I ordered a large pie. It came to me burnt and hard as a rock. If I bit into the crust it would have broken my tooth. I called the store and they kept on telling me to complain to Uber. I asked them "Why" being yo are the ones that cooked the food. They couldn't answer me. $28 down the drain. WARNING - YOU WILL BE SORRY TO ORDER FROM THIS STORE. read more

Bergenline staple for pizza! Sal's Pizza Bar might be it's new name but I remember when it was Sal's Pizza. To me it's a nostalgic spot that I used to go to as a young grade school kid. But this is a revamped upgraded version. When in town I decided to go down memory lane and stop in late night for a couple of slices. They are now split between a pizza place and a sit down restaurant/bar area. We decided to get a couple of slices and a Sal's own orange soda. The slices were really good. No flop and good crust. The ratio of cheese and sauce were spot on. We ended up getting a couple more slices because we devoured the first ones. The orange soda was ok. Would go with the dark cherry next time. Staff were super friendly and attentive. Glad to see Sal's still cranking solid slices out and looking forward to them continuing to be a staple of Bergenline. read more

See all

Very good food with exceptional value If you have not been here it's a must try Upside down pizza is a favorite read more

One of my favorite places for pizza in all of Hudson County! I have been coming here for over 15 years and have never been disappointed. This place has been a staple in my family and will continue to be for years to come, I am sure of it! read more

Ordered take out. Loved the garlic bread Loved the garlic and oil pasta spicy Jay liked the tomato pasta read more

So I recently started going to Sal's again since they rebuilt after the fire and let me tell you...the pizza is sooo good! Hands down one of the best I've ever had. I've eaten in and ordered to go and either way it's always hot and fresh. Their bread is delicious, but the stuffed shells are my absolute favorite. What's wild is my mom used to come here after school when she was a kid, and when she had it again after the renovation she said it brought her right back. That says everything! The staff is fantastic super sweet and welcoming. The renovation made the space bright, clean, and cozy with plenty of seating but not so much that it feels crowded. Not really a photo-op kind of spot, but if you're here for amazing food and great service, Sal's delivers every time read more

The food is pretty good ngl but $25 dollars for a water and a penne vodka? I order a penne vodka for pick up because I was a bit busy and didn't have time to sit , when I get there 30 mins later , I still had to wait 15 mins for my food. After I get my order , I get in the car and there are no utensils in the bag. After they remodeled the place there prices went over the roof read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

Food is great, it speaks for itself . BUT JESUS CHRIST THESE PEOPLE GOT AN ATTITUDE problem specially the skinny woman who looks like she has bad breathe. forget customer service what about simple hospitality? read more

My favorite pizza! New place looks great and the same great food. I always go for the Sicilian, best in Hudson county

I've been going to Sal's for ages, and even though I moved out of the area, I finally made it back recently. The pizza and food is as delicious as ever. They've renovated since I was last here, giving the place a fresh new look while still maintaining its classic charm. Can't wait to go back for more. read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

See all

Great service, beautiful restaurant, good prices and good food. We liked the pizza a lot and the garlic bread was ok. read more

See all

Oh man, this place fell off! I used to love ordering from here when I worked close by so was excited to hear they were open again after the fire. My mushroom pizza had vinegary canned mushrooms!!! Arrived cold. Chicken Parmesan was stringy meat and tasted like it had eggshells in it. Cesar salad was a soggy slopping watery mess with the world's tiniest croutons. Never again sals. Not sure if we had bad cooks tonight but it's So sad. rip to the pre-fire sals pizza. read more

The negative reviews read like they were written by people who were disgruntled prior to ordering. Now... WELCOME BACK SAL's! Newly renovated and nicely decorated. Pleasant staff that are attentive, friendly and accommodating. Yes, the slices did shrink a bit. But there was NO LOSS in flavor. Everything on the menu is made with the intention to please the customer. If not please with anything regarding food or service the owner will tend to correcting the situation immediately. Good Bronx pizza in Jersey is hard to come by. This place consistently pleases the palate and effortlessly. Great spot for family outings, business outings, quick bite or date night. Sal's aims to please and do it. Yummy Tummy! read more

Decided to give Sal's pizza a try after Barstool Dave posted his review about the pizza shop a couple weeks ago. Romano's had become our go to WNY pizza shop however it has now been usurped by Sals. We placed our order through UberEats but when our driver/order kept getting delayed, we canceled and decided to call them directly to place the order - worth it. We ordered a plain pie with half pepperoni topping and an order of mozz sticks. They told us 30-40 minutes but it felt like it came in 20. As Dave described, their pizza is a solid traditional NY pie. The dough was perfectly crispy and the pie was cooked well. Their mozz sticks were also good - 6 to an order and tasty marinara sauce. We look forward to ordering from Sal's again. read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Mozzarella Sticks - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

See all

Neighborhood spot, that I have been dropping in own, since last year. Today, I had an appetizer soup and a entrée. It's a iconic spot (est 1973) and now my Regan Beagle (Three's Company) as its a 5 minute walk from the house. Drinks were great and food was outstanding! read more

They normally don't deliver to our location but since we had a large order they delivered to us. A lot of food everyone seemed to like what they ordered. I happen to order way to much food so shared with other coworkers. Didn't care for the garlic bread but they sent plain bread as well. They even threw in a dessert, thanks so much read more

See all

Best Pizza in New Jersey. I recently moved but still drive down to this place for their pizza

Service was so helpful and nice! We decided on a hearty meat Stromboli with a fresh side of marinara. It hit the spot! So glad to have stopped by this gem! read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

Great pizza and atmosphere!! Authentic NY pizza - service was quick and professional - highly recommend if you are in West New York

