I highly recommend you eat elsewhere. I had a delivery order for over $50.00. I got the shrimp scampi, my husband got the shrimp/chicken Alfredo. I also ordered extra Alfredo sauce. it took over an hour to receive our order. My husbands Alfredo came with very little sauce, and the meats were almost non existent. (What you see is what was in the dish) My dish was bland, no seasonings at all. I called to speak to the manager. He was less than helpful. Hopefully this saves someone an awful experience. read more

Sal's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Portage, Wisconsin

OMG. I always order them from sliced delivery, but they have amazing. Food and salads are just oh my God out of this world I love them. The Slice delivery drivers are always super awesome. Now I'm hungry. read more

I haven't had a single dish I didn't like from sals. My absolute favorite is the fries there like nothing you've ever tasted. The staff is always so friendly and always a bright smile on their faces. I absolutely adore how the inside looks! It reminds me of when I was in Italy in the restaurants. read more

Great slices, go there with my family all the time. Buffalo Chicken pizza and Gyro pizzas are two favorites!

The only true Gyro's. I had one of the first in Madison Wis. in the early 70's. Only Sal's has ever matched that taste. They taste fantastic and service is great. All other places that have Gyro's have the commercial meat and pita bread and sauce that can never match up to what Sal's use. Quality all the way. read more

Outside of Chicago a couple of hours in Portage WI is a true Chicago hand tossed experience. My boyfriend is a pizza snob. I am a Domino's franchisee since 1986. We live pizza everyday. And Sal's is amazing. Right blend of ingredients ! Perfectly baked, no gummy layer, and pleasing portions. Don't miss Sal's and let them know if you agree! read more

I've been to this place for lunch twice in the past week, so it's time to report. It is a small, family-run establishment. It's in a small strip mall, with no fancy decor. If you want Fine Dining, go elsewhere. BUT, if you want Delicious food, served by friendly staff, then this is the place for you. I chose to eat in rather than do takeout. The first visit I had a large slice of Gyros Pizza. It turned out to be one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The same fresh, tasty ingredients as if you were eating a gyro at a Greek restaurant. The next visit I tried the Baked Ziti, as it came highly recommended by my sister-in-law. It did not disappoint. The noodles were great, and they were covered in mouth-watering cheeses and sauce. I look forward to going back to sample more of the menu, which had a nice variety of options. read more

Sal's Pizza - Baked Ziti - Pizza Near Me - Portage, Wisconsin

See all

DO NOT ORDER FROM THEIR APP!!!! We placed an order on line, the order was paid for, $50, and it came out of my bank account and after 45 min.s of no update/confirmation from them I called and they said they don't have my order and it's my problem to get ahold of the 3rd party THEY partnered with to get a refund. I have no way of contacting whoever the hell they are! The manager could've cared less. He offered no apologies or solutions. I will NEVER give them my business again!!! read more

We have been ordering delivery from Sal's for almost a year and the food is so good! Our usual is a large pizza..any kind is delicious. Philly cheese steak wrap and the grilled chicken wrap are also yummy! The Gyro is my personal favorite! We also love the garlic cheese bread. We just tried the meat raviolis and they were delicious! Pretty sure everything is delicious! You will not be disappointed! read more

Very disappointed in the food quality. Dry wings, and dry chicken wrap. We ordered delivery, super long wait, food arrived cold and items missing. Called to provide feedback and was offered $10 off the next order, we had a $75 order... Hopefully they can turn it around. There's such an opportunity in this area to provide a wide range menu and offer delivery. read more

Average tasting pizza, depending on your tastes, it along the level of a Dominos or Papa Johns type, ingredients taste fresh. They don't offer Italian sausage only Basic pork sausage. The crust isn't a flakey type crust but more of the spongey type. Probably good for feeding groups. They do have slices Available of assorted pizzas and that can be a good quick option. They also have a menu of many other types of dishes offered. This location has plenty of seating along with their takeout. Staff is friendly and pizzas are made quickly. read more

Sal's Pizza - Medium sausage and mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Portage, Wisconsin

