There's a lot going on amidst the reviews of Dortoni, but I want my own write up to really focus on…read morethe here and now and the bakery aspect of this place (which by the way, is quite good). My wife and I have been here a few times and found Dortoni to be delightfully delicious. Well, for the most part. On our first trip we tried a whole bunch of different baked goods (pastries, cookies, crumbs, cakes, etc.), though one thing we were excited about was their take on the Dubai chocolate sensation via the form of a cake. Unfortunately, it kind of missed the mark, but if you take that snafu aside, everything else at Dortoni is fantastic. For instance, my wife's new favorite dessert is their cheesecake waffle cone (which is exactly what it sounds like). For me, I loved the key lime bomb which was out of this world. There's just a great selection of stuff here that makes you curious as to what they'll have each time you enter. Beyond the baked goods, I will say the staff has been super friendly. Both visits they were helpful, gave suggestions, and (though it was close to closing) offered us some rolls free of charge. It doesn't take a lot to make you feel welcome and they do more than that which is nice to see. Perhaps you won't see what is nothing more than a few tables inside this small spot that you can sit at, but I wouldn't say this is a horrible turnoff. Yeah, maybe Dortoni isn't your bakery/cafe that's going to be a place you stay and enjoy your goods, but it's definitely worth some items to-go. Overall, Dortoni in Port Jeff earns a visit. There are other locations (perhaps even one closer to me) that I might have to check out, but even if I do, I'll at least know that the quality and service in PJ is top notch. I'd gladly return here in the future (and I probably will knowing my wife's new obsession) and you should too!

Super cute spot but not really a sit and drink coffee kind of place. It's more of a takeout or…read moreperhaps specialty cake establishment. Cappuccino not the best. The foam was very thin and watery.

Still over 10 years later I can't look at my wedding photos or hear a wedding story and not…read moreimmediately think how awful the Rolling Pin Bakery. The owner was rude and dismissive when I asked for refund of the profit she made. I really really suggest you go somewhere else. The fact they treat your wedding day like just another day, no care, no love, nothing but disappointment, disrespect, and distain if they screw up and you'd like it to be corrected. Rolling Pin is awful in all aspects. DO NOT ORDER ANY CAKE FROM THEM!!!!!

I had my wedding last Sunday 4/6 and had our cake made by Rolling Pin. They sent us a tasting a few…read moremonths before and we picked vanilla sponge cake with strawberry jam. Absolutely delicious and was even better in the actual wedding cake. The one blemish on a perfect cake was that we ordered lilac or light purple icing for flowers on the cake, they turned out to be a dark blue. But great tasting cake nonetheless.

The best in baked goods. The service is prompt and friendly. A scent of heaven when you walk in.read more

In Tilda's on April 21, 2026, about noon. Waiting in line. 3 people in front of were waited on by…read morepeople behind the counter. Came to my "turn" the lady, tall dark hair, talks to a lady behind me, like they are friends. She then looks at the lady behind me " what can I get you"? I spoke up, "wait, am I invisible"? The lady behind the counter, instead of waiting on me says" I have to go in the back, be right back"! I spoke kind of loudly, I am out of here, and will not tolerate that kind of service. Will never go back to Tilda's again, and mention that to all my friends etc...

The crepes were sooooo good and definitely worth coming back for. We tried both savory and sweet,…read moreand both versions were perfectly made and stuffed with high quality ingredients. The fruit was ripe, the cheese flavorful, and the crepes were soft while still holding up to the fillings. Thankfully we were the only customers at first, because everything took so long. The crepes came out at different times, and some in my party were halfway done before others got their orders. Also, the seating a decor may appeal to some, but not to me. Lastly, the idea of a rice pudding bar is awesome, but the pudding we tried (Tiramisu) was super sweet and a little soft. I like al dented rice pudding, so again, this may just be a preference issue.

Sweet & Savory in Port Jeff is a Stony Brook student favorite, and I'm glad I came. The vibe is…read moresuper chill, and their sweet crepes are amazing. Whether you're craving Nutella and strawberries or something totally loaded, you can't go wrong. Perfect for a study break or just a sweet fix!