My client picked this place to eat and I went in to pay for the food. The place was pretty clean and the guy behind the counter was nice. I was a little frustrated about something with my client and the server completely understood and even gave me a water before I left. I had the veggie wrap with what I believe was eggplant. I wasn't a fan of the eggplant honestly, but the fries were pretty good. The price was pretty high for the salmon but everything else was reasonable. Overall had a good experience. read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

Prices got jacked up and the slices got smaller and my favorite dish does not taste the same. But looks nice inside. read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Mini box - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

See all

This is my go to pizza spot when I'm feeling lazy, don't want to go anywhere or I'm in the area so I can call in an order to go. If I'm craving a good cheese pizza or chicken parmigiana dinner, which is what I usually get! The delivery time is very quick although they usually give you a longer estimate of time which I prefer! I know they have a bar restaurant side and the pizzeria area. I've only been to the pizzeria side, which has about 6 tables where you can sit down and enjoy your meal, they have a variety of fountain and bottled drinks. Service is fast and they accept cash and all major credit cards, however there is a minimum which I believe is $15. They are a little pricey not too much, compared to other pizza places that usually have a deal and are also good. I would recommend this spot if you're in the area and are in the mood for some good pizza or chicken parmigiana dinner. read more

See all

Sal's has been in the neighborhood for generations. They also have delicious food. I'd definitely recommend checking this place out if you are in the area. On our last trip we got some baked ziti, and it was very good. We also got eggplant parmesan and a salad. Everything was hot and cooked perfectly when we received our order. Wish we lived just a little bit closer! read more

Great place to eat and enjoy time with friends and family. The pizza is outstanding. We had the margarita pizza and typically it's a hit and miss where you eat it and it was a hit. I recommend. read more

Absolutely amazing pizza and every dish we had blew us away. The calamari is very finely breaded and crispy and delicious. We tried the upside down pizza, it was the best pizza l have ever had, try it! Any dish you try here will be made with love, the owner will come by and visit your table or seat at the bar if it is not too busy. A real taste of the old style Italian food. Unfortunately, after their 50th anniversary a couple years ago, the place burned down, but they did a fantastic job remodeling and making it nicer than it was before. Hands down, a great place to visit or take out from that you will never be disappointed in!! read more

Sals is our go to for Sicilian pizza. It's super light and doughy and reminds me of pizza from where I grew up in PA. I opted in to add basil to half the pizza this time and glad I did. Also had the chicken roll which has solid flavor but was a little dry for my liking. The chicken pasta dish we ordered was pretty solid too. The cavitelli pasta was cooked perfectly and enjoyed the lemon sauce. read more

See all

First timer and it is a great place, the service is top notch and the food is great!!

Really nice tasting pizza. I'm really impressed with their crusts. The bread tasted really good. Crispy not burnt. read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - One pep one reg, for the win. - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

After giving this pizzeria a few more shots, I've decided to update my review. I am not sure of past visits had a different chef but the food has become way better and is living up to the word of the pizza critics. I would recommend this spot! read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Sicilian Pie half pepperoni and sausage - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

See all

TERRIBLE!!!! Pizza was cold , cheese looked stale and old. Owner was rude. Outrageous prices for a pizza with hardly any sauce and old cheese. read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Slice of cheese looks eaten on top of pizza . - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

Ordered delivery and pretty disappointed but also wasn't expecting much. Pizza was below average. Tasted pretty bland. Wouldn't really reorder from here if I was craving pizza. read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

See all

Super fresh pizza!!! It's so delicious!!! They warm the slices to perfection.. not every place does. The pizza is crispy on the outside but soft and fluffy inside. The cheese is delicious and it's not too salty. Definitely recommend this place. I've been coming for years since 1997 and it's consistently delicious. read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

So glad to see Sal's back in biz. What a tough break for a business to have a fire. They were surely missed by the community. New place looks great - lots of old familiar faces and same great pizza. Welcome back, guys!!! read more

I've been going to Sals for over 40 years. It's never been a high end but always consistent and delicious. Service is fast and courteous. Place is split into two parts. A small restaurant side and a standard pizzeria type side which has been around since they opened in the seventies. Pizzeria side looks badly frayed at the edges and could use a major face lift. But the food is always good. read more

Absolutely love this place's pizza. Been a customer for years and nothing around beats this place. Their chicken Parmesan and fried calamari are also really good. The staff is very friendly and the renovations are nice. read more

See all

Just ordered a few things today and some things were disappointing . Ordered a tortellini alfredo and theyre wasnt much chicken and the pasta was small deff not worth $20 Ordered a siclian with peperoni and sausage and to us we felt like the crust was ok... garlic cheesey bread was great wouldve been nice if given with a side of marinara or more toasted. But overall ok experience just seemed a little to expensive for what we received . read more

Sal's Pizza Bar - Toretllini alfredo with chicken - Desserts Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

I love this place so much. im from Florida, but every time i visit new jersey this is a mandatory must have. I always order for delivery so i have never visit the place but their food is amazing. Love their baked zitis, fettucinni alfredo and penne a la vodka. Their prices are reasonable and the portions are really good. read more

What got me on dumb about Sal's, is their over pricing. I ordered 2 grilled chicken Cesar salads and 4 pepperoni slices cost come out to $50. If the food was quality, I don't mind paying but it's definitely NOT! Got me once but never again. I should have taken a picture but I was just so bothered. read more

The pizza is good. But the girl that answers the phone and takes orders is rude (and the careless attitude ) made me wanna hang up and not order. read more

Great pizza! Wouldn't miss it for the world. Hopefully I can try it again when I'm back there.