Ordered a pizza, a gyro, and a salad. The pizza was great. It had the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Loved it! The salad was decent. Unfortunately, the tomatoes were so old they were seeding. The Gyro was a huge disappointment. It was served like it was a Mexican tostada or something instead of wrapped like it's supposed to be. There was zero feta cheese, the tzatziki was fake store-bought crap, no oregano, and there were regular onions instead of red onions, and way too much fake gyro meat on it. All in all a complete fail. Any Greek could see it was an awful version of a Gyro. read more

We stopped by for lunch while visiting family. My husband had been here once before but I was a little hesitant to go here because it was 12:15 and the parking lot was empty. My husband ordered a gyro and I got the Chicken Parmesan on penne pasta. Both were very good! It definitely seems to be a small family restaurant with a home cooked feel. There was pizza by the slice available but they seemed to not be fresh. There was maybe a little too much cheese on the pasta because it had to be cut when it started to cool down. It was still delicious and the pasta was a very large portion and I was able to take over half of it home and it was only $11! Would definitely go back! read more

Sal's Pizza - Gyro with fries - Pizza Near Me - Portage, Wisconsin

See all

stayed nearby for a weekend getaway trip. our gracious airbnb host recommended this pizza joint to us. so naturally one of the evenings when there was some light snow out, we decided takeout pizza and a movie would be the best way to enjoy the night in. we didn't realize they have an online website at the time, so we stopped by to order. pleasantly surprised to find that we could order either whole pizzas or individual pizza slices. being suckers for variety, we decided to order slices of the following pizzas to try: spinach pizza, meat lover's pizza, and sal's special pizza. each slice of pizza also came with a garlic bread roll which was a nice touch. in addition to pizza, you can also order calzones, gyros, chicken wings, fries, etc. - all the takeout food favorites. there's a large seating area in the adjacent room to the counter/kitchen, so you can either choose to eat in or take away your pizza. folks here are real nice and friendly. the food is about 3.5 stars for me (it is after all takeout pizza), but the service is what really puts sal's over the top to round out at 4 stars for me. read more

Sal's Pizza - ordering counter - Pizza Near Me - Portage, Wisconsin

See all

Disappointed. I'm used to Sals in Madison and this is definitely not that. Generous ingredients but quality is not great. More like gas station pizza with a slightly better crust. Salad was just awful. See pic. Portage fails again. read more

Sal's Pizza - Sals "special" salad - Pizza Near Me - Portage, Wisconsin

Ordered a calzone, cheeseburger, and "salad" for delivery. Absolute grossest food I've ever bought. Do not waste your money. read more

Sal's Pizza - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Portage, Wisconsin

I love Sal's pizza and gyros, giant pizzas that you will crave. Stumbled across this restaurant by accident, but now make it a regular stop. I get the large which is 18" and its under $20. Friendly service, and good food. read more

Excellent pizza and excellent service! Got a medium pizza with pepperoni on one side and sausage mushroom and onion on the other side. Big pizza with generous toppings for only $14. We are only visiting Portage but if we lived here we would be back read more

Outstanding local pizza place! Can get almost anything you want on your pizza. Fast, friendly, and accurate service. Reasonable prices for what you're getting. read more

The food has been fair enough, not many other choices in Portage. I am allergic to mushrooms and put no "No Mushrooms" on my order. I didn't realize it until after a few bites they were in there, luckily I had my medication or I would have had to go to the hospital. I called to complain, not even to have them replace my food or anything, and the woman who answered said she would pass it along but frankly sounded like she didn't give a f*c*. So terrible for not reading their orders correctly, and terrible for whoever that woman who answers the phone she knows nothing about customer service. I didn't want a credit or anything because I will never go there again. read more

We ordered delivery and were not disappointed. My wife ordered the sausage pizza. It came with a generous amount of cheese and sausage. The gyro was huge with great flavor and the fries were homemade (or seemed to be). Great price too! read more

This pizza is so good! For vegetarians and otherwise. We had a crew up here for a project and were SO happy we got lunch from here. Thumbs up! read more

Very good New York style pizza. A lot of cheese. Excellent one and done slice. Fresh ingredients.

Was the Only one there at lunch time on a Sunday. Should have tipped me off to what lied ahead. Pizza looks like it's been sitting out for days. So ordered a Cesar salad. Response to "does it come with bread"? Was , "yeah, croutons". Less than 2 ounces of chicken on it but plenty of croutons. Than got sick within an hour of eating there. Never again... read more