like is the Kissimmee downtown area at night just be aware of your surroundings. But really this is one of the best pizza place in town.

I can't say enough good things about this place! The food was delicious! I was really surprised how…read moregood their pizza was and how much it reminded me of NY pizza. The slices are big. They also have a huge pie you can attempt eat in 30 minutes... but we knew that was too much for us! The staff were SUPER nice!!! It's a great little place and I will definitely be back!

WOW!!!! Pizza was excellent and definitely worth the wait. These guys prove the adage that good…read morethings are worth waiting for. The service was phenomenal, staff were friendly and informative, patient with us and so very kind. Excellent all around and a new tradition whenever we come back to Kissimmee/Orlando. Next time, we plan to eat inside and I'm already looking forward to it. Lots of business. So great to see a local place succeed!

Pizza is good a small lil place friendly an always busy some just like to write negativity but I…read morebeen coming here for years always busy an my food always on point!!!!

First, I must say, everyone was super friendly. The service is very attentive, and I'd even go as…read morefar as to say some of the best I'vereceived in a while. The restaurant fits in with the theme of downtown Kissimmee being old-timey with a modern flair. I thought the place was cute and quiet for lunch, but I could definitely see myself gearing up for a happy hour. The food was EXCELLENT. I had a calzone with pepperoni, mushrooms, and bacon. The dough was fresh, the cheese was high quality, and I enjoyed every bite. I was blown away by the marinara sauce too. Somebody's Nona passed down that recipe. Overall, I will be back!

Been coming here for years! Love their Pizza. Amazing specialty Pizzas with lots of flavor. Indoor…read moreor outdoor seating! Friendly service. Chill vibes with Bar seating.

One of the Best pizza in Kissimmee! At the Loop next to the theaters. Cheese pizza is perfection…read more The specialty pizzas are Amazing. Must try the Sicilian Flag which has red sauce, white sauce, and pesto sauce. Also Hot Honey Pepperoni was delicious. Mama's Lasagna pizza was Awesome! The service was super friendly. Small cozy restaurant with quick service! A must try! They also have pastas freshly made!

Had a better experience dining in on a Saturday at 2pm, not too busy and they had enough slices to…read morechoose from. They checked us out fast and it was the fastest I've had a pizza come out and it was hot enough we needed to wait a few minutes before we could enjoy. I got my favorite crazy margarita and my fiance got the Italian flag slices. Always great quality coming here!

As a lifelong restaurant industry person and being from up north, it's hard to wow me w anything…read moregood food wise in Central Fla. I was so excited to find this non chain restaurant. The ambience is amazing. Quaint. The food was exceptional. THE ALFREDO was a true Alfredo and not some cheesy mess. The chicken Marsala was fantastic (served w fried potato cubes!) and the salads were beautiful! I wanted to try everything on the menu because every dish sounded amazing. The burrata app w prosciutto and pesto and olives!? Don't miss it! It's fantastic. I regret not getting our servers name. As a business owner, that's the kind of server I'd keep forever. Beautiful younger girl w very dark long hair. Even after we ordered she explained exactly what was in each thing (including salad) to make sure we would be ok w everything. I've never had such a thorough experience. We will be back!

The extensive gluten free menu was what attracted me to this restaurant. GF pasta dishes and GF…read morepizzas. There is a whole Vegan menu as well but personally any Italian place that I can eat at as a gluten free human is a rare beast. The quality of the ingredients is obvious from the olive oil on the house salad to the perfect cream sauce on the Alfredo. Delicious and well prepared.

Great awesome I love ordering there amazing the food was on time and the food was greatread more

The girl working here is super super friendly and very quick with the orders. That's the only…read morereason why I'm giving a star because this pizza is not good at all for my personal taste. I never go to change like a little Caesars and this is another one I will avoid.

Came to dine here after looking online for the best pizza- WOW!! That was the right choice. Kim and…read moreJess met us at the door, described the menu, the authenticity of the ingredients, and the brick ovens. Don't miss out! We had pizza and wings and they were both excellent! The pizza is the best I've EVER had! Thanks yall!

Overall ill give this spot a 6.5 , The pizza is bad although it was 90% cheese and 10% dough. The…read morewings were really good with a nice kick to them and customer service was great as well

Delicious!!!! I had to drive out here (from Altamonte springs) on a doctor recommendation for…read moresomething else. I treated myself to 2 slices and they were AMAZING!! Yeah I'm a Floridian, but I love to visit NYC for weekend trips and I LOVE the city's pizza!! This is SO SO close!!! The "mall" itself is outdated but don't let that stop you if you're in the area and really love a good thin crust pizza!! Yummmmmmmm...thank you!!

This was my first time here because a friend said that this pizza will be the closes I will get to…read moreNew York's pizza, and you know what, this pizza is the Best Buy far. It was an interesting visit because the gentlemen that served me was Barry and Barry just happen to be from Brooklyn where I lived at. We went back into time and talked about the old neighborhood and me and my wife enjoyed the conversation that we had, but all that said he treated us like family and for this you have a customer and a friend for life. Thank you Barry it was nice meeting you. And for the owner, Hai un Buon laboratory e qualunque cost tu stia facendo continua cosi continua a farlo. Thank you.

Great place. I think the best slices ever!! The pizzas are large and delicious. The staff are…read moreextremely polite.

It's been sometime since we've tried this "New York Pizza Company". I was pleasantly surprised…read more The service was quick and friendly and established was clean and there are no issues with parking. You can place your order there, order on their website, or call ahead for pick up. They also have great specials by the slice. The pizzas also reheat nicely the next day if you're like me and you just can't quite make it through a whole pie in one sitting. Enjoy!