Found these gems at the Port Jefferson farmers market. Anything they make is over the top. Stop by…read moreand check them out!

This is the best place for desserts! I swear they have everything. My favorite go-to is definitely…read morethe frozen yogurt. They have great security which shows how much they care about the store and the customers. Their service is great as they are kinda and caring. The atmosphere is great and they welcome you at the door.

My husband and I came here yesterday afternoon to buy ice cream. The ice cream was good. But,…read morethe rocky road fudge was hard as a rock. You can kill someone with it. The fudge was not fresh, and how dare you sell old fudge to the public, and take there money. We always go to this place to get ice cream, but it will be our last since this is how you are going to treat your customers.

Absolutely creative and tasty cakes! The ladies at Land Of Cakes put so much thought and effort…read moreinto their work. I definitely recommend them.

From the owner: specialty cakes, kids cakes, character cakes, novelty cakes, wedding cakes, sweet 16 cakes,…read morechildren's cakes, cupcakes, specialty bakery cakes, tiered cakes, specialty cake fillings, specialty buttercream

Nice little bakery nestled by the train tracks in St James on Lake Avenue. The renovation really…read moreopened up the space and made the entrance more inviting. However it's hit or miss purchasing Kaiser rolls. It's amazing how quickly they "sell" out by 11am while there are plenty of plain and sesame seed rolls left to purchase. Additionally the size of the rolls had gotten smaller while the price keeps increasing now $1.00 a roll half the size of a roll from other bakeries and deli's. Apple turnovers are very good but again expensive ( flour going up I guess). Staff always friendly and welcoming but I wish someone would run numbers on roll sales so there'd be some Kaiser rolls left to purchase. Varied selection of cookies, pastries and pies and there's a coffee station for those needing a caffeine fix.

First time here and looking for the best sweet treat. Coming here towards the end of the day is…read morenot the best as many of their items are gone. With an ideal location across the street from the St James train station, I can understand why doughnuts and muffins would be gone. Smart! We picked up eclairs, Napoleons, cream puffs and cannolis to go. The black and white cookie looked really good so we'll come back for that as I'm always on the hunt for the best. The cannoli is a small size and has a distinctive nutmeg flavor. I am not crazy about the green sprinkles though. Crunchy though. The eclair is filled with a custard and the chocolate was discolored. Not sure why. It was okay. I have had the Napoleon or cream puff yet so we will see how they hold up the next day. The store has a nice variety of goodies including decorated cakes, cookies and breads so please give them a try.

In search of an authentic Italian bakery, someone highly recommended Dolci Momenti so I gave it a…read moretry! Funny how I was at the Turkish place right next door a few months ago and never thought of trying it then! Well, I'm glad for the recommendation because this is a really nice bakery! The tables and seating struck me as soon as I walked in on top of the displays and how clean it was, I knew I found a great bakery! I ordered some rainbow cookies, a couple of eclairs and cream puffs. The rainbow cookies are without a doubt some of the best I've had in a long time. The cream puffs I was expecting custard filling but what I chose were the cream puffs filled with chocolate pudding instead, I didn't know there were choices but these did not disappoint, I love chocolate pudding and the flavor/texture was perfect, not too sweet. I called the bakery when I got home and they actually offer 3 types of cream puffs. Chocolate pudding, custard and cannoli filling. The pudding has the chocolate stripe on top, the custard is the plain dough sprinkled with powdered sugar and the cannoli cream puff has a little cannoli cream coming out of it with shavings on top. The eclairs were delicious but they only make the mini size! There are LOTS of pastries, varieties of cookies, cakes, cheescakes and breads. It's too bad I do not like coffee because there is an expresso bar for you to have with your favorite dessert! I will definitely be back, so much more to try here! Dolci Momenti, you have a new fan!!

This makes me sad to write this bc i love this bakery. But yesterday i bought their fruit tres…read moreleches cake. Which wasn't cheap.I went home and put in fridge till time to sing happy birthday. I took the plastic off around the cake so we can cut it and the whole cake literally collapsed. It must have been too heavy and wet it turned to mush couldn't even eat it. Thank god i bought other pastries. But what a waste of 40 dollars for a cake.